Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's something going on at his school?

30 replies

RedRuby152 · 20/03/2022 13:26

My nephew who's just turned 6 has recently been excluded for a few days and by what the school says he deserves it as through this year he's been throwing furniture, jumping on tables, hitting out at other children.

The issue is we look after him several times a week and whilst he's not perfect with us he's polite, thoughtful in his actions and of others feelings. He's generally happy and can get excited and doesn't get out of control the same as when he's sad, the moments he can have a wobble they last a minute or two but theres been no hint of throwing furniture or the like.

We obviously ask about it and he clams up. Hes gone from liking school to faking illness to try and stay home. There seems to be instances where because he now has a reputation a child has hurt him and he gets punished the same as the other child, and now even when he's good in the morning they take him out of the afternoon just in case he misbehaves so even when hes good he gets punished.

I'm not saying he's perfect but AIBU to think there's something happening at his school this year to make his behaviour so bad? how likely is it that he's so terrible at school but consistently does a 180 out of school for extended periods of time?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
frostedfruit · 20/03/2022 16:34

My son struggled like this at primary school. It started in reception and carried on until he left primary. I was beside myself with worry for 7 years and the school and I tried everything to find out what was going on: educational psychologist, 121 help outside school, Thrive for 7 years in school, nothing seemed to help. He was wonderful in all the 121 sessions, then reverted back to being disuptive and rude in the classroom.

Now in the first year at secondary he's like a different child. He's bright, sociable, well behaved. I think primary was too claustrophobic for him - the same 30 kids in one crowded room every day for 7 years. As a PP said, the classrooms are overloaded with information on every square inch of wallspace.

At secondary he has a 1 mile walk uphill to school, the buidling is large, bright and airy, the lessons are more diverse (just endless bloody SATS maths and english at primary), he walks from class to class between lessons, different tutors throughout the day, different pupils in each class.
He seems to be in his element.
He still talks a lot and gets detentions but nothing like the trouble he got into in primary.

I really hope your lad settles soon. However, if he doesn't, try not to panic like I did. It could just be that primary is too much and he'll be better at secondary.

User65412 · 20/03/2022 14:48

Sitting in a corridor with nothing is absolutely awful and I've never known a school do that to a child at primary let alone at just 6 years old. They would never get away with - the parents need to demand to see the head about that and the to talk through everything else to get him the help he needs.

Mumofsend · 20/03/2022 14:39

Got confused by the name change error.

The parents need to insist upon school acting appropriately in terms of identifying triggers and prevention rather than punishing him constantly.

My DD was a nightmare in R and first half of Y1 but with a lot of work on identifying the causes she is now doing amazingly. Simply punishing isn't enough to do anything meaningful towards change.

And to the PP said the problem is probably at home is at best ignorant and at worst down right nasty.

Blomme · 20/03/2022 14:35

@Morph22010 @yellowbridgebang
Thanks for your replies. Very sad to hear similar situations. Every year I seem to have to explain again that he's unable to explain /speak up for himself in school. It's so frustrating. Good to hear your kids are happy now.

FrustratedTeddyLamp · 20/03/2022 14:30

@User65412

Are you sure he's being taken out of class for an hour as punishment? That seems unusual at age 6. What's he doing in that hour? In my school, if we know a child finds the environment too stimulating and it will negatively impact their behaviour (which is often worse in the afternoon when there's less structure), they may be taken out for an hour to do a quiet activity they enjoy with a TA or a structured intervention that helps them with cope with different situations. What do the school say to his parents? Why do you look after him so much?
He was going to another teacher who made him do jobs but he LOVES doing jobs so he wasn't seeing it as a punishment. So now he's sitting in a corridor with nothing. As a teacher has said " they know he's bored as he's singing to himself".

We look after him due to his parents work schedules for an hour or two somedays

Morph22010 · 20/03/2022 14:26

@00100001

It's actually probably something at home

.

Why would you say that?
User65412 · 20/03/2022 14:20

Are you sure he's being taken out of class for an hour as punishment? That seems unusual at age 6. What's he doing in that hour?
In my school, if we know a child finds the environment too stimulating and it will negatively impact their behaviour (which is often worse in the afternoon when there's less structure), they may be taken out for an hour to do a quiet activity they enjoy with a TA or a structured intervention that helps them with cope with different situations.
What do the school say to his parents? Why do you look after him so much?

Morph22010 · 20/03/2022 14:16

Did they get the proper paperwork for the exclusion? Make sure they get that whenever he is excluded and there should be a reintegration meeting when he goes back, ask the school what they are going to put in place to avoid further exclusions. School might try and informally exclude and pretend they are doing you a favour so it doesn’t go down on his record but you need the exclusions to be formal to help in the long run and it’s actually the school that gets judged if they have a lot of exclusions so they sometimes don’t want them to be formal.

yellowbridgebang · 20/03/2022 14:16

@Blomme tbh, the school didn't. They were useless looking back. Ds was to blame for everything but once we knew he was autistic it was very easy to see why everything was falling apart for him at school.

He was placed in an autism specialist school and all the school based issues evaporated over night. He's thriving now rather than failing.

Morph22010 · 20/03/2022 14:12

[quote Blomme]@Morph22010 apologies, that question was for you. What did the school do to help him explain what had happened? How did he show/ tell his side of the story? Thanks.[/quote]
To be honest the school weren’t great and just automatically used to blame him if another child said he’d done something, things then sometimes used to come out later at home when he was calmer which indicated things werent quite like what they’d said or he did have one ta who worked with him who was amazing and he’d speak to. I was abit nieve early on and thought kids with Sen got help in school when needed but really looking back all his school ever wanted was to get him out. I ended up getting him an ehcp with full time 1-1 in mainstream but it still didn’t work out and he moved to specialist in year 4 which looking back was the best thing I ever did and wish I’d fought for it sooner

FrustratedTeddyLamp · 20/03/2022 14:07

Ahh seen that NC fail between OP and replies as went back on the app. But

I don't think the school are lying but I think there may be contributing factors and for example I can understand his upset if for example a child is mean to him and they both get punished and because when he's punished the procedure has become to take him out of the class, so he was taken out of the class for an hour because another child was mean to him.

It sounds Incredulous to me but it was checked with the teacher

Morph22010 · 20/03/2022 14:07

@FrustratedTeddyLamp

I haven't been in a children's classroom since I was a child. Would it really overload him sensually ( is that the right word?) Compared to say him, his brother and sister all playing loud? It gets louder when others come to visit as well and he's still generally fine.

They are thinking he could be autistic, I am mostly uninformed but I would have assumed there would be behavioural issues at other times if that was the cause?

My son struggles more when there is a lot of noise at same time, rather than just say one or two children being loud like at home. I don’t think he can focus onto the one sound say like we would do if we were chatting to someone in a busy pub for example so he hears everything at once, that’s what’s overwhelming. At that age we didn’t see any extreme behaviours outside of school although things have escalated as he’s got older
Blomme · 20/03/2022 14:05

@Morph22010 apologies, that question was for you. What did the school do to help him explain what had happened? How did he show/ tell his side of the story? Thanks.

BluebellStreet · 20/03/2022 14:02

Do you think the school are lying? Or that they are doing something to set off this behaviour?

Blomme · 20/03/2022 14:00

@yellowbridgebang Please could you tell me what steps the school took to help your son? Especially explaining when an incident has occurred in the playground? We've having similar issues at the moment. Son was told off last week for pushing other kids away, the reason was that they'd really hurt him (slamming him to the ground, scratching up his face etc) but he is unable to explain.

FrustratedTeddyLamp · 20/03/2022 13:58

@BluebellStreet

It's not that there is something 'going on' at school, it's that you can't compare the two situations at all.

Do you make him sit down and listen while you read a book about Florence Nightingale?
If he says he wants a drink if water do you say 'no, not until we've done speed sounds for three minutes'?
Do you have 24 other children bumbling around the place?
Do you ring loud bells and then make him line up and go into an even more boring room and listen to a woman talking about Noah's ark?

No obviously not and I try to be impartial as possible as I know it's obvious I'd have bias to see the best in him but I'd just expect to see some of the behavioural issues but see no similar issues
Whatafielddayfortheheat · 20/03/2022 13:57

This is actually fairly typical of ND children OP, school is sensory overload often.

BluebellStreet · 20/03/2022 13:56

It's not that there is something 'going on' at school, it's that you can't compare the two situations at all.

Do you make him sit down and listen while you read a book about Florence Nightingale?
If he says he wants a drink if water do you say 'no, not until we've done speed sounds for three minutes'?
Do you have 24 other children bumbling around the place?
Do you ring loud bells and then make him line up and go into an even more boring room and listen to a woman talking about Noah's ark?

Blossombouquet · 20/03/2022 13:50

I agree he could find school overwhelming.

Are school actively trying to work with you to get to the cause of it?

Have they mentioned any possibility of neurodiversity?

My eldest would find it desperately hard to be treated differently to everyone else.

Can you change schools? Give him the opportunity for a fresh start?

FrustratedTeddyLamp · 20/03/2022 13:49

@Comedycook

Why do you look after him several times a week? Are there problems at home?
No problems at home, just different working schedules have meant at different times there's been gaps in childcare and I'm free at those times.
TeenPlusCat · 20/03/2022 13:48

I think that what can happen is families of ND children make adjustments for their child without hardly realising it. My DD2 doesn't like noisy busy places - so guess what - we don't choose to go to cities, shopping centres etc except on rare occasions. At home both my DDs needed routine and clear boundaries, so that's what we did.

Comedycook · 20/03/2022 13:46

Why do you look after him several times a week? Are there problems at home?

00100001 · 20/03/2022 13:43

It's actually probably something at home

.

Pinkflipflop85 · 20/03/2022 13:43

@FrustratedTeddyLamp

I haven't been in a children's classroom since I was a child. Would it really overload him sensually ( is that the right word?) Compared to say him, his brother and sister all playing loud? It gets louder when others come to visit as well and he's still generally fine.

They are thinking he could be autistic, I am mostly uninformed but I would have assumed there would be behavioural issues at other times if that was the cause?

Classrooms are overwhelming places. There can be times when 30 children are all talking. There are different colours all over the wall with all sorts of different information. Some classrooms will also have things hanging from the ceiling. The interactive whiteboard is a constant visual. The chairs can be uncomfortable, the carpet can be uncomfortable. Uniform can be uncomfortable.

Demands are constantly being put on you as a child and there is no escape.

TeenPlusCat · 20/03/2022 13:41

Classroom have very busy walls.
They have 30 children and a couple of adults.
The adults randomly make you stop what you were in the middle of to do something else.
Other children bug you by being noisy, or taking the pencil you want, or pushing in front of you.
Possibly bright lighting.
Strange smells too.