Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

World Suffering... Why?

59 replies

Burgoo · 20/03/2022 12:19

I wanted people's thoughts on this as I have wrestled with it recently.

I went with a family member to a church she wanted to attend. I am atheistic though went to church from 10-15 years of age and wanted to be supportive and find out whether it'd feel different as an adult.

The minister started by mentioning Ukraine and then moved on to how God has a master plan, that he is good, he is almighty and he is merciful. He went on saying that children of Christ will be with him and the rest of us will perish.

I sat there thinking "God is merciful? Tell that to my Aunt who died horrifically of cancer, or the kids being bombed in Yemen and Ukraine".

So! Firstly, what do people think? Is it a reasonable response to have or am I missing something? For those who are church goers please do feel free to explain because I feel that either 1) god isn't real 2) god is real and can't intervene (in which case what use is he) or 3) god can intervene but opts not to or actively harms children.

Thanks in advance!

OP posts:
DirectionToPerfection · 21/03/2022 08:08

Honestly, I find it strange that people actually believe God has a job to do of making life wonderful for everyone, it's rather simplistic and child-like to think that way.

To many of us it seems rather simplistic and childlike to believe in God at all.

AlexaShutUp · 21/03/2022 07:20

It's one of the fundamental problems of religion, I think. People tie themselves in knots trying to explain why there is so much suffering in the world but nobody has yet managed to come up with a plausible explanation. The get out clause that people fall back on is usually that God must have a grand plan and that we're just incapable of understanding it. Pretty unconvincing, I think, but I guess it gives some people comfort.

For me, there are only 3 logical explanations, as you say OP. The first is that God doesn't actually have the power to prevent human suffering. Given that he supposedly created the world, this seems to be a bit of a design flaw - did he fuck up at the beginning and then find that he couldn't fix the problem? The second is that he doesn't give a shit and/or is actually vindictive and enjoys to watch people suffering. The third is that he doesn't exist.

I know which I believe. What I don't understand is how people can continue to believe in the idea of an all-powerful, merciful deity who allows the suffering to continue. As a pp has said, even if you go down the route of saying that he allowed humans free will so they have to be allowed to fuck up, it still doesn't explain all the suffering from natural causes, e.g. sickness, natural disasters etc. There is no logical or believable explanation for this, no matter how hard people try to justify it.

I guess for some people, it helps them to believe that their suffering is all part of a grander plan. For me, I can't help but wonder who would make such a shit plan. 🤔

Parker231 · 21/03/2022 06:49

As a friend said ‘I don’t get this faith stuff - it doesn’t do anything good - a waste of space!’

LadyCordeliaFitzgerald · 21/03/2022 06:34

I can’t cope with man- religion any more. I sit in church now (mainly for funerals these days) and bristle at the gaslighting “the truth will set you free” eh?

I think there’s huge value in stories and narrative as a way to make sense of our existence, and I think it’s wise to pay close attention to the stories we tell because they shape both our understanding of the world and our interaction with it.

But I don’t understand why we can’t just accept that there’s a difference between symbol-rich stories and objective scientific fact. Pretending they’re the same is weird.

I’m sadly cynical these days and “don’t worry there’s a master plan” sounds a lot like “don’t despair and give up, because I might not have a job”

girlmom21 · 21/03/2022 06:26

Has anyone ever heard this before? I quite like it. It pretty much fits what I was trying to say.

SquirrelG · 21/03/2022 05:59

I don’t believe in a Christian god but I do believe in deity as part of a different faith. I don’t believe that gods/deities bring about the suffering because humans do that, and we have free will.

I'm not religious but I do sometimes wonder if 'God' created what we needed to survive and then left us to our own devices - like surely it's not God's place who decides who gets to live or die; they've given us the materials we need to create cures etc, we just haven't found them yet.

I agree with both these posts. Honestly, I find it strange that people actually believe God has a job to do of making life wonderful for everyone, it's rather simplistic and child-like to think that way.

Hawkins001 · 21/03/2022 01:46

@Burgoo

I wanted people's thoughts on this as I have wrestled with it recently.

I went with a family member to a church she wanted to attend. I am atheistic though went to church from 10-15 years of age and wanted to be supportive and find out whether it'd feel different as an adult.

The minister started by mentioning Ukraine and then moved on to how God has a master plan, that he is good, he is almighty and he is merciful. He went on saying that children of Christ will be with him and the rest of us will perish.

I sat there thinking "God is merciful? Tell that to my Aunt who died horrifically of cancer, or the kids being bombed in Yemen and Ukraine".

So! Firstly, what do people think? Is it a reasonable response to have or am I missing something? For those who are church goers please do feel free to explain because I feel that either 1) god isn't real 2) god is real and can't intervene (in which case what use is he) or 3) god can intervene but opts not to or actively harms children.

Thanks in advance!

As I understand it, humans wrote various religions in books, therefore they are a product of human creation, therefore even if their was a god, or advanced being, how can we know their true purposes, if we have to rely texts that were written, 're written, translated ect by humans ? Plus when the church changes or 're interpreting the word of God then how can it be God's orders ect ?
Smokeahontas · 21/03/2022 01:36

We can explain the universe, Big Bang etc. There is no evidence that a deity created it. I can’t believe something I have no evidence for.

If I go to a foreign country, I have to produce my passport to prove who I am. I can’t say ‘I’m Smokeahontas and you’ll just have to believe that cos it says so in a very old book’. There is no shred of evidence that proves there is a god.

Hugasauras · 21/03/2022 01:18

Stephen Fry had a take on this when asked what he would say to God.

"How dare you create a world in which there is such misery that is not our fault? It’s not right.
“It’s utterly, utterly evil. Why should I respect a capricious, mean-minded, stupid God who creates a world which is so full of injustice and pain?”
Pressed by Byrne over how he would react if he was locked outside the pearly gates, Fry says: “I would say: ‘bone cancer in children? What’s that about?’
“Because the God who created this universe, if it was created by God, is quite clearly a maniac, utter maniac. Totally selfish. We have to spend our life on our knees thanking him?! What kind of god would do that?”
On how to explain the wonders of the world, Fry then launches an another attack on all seeing, all knowing God creator.
“Yes, the world is very splendid but it also has in it insects whose whole lifecycle is to burrow into the eyes of children and make them blind. They eat outwards from the eyes. Why? Why did you do that to us? You could easily have made a creation in which that didn’t exist. It is simply not acceptable.
“It’s perfectly apparent that he is monstrous. Utterly monstrous and deserves no respect whatsoever. The moment you banish him, life becomes simpler, purer, cleaner, more worth living in my opinion.”'

RicherThanYew · 21/03/2022 00:50

@Tryingtoexplain That was nicely said, thank you.

Tryingtoexplain · 21/03/2022 00:26

Ok so Christianity in a nutshell.
Our world is broken and it’s not as God intended it to be as a result of our rebellion. We have free will to choose how to behave and the further we move away from Him and live for self the worse it all becomes.
Christianity is not a religion it’s a faith - in all other religions you are the one doing things to try and get into heaven, or achieve acceptance, and who knows if it’s good enough. We can never be good enough, or behave well enough for heaven. It’s a perfect place and we are all essentially flawed. With Christianity it’s different in that a thing was done for us out of love- Jesus who was God in human form was a sacrifice to pay for our wrong doing should we choose to accept him. He came to seek and save the lost and the broken -to save us from spending an eternity separated from God.
Suffering in this world is inevitable because of the brokenness of it all and that includes disease, war, famine the whole lot, but it’s what happens after this life that is the important thing. We are here for such a short time compared with eternity after.
I know that people are likely to come back and say look at all the bad things that have been done in the name of Christianity, and you’d be right to say that, but these are essentially evil people using the name of Christianity for selfish gain. Again living for self.

GreenNewDealNow · 20/03/2022 23:32

Suffering is a mystery. That's true whether you believe in God or not.

secretllama · 20/03/2022 19:24

Agree... i just cannot understand someone who can believe in an all loving/all powerful God that let's children die slowly of cancer.

Ownedbymycats · 20/03/2022 19:20

@DogandMog
What a beautiful and thought provoking quote.

RandomBasic · 20/03/2022 19:07

If you were sitting on a bench and saw a baby drowning in the pond next to you would you just watch and say, 'so sad.'?

If you saw someone come up to a little old lady and push her over as they snatched her purse, would you just watch her lying there for 3 hours until she died?

If you saw an infant being abused would you just sit and watch?

That's what the so called God does. Sit and watch. Because there's a plan.

Yeah, no thanks. Take that plan and shove it.

Theworkhouse · 20/03/2022 14:07

No, God as invented by humans does not exist. All religion has been invented by humans and therefore is nonsense.

However I do believe in some kind of life force, or Chi, or the Universe, or Mother Earth or something that we don't understand. And I do think that the soul or spirit or whatever carries on after death. I just don't think that as humans we can possibly understand it. But I don't believe it goes around saving people or curing cancer.

stairgates · 20/03/2022 14:05

I wonder if God created the earth, and if you follow his rules and go to heaven, did all the cavemen go to hell because they couldnt read and hadnt been given the book yet?

TheKeatingFive · 20/03/2022 14:02

Humans desperately want to believe that there's a righteous, kind, all powerful person in the sky directing operations, but pretty much nothing about the reality of human existence suggests that it's true.

axolotlfloof · 20/03/2022 14:00

I remember someone who survived the same illness that my Mum recently died of saying "I feel that God has saved me".

Does that mean God looked at my Mum and decided not to bother?

Loopytiles · 20/03/2022 13:55

Am an atheist so would just regard in the light of the person leading the service seeking to make sense of awful things. I’d disagree with their analysis!

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 20/03/2022 13:40

God believers tie themselves up in knots trying to explain this, but it never makes sense.

My sil used to believe that praying for a parking space would mean that God would grant her one 🙄 presumably because she really deserves to have her prayer wish granted whereas all the starving, trafficked, abused, neglected, sick and stricken people out there, don't.

You couldn't make it up......Only it is made up, so there's your answer. 'God' is merely an extension of a humans ego.

CorneliusVetch · 20/03/2022 13:34

I’m not especially religious, but theologically this is wrong:

If heaven is only for those who never sinned, it must be an empty place

It isn’t for those who have never sinned; Christianity teaches Jesus died for our sins, and by faith in Jesus Christians can enter heaven.

Eloradannin2nd · 20/03/2022 13:33

I think I really stopped believing at a grandparents funeral. The vicar said that they were in "a better place" . What, a better place than here surrounded by their family who loved them and grieved their loss?

girlmom21 · 20/03/2022 13:29

@BrightYellowDaffodil

I don’t believe in a Christian god but I do believe in deity as part of a different faith. I don’t believe that gods/deities bring about the suffering because humans do that, and we have free will.
This. I'm not religious but I do sometimes wonder if 'God' created what we needed to survive and then left us to our own devices - like surely it's not God's place who decides who gets to live or die; they've given us the materials we need to create cures etc, we just haven't found them yet.
BrightYellowDaffodil · 20/03/2022 13:26

I don’t believe in a Christian god but I do believe in deity as part of a different faith. I don’t believe that gods/deities bring about the suffering because humans do that, and we have free will.

Swipe left for the next trending thread