Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

World Suffering... Why?

59 replies

Burgoo · 20/03/2022 12:19

I wanted people's thoughts on this as I have wrestled with it recently.

I went with a family member to a church she wanted to attend. I am atheistic though went to church from 10-15 years of age and wanted to be supportive and find out whether it'd feel different as an adult.

The minister started by mentioning Ukraine and then moved on to how God has a master plan, that he is good, he is almighty and he is merciful. He went on saying that children of Christ will be with him and the rest of us will perish.

I sat there thinking "God is merciful? Tell that to my Aunt who died horrifically of cancer, or the kids being bombed in Yemen and Ukraine".

So! Firstly, what do people think? Is it a reasonable response to have or am I missing something? For those who are church goers please do feel free to explain because I feel that either 1) god isn't real 2) god is real and can't intervene (in which case what use is he) or 3) god can intervene but opts not to or actively harms children.

Thanks in advance!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WeCouldBeSpearows · 21/03/2022 17:58

Other advanced beings that knew genetic engineering

You missed the second question - who created them?

Hawkins001 · 21/03/2022 17:49

@WeCouldBeSpearows

But if we are all part of a simulated universe, who created it, and who created them?
Other advanced beings that knew genetic engineering
BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 21/03/2022 15:29

'If triangles had a god, it would have three sides'

Montesquieu

MistyGreenAndBlue · 21/03/2022 14:01

"God is a kid with an ant farm" - Constantine.

DogandMog · 21/03/2022 12:46

Another quote from Brothers Karamazov which sums up my philosophy and why I'm straddling paganism and Christianity:

“Love all God’s creation, both the whole and every grain of sand. Love every leaf, every ray of light. Love the animals, love the plants, love each separate thing. If thou love each thing thou wilt perceive the mystery of God in all; and when once thou perceive this, thou wilt thenceforward grow every day to a fuller understanding of it: until thou come at last to love the whole world with a love that will then be all-embracing and universal.”

***

"I think that using the word love is just too sappy, they don’t want to use the word love because that’s it, that’s the key, that love is the key to everything you know, and that’s the christian answer. That the world exists through love, and God is love, and god and love is that possibility for things to be in communion and one and multiple at the same time. And that goes all the way up into the trinity as the transcendent example of that existence in love"

Jonathan Pageau (sorry it reads a bit clunky, I transcribed it from youtube from the "Panpsychism and Logos" video)

DogandMog · 21/03/2022 12:14

I’m an ex-pagan @WeCouldBeSpearows. I’m kind of transitioning from pantheist (god is everywhere) to panentheist/panpsychist (god is immanent and transcendent; consciousness is an emergent property of matter). I also really agree with @tryingtoexplain ‘s post, but I’m more of a McGilchristian than a Christian.

channelmcgilchrist.com/the-matter-with-things/

I had a full mystical experience of God recently, which was profoundly healing, and also allowed me to see the full experience of human suffering, and God loving that into full remission... hence the Dostoevsky quote I posted on page one of the thread, which was uncanny to discover not long after my experience. I’m currently reading about Eastern Orthodoxy, but I think I’m too pagan to be Christian and too Christian to be pagan 😁

Motherdare · 21/03/2022 12:03

I believe there is something else, something bigger than us and beyond us. I believe all religions are trying in their own way to connect with that force, that otherness. I believe that how I live on earth and how I treat others will affect my understanding of that world beyond this one, when my time comes. Believing in something more is a comfort. I do not understand or have a clear belief in what it is or how it impacts the good or bad things that happen on earth. No-one does. Praying for me is a moment of quietness, organising thoughts, sending “good intentions” out into the universe. Feeling a small connection to the person I am praying for. It’s personal. I don’t expect others to see it the same way. I don’t need them to. I was raised a Catholic but I do not believe in many of the specifics of the Church. I attend Mass sometimes because I get a lot out of the stillness, the contemplation, the oneness, the hope and intention for good over evil.

I have no expectations of “God” therefore I don’t accept or reject “God” because of the things I see on earth.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 21/03/2022 11:49

I'm not a believer, but if you do believe then God gave us "free will". That means we make choices - we choose to start a war, use chemicals that give us cancer, etc. You can lead a Christian life but your life also depends on other people's decisions, who may not believe in a God.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 21/03/2022 11:48

But if we are all part of a simulated universe, who created it, and who created them?

WeCouldBeSpearows · 21/03/2022 11:46

So is your belief in God is more akin to a Pagan's belief in, say, mother nature, @DogandMog, than the more commonly espoused view of an omipotent, all-good creator?

Nicholethejewellery · 21/03/2022 11:39

Most "gods" are nothing of the sort, by definition most religions must be wrong because they are not the true one. Humans generally need to believe in some kind of supreme power because they cannot comprehend how existence began. Even if you believe in the big bang and evolution, how life was originally created and what created the matter that needed to exist for the big bang to happen is a mystery.

The likelihood is that we're living in a simulation of course. Assuming some "real" species has the ability to create a realistic simulation of a universe, it's inevitable that the simulated entities will eventually create simulations of their own. Therefore not only is it possible we're part of a simulated reality, it's actually almost certain.

This goes a long way to explain why humans create false gods. Because we can't understand how our universe came to be (someone turning on a computer and pressing "run") we either create all powerful deities to explain it or come up with outlandish theories that can never be proven. Our very existence came from nothing - but we're incapable of understanding how something can come from nothing.

The simulation theory also explains all the bad things that happen. Even in our reality someone might fire up "Sim City" and eventually get bored of growing and expanding their city and decide to inflict an earthquake on their citizens, or let a nuclear power plant blow up. They wouldn't feel any guilt because they know the simulation isn't real. Why would the entity powering our own simulation necessarily feel any different?

TwuntyFriend · 21/03/2022 11:27

@Tryingtoexplain

Ok so Christianity in a nutshell. Our world is broken and it’s not as God intended it to be as a result of our rebellion. We have free will to choose how to behave and the further we move away from Him and live for self the worse it all becomes. Christianity is not a religion it’s a faith - in all other religions you are the one doing things to try and get into heaven, or achieve acceptance, and who knows if it’s good enough. We can never be good enough, or behave well enough for heaven. It’s a perfect place and we are all essentially flawed. With Christianity it’s different in that a thing was done for us out of love- Jesus who was God in human form was a sacrifice to pay for our wrong doing should we choose to accept him. He came to seek and save the lost and the broken -to save us from spending an eternity separated from God. Suffering in this world is inevitable because of the brokenness of it all and that includes disease, war, famine the whole lot, but it’s what happens after this life that is the important thing. We are here for such a short time compared with eternity after. I know that people are likely to come back and say look at all the bad things that have been done in the name of Christianity, and you’d be right to say that, but these are essentially evil people using the name of Christianity for selfish gain. Again living for self.
Actually couldn't have written this better myself. Perfect.
DogandMog · 21/03/2022 11:11

How can consciousness and life forces and processes emerge in a cold, dark, inert, mechanical universe? IMO, there’s an underlying dynamic divine spark that brings consciousness and animation to matter. The wonder and mystery of the universe and its source is where God is. God isn’t some über-Santa Claus in his toy workshop, carefully crafting every single eyeball, pancreas, chloroplast and sea anemone (and sometimes fucking up a creation). God simply allowed that life and consciousness emerged out of his primordial cosmogonic divine love, and everything cascaded out of that fractally, leading to the diversity of matter, consciousness, patterns and arrays here and now.

DirectionToPerfection · 21/03/2022 11:04

Comparing the existence of God to the existence of French culture is a new one.

We have evidence of the existence of the French language, French cuisine, French music, theatre, literature, etc. If we want to see how French people interact with each other we can go and observe them! So no, France is not just a concept. 😂

MissyB1 · 21/03/2022 11:03

@Tryingtoexplain

Ok so Christianity in a nutshell. Our world is broken and it’s not as God intended it to be as a result of our rebellion. We have free will to choose how to behave and the further we move away from Him and live for self the worse it all becomes. Christianity is not a religion it’s a faith - in all other religions you are the one doing things to try and get into heaven, or achieve acceptance, and who knows if it’s good enough. We can never be good enough, or behave well enough for heaven. It’s a perfect place and we are all essentially flawed. With Christianity it’s different in that a thing was done for us out of love- Jesus who was God in human form was a sacrifice to pay for our wrong doing should we choose to accept him. He came to seek and save the lost and the broken -to save us from spending an eternity separated from God. Suffering in this world is inevitable because of the brokenness of it all and that includes disease, war, famine the whole lot, but it’s what happens after this life that is the important thing. We are here for such a short time compared with eternity after. I know that people are likely to come back and say look at all the bad things that have been done in the name of Christianity, and you’d be right to say that, but these are essentially evil people using the name of Christianity for selfish gain. Again living for self.
Phew! Someone who can explain much better than I can! Yes this sums up how I view it.
73kittycat73 · 21/03/2022 10:59

@Thatswhyimacat

Option 4. We really do live in a simulation and God is a Sims player. Some of us he works to get us to the top of the career track and the top priced TV, some of us he puts in the swimming pool and takes out the ladder.
Amazing quote, as a Sims player, made me chuckle. Grin
73kittycat73 · 21/03/2022 10:58

I struggle with the concept of end of days. There's lots of destruction, suffering and perishing. I can't believe a loving God would do that?

Thatswhyimacat · 21/03/2022 10:55

@DogandMog that sounds less like free will and more like serious design flaws.

Thatswhyimacat · 21/03/2022 10:53

Option 4. We really do live in a simulation and God is a Sims player. Some of us he works to get us to the top of the career track and the top priced TV, some of us he puts in the swimming pool and takes out the ladder.

CannaBelieve · 21/03/2022 10:43

I feel 'god' ( and I include all gods/religions here) is a mythical MALE ...created by MALES

He is there to promise us all heaven a good place to go when dead so that then leaves the earth MALES free to perform all sorts of violence/inhumane acts at free will because the deal is we all go to a better place eventually

We are being taken for a ride

WeCouldBeSpearows · 21/03/2022 10:34

How does our existing prove that God exists?

If it's just that everything needs a creator, then who created god?

DogandMog · 21/03/2022 09:50

God is real and eternal, the existence of existence and consciousness is evidence of God, ie existence and consciousness are synonymous with God, yet also transcends beyond. Christianity is merely a human medium to relate with God, so it’s like other human patterns and creations. Is “France” real? The landmass in that place obviously exists. France exists as a concept about how the people in that region relate to that “terroir” and each other with a common purpose.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 21/03/2022 09:22

Christianity is hundreds of years younger than other religions, so how can it be real?

AlexaShutUp · 21/03/2022 09:18

@DirectionToPerfection

Honestly, I find it strange that people actually believe God has a job to do of making life wonderful for everyone, it's rather simplistic and child-like to think that way.

To many of us it seems rather simplistic and childlike to believe in God at all.

Well, quite.
DogandMog · 21/03/2022 08:11

The thing about suffering from “natural” causes is that they most often have an unnatural root cause.

Earthquakes would still occur of course, but it’s the context in which they occur that makes them deadly. If we lived in simple tiny dwellings, eg mud huts or strawbale roundhouses, they’d be able to withstand earthquakes much better. Traditional Japanese building techniques did this. Brick, concrete and glass apartment buildings, office blocks, multistory carparks and houses are a catastrophe in an earthquake.

Likewise the plasmodium parasite causing malaria. It is part of natural existence of course, but it only became a problem when humans modified and destroyed the natural environment and it became massively out of balance. Pre-civilisation, central Italy and the hills around what would become Rome were heavily forested. Early tribes people lived on the land, unplagued by malaria, as the mosquitoes couldn’t get a foothold in the ecological niches. Then the city developed, trees were cleared, the soil washed from the hillsides and the Tiber became swampland... and as more and more people flocked to the city, the mosquitoes did too with their plasmodium parasites. The life expectancy of a newcomer to Rome was only about 18 months.

So, much of the phenomena of suffering is actually contextual... upon the unnatural ways we live our lives, rather than the fundamental processes of life and physical existence themselves. Cell division has to occur for life to exist in the first place, yet it can easily be triggered into being triggered to go out of control and start the cancer process. Many aspects of modern life are carcinogenic... higher levels of background radiation due to nuclear accidents and testing, flame retardant chemicals, agricultural pesticides, vehicular pollution etc etc. They’re arguably a necessary, intrinsic part of modern industrial life, but that is also where the world cracks open and the suffering falls in, alongside all the benefits, comforts and opportunities that industrial civilisation provides us.