Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To STILL not want to downsize?

216 replies

toconclude · 20/03/2022 11:43

Live in Victorian smallish semi - technically 4 bed but three bedrooms are singles and DH uses one as a study and always has. Downstairs bathroom which we've managed with so far.
Ongoing options are: convert one bed to bathroom so one on each floor - then as we get older would improve safety (currently average age late 60s)
Or downsize to smaller bungalow. In our town that means almost inevitably spending more money as land is pricey, and getting rid of DHs bulky Edwardian heirloom furniture
Also would lose my lovely neighbours of many years and my lovely garden.
Have already given both kids significant lump sum towards buying their own house.
A reaction to a comment in another thread about selfish boomers "hoarding" family houses.
Don't feel like a hoarder but maybe we are😳🤷

OP posts:
BanjoKnickers · 20/03/2022 12:55

I think that taxing people who choose to stay put in a home that they own, and have paid for (or are paying for) with money that has already been taxed at least once, is just unfair.

It's an interesting question of tax ethics I think.

There's a good argument that home owners have a huge unfair tax advantage in that their capital (the house) produces very valuable income (rent-free accommodation) that goes untaxed. Compare that with someone who has their capital in some other assets like shares. The income (dividends) are taxed.

Like I said, we'd be down sizing toot sweet if a system like that was brought in, and I do think overall it would be fairer (and better for a host of other reasons) to shift the tax burden away from earned income towards asset ownership.

bellac11 · 20/03/2022 12:55

@fogglez

Not sure why anyone 'young' should feel bitter about this.

I understand that some feel resentful when they are paying a lot of tax, seeing their pension age move out & pay very high housing costs. I don't think it's rocket science. I think the NI hike is wrong personally.

I don't personally know anyone who bought with an inheritance apart from one person - who points out that they'd rather not have been orphaned in their late 20s.

And I don't know anyone including myself who didn't have help. Plus people don't have to die to give help & plenty lose parents & have no inheritance.

Ive never had help to buy any of my homes.
bellac11 · 20/03/2022 12:54

@Gowithme

If you downsize you'll be buying a smaller cheaper house that a first time buyer would be more likely to be able to afford so to me it wouldn't make any sense. Anyway you bought and paid for that house so you can 'hoard' it all you like
Bungelows are much more expensive for fewer rooms.
MayMorris · 20/03/2022 12:51

@GeneLovesJezebel

Well that’s what my DM plans to do when the time comes, live entirely downstairs. She says the only time she is leaving her home is in a box 🤣
You must be my dc! I moved here last year and said it’s my “carry me out in a box” home. Or at least when I don’t know I’m being carried out or where I am It wasnt a true downsize but has ground floor bedroom and bathroom I can use when I can’t manage stairs
GeneLovesJezebel · 20/03/2022 12:50

We had no help to buy our house. And I wouldn’t have asked for help.

fogglez · 20/03/2022 12:49

Not sure why anyone 'young' should feel bitter about this.

I understand that some feel resentful when they are paying a lot of tax, seeing their pension age move out & pay very high housing costs. I don't think it's rocket science. I think the NI hike is wrong personally.

I don't personally know anyone who bought with an inheritance apart from one person - who points out that they'd rather not have been orphaned in their late 20s.

And I don't know anyone including myself who didn't have help. Plus people don't have to die to give help & plenty lose parents & have no inheritance.

GeneLovesJezebel · 20/03/2022 12:48

I’ve looked at bungalows where I live, and intend to stay, and I’d have to pay more to move to one.
So I’m staying, as I love where I live.

RewildingAmbridge · 20/03/2022 12:48

If you could potentially live in the downstairs rooms stay put. My grandparents have a converted bungalow advertised as a 3 bed with a downstairs bathroom, they used to have two large doubles upstairs but put a shower room in so now have one large room and one perfectly good sized double and upstairs toilet/shower. Downstairs they have kitchen, big bathroom, living room, a brick conservatory/sunroom that they use as a casual dining room mostly and a formal dining room/hobby room (advertised as third bedroom). When my grandad was unwell that last room became his bedroom. He passed away and my gran now lives there alone. She has no intention of moving as the house works for her even if a time comes when she can't make use of upstairs, it's still good for guests or even carers should that be needed. She also has lovely neighbours and a social life built around the small market town. Why on earth should she move?

godmum56 · 20/03/2022 12:47

@BanjoKnickers

I don't understand the reluctance to pay SD if downsizing as the vast majority will have made far more than that in gains over the decades.

It's one factor among many to think about when you're moving. If there are other factors that outweigh it, then I guess you move. But if there aren't (and you basically like where you live) then you stay. It will inevitably affect decisions at the margins.

It's well-documented that taxation affects decisions and behaviours. If in aggregate we want to encourage or discourage certain behaviour then changing the tax system is a good way to do it. It can be neutral as to the total tax take. Eg cut stamp duty for downsizers, pay for it by taxing those staying put.

Its not about what you make in gains over the years. Its about what your new place and the costs of moving will cost. If the new place doesn't cost significantly less than the one you live in and the existing one still suits you, or can be made to suit you, then why move and lose money? For many people there will be reasons not to move as well as plain old not wanting to and I think that taxing people who choose to stay put in a home that they own, and have paid for (or are paying for) with money that has already been taxed at least once, is just unfair.
MadMadMadamMim · 20/03/2022 12:45

Will you inherit anything? Will your parents circumnavigate IHT? Personally I think that's a big issue, some inherit lots but others don't & for many an inheritance is the only way to get on the ladder. Plus against the backdrop of very high taxes I do understand why the young may feel resentful tbh

Who knows? They may outlive me. I have some health issues. They may end up with dementia/needing care and the care home fees will likely swallow up any spare money.

I will have paid off a 30 year mortgage before I see a penny of it, anyway, (and have several siblings) so if an inheritance had been the only way to get on the property ladder I'd have been retired before being able to buy. Not sure why anyone 'young' should feel bitter about this. I don't personally know anyone who bought with an inheritance apart from one person - who points out that they'd rather not have been orphaned in their late 20s.

woodhill · 20/03/2022 12:44

@MadMadMadamMim

Agree with those saying the word 'boomer' is so insulting.

I'm mid 50s, so actually miss out on being a 'boomer' by a couple of years or so - but frankly people can fuck off to the far side of fuck if they think I owe them my home after all my years of work.

The idea that old people who won't fuck off and die or crawl off to somewhere smaller and let others have their home once they are deemed as old and useless is the MOST selfish and entitled attitude I've ever come across.

My parents (mis 80s) are still alive and in the large family home they've lived in for 50 plus years. They have no intention of going through the stress of moving house to gratify some entitled stranger who is eyeing up their home.

So does my dm and mil and I totally agree with you.
MichaelAndEagle · 20/03/2022 12:43

@Gowithme

If you downsize you'll be buying a smaller cheaper house that a first time buyer would be more likely to be able to afford so to me it wouldn't make any sense. Anyway you bought and paid for that house so you can 'hoard' it all you like
I agree. I'm trying to get on the housing ladder now after a few years renting and twice lost out to a cash buyer, which could well be a downsizer although I don't know that obviously.

Surely more of an issue is how many families could afford these large family homes even if they did become available?
These problems are systemic and not up to individuals to solve imo.

fogglez · 20/03/2022 12:43

It's well-documented that taxation affects decisions and behaviours.

And yet the gov are going ahead with the tax band freezes & tax hike.

fallfallfall · 20/03/2022 12:37

Boomer bashing and home ownership bashing is a sport on MN, don’t feel guilty over history.

BanjoKnickers · 20/03/2022 12:36

I don't understand the reluctance to pay SD if downsizing as the vast majority will have made far more than that in gains over the decades.

It's one factor among many to think about when you're moving. If there are other factors that outweigh it, then I guess you move. But if there aren't (and you basically like where you live) then you stay. It will inevitably affect decisions at the margins.

It's well-documented that taxation affects decisions and behaviours. If in aggregate we want to encourage or discourage certain behaviour then changing the tax system is a good way to do it. It can be neutral as to the total tax take. Eg cut stamp duty for downsizers, pay for it by taxing those staying put.

fogglez · 20/03/2022 12:35

@toconclude Yes obviously it's location specific but many do downsize to smaller & cheaper homes. I paid a load to move up the ladder & certainly resent it but it would certainly be more palatable if I had a shit ton of equity.

toconclude · 20/03/2022 12:34

@Calmdown14

Live however you want but do agree a bit of future proofing is wise. I'm that respect, having a downstairs bathroom is great. If you don't want to lose a bedroom, is there a large former airing cupboard or space that might accommodate a toilet and sink? We have a downstairs bathroom which we prefer but managed to fit a toilet and basin in a cupboard on landing that is only 1m by 1m. Door opened outwards which helped It did need a macerator for fall height but for a pee in the middle of the night it's made a great different without sacrificing a bedroom
Sadly no. It's really a small "artisans dwelling" with two modern extensions the 'landing' is a short narrow corridor
OP posts:
FeelFreeNotToAnswer · 20/03/2022 12:34

Nobody needs to downsize if they don't want to and you are lucky if you don't need to. We are making our house bigger while we can afford to in our 30s with the express intention of downsizing in our 60s as we refuse to work until we are at deaths door.

fogglez · 20/03/2022 12:33

My parents (mis 80s) are still alive and in the large family home they've lived in for 50 plus years. They have no intention of going through the stress of moving house to gratify some entitled stranger who is eyeing up their home.

Will you inherit anything? Will your parents circumnavigate IHT? Personally I think that's a big issue, some inherit lots but others don't & for many an inheritance is the only way to get on the ladder. Plus against the backdrop of very high taxes I do understand why the young may feel resentful tbh.

toconclude · 20/03/2022 12:32

@fogglez

If we do want older people to free up larger houses then they need either a carrot (some stamp duty exemption) or a stick (annual property tax as a percentage of the value of the home - that would have us out in a jiffy

I don't understand the reluctance to pay SD if downsizing as the vast majority will have made far more than that in gains over the decades.

The property tax is interesting and normal in other countries.

Because you still have to live somewhere and the prices of those properties have also risen. As I said, price of small bungalow around here is higher than value of our house
OP posts:
Calmdown14 · 20/03/2022 12:32

Live however you want but do agree a bit of future proofing is wise.
I'm that respect, having a downstairs bathroom is great.
If you don't want to lose a bedroom, is there a large former airing cupboard or space that might accommodate a toilet and sink?
We have a downstairs bathroom which we prefer but managed to fit a toilet and basin in a cupboard on landing that is only 1m by 1m. Door opened outwards which helped
It did need a macerator for fall height but for a pee in the middle of the night it's made a great different without sacrificing a bedroom

Gowithme · 20/03/2022 12:31

If you downsize you'll be buying a smaller cheaper house that a first time buyer would be more likely to be able to afford so to me it wouldn't make any sense. Anyway you bought and paid for that house so you can 'hoard' it all you like

toconclude · 20/03/2022 12:29

@TheSandgroper

It’s the little things, though. What is your access like from the street to the front door? If you are almost immobile, can you sit in the sun in your own garden?

If you have two reception rooms downstairs, then one can be turned into a bedroom seeing as you have a bathroom downstairs already. Do you have two reception rooms? Will that bathroom take a wheelchair?

Does your toilet have the space for someone to be manhandled onto it and off again, including turning them around and into a wheelchair again? If there isn’t enough space, it’s bloody hard.

If you need carers, can they park outside your front door? I don’t think carers get paid until they are inside. (Happy to stand corrected here). Are they getting paid to walk x number of minutes up and down the street having had to search for parking?

I agree that good neighbours are a blessing but they live their own lives with their own priorities.

These days, those mobility scooter thingies are so useful in maintaining one’s independence. But can you park it, charge it and get to it?

My DM planned to live a long life but died of cancer at 64. Prior to that, we had elderly, frail relatives. A lot of lessons were learnt and I will not forget them. If you are unsure, a discussion with a geriatric occupational therapist (do you have them in the uk?) will perhaps guide your thinking.

One of my friends is an OT and she thinks it's fineSmile
OP posts:
MadMadMadamMim · 20/03/2022 12:28

Agree with those saying the word 'boomer' is so insulting.

I'm mid 50s, so actually miss out on being a 'boomer' by a couple of years or so - but frankly people can fuck off to the far side of fuck if they think I owe them my home after all my years of work.

The idea that old people who won't fuck off and die or crawl off to somewhere smaller and let others have their home once they are deemed as old and useless is the MOST selfish and entitled attitude I've ever come across.

My parents (mis 80s) are still alive and in the large family home they've lived in for 50 plus years. They have no intention of going through the stress of moving house to gratify some entitled stranger who is eyeing up their home.

fogglez · 20/03/2022 12:28

If we do want older people to free up larger houses then they need either a carrot (some stamp duty exemption) or a stick (annual property tax as a percentage of the value of the home - that would have us out in a jiffy

I don't understand the reluctance to pay SD if downsizing as the vast majority will have made far more than that in gains over the decades.

The property tax is interesting and normal in other countries.