Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To STILL not want to downsize?

216 replies

toconclude · 20/03/2022 11:43

Live in Victorian smallish semi - technically 4 bed but three bedrooms are singles and DH uses one as a study and always has. Downstairs bathroom which we've managed with so far.
Ongoing options are: convert one bed to bathroom so one on each floor - then as we get older would improve safety (currently average age late 60s)
Or downsize to smaller bungalow. In our town that means almost inevitably spending more money as land is pricey, and getting rid of DHs bulky Edwardian heirloom furniture
Also would lose my lovely neighbours of many years and my lovely garden.
Have already given both kids significant lump sum towards buying their own house.
A reaction to a comment in another thread about selfish boomers "hoarding" family houses.
Don't feel like a hoarder but maybe we are😳🤷

OP posts:
Blimeyherewegoagain · 20/03/2022 13:22

Studies have shown that older people living in houses keep better health that those in bungalows. The going up and down stairs helps keep your muscles and heart healthy. X

caringcarer · 20/03/2022 13:20

DH and I don't know what to do next year when my youngest son leaves home. We have 4 bedroom with loft extension to 2 further bedrooms and shower room. There will be DH, and me who neither have good health and 1 foster son we ho will be 16. Not sure if we should downsize to 3 bedroom whilst still just about able to manage to do a move. We would still have spare room for guests or DH WFH for a couple more years. We do love the garden though and dogs love garden too.

Nothappyatwork · 20/03/2022 13:20

@BanjoKnickers

House prices are controlled by controlling lending. It truly is that simple

It truly is not! There are countless factors that contribute to supply and demand. And supply and demand determine house prices.

Correct if there’s no supply of lending, Watch what happens to demand
Branleuse · 20/03/2022 13:19

its your home. If you want to stay in it, then stay in it. Why would anyone put themselves through the stress of housebuying/selling and moving unless it was absolutely necessary

Nothappyatwork · 20/03/2022 13:19

[quote toconclude]@Nothappyatwork
I can assure you that we have nothing like that amount of equity and am well aware that a valuation is just a number. The house is just where we live.
You clearly aren't remotely bothered upsetting people if you think snotty digs like that are amusing.[/quote]
The comment was not directed at you it was a different user who basically made the point that nobody could afford to buy her house anyway so it didn’t matter whether she sold it or not … erm okay

BeanStew22 · 20/03/2022 13:19

@WomanStanleyWoman

You don’t owe anyone else a house!

The bathroom plan sounds like a good idea.

^ this!

Moving is expensive

  • the stamp duty, fees, and then you always end up buying different furniture etc

A double bedroom, spare room, office & bathroom is hardly excessive for a cot and even if you were in a ten room mansion it’s YOURS, you earned it!

2 bathrooms is perfect & future proofs your house. If push came to shove could you have a bedroom downstairs (dining room?)

BanjoKnickers · 20/03/2022 13:18

House prices are controlled by controlling lending. It truly is that simple

It truly is not! There are countless factors that contribute to supply and demand. And supply and demand determine house prices.

toconclude · 20/03/2022 13:16

@Nothappyatwork
I can assure you that we have nothing like that amount of equity and am well aware that a valuation is just a number. The house is just where we live.
You clearly aren't remotely bothered upsetting people if you think snotty digs like that are amusing.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 20/03/2022 13:15

Don’t worry about ill informed comments which are not based on any understanding of how the economy works. Boomer homeowners are not responsible for the housing affordability issue. The problem is the culture of low pay and nimbyism.

Nothappyatwork · 20/03/2022 13:14

@godmum56 - House prices are controlled by controlling lending. It truly is that simple if the bank will honey land first time buyers three times their salary and a 10% deposit and that is what your starter home will sell for

Nothappyatwork · 20/03/2022 13:14

Quite simply you control lending.

godmum56 · 20/03/2022 13:13

@Nothappyatwork

Hopefully it’s not one of my comments on the other post that’s upset you I don’t think anybody should be forced to downsize at all but I do think that house prices shouldn’t be allowed to run away with themselves to the point where at the beginning of the journey it doesn’t cost more than three times a young person salary to get on the ladder. After that I guess it’s open season and the lady with her millions in on paper equity can continue to convince herself that she’s earnt them 😉 As for your situation I would say don’t put the bathroom upstairs because a four bedroom house can command a premium I remember looking when DC3 was a baby for a four bedroom house and it was just impossible to find anything.
there are loads of 4 bed houses round here....and how will you control house prices?
BanjoKnickers · 20/03/2022 13:12

Its never "free" owning a home vs renting, I am amazed that you should think that it is.

I do not!

Nothappyatwork · 20/03/2022 13:12

@godmum56

oh and PS...all the repairs maintenance and insurance are also payable at the same time as the mortgage is....it doesn't just kick in once the mortgage is paid off.
But if you never insure it and you never do any repairs it is indeed tax free. I’ve never paid buildings insurance in my life, 🤷‍♀️ Just had a look at it though and it’s like 150 quid a year. Asked for maintenance entirely optional driving round the streets of our town, there are plenty not doing it
DaphneduM · 20/03/2022 13:11

It's actually quite daunting to make downsizing work for you, especially if you move while you're still relatively fit, which is obviously the time to do it, as it's both physically and mentally challenging. Often there's another reason - moving to be nearer adult children. This is what finally decided us to move, - wanting to be nearer our daughter and grandchild. We moved from a large semi-detached cottage with a huge garden to a decent sized four bed detached with a small garden. We were lucky, the house is a one-off with a beautiful walled garden, in a beautiful area but near amenities. It's lovely to have a light practical house with large rooms, so I don't consider we've actually downsized really, only in terms of the land we now have, which is a good thing when thinking ahead to the future. We're in our late 60's and still very fit at the moment. It's also a considerably cheaper area too. So thankfully it's worked for us. I'm also glad we achieved this in 2019, before the pandemic and the housing market mayhem. At the time there actually wasn't that much on the market either, but in the area we bought there wasn't much competition.

We helped our daughter and son-in-law with their housing deposit quite a few years ago now, passing on a family inheritance, which we felt was a good use of that money.

I've got several friends who have moved from their beautiful homes to smaller houses and have actually been unhappy, so we were well aware of the pitfalls of going down that route. My husband is a very analytical person and was amazing in facilitating our successful move - indeed it was due to his research that we found the area we are now in. While we wanted to be nearer our children, we didn't want to be too near. We have a downstairs room that could become a bedroom and with a bit of tweaking there would be room for a downstairs shower too. So definitely no plans to move again.

ChiswickFlo · 20/03/2022 13:10

@toconclude

Live in Victorian smallish semi - technically 4 bed but three bedrooms are singles and DH uses one as a study and always has. Downstairs bathroom which we've managed with so far. Ongoing options are: convert one bed to bathroom so one on each floor - then as we get older would improve safety (currently average age late 60s) Or downsize to smaller bungalow. In our town that means almost inevitably spending more money as land is pricey, and getting rid of DHs bulky Edwardian heirloom furniture Also would lose my lovely neighbours of many years and my lovely garden. Have already given both kids significant lump sum towards buying their own house. A reaction to a comment in another thread about selfish boomers "hoarding" family houses. Don't feel like a hoarder but maybe we are😳🤷
Yanbu to feel as you do of course, but things change... Your "lovely" neighbours may sadly pass away or move and the new neighbours may not be as lovely... And tbh the cost of works and materials now is massive compared even 2 years ago Moving may end up cost the same as renovating!
godmum56 · 20/03/2022 13:09

oh and PS...all the repairs maintenance and insurance are also payable at the same time as the mortgage is....it doesn't just kick in once the mortgage is paid off.

godmum56 · 20/03/2022 13:08

@BanjoKnickers

I think that taxing people who choose to stay put in a home that they own, and have paid for (or are paying for) with money that has already been taxed at least once, is just unfair.

It's an interesting question of tax ethics I think.

There's a good argument that home owners have a huge unfair tax advantage in that their capital (the house) produces very valuable income (rent-free accommodation) that goes untaxed. Compare that with someone who has their capital in some other assets like shares. The income (dividends) are taxed.

Like I said, we'd be down sizing toot sweet if a system like that was brought in, and I do think overall it would be fairer (and better for a host of other reasons) to shift the tax burden away from earned income towards asset ownership.

Its never "free" owning a home vs renting, I am amazed that you should think that it is. if you own your own home then all repairs and maintenance fall on you, also buildings insurance including third party cover. As a purchaser vs a renter, you have chosen to "pay rent" ahead of time by taking on a mortgage. ....oh and you pay insurance premium tax on insurance premiums too. How often should people have to move in order to not pay "staying put" tax.....maybe it should also be charged to people who rent but stay put too? after all starter rentals are needed?
fogglez · 20/03/2022 13:07

My point was in answer to someone who said that they didnt know anyone who didnt have help

That's was me because I don't. That doesn't mean I believe everyone has help because they don't but nonetheless lots do.

Nothappyatwork · 20/03/2022 13:07

Hopefully it’s not one of my comments on the other post that’s upset you I don’t think anybody should be forced to downsize at all but I do think that house prices shouldn’t be allowed to run away with themselves to the point where at the beginning of the journey it doesn’t cost more than three times a young person salary to get on the ladder.

After that I guess it’s open season and the lady with her millions in on paper equity can continue to convince herself that she’s earnt them 😉
As for your situation I would say don’t put the bathroom upstairs because a four bedroom house can command a premium I remember looking when DC3 was a baby for a four bedroom house and it was just impossible to find anything.

Kirstos1 · 20/03/2022 13:04

What's a 'boomer'? And what's the issue with it?

yorkshireteaspoonie · 20/03/2022 13:02

You absolutely don't have to move and you shouldn't feel pressured to. I'm probably the opposite to you as I'm 39 and live in a large open plan bungalow, I'd never consider living on two levels it just doesn't appeal and I'd be most aggrieved at someone telling me what I should do!

I wonder if I'm considered as taking up housing stock for an older person! ?

bellac11 · 20/03/2022 13:01

@fogglez

Ive never had help to buy any of my homes.

and your point is?

The Bank of mum & dad is the 9th biggest lender so I'd say statistically it's fairly common.

My point was in answer to someone who said that they didnt know anyone who didnt have help. I also dont know anyone who has had help, probably only because of the mixture of people I know and we're all from the same background (ie not well off), so its horses for courses.
TheFairyCaravan · 20/03/2022 13:00

We’re in our fifties and are in the middle of buying a 4 bed house. I didn’t realise it was another thing we weren’t meant to be doing. I’m disabled so we looked at plenty of bungalows but they just didn’t work for us. The ones we could afford were just too small.

The house we’re buying is very new so the light switches and sockets are all accessible, the doors are wide enough for a wheelchair and we can convert the main bathroom to a walk in shower room really easily. The stairs are straight up and down so a stair lift won’t be a problem, either.

Honestly people need to get a grip. No one is “hoarding houses” they’re living in their homes.

fogglez · 20/03/2022 12:56

Ive never had help to buy any of my homes.

and your point is?

The Bank of mum & dad is the 9th biggest lender so I'd say statistically it's fairly common.