Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To STILL not want to downsize?

216 replies

toconclude · 20/03/2022 11:43

Live in Victorian smallish semi - technically 4 bed but three bedrooms are singles and DH uses one as a study and always has. Downstairs bathroom which we've managed with so far.
Ongoing options are: convert one bed to bathroom so one on each floor - then as we get older would improve safety (currently average age late 60s)
Or downsize to smaller bungalow. In our town that means almost inevitably spending more money as land is pricey, and getting rid of DHs bulky Edwardian heirloom furniture
Also would lose my lovely neighbours of many years and my lovely garden.
Have already given both kids significant lump sum towards buying their own house.
A reaction to a comment in another thread about selfish boomers "hoarding" family houses.
Don't feel like a hoarder but maybe we are😳🤷

OP posts:
QueenoftheFarts · 21/03/2022 17:43

I think you should stay put. My kids have left home and I can finally afford my dream house. I don't give a rats fart that it's bigger. I'm making space for the grandkids sleepovers now and u refuse to feel guilty about it. If you downsize your are just taking up a smaller, xheaper property that a first time buyer might be able to afford so the logic is twisted.

MadMadMadamMim · 21/03/2022 17:35

@mjf981

The young have been shafted financially. They see older people living in a million pound houses who paid a fraction of what they are now worth. Usually these are people with regular jobs - nurses, teachers etc.

Meanwhile they are in their 20s and 30s, doing similar jobs, and sharing a flat with no prospect of ever buying a home (unless they are lucky enough to inherit or be gifted money). Its no wonder they're jealous. A little empathy would go a long way.

But - as the saying goes - don't hate the player, hate the game. The problem and solution lies with the government and the bankers. Remember this at the next election.

We obviously live in very different areas. No one I know lives in a million pound house. Most of the 20-30 somethings I know CAN afford to buy - they are not 'sharing flats with no prospect of ever buying'.

These type of comments feels massively London centred, or in the leafy and pricey South - and it might be worth considering that for the majority of the UK that isn't the case. No one 'young' has been shafted financially here.

I'm from Scunthorpe. This is what looks to be a pretty decent family home up for sale. 4 bed, 3 bath. £260,000. That should be within reach of many families. Underneath I've posted a 2 bed starter home. Under £100,000.

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/118579817#/?channel=RES_BUY

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/109026740#/?channel=RES_BUY

mjf981 · 20/03/2022 23:58

The young have been shafted financially. They see older people living in a million pound houses who paid a fraction of what they are now worth. Usually these are people with regular jobs - nurses, teachers etc.

Meanwhile they are in their 20s and 30s, doing similar jobs, and sharing a flat with no prospect of ever buying a home (unless they are lucky enough to inherit or be gifted money). Its no wonder they're jealous. A little empathy would go a long way.

But - as the saying goes - don't hate the player, hate the game. The problem and solution lies with the government and the bankers. Remember this at the next election.

Zazdar · 20/03/2022 22:55

Secondly, you're going to die one day, too, and no-one knows the hour of their death.

You don’t say. That’s my evening ruined.

LindyLou2020 · 20/03/2022 22:48

@MadMadMadamMim

Agree with those saying the word 'boomer' is so insulting.

I'm mid 50s, so actually miss out on being a 'boomer' by a couple of years or so - but frankly people can fuck off to the far side of fuck if they think I owe them my home after all my years of work.

The idea that old people who won't fuck off and die or crawl off to somewhere smaller and let others have their home once they are deemed as old and useless is the MOST selfish and entitled attitude I've ever come across.

My parents (mis 80s) are still alive and in the large family home they've lived in for 50 plus years. They have no intention of going through the stress of moving house to gratify some entitled stranger who is eyeing up their home.

@MadMadMadamMim

👏👏👏

Bloody well said! And bloody well true!
You have said everything I would have wanted to say, only better.

fogglez · 20/03/2022 22:38

I think you’ll find it can - the basic rate was 33% in 1979.

I wasn't talking from an historical perspective as a comparison though.
I don't believe with the cost of living crisis, wage stagnation, high house prices & skilled job shortages income tax can go higher then it is with the new levy & band freezes.

Elphame · 20/03/2022 22:37

I really "should" downsize but I don't want to. Once I had my "in -laws" living with us as well as the children so I have a rambling old house that accommodated all of us comfortably. In laws are now passed on and children long gone so there are 2 of us in a 7 bedroom house.

One of the empty bedrooms has become an ironing/dressing room. One is now my craft studio ( OK actually 2 of them are now my craft studios - I've overflowed!). DP has adopted a 3rd as "his" space.

Once you have space then you do get used to it. I've been looking at bungalows for my parents who can no longer manage their large 4 bed but it's a depressing experience. I have yet to find one I'd want to live in myself.

milkyaqua · 20/03/2022 22:33

@Zazdar

I wouldn’t get upset about any hoarding comments. You won’t be hoarding it forever.
Oh, nice. Firstly, she is not 'hoarding' a house, she is living in her own home with her husband. Secondly, you're going to die one day, too, and no-one knows the hour of their death.
Fairisleflora · 20/03/2022 22:18

Build!

Fairisleflora · 20/03/2022 22:18

Basic rate of 30-odd % is the norm in Scandinavia, hence better public services there. I think we do need to buy more down-sizing friendly properties. New properties have such pokey rooms and such lame storage it’s no wonder people don’t want to downsize.

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2022 22:13

earned income can't really be taxed anymore

I think you’ll find it can - the basic rate was 33% in 1979.

LikeABreathRipplingBy · 20/03/2022 22:10

Stamp duty does stop people moving. We're late 50s, still in the family home. We're obviously not ready for retirement accomodation, but an interim move to a smaller house would cost us a fortune in stamp duty. It's way cheaper for us to stay where we are for the next 10-15 years.

bellac11 · 20/03/2022 21:31

People have paid tax on the income they used to buy the house though

Blimeyherewegoagain · 20/03/2022 21:23

If most of your investment is tied up in assets- say you have a large house, you would need to have a large amount of ready cash to pay an annual tax on it. Many people don’t have that because they have big mortgages or are retired, so the people would sell up and downsize. Owning a larger home would no longer be viable which would put even more pressure on small/medium sized homes. Where I live there is massive competition for these already as there’s such a shortage. Is it really viable long term? It might raise money in the short to medium term, but it’s still tax that needs to come out of income.

fogglez · 20/03/2022 21:05

We’re not paying enough taxes on assets, not nearly enough. Pay more tax on assets and less on earned income. It’s a MUCH more progressive means of taxation.

100% I think they may have to do this soon though as earned income can't really be taxed anymore.

Fairisleflora · 20/03/2022 21:00

We’re not paying enough taxes on assets, not nearly enough. Pay more tax on assets and less on earned income. It’s a MUCH more progressive means of taxation.

bellac11 · 20/03/2022 20:54

We are an incredibly low tax economy.

And what we do pay is filtered through to private companies in terms of handouts for the elite.

woodhill · 20/03/2022 20:52

I think we are paying enough tax as it is.Confused

Fairisleflora · 20/03/2022 20:48

There is a housing shortage in this country. I live in a place where my street is filled with elderly couples in big houses, with 2-3 unused bedrooms each, and yet they are the vilest sort of whining nimbys when developers want to build houses for others to live in. The elderly hoarding housing stock is much less of a problem than 2nd homes and properties bought for investment and left vacant, but let’s do what they do in many European countries and have council tax as 1% of a house’s value a year. That might bring minds into focus sonewhat. If you want to live in a big place, be prepared to cough up and help society out.

Cameleongirl · 20/03/2022 20:40

@EinsteinaGogo

OP,

You should absolutely not move out of your home that you've loved, unless you want to or have to.

Blimey - stair lift, mobility scooter, hoist - eff me, the list of things some posters are saying you need to plan for 🙈🙈🙈

Let's put oxygen masks and hospital beds in every room and be done with it, shall we?

I disagree, @EinsteinaGogo, you do need to plan for mobility limitations if you plan to stay in a house forever. My Mum fell down the stairs as her health deteriorated (a stairlift would've been great for her) and my step-Mum had a stroke last month after having a checkup at the doctor's the week before - they said she was in good shape. Her mobility is now limited, it's happened literally overnight Sad I think it's naive to assume that things like that won't happen after a certain age.

I completely agree with you on home insurance though! A few years ago, neighbor's tree fell onto our garage during a storm. The insurance company was great, the $7,000 repairs were completely covered after the deductible (we're in the US). It's bizarre to not to have insurance.

Ireallycantthinkofagoodone · 20/03/2022 20:09

All this silly talk about ‘bungalow legs’ - how ridiculous!! What about people who live in apartments, with lift access? Do they also have ‘apartment legs’? People can become unwell or disabled at any age, so their homes might need adaptations to enable them to remain. Or they can move into something more suited to their needs.
It’s important to think about your future needs once you get to retirement age. It would be pointless to wait until you cannot manage in your property, and then try to organise an alternative urgently. These things take time.
We bought a beautiful bungalow in a mixed development, so there is a complete mix of young families, older people and everything in between. Shops/public transport/GP/dentist etc., all available locally. We did lots of homework before making the decision to move, as whilst still very healthy and active, things could (and did) change quickly.
If 9 years of bungalow living has damaged my knees, I wouldn’t have spent Saturday night on the dance floor.

PiperPosey · 20/03/2022 19:58

@EinsteinaGogo

OP,

You should absolutely not move out of your home that you've loved, unless you want to or have to.

Blimey - stair lift, mobility scooter, hoist - eff me, the list of things some posters are saying you need to plan for 🙈🙈🙈

Let's put oxygen masks and hospital beds in every room and be done with it, shall we?

Let's put oxygen masks and hospital beds in every room and be done with it, shall we?

Best comment ever...hahahahahhahahaha Grin
absolutely brilliant
I think I will say where we live we should always wear an inner tube around our waists at all times so we don't fall in the lake and drown.

bellac11 · 20/03/2022 19:16

Ive heard this about bungalows but does it take into account that you're more likely to move into one if your health is failing anyway? Therefore it might make sense that people who live in bungalows or single storey living have worse knee problems anyway

godmum56 · 20/03/2022 19:14

yeah and here's the conclusion
"Despite the above-described limitations, to our knowledge, this is the first report to identify an association between home type and IADL of community-dwelling older people with a large-scale prospective cohort study. Although a barrier-free house is recommended for older people, our findings suggest that living in a home with stairs may have the benefit of IADL maintenance for older adults who are functionally independent."

basically all they can come up with is while you are able to do stairs then stairs MIGHT be a good idea.

EinsteinaGogo · 20/03/2022 18:57

[quote Nothappyatwork]@EinsteinaGogo - you dont need to be afraid dear. Would you like to see the ombudsman’s report about how the insurer doesnt need to pay out for astolen car ? Pm me hun 🙄[/quote]
I work in insurance.

I'm also a generally intelligent person.

For a homeowner to not have buildings cover because 'their friend told them it's worthless' is genuinely hilarious.

Goodness me, you are a very silly person!