Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To STILL not want to downsize?

216 replies

toconclude · 20/03/2022 11:43

Live in Victorian smallish semi - technically 4 bed but three bedrooms are singles and DH uses one as a study and always has. Downstairs bathroom which we've managed with so far.
Ongoing options are: convert one bed to bathroom so one on each floor - then as we get older would improve safety (currently average age late 60s)
Or downsize to smaller bungalow. In our town that means almost inevitably spending more money as land is pricey, and getting rid of DHs bulky Edwardian heirloom furniture
Also would lose my lovely neighbours of many years and my lovely garden.
Have already given both kids significant lump sum towards buying their own house.
A reaction to a comment in another thread about selfish boomers "hoarding" family houses.
Don't feel like a hoarder but maybe we are😳🤷

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nothappyatwork · 22/03/2022 17:38

@Snaketime

As someone with a young family I don't think you are hoarding, tbh I couldn't afford your house. It is more the ones that are renting council/housing association houses that could downsize so that young families can get a chance that are the problem.
How do you think they ever came to afford that house in the first place ? My auntie has an absolutely beautiful property and she only got on the latter because she bought her ex cancel house for £32,000 when she and a husband were both earning £17,000 each. Which is pretty poorly paid jobs he was a trainee mechanic and she was a care worker. The house is now worth £150,000. This is not an accident, this is not the free market the market has been interfered with that has led to these massive inflationary rises.
Snaketime · 22/03/2022 16:18

As someone with a young family I don't think you are hoarding, tbh I couldn't afford your house. It is more the ones that are renting council/housing association houses that could downsize so that young families can get a chance that are the problem.

Thewindwhispers · 22/03/2022 08:42

You don’t have to move house if you don’t want to.

Don’t worry about hoarding. Near me, most houses are either two bed attached cottages, or detached 4 double bed houses with big gardens. The detached houses are mostly occupied by couples in their sixties/seventies and the two bed cottages are mostly young families who can’t afford to spend another £600k to get an extra 2 bedrooms. I think when people talk a out selfish boomers they mean that kind of thing, but the problem is how the government has allowed the housing market to be controlled by investors (who are constantly knocking down bungalows to build townhouses and 2 bed flats, not family housing).

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 22/03/2022 07:46

Stay in your house and enjoy it..when FIL died at 64 my MIL often said she felt selfish staying in her 4 bedroom house but she loved it and so did we. Stay.

DanceItOut · 22/03/2022 05:45

It’s not as simple as people hoarding the family houses. The reality is that in 1960 houses were on average only twice the cost of the average salary. By 2005 the year I turned 16 so the earliest year I could start working full time and considering moving out the average wage was £23k a year and the average house price was around £156k so over 6 times average salary. So buying a house was already going to be more difficult for my generation before we even began working. Where I live currently even though I have a degree, my job options mean I am likely to never earn over £25-28k a year but if I wanted a modest 3 bed house in my town it is £800k-£1mil. I didn’t move here, I grew up here and it’s where all my relatives are, most of whom do not own their own homes either. I am holding out hope that one day when I’m in my 50s maybe I can afford to get a mortgage for a little 1 bed place to retire in 😂 unless people at earning over the average wage by quite a bit they can’t buy where i live.

Italiangreyhound · 22/03/2022 02:39

Stay in your lovely home. Don't feel guilty. It's fine. Enjoy.

milkyaqua · 22/03/2022 01:17

*supercentenarians

milkyaqua · 22/03/2022 01:16

There is no set time limit or indeed any actual requirement to down-size. I know a woman who moved into a retirement village unit when she was in her fifties; I know others who have stayed on happy and well in their own homes well into their nineties. There are supercentarians (up to age 119!) still living in their own homes with minimal outside assistance.

CelestiaNoctis · 22/03/2022 01:14

When you start to struggle with stairs, get a stair lift. My in laws are 70 and are still fine with the same size house though.

Summer776 · 22/03/2022 00:26

My parents are divorcing in their mid seventies meaning my DM is having to leave the family home for the last 35 years, a 3 bedroom rural detached house. DF is settled abroad and us justbawatubg settlement of finances.
It's heartbreaking downsizing when unwanted. Half the value of the home equates to a very limited choice in current t area. Also having to give up a large garden.
Downsizing is practical at this age but a massive emotional upheaval.
Any advice welcome as denial is the current state I am having to move.....

AnnieSnap · 22/03/2022 00:12

@Nothappyatwork

I have a friend who is an loss adjuster and honestly like the effort and time and expense they go to to not pay out with blow your mind. I wouldn’t be hopeless I just move into another house and then get it fixed 🤷‍♀️ Obviously car insurance is the law so you don’t get a choice as to whether to pay for that or not but I’ve had my car stolen written off and they didn’t pay out on that, despite loss adjuster friend actually writing out the claim 🤦‍♀️ kind of puts me off any insurance that’s voluntary.
If you have a mortgage, Buildings insurance is required or you are in breach of contract. Also, if your house is a right off (returning to your car analogy), you are legally required to rebuild it. How would you do that if you were bankrupt? It sounds as though you would be 🤷‍♀️
AnnieSnap · 21/03/2022 23:24

My husband is 68 and I’m 63 in a few months. Like you we have a lovely garden and lovely neighbour and value both. We also love our house, having spent years getting it as we want it. We have no plans to move and will put a stair lift, or one of those mini lifts through the living room ceiling if we need it! If you’re happy and settled, why move?

Learningstill · 21/03/2022 21:32

Haven’t read the whole thread so I’m sorry if I’m repeating anything.
Difficult decisions, but my wonderful sil says .......
Bungalow estates are GWR - Gods Waiting Room. Are you really ready for that?

Make your present home usable for you now and for the future. Who knows what awful things could await if you move, bad neighbours, twitchy curtains, no room to host family, no memories.

NannaKaren · 21/03/2022 20:33

Keep your lovely house and concert one of the brooms to a fab walk in shower room with loo.

sherbertdib · 21/03/2022 19:12

At your age, i al sure you're fit and able and see no reason to downsize.

All of mine and DH'a grandparents would have struggled in a Victorian house in their 80s

My own GM really struggles to keep her tiny bungalow clean (too proud to accept
Help) now and she shuffles about on a frame. Her bathroom has been adjusted. She's very Immobile suddenly. Getting up the few steps from drive to front door is hard

DH's GP struggles on in a large house. He
Can no longer get up the stairs. House is falling down around him

Don't be too proud to admit you're too old to live the same life and accept that your needs change

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 21/03/2022 18:50

@Blimeyherewegoagain

Studies have shown that older people living in houses keep better health that those in bungalows. The going up and down stairs helps keep your muscles and heart healthy. X
True, at least it was for my folks, then mid 60s. After 3 years in a bungalow they’d downsized to, they decided they didn’t like the area after all, moved again - to a house. And found that lack of stairs had seriously affected their fitness.

It did return eventually, and my Dm was still well able to manage stairs when she moved to a care home (dementia) at 89.

FollowtheLizards · 21/03/2022 18:46

I don't see the problem with staying in your much loved home for as long as it suits you. My Mum is 76 and is still living alone in our family home after my Dad passed away over a decade ago. It's a big 3 bed detached with huge gardens and she has no plans to move until she has to. If anything the house is probably in a better state of repair now than when my Dad was alive as he used to begrudge spending money on modernising it. My brother sometimes makes comments about his 'inheritance' but he's a selfish a-hole at times so I tell Mum not to take any notice!

Sailorsusan · 21/03/2022 18:41

Every generation gets shafted financially in some way. Young people in the 70s were paying a third of their salary in income tax and the mortgage rate in 1979 was 11%. Added to which the annual inflation rate was almost 20%.

My DM often says how hard the early 70s were for a newly married couple. Houses were put on the market in the morning and disappeared by lunchtime, or would cost several thousand more by the next day. My Dad had to buy their first one without her even seeing it. He lost his job in the late 70s recession and they had to get free milk. My Gran lost the value of all her savings due to hyper inflation. I agree that every generation has their complaints. It's easy to forget though.

Lincslady53 · 21/03/2022 18:37

Both our parents left moving too late. My in laws were in their 80s FIL not mobile at all, and their mental faculties starting to fail. They found it stressful moving to a flat, struggled to get to grips with how things like the hot water system, the oven and the heating worked. We had to handle all the selling and buying process, and regularly pop in to set their heating, go to tenant's meetings. If they had moved a couple of years earlier that would have been able to familiarise themselves with all of this. My parents lived in a large Victorian terrace, 4 beds. Dad wanted to move to a bungalow, mum refused as she had a lot of friends. 20 years after retiring when dad died, the house had a leaking roof, central heating was iffy, it needed a rewire, all local friends had either moved or died, mum was immobile needing stair lift and aids to help her stand, so mum was left in a house she couldn't maintain, couldn't afford to fix up, was cold and totally unsuitable, but still didn't want to move. My sister sorted out a sheltered flat for her to move to, we all (5 of us) helped her move and auctioned off the house. Again, she had no idea how to use the new kitchen appliances and hdd no desire to bother so lived on ding meals for the rest of her life. So I think the trick is to downsize while you still have your faculties to enable you to settle into your last home. Difficult to know when that is as these ailments creep up on you.

BiscuitLover3678 · 21/03/2022 18:34

Your house isn’t so big that you should need to downsize. Your bathroom plan sounds good. Main thing is being able to live downstairs and you already have a bathroom there so that works. Would you extend downstairs to get more room for a separate bedroom?

Mellowyellow222 · 21/03/2022 18:31

I agree there is a lot of generalisation I. This thread.

I am early forties - I am single and own a bigger house than my parents. My friends are teachers, scientists, doctors and lawyers. Our parents are I. Their late sixties and early seventies.

All my friends have homes the same size or larger than our parents - and no parents have downsized.

I think some of those commenting are very focused on the London market - it’s not the same outside London. Home ownership is achievable for lots of people I. Their twenties

Movemyshed · 21/03/2022 18:21

MadMadMadamMim is right.

I live in a cheap area, comparatively. My first flat came up for sale again recently. I bought it on my own in the late seventies. A buyer here now in the same career and at the same age could still buy this flat on their own.

I'm now surrounded by very spacious Victorian terraced houses with four or more bedrooms and two to three reception rooms. They are mostly owned now by couples in their forties with children. Lecturers, doctors, scientists, teachers buy these houses, which go for under £400,000.

Friends and I who are who are single, and boomers, live in two- or at most three-bedroom houses or flats. We're not all rattling about in large family homes.

janj2301 · 21/03/2022 17:59

We only have an upstairs bathroom, when husband got his new knees we installed a stair lift, great things if you have room. Ours was touch and go as the stairs bend at we only had literally a few centimetres clearance.

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2022 17:51

The young have been shafted financially

Every generation gets shafted financially in some way. Young people in the 70s were paying a third of their salary in income tax and the mortgage rate in 1979 was 11%. Added to which the annual inflation rate was almost 20%.

My social circle includes nurses, teachers, etc and none of us live in million pound houses. The closest is a friend who lives on the outskirts of London who paid £89k for their house in 1996 and it’s now worth around £700k.

godmum56 · 21/03/2022 17:48

@Fairisleflora

There is a housing shortage in this country. I live in a place where my street is filled with elderly couples in big houses, with 2-3 unused bedrooms each, and yet they are the vilest sort of whining nimbys when developers want to build houses for others to live in. The elderly hoarding housing stock is much less of a problem than 2nd homes and properties bought for investment and left vacant, but let’s do what they do in many European countries and have council tax as 1% of a house’s value a year. That might bring minds into focus sonewhat. If you want to live in a big place, be prepared to cough up and help society out.
why? I coughed up all my working life, as did my late husband.