Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will Labour ever get back in?

411 replies

Blueblossompinksky · 20/03/2022 10:32

My understanding is that the labour majority was in part because of the Scottish vote, which seems to have gone to the SNP.

I realise it’s unlikely that the Tories will get back in with such a large majority as 2019 but will there actually be enough seats for Labour to win?

OP posts:
MangyInseam · 22/03/2022 16:42

@TheKeatingFive

You aren't going to win elections going out there telling the electorate "we're right, you're wrong" and expecting them to vote for you.

This attitude from Labour never ceases to amaze me. It's lacking the most basic political understanding.

I know, right!

It's like telling people that if they don't plug their noses over self-id, it's their fault when they get Tory or other policies they don't really like.

As opposed to the fault of Labour who for some reason keep pushing it even though it is a known vote loser. Clearly, it's the Labour leadership that cares less about austerity and more about gender ideology.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 22/03/2022 16:41

Oh yay. Loads of people yelling past each other.

For all those of you shouting, "how can you not vote Labour?" please read.

I can explain it all!

Imagine that overnight the Labour party undergoes a sea-change. Their policies are exactly what you want: from employment rights, the NHS budget, improved disability support, a plan to build more social housing, future-proofing the country against climate-change, animal welfare in farming, to increased funding of schools and colleges. Everything you could ever dream of, they are perfect on, and the manifesto is fully costed. And you believe them

But there is one thing you don't like. Imagine they also plan to remove trans people's human rights. Imagine that under the Labour party, gender reassignment will no longer be a protected characteristic in the Equality Act, hate crimes against trans people will no longer be recorded, transgender surgery will be banned, and cross-sex hormones will be banned. Would you still be willing to vote Labour?

I'm not going to ask you to disclose which way you would vote, but can you accept that not everyone would be willing to entirely sacrifice trans people's safety for everyone else's happiness? That they can't accept seeing trans people used as a bargaining chip?

If you can, good.

Now, here's the shocking part. Some people feel equally as strongly about women's legal rights.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/03/2022 16:33

They don't want my vote, so it's fine by me, I won't be voting for them.

"No self respecting woman should wish or work for the success of a party that ignores her sex"

Susan B Anthony

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/03/2022 16:29

I'm going to repeat the post I made on a thread on Chat the other day about why I and other women are exercising our democratic right not to vote Labour until they sort themselves out in terms of their attitude to women's rights. And yes all the things I cite can be evidenced:

I'm going to illustrate all the many reasons why I, a former Labour member, will not be voting for them:

Their support of misogynist troll Lily Madigan as "women's officer" and other such characters

Their abuse of all women shortlists to allow males to stand as "women"

MPs joining secret Facebook groups set up to doxx gender critical women, get them suspended from the party and get them sacked, keeping Stasi like lists in breach of Data Protection law

Suspending gender critical women in disciplinary proceedings worthy of O'Brien and Winston Smith

Key MPs signing a pledge to persecute gender critical feminists within the Labour Party

Key MPs saying that they believed MTF transgender sex criminals had the right to go into women's prison

A leader and numerous MPs who can't bring themselves to define the word woman in any coherent way and make themselves and the party a laughing stock

A party that turns a blind eye to the horrific online abuse of gender critical female MP Rosie Duffield, egged on by left wing commentators on social media

A hugely misogynistic culture overall, with a history of telling women their rights can wait until more important things have been achieved.

I've probably forgotten some, but hopefully that gives an idea of why many women will be making the only protest they can, by not voting for them.

***

Distantview · 22/03/2022 16:24

@JustAnotherPoster00 Labour and their supporters in Wales constantly bleat about the Barnett formula and the Tories when they've had 22 years to take positive steps to attract and start new businesses,
and stop encouraging a dependency culture and especially dependency on the state.
Instead, they've focussed on looking after their cronies and keeping their mates in the trade unions happy at the expense of what's best for the population. I'm a trade union member myself btw.
They promised to re organise the ridiculous situation of 22 councils when the assembly was created - a terrific waste of money in a small country - with 22 directors of education, social services etc - but that would upset the aforementioned cronies and they've never done it. Now they want to increase the number of largely useless MS's.
Many of their policies are excellent in practice, but there are too many fat cats and not enough skilled workers in the right places.

Allowing education to become so dire has made that happen - it's all very well reorganising the curriculum now, but why let it get that bad? I'll tell you why - dogma was more important than kids' achievements and qualifications in shortage occupations. And by that, I don't mean Mickey Mouse degrees in some of the Mickey Mouse colleges and so-called universities that have sprung up.

I admit we have historic issues of work-shyness, sickness, an elderly population and poverty - but for goodness sake, there's still room for good governance, ambition and intelligence - all of which are sorely lacking in Welsh Labour.

Our natural resources aren't enough to bring financial independence - we have lots of rain, but no oil.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/03/2022 16:21

what Is right wing about being against lockdowns and mandates?

The affluent were very well protected during lockdowns. They had nice gardens and space in their homes for everyone to have a room to study and work. All with their own laptops, of course. They had time to make sour dough bread and still keep earning and being protected from the worst variant of covid.

Its the poorer who had to keep working and struggling to educate their children and limited access to tech. Often they didn’t have access to good outdoor space either and spent weeks indoors.

It’s ridiculous how ‘Right wing’ is thrown around like an insult these days. I’m quite comfortable with both my right wing and left wing views. It’s possible to have views that fall into different camps so go ahead and throw insults.

This.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/03/2022 16:20

I'm not sure I'll ever understand why being very pro lockdown, which hit the poorest and disenfranchised in our society the most significantly, became associated with the left.

Yes, Piers Corbyn is very right wing, of course.

Beowulfa · 22/03/2022 15:55

There is one journalist at the Guardian-John Harris- who has the revolutionary approach to political writing of leaving Westminster and asking people in ordinary jobs in unglamorous parts of the nation what they think about stuff.

Perhaps Labour could try this?

TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2022 15:26

Jesus 🤦‍♀️

Fluffymule · 22/03/2022 15:19

There are dozens of these examples of Labour MP quotes to be found now, but this one was from today. A female Labour MP (Warrington North), telling women to rejoice in being beaten by biological males in sport, and to 'pipe down' and stop being 'transphobic'.

Not a shred of concern, compassion or 'kindness' for the girls robbed of their achievements.

This is a party position. Kier Starmer has set out his stall by coming off the fence in the past few weeks. They don't deserve women's votes.

Will Labour ever get back in?
JustAnotherPoster00 · 22/03/2022 15:09

stop despising the working classes

Right wing dog whistle meaning immigration

TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2022 15:09

I think it was more to do with those that were against the lockdowns having more right wing opinions, here and in the states

I don't personally think that's true. I think it's more that those with right wing opinions were noisier about it and it suited the media to position it in that way.

There was a lot of silencing of concerns from more moderate views, in the press, Twitter, forums like this one.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 22/03/2022 15:08

but after 22 years

Says a lot

BlancheB · 22/03/2022 15:06

Nah they're unlikely to get back in until they can a) stand up for women and b) stop despising the working classes.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 22/03/2022 15:06

@Distantview

Labour are in in Wales and our lives are better for it, compared to those in England. I hope they stay in Wales and if they get into Westminster, even better. Really? On every metric things are worse than England in Wales - health, education, economy, transport... Unless you think TWAW of course, on which case, come on team Wales. I used to vote Labour but after 22 years of seeing what a shitshow they've been here, and especially because they don't know what a woman is, absolutely no more. I'm no fan of the Tories but there's no credible opposition and can't see that happening for a long time.
Going to mention the unfair Barnett formula and the fact that England has stripped away any natural resource Wales had and gives back a miniscule amount in comaprison to the wealth it stripped out?
JustAnotherPoster00 · 22/03/2022 15:04

@TheKeatingFive

Anymore off the right wing check list?

I'm not sure I'll ever understand why being very pro lockdown, which hit the poorest and disenfranchised in our society the most significantly, became associated with the left.

I think it was more to do with those that were against the lockdowns having more right wing opinions, here and in the states, a lot of it fuelled by the QAnon nonsense, even now any anti lockdown protest seems to have a lot of nazi salutes thrown around and I only mentioned it because any thread about Labour no matter what will always bring down the right wing element of MN, likewise with the racism/anti racism threads and trans threads you see an overlap of posters who are clearly right wing and would have never voted for the party insinuating its the only thing stopping them from voting for Labour Hmm
Distantview · 22/03/2022 15:02

Labour are in in Wales and our lives are better for it, compared to those in England. I hope they stay in Wales and if they get into Westminster, even better.
Really? On every metric things are worse than England in Wales - health, education, economy, transport...
Unless you think TWAW of course, on which case, come on team Wales.
I used to vote Labour but after 22 years of seeing what a shitshow they've been here, and especially because they don't know what a woman is, absolutely no more.
I'm no fan of the Tories but there's no credible opposition and can't see that happening for a long time.

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 14:59

I agree about lockdown and Labour / left wing and who it hit hardest - and that being incongruous.

And I think some of that insult and attempt to control other voters is an overhang of pandemic where people just insulted people into doing what they thought best - eg you’re selfish etc

It’s not very convincing as a tactic to get more votes though

Charles11 · 22/03/2022 14:56

@JustAnotherPoster00

what Is right wing about being against lockdowns and mandates?

The affluent were very well protected during lockdowns. They had nice gardens and space in their homes for everyone to have a room to study and work. All with their own laptops, of course. They had time to make sour dough bread and still keep earning and being protected from the worst variant of covid.
Its the poorer who had to keep working and struggling to educate their children and limited access to tech. Often they didn’t have access to good outdoor space either and spent weeks indoors.

It’s ridiculous how ‘Right wing’ is thrown around like an insult these days. I’m quite comfortable with both my right wing and left wing views. It’s possible to have views that fall into different camps so go ahead and throw insults.

TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2022 14:31

Anymore off the right wing check list?

I'm not sure I'll ever understand why being very pro lockdown, which hit the poorest and disenfranchised in our society the most significantly, became associated with the left.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 22/03/2022 14:26

@Charles11

I couldn’t vote for labour. As well as the women’s rights issues, I didn’t like their enthusiasm for lockdowns and mandates.
Anymore off the right wing check list?
TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2022 14:12

But just to be 100% clear, that doesn't mean they are supportive of the Tories either.

TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2022 14:11

For many women it is fundamental.

Exactly. This is about women's essential identity and biology based rights. Calling it a 'safety issue' is such a total misunderstanding of the consequences of what Labour are supporting.

Many women do see this as much more threatening to them than anything the Tories are doing. If you don't understand why, you know where to go to find out.

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 14:06

women's safety issue

Part of the reason is a misunderstanding of the issue centred on women’s rights. For many women it is fundamental. It is crucially important to me and I would always focus on women’s rights not ‘trans rights’ or a ‘safety issue’. There is a good section on here where people talk about why it’s so crucial to them if you’re interested in knowing more about why.

TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2022 14:04

I am pointing out the complete lack of respect Boris and to Tory party have for women which is completely being brushed over. I'm pointing out anyone here who is against labour because of women's safety but instead supports the conservatives is a complete hypocrite.

I don't think anyone is brushing over it. This thread is about labour. Start a thread about Boris if you want. I'm sure you'll get a lot of responses, he's not very popular on here.

A willingness to not vote for a party because of a women's safety issue but will instead vote for another one who is run by misogynistic twat.

One misogynistic leader, while pretty appalling, is not more serious in my eyes than the erosion of women's identity, language and spaces. Now please note this does NOT mean I am advocating for Boris. I have never and would never vote for the Tories. But the fact that the Tories are dire does not let Labour off the hook for their position on women.

As I said earlier, if you want to actually understand the threat that women feel under (rather than y'know, just call them crazy), I recommend the feminism board. I know that's in vain because you aren't actually interested, but I'll throw it out there one more time.

I'm making general statements here to everyone who is going to vote Tory.

Which is who exactly?

Swipe left for the next trending thread