Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will Labour ever get back in?

411 replies

Blueblossompinksky · 20/03/2022 10:32

My understanding is that the labour majority was in part because of the Scottish vote, which seems to have gone to the SNP.

I realise it’s unlikely that the Tories will get back in with such a large majority as 2019 but will there actually be enough seats for Labour to win?

OP posts:
PastMyBestBeforeDate · 20/03/2022 13:03

Just because people won't vote Labour, it doesn't mean they'll vote Conservative. Unless you live somewhere marginal or somewhere that might well be subject to a protest vote it makes little difference. My MP gets a huge proportion of the vote. Nothing I do will make the slightest difference.

DdraigGoch · 20/03/2022 13:03

@ilovesooty which interviews did you have in mind?

I've just remembered Natalie Bennett's car crash when she was leader of the Green Party.

Nothappyatwork · 20/03/2022 13:02

Well you’ve just ruined my day I forgot that that was a nearly 20 year period Jesus Christ, imagine.

Unfortunately I think their policies working. I’ve decided to just do me now because if the government can’t take care of those who are most vulnerable, my job is to make sure I don’t become the most vulnerable.

Somanysocks · 20/03/2022 13:02

Women's rights may be seen as single issue voting but it has vast ramifications and is wide ranging in all areas of life.

Linguini · 20/03/2022 13:02

Erm, they proposed the GRA Reform under May. Crispin Blunt, Penny Mordaunt and other Conservatives are active TRAs, more take the stance YWAW

Yes ok GRA reform was proposed under May, but the Tories have since blocked it.
TRA Tories are in the minority.

Labour MPs are committed to the TRA line as a whole overall, look what happened to MP Duffield. They're dangerous and can't be trusted they've swallowed too much Kool Aid and live in an elite bubble, no use to anyone other than their privileged friends.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 20/03/2022 13:01

wing not win

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 20/03/2022 13:00

@maltravers

I don’t like the tories, but how can I vote Labour when they are so awful about acknowledging the need to balance rights so as to protect women? They don’t even know what a woman is it seems. Yeah right.
Who would you vote for ? We only have a right win - Tories and Left win - Labour. I know I am not a right wing nutter.... Choices are few and far I wish the green party would be in seat, 4 day working week sounds great. But that will never happen
Pluvia · 20/03/2022 12:59

@Nothappyatwork

Historically by the time any parties had three terms the electorate has had enough of them and is ready for a change it’s almost like seven years of feast and seven years of faming.
Based on the Thatcher-Major period (1979-97) we've still got several years of Tory rule to go.

What Labour needs now is the new Neil Kinnock to rid the party of its unelectable element (Militant in his day, Momentum now) and a new Blair/ Brown combination waiting in the wings once the job of bringing Labour back towards the centre and reality (adult human females being the prime reality they need to acknowledge) and then they'll have a chance. Till then people will keep voting Tory because they're a shit-show but a known shit-show. No one knows what depth of shit a Labour government run by a man who has shown no inclination to take control of his party would get us into.

DdraigGoch · 20/03/2022 12:59

[quote Overtheseas]@DdraigGoch I couldn’t disagree more vehemently. The Welsh NHS is bloody amazing compared to England. I had breast cancer identified, scanned, operated on and follow up treatment all in 3 months.
Meanwhile my friend in England is dying on a waiting list.

Education in Wales is being transformed with a new curriculum and arrangements for ensuring ANY child with ALN (the old SEN) gets a legally binding support plan and person centred support. In England the education system is crippled by profitmaking schools and providers companies hoovering up taxpayers money because money-starved Councils lose tribunals due to not being able to meet pupil needs. Meanwhile local schools miss out. It’s a shambles.

Transport for Wales is bad, but so is rail travel everywhere. The rail network needed investment, not privatisation.[/quote]
Great that it worked for you. It doesn't work for everyone. All in all, outcomes are poorer.

Again in education, Welsh pupils' attainment is less than in England.

When people are calling for the return of Arriva Trains Wales, you know that things must be desperate with the nationalised operator.

ilovesooty · 20/03/2022 12:59

Exactly @TooBigForMyBoots.

As for the poster talking about single people paying 75% council tax under Labour I've been paying that for the entire time the Conservatives have been in government.

Againstmachine · 20/03/2022 12:58

Labour problem is a lot of time, they are chasing the same middle class vote that the Tories.

What labour needs to be doing is encouraging the disenfranchised who are minimum wage who don't vote to vote for them, these are the people who work in care homes, factories, distribution centers like ASOS and many more, But Labour won't do this as they are too lazy.

crosstalk · 20/03/2022 12:56

How many floating voters are there in GB? The pollsters should get on to this and the issues.

There are too many safe seats throughout though there have been some surprise turnarounds (Churchill being turfed out, John Major winning, Blair's first win).

My prediction is that the LibDems and Greens will lose badly. Tories will only come through if they can mitigate the disaster of Brexit (the NI agreement is still in the air) Covid/energy prices/Ukraine/cronyism/partygate.

Labour need to sort their front bench and agree policies now. At the moment they seem more fractious than the Tories which is never good.

The SNP need to come clean and stop pretending they've improved medicine, education and care for the elderly.

In the end of the day votes tend to go for (a) tribal leanings (b) local issues and impact (c) economy (d) popularity of leader and local MP.

Then there's the hills you would die on. Clearly not enough people objected to the invasions of Iraq or our troops in Afghanistan.

I wonder if enough women will vote or know enough about the GRA and the politics of Transgender/trans issue to vote accordingly. We know Labour, Greens, SNP, Liberals are all on board with trans rights, but some Tories are on the same hymn sheet.

TooBigForMyBoots · 20/03/2022 12:55

@Linguini

So you're quite happy to see the Conservative Party reelected? How have they benefited or protected women while in government?

They blocked GRA reform. They know what a woman is. In the current climate that's showing some balls.

Erm, they proposed the GRA Reform under May. Crispin Blunt, Penny Mordaunt and other Conservatives are active TRAs, more take the stance YWAW.
BeryltheMenaceneePeril · 20/03/2022 12:53

I will never vote for the Labour Party. When I was Single, no children and working full time, not claiming any benefits, I was seen as a "cash cow" by them. Gordon Brown's mantra, it was all about "hard working families". Nothing for single people, happy to let them pay 75% rate for council tax. They bit the hand that was feeding them. I have a long memory.
Years later when I was living in a bungalow, Corbyn's master plan was to tax people locally according to how much land their property was built on. Wouldn't matter how many people were living in the property. I wouldn't mind but I haven't ever been a high earner. Never paid higher than the basic rate of tax. They are supposed to be the party that I should be drawn to.

DdraigGoch · 20/03/2022 12:53

@Overtheseas

I find it utterly bizarre that people feel they have to agree with EVERY SINGLE policy point of Labour in order to vote for them! Meanwhile, the Tories destroy the country.

This is the Left’s problem- too principled / idealistic / stubborn.

We would rather sit comfortably on our high horse as the opposition, than compromise our own self-righteousness by supporting a less-than-perfect opposition for the wider good of the country.

No, not every single point. Only the important ones are non-negotiable. Just a majority of the rest will do.

Looking through the detail of Keir's 10 pledges, I don't support much there, even if the headings might seem laudable.

ZaraSizeMedium · 20/03/2022 12:53

So you're quite happy to see the Conservative Party reelected? How have they benefited or protected women while in government?

Well just off the top of my head, Sajid Javid ordered a review into the guidance that allows male patients into female-only NHS wards.

They blocked the reform of the Gender Recognition Act.

Scrapped the tampon tax and started rolling out free period products in schools. Under a Labour government schools would probably be told they must give out sanitary towels to boys, seeing as Kier Starmer doesn’t seem to know which group of humans has a cervix and which doesn’t
Hmm

A bunch of their MP’s are happy to go on record stating what a woman is.

Violetparis · 20/03/2022 12:52

In the next election run up Labour MPs and Tory ones I expect are going to be asked by journalists time and time again to define a woman. Unless Labour MPs with the exception of Rosie Duffield come up with a clear, coherent answer they are going to make utter fools of themselves and cost Labour the election. I've always voted Labour and want to again but I am in two minds because of this issue, I would never vote Tory.

ilovesooty · 20/03/2022 12:51

@DdraigGoch

Well that didn't take long.

Forget any wide ranging discussion on electability OP.

@ilovesooty a significant factor in electability is how you come across in interviews. Diane Abbot fell apart when trying to say how much it would cost to increase the number of police officers, her performance became symbolic to many people of the Labour party' lack of competence. So if all an interviewer has to do to make a prominent Labour politician fall apart is to ask a very straightforward question, then Labour are doomed.

Various members of the Conservative Party have had any number of car crash interviews since.

This reminds me of Ed Miliband and the bacon sandwich.

Linguini · 20/03/2022 12:49

*12:40 Overtheseas"

Unfortunately the woke Labour line of TWAW and how they've implemented it has insulted, offended and terrified me to such an extent that I can't ignore it, even "for the greater good".

Some women feel really really strongly on this single issue.

Unfortunately they've let themselves down in a few other areas which has resulted in them becoming entirely unelectable, which is sad because against Theresa May Labour were a breath away from winning and I voted for them then.

Overtheseas · 20/03/2022 12:48

@DdraigGoch I couldn’t disagree more vehemently. The Welsh NHS is bloody amazing compared to England. I had breast cancer identified, scanned, operated on and follow up treatment all in 3 months.
Meanwhile my friend in England is dying on a waiting list.

Education in Wales is being transformed with a new curriculum and arrangements for ensuring ANY child with ALN (the old SEN) gets a legally binding support plan and person centred support. In England the education system is crippled by profitmaking schools and providers companies hoovering up taxpayers money because money-starved Councils lose tribunals due to not being able to meet pupil needs. Meanwhile local schools miss out. It’s a shambles.

Transport for Wales is bad, but so is rail travel everywhere. The rail network needed investment, not privatisation.

HeDidWhattt · 20/03/2022 12:47

Voting labour wouldn’t be for the good of the country though would it, as 50% of the country are women.
What I find frustrating is labour could absolutely smash the opposition out of the water with no effort at all….but instead they’ve decided not to and go down a line that alienates so much of the population!! Why!?

We need a new party to vote for!

Sexnotgender · 20/03/2022 12:45

Not until they stop pissing all over women’s rights.

Crimesean · 20/03/2022 12:45

Labour are far too removed from what the working class actually wants and needs. They're too busy naval-gazing and arguing about bullshit topics like identity politics and other similar woke rubbish.

People care more about stuff like jobs, the economy, the welfare state, the NHS, transport, women's and children's safety, and immigration. Labour seem to have forgotten all of that, and have only the vaguest of policies with no underpinning data on affordability. They're lost in a sea of Westminster chatter, I can't see them finding their way back unless Momentum fucks off to form their own party.

maltravers · 20/03/2022 12:44

Raspberryjamchicken The current balance of rights issue is not something I would discuss outside my family as it causes such vitriol. It will probably determine my vote though, even though I would usually vote labour. I don’t see it as a niche issue myself. A friend told me last week that half her dd’s class are now saying they are trans. Puberty is a confusing time. Some of these young girls may harm their bodies with blockers/hormones/surgery. At the same time women are supposed to accept male bodied people into women’s sports, baking in failure for women and deterring their participation. Trans people should be treated with dignity and respect but so should women. Calling me a vagina haver is not treating me with dignity and respect. Denying sick women female only spaces in hospitals is giving precedence to others’ feelings over women’s safety and ability to recuperate. That’s before you consider the wider implications of the acceptance of totalitarian thinking, the witch hunting, the threats. How can we turn a blind eye to this and condone it? If Labour would promise a mature discussion how to balance these rights, and safeguard children, rather than behaving like terrified hostages, I would vote for them.

LondonQueen · 20/03/2022 12:44

I hope not, their stance on women is disgusting.