Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will Labour ever get back in?

411 replies

Blueblossompinksky · 20/03/2022 10:32

My understanding is that the labour majority was in part because of the Scottish vote, which seems to have gone to the SNP.

I realise it’s unlikely that the Tories will get back in with such a large majority as 2019 but will there actually be enough seats for Labour to win?

OP posts:
Tabasco007 · 20/03/2022 16:27

@raspberryjamchicken

Every thread about voting Labour is immediately taken over by posters who say they wouldn't vote for them on the basis of definition of a woman. I consider myself a feminist and am concerned about things like safe spaces for women but I would still vote Labour as I have other priorities when I vote.

I would be interested to know if there has been any actual polling on whether this issue would in fact lead to a reduction of numbers voting Labour. I never hear anyone say anything about it in real life and wonder if the number of people in demographics outside of MN who would actively choose to vote Labour because of their stance on trans rights would outweigh those who wouldn't? Presumably the Labour Party itself think so.

I definitely won't, I'm north London based, having said that my friend very much aligned with my thoughts on women has a said that she probably would still vote them, and I have other friend that probably would too, I won't though -100%, I'll either not vote, which pains me, or vote Tory, which pains me even more. I have joined the social democrats party though, so maybe they can grow out of this shit show.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/03/2022 16:24

Philosophers call it utilitarianism.

What's "utilitarian" is in the eye of the beholder. Your vote is your own.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/03/2022 16:24

I don't think labour realise how damaging the line TWAW is to them

That's the nature of those holding extreme positions though; they're so wedded to their preferred "cause" that reality doesn't stand a chance

Much the same applies to the Tories, except they favour corruption instead of minorities, but they also have an 80 majority and while it may get dented I don't see it being overturned unless people feel there's something good to vote for, instead of just "less bad"

PinkGinBigGrin · 20/03/2022 16:23

Good god I hope not!

Tabasco007 · 20/03/2022 16:20

@Florenz

Things would have to get REALLY bad for Labour to get in. They have driven away so many of their core supporters in an attempt to appeal to a very small number of activists, and I have absolutely no idea why. They need to be as far away from "woke" as possible as it is electoral poison.
This !
Tabasco007 · 20/03/2022 16:18

@FrancesGumm

I agree - I will be asking any Labour canvassers again for their definition on ‘what is a woman’ …
The lib dems knocked at my door yesterday, and I told them that I won't be voting for them as they don't know what a women is. TBF the younger of the two men, said he understood the issue and agreed with me, the older one just banged on about how his daughters friend (19/20) was non binary and needed top surgery and how expensive it was, I told him to call it what is was, a double mastectomy and how can he justify men in women sports etc. anyhoo, mad world we seem to live in now.
SueSaid · 20/03/2022 16:13

@Acheyknees

Not until they change their entire front bench.
This.

Bunch of utter clowns. When are they going to realise optics matter?!

Surely, surely someone in their party must see they need to have more convincing leaders than wibbly Starmer and bellowing Rayner to have a cat in hells chance of ever being credible.

Tabasco007 · 20/03/2022 16:12

sadly, No not while they are so immersed in gender ideology assuming don't know what a women is. single sex spaces, sports for women etc. are disappearing , it will just turn 'most ' people off. I mean how many of us really think we have the identity of a man or women - I'm mean 14 -19 year old me, would defo had been Non binary, in todays world that would mean I'd end up wanting my breasts cut off! It's a massive disservice what we are doing to woman and our young. Well that's my opinion and why, having been a labour voter all my life, I won't be voting for them anymore,

TooBigForMyBoots · 20/03/2022 16:02

Serious question; Has anyone asked Boris what definition of a women is?

GB News did. He did his usual waffle and bluster about "dignity for everyone" and refused to say that only women have a cervix.Hmm

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2022 16:01

@FrancesGumm

I agree - I will be asking any Labour canvassers again for their definition on ‘what is a woman’ …
Do you know what? I’m actually over this now. I want a government that isn’t corrupt, isn’t handing my money over to its multi millionaire mates and funds decent services. There’s no way I’ll vote against that because they “don’t know what a woman is”. It’s one issue and even as a gender critical cis woman I can swallow that issue to get the right result on a multitude of others. Philosophers call it utilitarianism.
Teddeh · 20/03/2022 15:55

RE Scotland, I agree with Cazziebo.

Scotland has 59 seats (reduced to 57 in 2023) out of 650 in the HOC. The SNP won 48 seats in 2019, vs Conservatives’ 365 and Labour’s 203. Had every SNP seat gone to Labour, it would have been LAB 252, CON 365 - still a clear Conservatives majority. If Labour had won EVERY seat in Scotland, it's still a clear CON majority (361 CON to 262 LAB). This would hold true even if every single person eligible to vote in Scotland showed up and voted Labour.

But the SNP winning seats only damages Labour in a UK General Election if no party has a majority. Then the number of seats won determines which party has first rights to form a minority or coalition government - e.g., 2010 when, arguably, EITHER CON or LAB could have formed and led a workable coalition government but CON had the first opportunity due to winning the highest number of seats. The problem now is, Labour isn’t anywhere close to competing with the Conservatives UK-wide (no matter how Scotland votes). Labour have to win back vote(r)s from the Conservatives; there's no other way.

TooBigForMyBoots · 20/03/2022 15:54

May's government is history. It's the current policy which matters, and the Conservatives are the only major party to have shelved it.

They are the only party in power, so they are the only ones who can get totally rid. But they haven't. May's government is history and one day so will Johnson's. Just a few weeks ago Penny Mordaunt was being tipped as the next Conservative leader.Shock

zafferana · 20/03/2022 15:50

The only time Labour has been electable in the past 40+ years is when it shifted to the left of centre and became 'New Labour'. In that position and with a young, dynamic team at its helm, it was able to mop up a lot of centrist voters who had become disillusioned by the Tories under Thatcher and Major.

I thought that perhaps Keir Starmer would be able to steer the party back towards that middle ground, but so far not only has he failed to do that, he's headed down the woke rabbit hole with the loony left of the party. His unwillingness to define what a woman is was a new low for the party, compounded by senior Labour women like Annaliese Dodds and Yvette Cooper doubling down. If Labour is prepared to chuck 51% of the population under the bus in order to placate the hard left of the party I can't see them regaining power any time soon.

stuckdownahole · 20/03/2022 15:42

The Tories have always been the party for middle class people with assets or inheritance to protect. That left plenty of the field open for Labour. Unfortunately Labour seem to have decided to go after middle class votes as well. Since 2010 they have chosen three successive leaders who stayed firmly inside their own personal comfort zone and the current situation is the result.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 20/03/2022 15:23

No, Labour has been infected by the woke virus.
No known cure, unfortunately.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/03/2022 14:30

Men are not women and the fact that Labour MPs continue to actively insist they are because they’re either too stupid to know the difference or to scared to say it out loud is why I won’t vote for them

If they’re that stupid and/or spineless over a basic biological fact and have allowed themselves to captured by TRA then what else will they be stupid/spineless and captured over

This. It's about their craven dishonesty more than anything.

ilovesooty · 20/03/2022 14:19

@Yeahthat

Well that didn't take long.

Forget any wide ranging discussion on electability OP.

@ilovesooty

Unfortunately for you, you don't get to decide what other people base their vote on.

Of course. I'm still allowed to express my point of view though.
Yeahthat · 20/03/2022 14:13

I doubt I'll ever vote for them as long as they firstly: Don't seem to actually like the UK very much and back any movement which seeks to condemn it and/or selectively use history to demolish our symbols and national icons. Secondly: They're championing identify politics, and are unable to say what a woman is.

DdraigGoch · 20/03/2022 14:13

Dominic Raab... assertion that misogyny applies to both sexes.

I hate to break it to you, but most of the population would assume the same. Plenty have never heard the word "misogyny" fewer still would have heard the word "misandry".

As an interview question, "what is a woman?" is ideal because of its simplicity. Everyone knows what a woman is so watching politicians tie themselves up in knots trying not to say so is prime entertainment.

catgirl1976 · 20/03/2022 14:08

They’ll need to work out what’s woman is first

QueenBitch666 · 20/03/2022 14:07

Not while they're pushing identity politics and have no idea what a woman is

Yeahthat · 20/03/2022 14:06

Well that didn't take long.

Forget any wide ranging discussion on electability OP.

@ilovesooty

Unfortunately for you, you don't get to decide what other people base their vote on.

Blueblossompinksky · 20/03/2022 13:59

The women thing matters and is important because once you redefine what a woman is every single hard won right women have becomes a man right too.

OP posts:
EmpressaurusWitchDoesntBurn · 20/03/2022 13:53

Labour have stated very clearly that they don’t want me to vote for them. So I won’t.

Fluffycloudland77 · 20/03/2022 13:48

No, it’s worse than the Kinnock years now.