Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will Labour ever get back in?

411 replies

Blueblossompinksky · 20/03/2022 10:32

My understanding is that the labour majority was in part because of the Scottish vote, which seems to have gone to the SNP.

I realise it’s unlikely that the Tories will get back in with such a large majority as 2019 but will there actually be enough seats for Labour to win?

OP posts:
RubyTrees · 20/03/2022 21:17

@Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky

Expanding the definition of women to include men, and on the basis of their own declaration which is what Labour unacceptably want to do, destroys any hope of evidence based policy making

Want to tackle issues around woman’s pay or violence against women or the under representation of women in politics or womens poverty or improving woman’s health? How do you do that when you don’t know if you counting biological women or including men who feel like women? Whose testimony are you listening too - biological womens or men who feel like women? Are they not very different experiences?

And the evidence of the last years shows us that there is nothing women have that TW won’t try & get in on. Programmes to increase womens representation in politics & STEM , sport, the menopause & even still birth ffs

It’s not just that we will be forced to include TW in all women related things, it’s that they will be privileged over women because they already are. Witness how rules and guidelines everywhere are being torn up in the face of objections from women to appease them

Plus as said above. Men no matter how they present are not women & I will not vote for any party whose MPs are hell bent in paddling such patent fucking nonsense

Perfectly put, thank you @Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky
Cyw2018 · 20/03/2022 21:08

but what are the Tories position on trans rights? Or rather, what party has been in power for the last 12 years. I'll give you a clue, it ain't labour.

The UK is massively behind other western nations (US, Canada, NZ, Aus) in the progression of trans rights at the expense of women and this is part due to having the Conservatives in power for the last decade, without them it would have been much worse. It is also likely due to UK being 'distracted' by Brexit, and then that rolling into COVID and now the potential for WW3, which has meant thankfully less progress on Gender ideology in the UK

Anon778833 · 20/03/2022 21:07

They could get in again but I don’t think Keir Starmer is ever going to be PM. This man apparently has decided to go around saying that he doesn’t know what socialism is and feels the need to be called Sir. He isn’t a creature of the Labour Party.

Labour should be the ones calling out the shit that the Tories are doing to the UK, but no they don’t - they leave it to Marcus Rashford.

ParsleySageRosemary · 20/03/2022 21:07

Not until they grow up and start standing for something other than a typical British class-based power stitch-up, and remember who they’re supposed to stand for.

Slothtoes · 20/03/2022 21:06

Sorry but nobody’s arguing about trans rights. Trans people have rights under the Equality Act like everyone else and that’s all good.

We’re arguing about women’s rights, under severe attack from an authoritarian, anti-democratic, wildly misogynistic political agenda.

chilling19 · 20/03/2022 21:05

'Who wants the lying head the ball crazy clown car gender nutter party in. Lol. Not me.'

Nor me. 😂

WouldBeGood · 20/03/2022 21:02

What @Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky said

Perfectly put

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 20/03/2022 21:01

Again. Not voting Labour does not mean voting Conservative.

Slothtoes · 20/03/2022 21:01

Unfortunately the shitty authoritarian atmosphere created by the extremely privileged and sexist adherents of gender identity politics, means that in real life, lots of us don’t feel free to talk about this. We can’t because we fear the consequences for ourselves or others if we do. MN deserves praise for allowing women to talk to each other about their lives, which current mainstream political party thinking would say is being ‘hateful’. Hmm

SecretSpAD · 20/03/2022 21:01

@AgentProvocateur

Not now that they’ve alienated 50% of the population by their inability to define a woman.
I'm pretty gender critical, but when it comes to looking at the bigger picture Labour are the only hope for working class women and children. It might help some people to remember which party has done the most damage to our sex with its policies in the last 12 years. It is often mentioned on here that labour and Lib Dem's don't know what a woman is, but what are the Tories position on trans rights? Or rather, what party has been in power for the last 12 years. I'll give you a clue, it ain't labour. At the end of the day we will have to decide, as a country, whether trans rights are more important than feeding people, protecting the NHS, investing in public services...or are we saying that arguing about trans rights are more important than families not having to choose between heating and eating.
SuitcaseOfWhine · 20/03/2022 20:58

@Mistygreyeyes

Johnson cocks up and the next day yet another labour bashing thread with hundreds of ex labour voters (yeah right Hmm) promising to vote for the tories because Labour don't know what a woman is. What about a thread criticising the actual government for the numerous cluster fucks they've caused which involve millions of women and children like austerity ? But no lets divert attention. Again..
Yes I know. What a coincidence 🤔

The funny thing is, Tories blatantly do not give a monster fuck about women either, or anyone below the poverty line, the disabled, public sector workers, kids who barely get fed, basically anyone under the age of 50. I could go on.....

Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky · 20/03/2022 20:52

Expanding the definition of women to include men, and on the basis of their own declaration which is what Labour unacceptably want to do, destroys any hope of evidence based policy making

Want to tackle issues around woman’s pay or violence against women or the under representation of women in politics or womens poverty or improving woman’s health? How do you do that when you don’t know if you counting biological women or including men who feel like women? Whose testimony are you listening too - biological womens or men who feel like women? Are they not very different experiences?

And the evidence of the last years shows us that there is nothing women have that TW won’t try & get in on. Programmes to increase womens representation in politics & STEM , sport, the menopause & even still birth ffs

It’s not just that we will be forced to include TW in all women related things, it’s that they will be privileged over women because they already are. Witness how rules and guidelines everywhere are being torn up in the face of objections from women to appease them

Plus as said above. Men no matter how they present are not women & I will not vote for any party whose MPs are hell bent in paddling such patent fucking nonsense

SuitcaseOfWhine · 20/03/2022 20:49

@raspberryjamchicken

Every thread about voting Labour is immediately taken over by posters who say they wouldn't vote for them on the basis of definition of a woman. I consider myself a feminist and am concerned about things like safe spaces for women but I would still vote Labour as I have other priorities when I vote.

I would be interested to know if there has been any actual polling on whether this issue would in fact lead to a reduction of numbers voting Labour. I never hear anyone say anything about it in real life and wonder if the number of people in demographics outside of MN who would actively choose to vote Labour because of their stance on trans rights would outweigh those who wouldn't? Presumably the Labour Party itself think so.

Lots of bots jump on these types of threads as soon as Labour is mentioned in the thread title - it goes over my head. It's very clear that while gender ID is an issue for some (it is for me too, I won't go into why on here though) it does not eliminate the endless list of failings of this Tory government. Nobody talks about it to the degree they do on MN in real life, and it certainly wouldn't be the only thing considered when voting for a political party. I would not see MN as representative of the rest of the population.
NiceWelshLady · 20/03/2022 20:45

WildPoinsettia

"Labour are in in Wales and our lives are better for it, compared to those in England. I hope they stay in Wales and if they get into Westminster, even better."

Isn't the NHS in Wales even more buggered than everywhere else in the UK though?

Absolutely buggered. Add to that we've lived under the tightest restrictions in the UK for the last two years. That wouldn't be so bad if it had kept us safer. Instead we have the highest covid death rate in the UK and the second highest in Europe.

If anyone wants to a very good reason not to vote Labour, take a look at Wales.

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2022 20:38

Men already dictate how safe women can be. Always have, always will. I went on Reclaim the Night marches in the 80s, they were a complete waste of time.

Ionlydomassiveones · 20/03/2022 20:32

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Florenz · 20/03/2022 20:32

@Slothtoes

I’m not sure what the AiBU question is here so I didn’t vote. But to answer the OP’s question, yes I think at some point Labour have to get back in. With a new leader, probably, though. Rachel Reeves?
They will get back in eventually but the point is how bad things will have to get before they get back in. Which as it stands is very bad. It'd be nice to have a Labour party that could get in on their own merits, not just because the incumbent party is so awful that people hold their nose and vote Labour to get them out.
FindingMeno · 20/03/2022 20:29

I don't care who runs the country so long as its not the tories

Slothtoes · 20/03/2022 20:28

I’m not sure what the AiBU question is here so I didn’t vote. But to answer the OP’s question, yes I think at some point Labour have to get back in. With a new leader, probably, though. Rachel Reeves?

Cyw2018 · 20/03/2022 20:27

I'm another one who will NEVER vote for a party that doesn't understand biological reality and what a women is.

Slothtoes · 20/03/2022 20:23

AllofUs I agree with what you’re saying and think it’s awful that someone with Boris Johnson’s lack of integrity is running the country- but that’s a huge insult to sperm donors, who have actually done something altruistic for other people. Smile

Florenz · 20/03/2022 20:23

WHY are Labour siding with the activists? It doesn't make any sense. I don't understand it all. They know full well that it will cost them elections. The Tories will make it a big issue and they will be on the side that most people are on, and Labour will be on the other side, and there is no possible way that everyone in the Labour party does not know this. So why?

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2022 20:23

“Labour doesn’t know what a woman is” has become the 2022 version of “I couldn’t vote for Corbyn”.

Slothtoes · 20/03/2022 20:20

I’m confused by previous Labour voter posters on this thread saying they won’t vote Labour.. or that they will vote Tory.. because ‘labour don’t know what a woman is.’

The exact same problem goes for the Tories, who have refused to reform the GRA at all. They have a massive Parliamentary majority and could have put through any woman-friendly policies they wished to. But no. They have instead held a constant trump card over UK women- if they wanted to, in future they can argue to bring in self ID etc. We don’t have any new protections from this Tory government. The advances we have come from case law that we women have crowdfunded, and millions of unpaid woman-hours of campaigning by women at grassroots level. (Thank you Maya Forstater, Keira Bell, Ann Sinnott and others) It’s really not the Tories ‘knowing what a woman is’. Hmm

There’s lots of reasons to be pissed off with Labour and it’s enraging that Starmer, who seems decent enough, isn’t cutting through when the lives of more and more working people are getting harder and harder.

But that specific gender-critical reason for not voting Labour is equally applicable to the Conservatives, Lib Dems, SNP, Greens, WEP. You name it. They all have sexist, regressive policies which endanger single sex spaces and services and opportunities for women.

That’s the whole problem- we don’t have any mainstream party to vote for who knows what a woman is.

urbanbuddha · 20/03/2022 20:12

But we are going to allow all of that to happen because Labour don't know what a woman is. Nor does Boris! Someone quoted earlier that he refused to say that only women have a cervix. So he is the exact same as Labour, and yet you'll all vote for him and the measures to make our lives worse?

Not voting Labour does not equal voting Conservative.
Unfortunately Labour is refusing to listen to women's very valid concerns and that's a line in the sand for me. I value the NHS but I also want DD to have safe spaces if she needs them and to be able to compete fairly in competitive sports if it turns out that's her thing. It's a shame Keir Starmer can't show the same committment to women's issues that he did to anti-semitism. He doesn't even seem to acknowledge or understand the concerns.

Boris is actually worse really. He has gotten how many women pregnant and then ran off? He seems to see himself as simply a sperm donor. And we allow this behaviour to be applauded.

No-one I know, of any political persuasion, applauds this behaviour. He has the public schoolboy's attitude that women are lesser beings and he himself seems to view them as disposable. That's deplorable. But it doesn't give Labour the right to ignore women's views.