Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will Labour ever get back in?

411 replies

Blueblossompinksky · 20/03/2022 10:32

My understanding is that the labour majority was in part because of the Scottish vote, which seems to have gone to the SNP.

I realise it’s unlikely that the Tories will get back in with such a large majority as 2019 but will there actually be enough seats for Labour to win?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
babyjellyfish · 23/03/2022 19:23

@PurgatoryOfPotholes Crazy, I know!

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 23/03/2022 17:28

@babyjellyfish

Nimco Ali is a friend of the Johnsons and I bet Carrie reads Mumsnet, so I wouldn't be surprised to see the Tories adopting a more TERF-y position before the next election even if it's only to get more votes.
A party... trying to get more votes? What, instead of acting as if they'd rather lose an election than be tainted by association with The Wrong Sort Of Voter?

What? There are parties that try to increase their vote-share?

FOJN · 23/03/2022 17:15

Maybe I wasn't clear enough in what I was saying, which is on me.
I'm not saying that everyone that cares about this issue are bots, at all - the knee-jerk rage!

I'm confused. Did you just take responsibility for not being clear but then immediately take it back by accusing those who objected to your "Tory bot" comments of "knee jerk rage"?

NONE of the main parties have said "a woman is someone born with F on their birth certificate and we will always stand up with that viewpoint" and yet its an issue that has been framed so often as a purely anti-Labour view.

No one is born with an F on their birth certificate; that document is completed after you are born and your sex has been observed.

The Labour party are being criticized because the are the party of opposition and they support self ID. Whilst the conservatives have not publicly spoken about the definition of woman they have stated they will not reform the GRA to include self ID which means that we can use the protections and definitions contained within the EA 2010 to protect our rights and single sex spaces. The EA defines a woman as a female of any age and a man as a male of any age. Female and male denote biological sex which is immutable and not a spectrum.

Xenia · 23/03/2022 16:31

I think the distinction is as clear as day - Labour wants the law changed and the Tories under Mrs May decided not to do so after their consultation to which I responded (on the trans issue)

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/03/2022 16:28

Knee jerk rage?

Good lord 😀

MangyInseam · 23/03/2022 16:19

@StormTreader

Maybe I wasn't clear enough in what I was saying, which is on me. I'm not saying that everyone that cares about this issue are bots, at all - the knee-jerk rage!

I'm saying that there are a lot of bot accounts out there that have managed to frame these issues as a case of "if you have this view on this issue then you CAN'T vote Labour because a vote for Labour is a vote against this view you care about" when the truth of the matter is usually that ALL the main parties won't have expressed a clear stance thats in favour of the outcome you want.

NONE of the main parties have said "a woman is someone born with F on their birth certificate and we will always stand up with that viewpoint" and yet its an issue that has been framed so often as a purely anti-Labour view.

It's also not helpful to say "well I won't vote for anyone then!" because there are so many other also important points - womens voices and votes are important and we should have a voice in trying to direct our countries politics and not stay silent because no parties are publicly supporting one side or the other on an issue even if its the most important one to you.

Even if no party is or has been perfect on this, there is actually a huge gap between them.

Labour have made it clear that they, as a party, maintain TWAW/TMAM and that those who say otherwise are bigoted. The Conservative party doesn't.

Labour MPs are hounded for speaking against the party view on this, and so are party members at the local level. Voters have been told they are bigots for not agreeing. The Tories have a wide variety of views with many of them speaking out against these ideas, and have not called voters bigots.

Labour intended to pursue self-id, and it's possible to imagine also hate-speech type laws like those in Canada. The Tories don't and have not been all that receptive to the idea of that kind of hate speech law.

Labour MPs have said things like TW should be housed in women's prisons and seem keen to expand treatments for kids. The Tories seem to have a lot of MPs against this kind of thing.

LibDems and Greens overall are the same as Labour on this.

So if we think about these groups actually being elected, it simply looks like there is a shit-ton to worry about with Labour, while even Tories who do support those things would struggle to get support in their own parties.

And that's without considering the bad taste that Labour's dismissal of women's views on this has left in people's mouths.

babyjellyfish · 23/03/2022 15:35

Nimco Ali is a friend of the Johnsons and I bet Carrie reads Mumsnet, so I wouldn't be surprised to see the Tories adopting a more TERF-y position before the next election even if it's only to get more votes.

StormTreader · 23/03/2022 15:00

I also believe its less that women are having an effect, and more that the current trans swimming issue in the news at the moment is highlighting that there is definitely still a lot more work to do in regards to fairness in sporting events at least.

StormTreader · 23/03/2022 14:58

Ok, so he has expressed a general personal view but hasn't committed in any real way to any pledge as a party to do or not do anything specific? Just that "When it comes to distinguishing between a man and a woman, the basic facts of biology remain overwhelmingly important" which means as much or little as you want it to mean really.

Let's see if that's still the view he has in a week or two I guess, and if that translates to any actual concrete pledges or assurances that will affect anything at all - he does love to speak in favour of whatever direction is blowing in the wind this week. At least its the start of a view on it.

WouldBeGood · 23/03/2022 14:50

But women saying this is having an effect @StormTreader hence the Johnson answer today

StormTreader · 23/03/2022 14:44

Maybe I wasn't clear enough in what I was saying, which is on me.
I'm not saying that everyone that cares about this issue are bots, at all - the knee-jerk rage!

I'm saying that there are a lot of bot accounts out there that have managed to frame these issues as a case of "if you have this view on this issue then you CAN'T vote Labour because a vote for Labour is a vote against this view you care about" when the truth of the matter is usually that ALL the main parties won't have expressed a clear stance thats in favour of the outcome you want.

NONE of the main parties have said "a woman is someone born with F on their birth certificate and we will always stand up with that viewpoint" and yet its an issue that has been framed so often as a purely anti-Labour view.

It's also not helpful to say "well I won't vote for anyone then!" because there are so many other also important points - womens voices and votes are important and we should have a voice in trying to direct our countries politics and not stay silent because no parties are publicly supporting one side or the other on an issue even if its the most important one to you.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 23/03/2022 14:20

@Mistygreyeyes

I’m constantly surprised by the number of threads about labour’s unsuitability to be in power when we have had a tory government for the last 11 years that is totally corrupt and inept. So many examples of their incompetence and dishonesty, pork barrel politics, dodgy deals that have affected every one in the UK and in particular woman but nope Labour are even worse. Very few threads about their corruption but one condemning labour every few weeks. I’ve been on MN years +15. It used to be a kind mildly left leaning site. Not any more.
It's because this site is a left-leaning one that there are more threads about Labour.

Users here feel personally betrayed by Labour, and apprehensive about having to hold their nose to vote for Labour as a "least-bad" option. It is upsetting. I always used to be able to make a cross in the Labour box with a song in my heart. Now I can't. So, yeah, I post more about that than I post about the Conservative party being sleazy.

HouseOfGoldandBones · 23/03/2022 13:39

It seems he knows

twitter.com/BloombergUK/status/1506613982697775113?t=bwnvT7wPAQ2VPQwtweCmEA&s=19

WouldBeGood · 23/03/2022 13:37

@MarshaBradyo that’s very good news, as it demonstrates that the issue has been noticed.

Maybe he’s been reading this thread?? 😃

Otherpeoplesteens · 23/03/2022 13:36

@Mistygreyeyes Angela Rayner was not the first, and I very much doubt the last, Labour member to refer to anyone else as "Tory scum." I have had it said about me, in my presence, by Labour door-to-door canvassers during both local and Parliamentary elections - i.e. more than once. As in shouting to the bloke with the clipboard "no bothering point here, just more Tory scum" as they walk down my driveway.

I was in Wrong-Daily's constituency at the time.

Brexit was not a Tory project. It was an ERG and UKIP project - the entire European Union was effectively held to ransom by about 30 unhinged MPs. Labour could, and should, have properly campaigned to Remain, but Corbyn is a neo-communist who saw a chance to weaken capitalist Britain and the entire EU and took it.

CarbonelCat · 23/03/2022 13:28

It's my hill too.

It's now my starting point when examining a party manifesto and policies.

I am appalled. Absolutely appalled by the behaviour of labour over this issue. I voted labour at every opportunity prior to this. No chance now.

Why people feel that is unimportant baffles me. I am a very clichéd left leaning middle class professional woman - indicative of thousands like me. I am the sort of person who does the teas at the school fayre, joins in with the local tree planting, litter picking, cake baking. I am community minded and focussed. I coordinate the food bank collection for the harvest festival, I run the second hand uniform stall, the shoebox collection for the homeless at Christmas, snack time at playgroup, song group at the library...I'm not right wing, I'm not religious, I'm not bigoted.

I'm sick of being dismissed.

DdraigGoch · 23/03/2022 13:18

[quote Mistygreyeyes]@Otherpeoplesteens Corbyn has been well and truly kicked out, no longer a labour MP. Angela Rayner
apologised for that insult and I agree it was pathetic. But tory policies are already affecting us, Brexit was a Tory project, to blame Labour for brexit is frankly weird.[/quote]
Rayner was interviewed by Andrew Marr last night. Still a Corbynista through and through. I can't trust a party that has her on the front bench.

MarshaBradyo · 23/03/2022 12:58

Looks like Johnson has said views today

Few threads on it

Good to hear finally

TooBigForMyBoots · 23/03/2022 12:53

Why don’t you try and listen to what many women are saying rather than do the typical Labour insult / belittle and bot part?

I havent insulted or belittled anyone. Nor have I called anyone a bot.Confused

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/03/2022 12:20

I don’t actually believe any of the posters wobbling on about bots are politically minded in the slightest

Every single thread like this over the last few years has had posters saying they feel they can’t vote for labour…and gets bombarded with people saying how dreadful they are for voting tory

When a lot of those posters (not all) have never voted tory and don’t intend to

Other parties exist and can be voted for and people can spoil their votes if they want to

Its this pesky thing called democracy and a number of ‘everyone is a tory bot’ posters are sounding like the more vocal brexit posters and seem very unhappy that the voting public are allowed to vote for anyone they want to

More than two parties exist

People can vote for whomever they like

I am curious though….a poster upthread mentioned gay people voting for a party with homophobic policies. One assumes that the ‘tory bot’ posters believe that gay people should indeed vote for those parties?

TooBigForMyBoots · 23/03/2022 12:14

Which party has the best stance in terms of stating what a woman is?

Probably the DUP.Grin

MarshaBradyo · 23/03/2022 11:57

Or least likely to press ahead with Self ID?

FOJN · 23/03/2022 11:57

Then you better beware of Conservative MP, Crispin Blunt who recently reported a woman for retweeting JKR @FOJN. I'm glad you're doing your homework, everyone should because it's dangerous to assume how any candidate stands on this issue.

I'm fully aware of Crispin Blunt's behaviour thanks. I make a point of reading or watching the news and informing myself before forming an opinion on a political issue.

Perhaps you better beware of being so patronising. I hope it's not a surprise for you to be told you are not the most informed of informed things just because you think you are.

MarshaBradyo · 23/03/2022 11:54

@TooBigForMyBoots

The thing is, they aren't actually doing anything about that issue they know people are passionate about. They're just using it to manipulate the vote, the way they did with Brexit.

I'm keeping JKR company on this hill and will die here if I have to.
Then you better beware of Conservative MP, Crispin Blunt who recently reported a woman for retweeting JKR @FOJN. I'm glad you're doing your homework, everyone should because it's dangerous to assume how any candidate stands on this issue.

Which party has the best stance in terms of stating what a woman is? in your view