Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be utterly sick of toxic positivity?

119 replies

Goldenbunnies · 20/03/2022 08:03

Over the last 4 years, I have had some of the most difficult and painful experiences of my life. A close family member passed away, I had a cancer scare which required surgery, ex DP cheated on me while I was pregnant, then abandoned me and DC when I ended things and witheld money for DC (dodger maintenance by being ‘self employed’), I had a bad episode of depression and gained 50lbs which I’m trying really hard to lose.

Despite all this, anyone I have opened up to about how difficult the last few years have been have had the same sort of response - everything happens for a reason, try not to dwell on the negatives, don’t you feel grateful to have healthy DC. I know people say these things with good intentions but I find it so deflating. Social media is awash with the same sort of stuff.

AIBU to feel fed up with it and just want to be able to acknowledge that the past few years of my life have been pretty shit?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Katieandthekids · 22/03/2022 09:21

@couchparsnip

I hate the phrase 'everything happens for a reason'. It's absolute bollocks. Sometimes awful things happen to people for no good reason at all and saying this sort of crap makes it worse.
I agree. My sister is 30 and is going to have to live her life with cancer for however long she survives it. What possible f*ing reason is there for that? If someone said that to me they would be at risk of a black eye
FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 21/03/2022 22:48

*In less than a year my father got diagnosed with cancer,then died ,then I found out I was adopted and then had a cancer scare. At which point should I have stopped "moaning" ? Which event could be ignored and got over it just in case it overwhelmed my friends? Or maybe that's actually better because it was just 6 months and not 4 years?

OP isn't talking about losing her favourite bag, washing machine died and her chocolate being unavailable. She had significant life events/trauma on top of each other that have left a mark and of course she wanted to talk about it. What the hell are friends for? Just banter ,drinks and the last episode of "Emily in Paris"?*

What you've highlighted is that everybody goes through shit times. I get it. But there has to come a point where you just crack on. Opting to wallow instead is up to the individual. Just as its up to me to actively avoid it because I don't want my good mood drained away by other people's incessant negativity.

Titsywoo · 21/03/2022 22:30

This is one of the reasons I see a wonderful counsellor. She actually listens and her replies are always supportive.

ldontWanna · 21/03/2022 22:29

@FrankLampardsBrokenHand

It all really depends. You said you've had it bad for 4 years. If you've been complaining for that long, I can fully understand why you're hit with a positive message because its really draining being around people who only ever highlight the misery in life.
It's not exactly OP's fault that shit happened is it? There's no specific timeline and life doesn't go "oh this person has had some really crap years and might lose some friends if she moans about anything else" .

In less than a year my father got diagnosed with cancer,then died ,then I found out I was adopted and then had a cancer scare. At which point should I have stopped "moaning" ? Which event could be ignored and got over it just in case it overwhelmed my friends? Or maybe that's actually better because it was just 6 months and not 4 years?

OP isn't talking about losing her favourite bag, washing machine died and her chocolate being unavailable. She had significant life events/trauma on top of each other that have left a mark and of course she wanted to talk about it. What the hell are friends for? Just banter ,drinks and the last episode of "Emily in Paris"?

Pluvia · 21/03/2022 22:18

This positivity thing is nothing new. It's what the dope-addled old hippies around here believe in: a mixture of Buddhism and 'spirituality' that enables them to be exceptionally selfish while believing they're wonderful human beings.

I had a neighbour who had a full-term stillbirth: terribly distressing. A couple of days after she came home from hospital, shocked and grieving, one of the lovely floaty spiritual women called round and explained to the distraught mother that she must have done something bad in a previous life to merit losing her baby. Another one of the enlightened spiritual lot told the man who ran the local shop that his motor neurone diagnosis (a horrible disease that involves awful suffering) would do wonders for his karma.

There are several similar charmers on this thread, I see.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 21/03/2022 21:25

You can acknowledge that it’s been shit but how far does that get you? Only so far… at some point your thoughts have to change and it’s not toxic positivity to have people try and help you with that… The foundation of most types of therapy is to be able change unhelpful thoughts into one’s that are more helpful

You can’t change your thoughts until you’re ready to do so, and sometimes you need time to come to terms with something. Rushing people into “changing their thoughts” smacks of not being able to respect the idea that people process things at different speeds and in different ways in favour of a “pull yourselves up by your bootstraps” approach. The idea that “acknowledgement doesn’t get you anywhere” implies that at each point in the process that there’s somewhere else to be.

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 21/03/2022 21:03

It all really depends. You said you've had it bad for 4 years. If you've been complaining for that long, I can fully understand why you're hit with a positive message because its really draining being around people who only ever highlight the misery in life.

workwoes123 · 21/03/2022 17:57

I hear you OP.

Have you read Oliver Burkeman's The Antidote: Happiness for people who can't stand positive thinking? It's a good read and will give you some relief from the 'look on the bright side' crap people come out with.

A lot of the time I think it might be well meant, but it's mostly to make the speaker feel better. I choose very carefully who I moan to these days.

OTOH endless negativity can be pretty draining. DH can get really, really grumpy when he's feeling down: it doesn't help him and makes people just avoid him. I try to aim for a middle ground: realistic, acknowledging pain and trauma, but not inflicting a stream of doom, gloom and grumpiness on people that don't deserve it.

Peakypolly · 21/03/2022 17:51

Thanks Samphire and Bower

Clarabe1 · 21/03/2022 17:51

Grrrr! Drives me mad. What are you grateful for today? Count your blessings. Shitty inspirational quotes. I totally agree with you op. Sometimes you just need acknowledgment that you are having a shit time and for someone to just listen without telling you to be strong and think positive. The one that really annoys me is ‘you have got this’ Well no actually I haven’t, it’s all falling apart here.

ldontWanna · 21/03/2022 17:45

Here's the thing, if your friend breaks their leg do you respond with:

Oh no, I'm so sorry/That's so shit . How are you feeling? How can I help ? Or some variation of this.

Or :

Everything happens for a reason.
Well at least you only broke one leg.
Just think how much stronger your other leg will be.
Your cast will look so cool!

?

If you'd normally respond with the first, the same principle applies for trauma,hurt feelings,anger ,sadness ,grief etc. it's not rocket science.

Momicrone · 21/03/2022 16:23

Sunny two bridges, one can still be happy in the midst of grief

PinkFluffyUnicornSlippers · 21/03/2022 16:14

@Horological

I’m so sorry OP. That all sounds like shit and I really hope things improve for you.

I get exactly what you are saying about toxic positivity. It’s like nobody is allowed to have a hard time, tell the truth about how it feels and simply have people listen and keep you company through it, however long it takes.

The worst, worst things are ‘gratitude journals’

Going to have to completely disagree with you over the gratitude journals and feel it may actually help the OP. Sometimes it’s good to recognise the good in your life, however small. The small good things can often lead onto bigger good things.
MangyInseam · 21/03/2022 16:07

I think it's not a great thing that people feel they have to respond and think in terms of positivity all the time - but people really struggle not to. We don't really allow for being sad or melancholy as a normal part of life, especially if it goes on for long. We even medicalize it.

LizzoBennett · 21/03/2022 16:04

@RobotValkyrieb It's because I can self soothe that I don't need my friends to soothe me and I don't expect to soothe them constantly. Every now and then is fine but I'm not a comfort blanket. I'm a happy positive person to be around but in return I want to be around happy, positive people, not fun suckers.

Sunnytwobridges · 21/03/2022 15:23

I had to end a friendship because of someone with toxic positivity. She always saw the bright side of everything, and didn't believe in being down about anything. So when my DM passed away she for some bizarre reason expected me to be happy and over it only 6 months after. She couldn't understand why I was still depressed and sad, when she had as much tragedy in her life but she'd "moved on with her life" and I couldn't. Our "friendship" was never the same for years afterwards to the point where we dont speak anymore.

Strawberry33 · 21/03/2022 15:07

You can acknowledge that it’s been shit but how far does that get you? Only so far… at some point your thoughts have to change and it’s not toxic positivity to have people try and help you with that. I hate all this stuff about “toxic positivity” as it’s like the word “narcissist” where everyone thinks they know all about it. The foundation of most types of therapy is to be able change unhelpful thoughts into one’s that are more
Helpful. That’s it. So what is the point in anyone being stuck in the same place because they won’t hear anyone giving alternatives?

Lampan · 21/03/2022 14:55

I agree. I was on a date with someone and I told him my mother has Alzheimer’s. His response was to tell me “it’ll make you a stronger person”
I don’t want to be a stronger person, I just want a mother who can remember who her family are Sad

BowerOfBramble · 21/03/2022 14:52

@Peakypolly

With this in mind, how would you address sending a (21st) birthday card to my family member who is having a very tough time with her mental health. My tendency was always a 'find how to dance in the rain' type message but now, thanks to conversations like these, I realise how inappropriate and even offensive they can seem. Currently she is unable to see anyone apart from her next of kin. I do want to acknowledge her birthday but don't know what to say. Any tips Goldenbunnies or anyone?
I would write “Dear Niece, sending you my best wishes for your birthday. I’m sorry things are so hard at the moment and I hope the next year is an easier one for you. Don’t forget I’m always there on the end of the phone if you want a chat/silly auntie joke” or something those lines
SamphiretheStickerist · 21/03/2022 14:50

I sent a cousin a Hug in a Mug when her mum was detriorating fast.

A plain mug with small chocolates, a large folded pink heart and a hot chocolate sachet in it. Totally inappropriate for a skinny minny who never eats chocolate and is always watching her weight.

She thanked me for being me, knew it was a gift from me as soon as she opened it and that she and her mum had had a smile at my knowing her so well! The mug was a good'un!

Maybe something like that would help you.

Lambanddog · 21/03/2022 14:49

My God, you are so not wrong! Sick of it also.

Looubylou · 21/03/2022 14:48

Thankyou for saying this OP. People find it very difficult to just listen and support, some can't cope and some do care, but feel they must make you feel better and fix things somehow. I'm in my early 50's. My hair is still dark shiney and thick - but I have lost 2 inches of my hairline due to a form of permanent alopecia. My much loved friend of 35 years cheerfully exclaimed that we could find me some fabulous scarves and was very "positively dismissive", when I shared my despair 7 years ago, when it all started. I know she cares, but I don't quite see her the same way, since then. I know that's nothing compared to your experiences OP, but it definately is important to be able to share that things are or have been frankly shit 💐

BrightYellowDaffodil · 21/03/2022 14:47

@Relentlessrose

I think we are taught from a young age that if somebody has a feeling it always needs some kind of response. So instead of truly listening, we are busy thinking of how to respond. Instead of sitting with them in their dark place, we are busy turning lights on. Instead of letting them process their feelings at their own pace, we are hurrying them to be better. Instead of letting things just be as they are, we find the need to fix everything. Not every feeling needs a response. That person doesn't always need a platitude or a sticking plaster or a cup of tea or a box of tissues. That person may not need a hand hold or a hug or a bit of humour to break the mood. That person may not need you to wrap their problems up in pretty packaging and hand it back to them. They may not need to hear that you have experienced something similar so know how they feel. They don't need you to help them get some gratitude, or some perspective or to be reminded of people who have it worse off than them. There will always be famine, war and disease. There will always be someone worse off than you too, but that does not diminish that persons suffering. Sometimes they do not need a response of any kind, they just need to be heard, to be seen, to know that they are not alone. That you can handle their pain and darkness and sit in it beside them despite the awkward feelings that make them want to shine a light somewhere. Sometimes all people need is for you to be there. To bite your tongue and hold their gaze and let it all flow out of them and all around you. To just be together. That is the greatest gift you can give a friend in pain. To just let them be authentic and open and know they are not alone.
I very much agree with this. Sometimes you just want someone to acknowledge and agree that things are shit. Company while you work through stuff and all that, rather than trying to jolly you on before you've processed.
Peakypolly · 21/03/2022 14:46

With this in mind, how would you address sending a (21st) birthday card to my family member who is having a very tough time with her mental health. My tendency was always a 'find how to dance in the rain' type message but now, thanks to conversations like these, I realise how inappropriate and even offensive they can seem.
Currently she is unable to see anyone apart from her next of kin. I do want to acknowledge her birthday but don't know what to say.
Any tips Goldenbunnies or anyone?

Back21970 · 21/03/2022 14:46

Toxic Positivity is a brilliant description of it! I could have written this post, thank you OP, you’ve made me feel semi normal!

A few people in my workplace, especially my boss, are like this, everyone has to keep smiling and not be negative no matter what is going on. It’s not even a public facing job, which I could at least understand.

Apparently ‘fake it till you make it’ and ‘just do it’ are the way to go when you are feeling shit.

Sometimes things in life can be shit and its ok to acknowledge that in my opinion instead of being expected to always see the positive in everything X