Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you have mental health problems that stop you from doing things do you get sick of people saying they can’t do things because of their mental health.

118 replies

Toothiehurtie · 19/03/2022 22:47

No trolling genuinely wondering. There are kids in my kids classes at school who are starting to get attention for mental health issues and there are more kids than not now with a reason why they need to be treated differently tk the majority to the point where the kids doing what they are supposed to be doing are in the minority. If you’re the one who normally gets an allowance for your mental health does it piss you off when it’s allowed for everyone or do you feel like it’s great that mental health is being acknowledged. The example I’m thinking of is a kid at school who was allowed not to wear school shoes and now most of the class wear trainers and the whatsapp grouo mums are saying their kids are much happier if they get to wear what they want, and now school are clamping back. Not trolling not fishing just interested if you or your kid gets treated differently to everyone else and allowances are made fo you then does it ruin it for you if lots of people get it too

OP posts:
glowingcandle · 20/03/2022 08:26

You're right, but it's so pervasive in state primary schools, well behaved girls are sat next to naughty boys all the time. It makes girls think they are responsible for moderating others' behaviour.

Does this still happen? It was the case at my state primary 30 years ago. Also a star chart on the wall, and according to that all the naughty kids were the best in the class as they'd get a star for basic things like sitting quietly doing their work 🤦🏻‍♀️

Gardeningcreature · 20/03/2022 08:21

Yep I see this at work too.
Colleagues who basically throw in the mental health card to get away with doing what they want.
The rest of us who might suffer just as much from mental health issues but prefer to keep it private and try other methods of dealing with it, are then left to do all the hard work.
The tell tale give away in all of this is that whenever it suits those who won't do the hard work, they swap and change.
So A refuses to work weekends as it is too stressful and affects their mental health. This means the rest of us have to do it even though we would rather not.
Yet whenever A's dh needs the car midweek A suddenly has to work weekends as they can't work midweek. Now person B decides they cannot possibly work weekends either so yet again the rest of us are told we have to cover for them. Except it also suits person B to work specific weekends and have time off mid week, surprisingly this is always when their oh is off mid week.
Whenever managers try and rectify this as A and B are contracted to work weekends and not pick and choose they go off sick, again causing the rest of us more stress.
Nobody else can state when they will work we are told you are contracted to work blah blah blah. Exactly the same as A and B are.

Sorehandsandfeet · 20/03/2022 08:17

As long as the needs of my children are being met, I think that overall understanding of difference/ mental health is a good thing. If my son is to be taken out for small group lessons or quiet movement breaks, I would expect that to continue. However, it can only be a good thing if others get the same without compromising the quality of sn provision. There are ECHPs for a reason, they are a legal document and the school has to adhere to the provisions they stipulate. There would be no jealousy as it is about getting my child's needs met, not about having them feel 'special'

Jonny1265 · 20/03/2022 08:14

@Penyu

I was prepared to not agree with what you wrote OP but I'm a primary teacher you are basically describing my class. So many (17) out of 29 have some kind of official diagnosis/accommodation etc and it's very hard to keep track. Some appalling behaviour is swept away under the "additional needs" umbrella - calling peers fat cunts, punching in the face, telling teachers to fuck off, telling a girl she's a fucking fat (country name here) and this is year 6. No consequences, just "restorative conversions".

Other children are scared and parents complain but very little done.

The world's collide when both children have additional needs and generally it's the scariest parents who tend to get their way as they threaten to make formal complaints etc etc.

I suspect quite a few are questionable labels to be honest but to be fair I guess the last two years have made everyone's mental health worse.... But where do we draw a line- what makes one person's experience deemed worse than others?

It's exhausting. And sad.

That sounds liker a complete shitshow and wouldn't be tolerated in my schools. The head has a lot to answer for it would appear.
sst1234 · 20/03/2022 08:12

Everyone nowadays has a mental health condition, right? No one can just be lazy or abusive or a bully. They are mentally ill.

Mnusernc · 20/03/2022 08:10

You're right, but it's so pervasive in state primary schools, well behaved girls are sat next to naughty boys all the time. It makes girls think they are responsible for moderating others' behaviour.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 20/03/2022 08:06

One friend he husband gambled behind her back thousands of pounds of their money - he was diagnosed with ADHD and their counsellor and friends said it was the ADHD and not ‘him’. Another has been diagnosed with mental health issues that she has to ‘accept’as his anxiety
It may well be the case, people with ADHD make decisions without consequences.
IMO not a professional - I think most adults who are homeless, addicted, alcoholics, gambling addicts are not NT.
Maybe awareness of the issues in DC will prepare better adults.
There was a boy in my class in 80's he would throw tables, have massive meltdowns, he died an addict homeless in a doorway.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 20/03/2022 08:00

whose parents have diagnosed them with anxiety/asperger's/adhd) get my children to support them for the slightest imagined problem- the teachers set this up.
Parents cannot diagnose DC.
The Teacher should not be using your DC to look after another DC.

Squeakywheels · 20/03/2022 07:59

What are your medical qualifications Op?

Squeakywheels · 20/03/2022 07:57

"whose parents have diagnosed them with anxiety/asperger's/adhd"

Parents cannot diagnose these and so if your child's school is treating them as actual diagnoses then your problem lies with the school.

Toothiehurtie · 20/03/2022 07:55

Direct experience

OP posts:
Toothiehurtie · 20/03/2022 07:55

@DoobryWhatsit

Once you're at a stage where more than half a population have "additional needs", you can't really say those needs are "additional" any more, they're just the norm. And then the people with the more significant additional needs can get lost.
You’ve hit the nail on the head. Do you work in a job where you explain things to people? That’s exactly it
OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 20/03/2022 07:54

It's difficult, when DD was little there was one DC in her class who had a lot of extra attention.

They're 13 now, the little girl above still has serious issues with a debilitating learning disorder and awful social skills, she would have been institutionalised in the olden days DC have to learn to except others.

My DS has autism with pda he wears different uniform due to sensory issues and his teachers let him take the lead, now 4 years later he is brilliant child who loves school, he was out of control.

I'm forever indebted for the patience kindness and support making him a better person.

Mnusernc · 20/03/2022 07:50

I do get really fed up of my daughters being used as support humans for others, just because they're resilient. When mine have actual trauma they're supposed to cope but their friends (whose parents have diagnosed them with anxiety/asperger's/adhd) get my children to support them for the slightest imagined problem- the teachers set this up.

Mybestyear · 20/03/2022 07:48

I work in a university and the amount of students with ‘additional needs’ is astounding. So many need their own room for an exam that we cannot cope - just not enough rooms to give them all their own room and invigilator. Lots of these exams are for professional programs and the regulatory bodies insist on some exams as nowadays, cheating in essays is so prevalent that an exam is the only way you can guarantee it is the student’s own work. They will be entering high stakes professions so god knows how they will cope on a daily basis if they can’t handle sharing a room for an exam. There doesn’t seem to be any recognition that exams cause a level of anxiety- which is not the same as having an anxiety disorder.

Fishpondinthegarden · 20/03/2022 07:46

I think the biggest problem is that some teachers have listened to mental health snake oil people and therefore children have confused ‘anxiety’ with ‘anything that might make someone anxious.’

They aren’t the same thing.

Cocomarine · 20/03/2022 07:43

@Toothiehurtie

About the ruining I guess I mean if child a struggles in a large size class and is taken out to a much smaller class for an hour a week to work on self esteem and then eventually 18 of the thirt kids in a class are being taken out of the standard lesson to go to the smaller glass it isn’t smaller any more and it’s meant that the people who really needed it in the first place haven’t got it anymore
Do you actually have experience of that happening though? It sounds like you’re making it up. Not in a trolling way, but a “for instance” way.
OneInEight · 20/03/2022 07:40

I would question that if over half the children in the class need interventions then it might be more effective to change how the class is run rather than to remove half of them.

Prettynails · 20/03/2022 07:38

It’s a highly complex issues. I have seen friends of mine put up with awful behaviour - gambling, cheating, obsessive behaviour under the guise of mental health in their partners and any attempt to deal with it sometimes means that their needs are not being heard.

One friend he husband gambled behind her back thousands of pounds of their money - he was diagnosed with ADHD and their counsellor and friends said it was the ADHD and not ‘him’. Another has been diagnosed with mental health issues that she has to ‘accept’as his anxiety of meeting his needs of knowing where she is at all times and he doesn’t like being left. Needs are great but when they adversely affect the other person when do you draw a line over consent and the other persons right.

Theunamedcat · 20/03/2022 07:28

In the meantime genuine children with genuine difficulties get overlooked even my youngest he has always had difficulties had SALT involved from before he was two on school sen register from nursery was set aside to support a child academically brighter but who had outbursts and needed to be medicated the school didn't need to do that his mum was doing it all but the ehcp for my child was put off for 12 months due to this then he got caught up in the pandemic he never has seen a paediatrician despite being referred several times the last time he was referred they refused saying it sounded more like autism than adhd and to re refer under umbrella to clarify its the same paediatrician same clinic time just opposite week and it's taken another 12 months for him to be accepted on the umbrella pathway and its fucking ridiculous

Squeakywheels · 20/03/2022 07:21

Loving all these armchair experts with there vast array (not) of medical qualifications and experience, stating their knowledgeable opinions on 'too many diagnoses'.

Sirzy · 20/03/2022 07:20

cocktailclub is showing their ignorance of the hoops parents have to just through in order for a diagnosis to be made.

Theunamedcat · 20/03/2022 07:19

@cocktailclub

Sadly I think some diagnosis now of ADHD are just lazy parenting and badly behaved kids. Not all but I do think some. So many excuses made for additional needs but why should these kids be able to suck up all the teachers time and scare other kids who suffer. They need to rein back on the criteria for diagnosis, offer more parenting courses and save a diagnosis for actual additional needs not bad behaviour due to diet, parents not setting boundaries or bed times, constant tv watching or screen time etc. Probably be flamed for this but really, what's behind all these needs?
This is the last thing we need if I'm honest I have a child who has adhd and autism he hasn't been able to "get a diagnosis" for the six years I've been trying to get him seen if he punched or kicked a teacher he would but he daydreams his way through school life because his adhd is "innatentive" what we need to do is switch the narrative and accept these children exist and stop prioritising violent children all through primary we had a violent child bully him the bully was accommodated everytime ds was not because he lives in his own world high school, the bully was told no probably for the first time in his life so he left the school tried another got told "no" again ended up at the PRU he is now on his third high school and he is only year 8 he has no special needs he is just violent and aggressive there were reports of a child with a knife at the park its him banned from the local shop again him his mum has been unable and unwilling to deal with him since he was small but my child has been pushed aside for him and all the parenting classes in the world won't help my child they didn't help him either but telling him no sooner might have except no-one in authority ever did
Squeakywheels · 20/03/2022 07:18

"Not trolling not fishing just interested if you or your kid gets treated differently to everyone else and allowances are made fo you then does it ruin it for you if lots of people get it too"

No.
My child has several disabilities as does every other child in his school. It makes no difference to him what support/ accommodations any other child gets.

cocktailclub · 20/03/2022 07:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread