@Squeakywheels
You would expect a child with an ehcp and risk assessment to get some level of dla. Dla is about support needed, not about diagnosis.
Exactly however, diagnosis or not, the regulations say the needs have to arise from a disability. Not every child with an ehcp has a disability. I am talking about mainstream school not SEN school.
You seem to have focused on my comment about DLA so I will explain why I wrote that.
If a child has a diagnosis and additional needs the school are under a duty to address this and put strategies in place. And the resulting paperwork can help with a DLA claim.
Earlier you said that parents can't diagnose ASD, ADHD etc in a child and if they are treated as such the the problem lies with the school. It is not that clear cut.
You may be surprised at how many parents are suggesting that their aggressive and defiant child's behaviour is due to additional needs, possible ASD, PTSD, ADHD. And the school are under a duty to address this and put strategies in place while waiting for assessment. And the resulting paperwork can help with a DLA claim.
In my experience very often the second group are taking services needed by the first group meaning those in need wait longer. It dilutes the service and also the struggles that the first group face. Often the second group are advised to go to parenting classes as part of the assessment, many can't be bothered. No doubt their child has difficulty regulating their emotions but how much is learned behaviour or environmental rather than a disability?
And yet a child in the first group could well receive less DLA than a child in the second group. Call me cynical but for the second group there can be financial reward in not addressing the real issues.