Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you have mental health problems that stop you from doing things do you get sick of people saying they can’t do things because of their mental health.

118 replies

Toothiehurtie · 19/03/2022 22:47

No trolling genuinely wondering. There are kids in my kids classes at school who are starting to get attention for mental health issues and there are more kids than not now with a reason why they need to be treated differently tk the majority to the point where the kids doing what they are supposed to be doing are in the minority. If you’re the one who normally gets an allowance for your mental health does it piss you off when it’s allowed for everyone or do you feel like it’s great that mental health is being acknowledged. The example I’m thinking of is a kid at school who was allowed not to wear school shoes and now most of the class wear trainers and the whatsapp grouo mums are saying their kids are much happier if they get to wear what they want, and now school are clamping back. Not trolling not fishing just interested if you or your kid gets treated differently to everyone else and allowances are made fo you then does it ruin it for you if lots of people get it too

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cocktailclub · 21/03/2022 17:57

@Girlmumdogmumboymum

I agree with you RE the good girl comment. My DD is a good girl, she's hard working, engaged at school, and is often sat next to the worst behaved in her classes. What this in turn means is that she is the closest verbal punching bag "I'd rather kill myself than sit next to little noway out" "UGH I HATE littlenowayout" "Youre punishing me, making me sit next to HER!!!" "I wish I could sit next to SOMEONE NORMAL!" "SHES SO BORING!" is the sort of shit she deals with day in and day out because she isn't going to talk and disrupt the lessons.

Teachers ignore it. Doesn't mean she is capable of dealing with it. She comes home and tells me; oh I'm dreading x lesson tomorrow, I need to sit next to x/or y or z. I wonder what they'll say tomorrow.

It makes her anxious going into school, being saddled with kids who are going to be arseholes to her, because she's a good kid trying her best.

That's awful. It makes me so cross. These kids can't blame 'additional needs' for that behaviour. It is rude and bullying and that's a lack of parental input or accountability. Now perhaps your daughter should have additional support to manage the impact of this behaviour and so it goes on. But I don't expect she will because being well behaved and contributing to society doesn't get you much in the way of help.
Onlyforcake · 21/03/2022 15:47

I have two children in secondary school. One being assessed for ASD and needs a certain amount of support with regard to self esteem after being bullied for things she says, how she looks hobbies etc. My other child in the same school has no referral but is under cahms because of an overdose. LOTS of children are hugely struggling and there is a very very long waiting list. Personally i think school have totally fucked up. Instead of spending maybe two weeks at the start of the full post COVID restrictions education really we orking with ALL children on mental health they ploughed into work, increased the pressure putting in place compulsory revision and catch up sessions. A very very high number of students are now cracking under pressure.
Tutu once said. We need to stop pulling people out of the river and go upstream and find out why they are falling in.

Children's mental health is treated as a joke by the government and the department of education. Children with great home support are going under. It's totally wrong. I wouldn't resent ANY child getting support in school anyway my children are under CAHMS so have other avenues of support for their need.

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 15:43

It wouldn’t be at the parents’ say so if the child has an EHCP. There will be evidence from the EHCP and other evidence.

Some people seem to be saying there are loads of grabby parents saying how difficult their child is just to get benefits.

Exactly, I don’t believe there is when the child has an EHCP. A child with an EHCP will have significant needs that would meet the DLA criteria.

Underhisi · 21/03/2022 15:32

But not likely just at the parents say so. Need at night requires evidence from professionals. Some people seem to be saying there are loads of grabby parents saying how difficult their child is just to get benefits.

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 15:18

No one here has mentioned only HRC or HRM, and no one specifically focused on SMI rules. In fact @Squeakywheels specifically said “some level of DLA”. And it is possible for a child with ‘only’ behavioural needs to meet the criteria for HRC. A child with behavioural needs may need supervision and care throughout the day and night therefore they may be eligible for HRC.

LadyCordeliaFitzgerald · 21/03/2022 15:14

Haven’t rtft so this might have been raised already but a significant barrier for dc with sn taking advantage of adjustments is that they feel different and don’t want to stand out.

Sometimes letting all the dc wear comfortable shoes is a way of helping the one who needs it most.

Underhisi · 21/03/2022 15:10

Behavioural needs only form a small part of the Dla assessment so if a child has no other needs they will not get any of the higher dla rates. Eg to be awarded higher rate mobility under severe mental impairment criteria you have to show medical evidence that the behavioural difficulties are from a disability such as a significant learning disability. A child in a mainstream school is very unlikely to meet the criteria.

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 15:02

I didn’t say it was easy, I was challenging your assertion that “not every child with an EHCP has a disability”, which is frankly baffling if you are an expert and believe that given the legal definition of a disability, and therefore not all with an EHCP should get DLA, which as another poster said you would expect them to be eligible for some level of DLA.

Just because DWP say a child isn’t eligible for DLA doesn’t mean the child isn’t disabled and doesn’t have needs that meet the criteria for DLA. If it did no one would be successful at Tribunal when 2/3rds of DLA appeals are upheld. It’s why parents should always be encouraged to ask for a MR and if unsuccessful appeal. Just like just because the LA say a child isn’t eligible for an EHCP doesn’t mean the child doesn’t meet the criteria for one.


I can honestly say I have seen schools under sustained pressure from parents to complete an ehcp.

That’s often because many schools say the pupil is ‘fine’ or believe the LAs unlawful policies and refuse to apply saying the parents won’t get one or the pupil doesn’t need one yet when the parents apply themselves they successfully go on to secure an EHCP. These parents should just apply themselves, they don’t need to school to apply.

I can also honestly say I have seen children with complex needs or a disability with no ehcp.

No one on here has said you haven’t, of course there is, but that doesn’t mean support should be taken away from other DC. Instead more support should be given to support the DC and parents through the EHCP process.

Faevern · 21/03/2022 14:42

I know a diagnosis is not needed I have never said it was.

This goes back to the legal definition of a disability I posted above. A child displaying behaviour at the level of need posted here and with functional impairments to the level an EHCP is in place would be covered by the Equality Act’s definition of disabled, and would meet the criteria for DLA.

You would think, wouldn't you? However If it was that easy there would be no parents wringing their hands and desperately trying to convince the DWP of their child's needs. The law is open to interpretation and that includes the legal definition of disability. The DWP also have varying opinions on level of need and how much control the child has over their own actions.

I can honestly say I have seen schools under sustained pressure from parents to complete an ehcp. Whether the LA agrees is another matter, the plan is already written for DLA purposes. I can also honestly say I have seen children with complex needs or a disability with no ehcp. In the geographical area where I work the teachers are exhausted I really don't know where they get the time to teach.

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 14:13

Sorry yes of, not or. But it still means a diagnosis is not required in order to claim. If one had a recognised (i.e. one you could put a name to) condition or disability one would have a diagnosis.

The starting point is that the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992 require the claimant to be “so severely disabled physically or mentally'

The rest is determined by evidence etc and while no need for a diagnosis the needs have to arise from a disability.

This goes back to the legal definition of a disability I posted above. A child displaying behaviour at the level of need posted here and with functional impairments to the level an EHCP is in place would be covered by the Equality Act’s definition of disabled, and would meet the criteria for DLA.

Faevern · 21/03/2022 13:56

@Imitatingdory

Bottom left of Page 6 states ”Your child does not have to have a diagnosis of a recognised condition or disability in order for you to claim DLA…”

The guide is helpful for all parents completing DLA forms, not just those with brain conditions.

Yes the guide is helpful, it also states does not have to have a diagnosis of not or. One letter big difference and yes it matters.

The starting point is that the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992 require the claimant to be “so severely disabled physically or mentally'

The rest is determined by evidence etc and while no need for a diagnosis the needs have to arise from a disability.

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 21/03/2022 13:38

I don’t know whether it’s still the case, having not dealt with the code of Practice for SEN for a while, but it used to be the case that some children require something that is ‘additional to, or different from’ what is available in general to a class. Maybe you could argue that if over half the class require that, it becomes the norm rather than the additional need.

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 13:15

Bottom left of Page 6 states ”Your child does not have to have a diagnosis of a recognised condition or disability in order for you to claim DLA…”

The guide is helpful for all parents completing DLA forms, not just those with brain conditions.

Faevern · 21/03/2022 12:50

You don’t need a diagnosis or recognised condition or disability to get DLA. Cerebra guide clarifies this. Where does the guide say that, it is talking about children with a brain condition and states if your child has a disability, health condition or developmental disorder?

You can doubt as much as you like I know what I see. I am a strong advocate of DLA providing evidence and legal argument to support the claim. I know the law and the regulations. I see the struggle that parents have to be heard and have their child assessed.

Totally agree that carers allowance is pitiful and DLA doesn't cover the costs of all additional need. However for means tested benefits the rewards can be very generous. I have undeniably worked with families where this has been the driver behind their child's additional needs.

Girlmumdogmumboymum · 21/03/2022 12:31

I agree with you RE the good girl comment.
My DD is a good girl, she's hard working, engaged at school, and is often sat next to the worst behaved in her classes.
What this in turn means is that she is the closest verbal punching bag "I'd rather kill myself than sit next to little noway out" "UGH I HATE littlenowayout" "Youre punishing me, making me sit next to HER!!!" "I wish I could sit next to SOMEONE NORMAL!" "SHES SO BORING!" is the sort of shit she deals with day in and day out because she isn't going to talk and disrupt the lessons.

Teachers ignore it. Doesn't mean she is capable of dealing with it. She comes home and tells me; oh I'm dreading x lesson tomorrow, I need to sit next to x/or y or z. I wonder what they'll say tomorrow.

It makes her anxious going into school, being saddled with kids who are going to be arseholes to her, because she's a good kid trying her best.

Itwasnotmeormydog · 21/03/2022 12:01

I think all the kids should be able to wear trainers. They do in our primary school. And no, I don't think it matters if a child with SEN gets to be the only one wearing trainers or if they all wear them. As long as the child with SEN who needs to wear trainers gets to what does it matter?

neverbeenskiing · 21/03/2022 11:52

It is in the benefit of every child in the class that children with additional needs are properly supported.

This. If schools are getting it right for their most vulnerable, then they'll be getting it right for children across the board.

Some of the anger and unpleasantness on this thread directed at "naughty" children, "lazy parents" would be much better directed at the Government, who have systematically decimated the budgets of services that support children and families with complex needs for over a decade.

Squeakywheels · 21/03/2022 11:38

It is very unlikely that a child who has needs to the extent that an ehcp has been granted, does not have a disability. We all know that LAs do not want to give those out.

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 11:28

Using the legal definition of disabled I highly doubt any child has an EHCP without being disabled.

The Equality Act "defines a disabled person as a person with a disability. A person has a disability for the purposes of the Act if he or she has a physical or mental impairment and the impairment has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on his or her ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities” (S6(1)).

The guidance states "It is not necessary for the cause of the impairment to be established, nor does the impairment have to be the result of an illness." source.

Complex behavioural needs that result in an impairment of functioning to the extent being discussed here and that qualify for an EHCP are a disability.

You don’t need a diagnosis or recognised condition or disability to get DLA. Cerebra guide clarifies this. It is based on needs.

Many parents spend way more on meeting their DC’s additional needs than they receive in DLA and the ever so generous CA. I mean it’s going up a whole £2 a week.

BogRollBOGOF · 21/03/2022 11:26

DS has a collection of high functioning neurodiversities. He masks through a school day, then explodes at home. School making some reasonable adjustments for him does help reduce that brewing tension. The reality is not many adjustments are made and provided. We've funded the tinted glasses, the laptops etc. School makes little effort into reminding and facilitating him to use them.
Because he presents quietly in class, he is often placed with the chatty girls because he doesn't engage with them. Unfortunately not engaging also refers to him being able to discuss the work with them because they're not on the same academic/ social wavelength and his social skill isn't sophisticated enough to deal with that. I have intervened when certain unworkable combinations have repeated over the years. I've been a teacher. There's a set number of desks and a set combination of personalities to spread around them. He logistically very rarely gets chance to work with the other calm, brightest kids that he works best with because of the way you have to manage the whole class. I only intervene when a particular combination has history of going wrong.

Getting diagnoses is not for the lazy. It's not quick. It's not easy. It doesn't guarentee much when you have them. There's a lot of gate-keepers. You have to demonstrate the long term nature of the issue. We had a paper trail going back to infancy. People don't look at DS and see his difficulties (unless it's been a particularly bad day and he comes out spoiling for a fight with his sibling) they just see a quiet, intelligent, quirky child. In years gone by, his difficulties probably would have been overlooked and punished for laziness when he writes his name incorrectly at the age of 11.

Unless someone is actively compromising DS's needs, I have no issue with others having extra support when needed.

The real issue is poor funding, training and access to support services.

Faevern · 21/03/2022 10:43

@Sirzy

If a child has been granted an Ehcp and dla then I think I will take the experts view on their level of need rather than some judgemental person online.

Both take a massive fight and a lot of evidence to get. More likely people won’t be getting what they need rather than getting more than they need

If that is directed at me. I am an expert, not judging just stating facts.
Faevern · 21/03/2022 10:41

@MabelsApron totally agree with you. My DGD teacher has just asked my DIL if her child would like to attend group sessions, in school to improve her self esteem, she is 10. Why does she need this group because she has been repeatedly sat next to one naughty child or another in class despite my DS & DIL repeatedly challenging the school on this. So the school now have now introduced group sessions to help the children who have to sit in class with the disruptive pupils.

Not only madness but what is it teaching our children about gender roles, sitting the good girl next to the naughty boy so that she can be a calming influence because he can't help himself, in primary school ffs.

Sirzy · 21/03/2022 10:27

If a child has been granted an Ehcp and dla then I think I will take the experts view on their level of need rather than some judgemental person online.

Both take a massive fight and a lot of evidence to get. More likely people won’t be getting what they need rather than getting more than they need

Faevern · 21/03/2022 10:26

@Squeakywheels

You would expect a child with an ehcp and risk assessment to get some level of dla. Dla is about support needed, not about diagnosis.
Exactly however, diagnosis or not, the regulations say the needs have to arise from a disability. Not every child with an ehcp has a disability. I am talking about mainstream school not SEN school.

You seem to have focused on my comment about DLA so I will explain why I wrote that.

If a child has a diagnosis and additional needs the school are under a duty to address this and put strategies in place. And the resulting paperwork can help with a DLA claim.

Earlier you said that parents can't diagnose ASD, ADHD etc in a child and if they are treated as such the the problem lies with the school. It is not that clear cut.

You may be surprised at how many parents are suggesting that their aggressive and defiant child's behaviour is due to additional needs, possible ASD, PTSD, ADHD. And the school are under a duty to address this and put strategies in place while waiting for assessment. And the resulting paperwork can help with a DLA claim.

In my experience very often the second group are taking services needed by the first group meaning those in need wait longer. It dilutes the service and also the struggles that the first group face. Often the second group are advised to go to parenting classes as part of the assessment, many can't be bothered. No doubt their child has difficulty regulating their emotions but how much is learned behaviour or environmental rather than a disability?

And yet a child in the first group could well receive less DLA than a child in the second group. Call me cynical but for the second group there can be financial reward in not addressing the real issues.

MabelsApron · 21/03/2022 10:24

@Penyu

A few things here are spot on
  1. Yes the policies and procedures in a lot of schools need adjusting and honestly in my school there are no negative consequences at all, just conversations
  2. Which hardly ever happen because staff absence from covid has decimated the slt times they could normally have tried to address some of the issues as they are also in class and can't - after school is too late
  3. When I talk about accommodations/diagnosis this is a big range from very easily adaptable dyslexia to extreme ASD/enhanced provision, so it's not all crazy all the time but those are some real examples my class has to deal with
  4. Yes sometimes i am guilty of placing a good girl next to the most extreme child because no-one else can deal with the behaviour (see point 2) it sucks.
  5. The example of alternative provision for gcse is scary and I totally believe it - how can schools actually staff this?
6 I don't think parents realise/have any idea how many children have additional needs and accommodations in class due to gdpr and also no parents actually in school the last two years to see some of the stuff actually going on!

And yes, money is at the heart of this... More staff, more qualified staff.... And special breakout rooms and better play equipment and spaces and better cooked lunches, etc etc etc which I can't see happening anytime soon.

Another former good girl who had this experience - please, please stop doing it. The fact that nobody else can deal with the behaviour so young children are being asked to do it is abhorrent. I remember teachers putting me with the aggressive, unruly boys because I could "talk some sense into them" and "set a good example". What ended up happening is I'd do their work for them after they called me an ugly, fat swot.

I went to school two decades ago and it was already showing signs of becoming like this. I can't imagine what it's like now. I've suffered with MH issues my entire life, including a teenage suicide attempt that was ignored by the authorities. I'm not suggesting we go back to that, it was awful to have that ignored, but now we've gone too far the opposite way. The kids being described in this thread are not going to manage in the real world, where accommodations are reasonable, not unconditional.

Swipe left for the next trending thread