Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think blocking former friends is often unnecessary and cowardly?

106 replies

cranberryhaddock · 19/03/2022 15:56

I keep seeing this all around social media, not just on MN, often in response to relatively minor things that are annoying someone about a friend. It feels like the standard advice nowadays if someone happens to have put a person's nose out of joint in any way is 'Unfriend, block, and move on with your life.'

Don't get me wrong, if someone is harassing a person, causing major distress or acting in a threatening way, obviously that's different and blocking is the right thing to do. But so often it seems as though the other person is just getting on the poster's nerves or there's been a falling-out or misunderstanding of some kind that could possibly be straightened out with a bit of old-fashioned talking. It feels like people don't value their friendships enough for that any more, and aren't willing to give their friends the chance to put things right - tbh the unfriend/block advice is trotted out so much of the time that I get the impression people don't really care about their friendships as much these days, and also - to be blunt - that a lot of people are just plain cowardly.

I know it sounds like I've had this happen to me - for the record, I actually haven't, but I (like most people, I imagine) do find it painful when friendships end and I just feel blocking someone who isn't acting in a threatening/harassing/distressing way is hurtful and unnecessary.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Quirkyme · 21/03/2022 15:06

Yes YABU.

Meadmaiden · 21/03/2022 14:59

I think it's unfair unless there is a genuine reason, for example harrasment. Same as 'ghosting' for no apparent reason. If someone has done something to offend, it would be courteous to at least let let them know why the friendship cannot continue, or allow them to make amends, if appropriate.

cranberryhaddock · 21/03/2022 14:07

@incognitoforthisone

I don't quite understand what your issue is.

You say you've never been blocked yourself. You also say that if you were no longer friends with someone, you wouldn't want to look at their social media anyway.

So ... what exactly is the problem? You've never been blocked, and if you were blocked it wouldn't actually stop you from doing anything you wanted to do. But you've come here to make personal judgements about the character of people who use the block function?

To be honest, if you talk to your friends the way you've talked to people on here, and make similarly arbitrary judgements about the boundaries they set for themselves, I'm actually amazed nobody has ever blocked you.

I've been perfectly civil on this thread and my interactions with friends are not problematic. Like everyone I've had friendships end, but in my personal experience and to the best of my knowledge, I have never blocked or been blocked therefore I was asking why people do this.

I've been judging the action of blocking, not making 'personal judgements' (even though your post has done the latter - oh, the irony). Hmm Some people agree with me and some disagree, and that's absolutely fine, it's how debate works. Some of the responses (including some of the YABUs) have given me useful insights, but tbh some replies on this thread, yours included, are far more unpleasant than anything I've said.

OP posts:
incognitoforthisone · 21/03/2022 12:36

I don't quite understand what your issue is.

You say you've never been blocked yourself. You also say that if you were no longer friends with someone, you wouldn't want to look at their social media anyway.

So ... what exactly is the problem? You've never been blocked, and if you were blocked it wouldn't actually stop you from doing anything you wanted to do. But you've come here to make personal judgements about the character of people who use the block function?

To be honest, if you talk to your friends the way you've talked to people on here, and make similarly arbitrary judgements about the boundaries they set for themselves, I'm actually amazed nobody has ever blocked you.

Gonnagetgoing · 21/03/2022 10:08

Just seen this come back on feeds.

I have about 3 ex friends - various reasons why we are not friends any more.

I didn't block them on social media and them not me either.

I think if you want to block someone who's rude, malicious and you fell out as a friend then that's fine. But as in my case - I was friends with one person for 8 years, another for 20 years as best friend - so the doors are open. One person though I just wasn't clicking with after 8 years and she did some things which were unacceptable to me, so friendship had to go.

CosmoMint · 21/03/2022 09:48

I don’t see a problem with blocking on social media. If you have had a run in with a friend and discussed it in person. If the friendship is no longer going to be continuing. Then why not block? Then they won’t appear on your news feed and you won’t get notifications about anything involving mutual friends.

I can see if you mean you have had a fall out and the friend has immediately blocked you with no explanation or discussion. Or you get blocked and you have no idea why-then, you would feel more hurt about it and wonder why the block.

But if the friendship has ended in person, then no need to continue the friendship online. Not a friend anymore. No need to see, so no problem blocking.

cherryonthecakes · 20/03/2022 19:45

The last person that I blocked was due to his constant Covid conspiracy theories on FB. He is free to post what he likes and I am free to block that content. It's not for me to confront his views in the same way that it's not for him to try and sway mine.

I do have anti vaxx people on my timeline but in 2 years, they've posted less than a handful of memes about vaccines so it's easy to scroll past. (Plus a couple of them were about how many boosters would people take-5? 10? 20? Which I can understand) The other person was posting daily at one point which was just tedious.

Squeezita · 20/03/2022 15:56

It might seem sudden and black and white with no greys to you OP but it’s usually more complicated than that. Only the person in that friendship knows the reality.

I had a friend who I loved, but I was often aware that she didn’t treat me well or like her other friends. I couldn’t make the break for a long time but when I did make the break, we went from a lovely last meal with lots of catching up to zero contact. It was absolutely the right decision for me.

RainbowConnection1 · 20/03/2022 15:12

I blocked a 'friend' on messenger when I realised her messages were all exactly the same, usually along the lines of 'Hi E, how are you? We are well. I did A,B and C. Mum got a new puppy. Message me back. J'. If/when I responded there was no further conversation and the message from her came in every Friday, each message almost exactly the same as the last.

cherryonthecakes · 20/03/2022 14:45

The blocking function is underused imo.

How many dilemmas on here include an ex seeing something on OP's SM (or vice versa) ?

I think that blocking is less cruel than gradually phasing someone out tbh.

I think it's naive to assume that people should have a right to protest a reason that their friend might feel is enough to use the block function. You used the example of being stood up twice. The person who blocked is in the right imo- they don't want the person to even consider inviting them again and being stood up twice is shit.

Is it really a good thing to tell your "friend" that they feed makes you feel like shit even though they aren't trying to flaunt their good life? I know that people can unfollow but I understand why someone would just say fuck it and block so they don't see that content and the algorithms don't sneak their content back in your feed. What is the person who's lucky enough to have healthy children/lots of holidays/great life supposed to do with the info that their SM makes someone feel shit? If that person restricts what their friend sees or stops posting what they want can that friendship last ?

I also disagree with keeping people you don't care about because it's less drama. This is a very teen way to use SM imo- adding your friend's brother that you've never met sort of thing. My circle is small and I feel no desire to collect every acquaintance that I make in life. If you add everyone then I can see why culling and keeping my circle tight looks weird.

cranberryhaddock · 20/03/2022 14:12

@Mummyratbag

Ha ha - it's an expression I have learnt on Mumsnet! I have probably got the wrong context. When you put down a boundary (another MN favourite) and the person sends in mutual friends/family to find out why etc... I got a few messages all on the same day from people asking what was happening. I know she already knew that I had blocked her some time before so she had obviously had a FB rant about it. I just played it down, changed the subject.
Ahh I see Grin
OP posts:
gumball37 · 20/03/2022 13:11

I do it because 1. They don't need to know what's going on in my life, we aren't friends; 2. I don't need to relive the upset by seeing their interactions.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 20/03/2022 12:35

But in that scenario, unless they've done something really egregious, doesn't the dropped friend even deserve the courtesy of an explanation/the opportunity to make it up to the 'injured party' so to speak?

No is the simple answer. You dont owe anyone anything.

TabithaTiger · 20/03/2022 12:32

I blocked a former friend yesterday. I've been trying for months to reach out to her after she decided to cut herself off from the rest of our friendship group. Yesterday she sent me a ranty text accusing me of being a shit friend. It was quite clear she has no interest in reconciling the friendship and it makes me sad to see posts about her life and know I'm no longer a part of it.

Mummyratbag · 20/03/2022 12:26

Ha ha - it's an expression I have learnt on Mumsnet! I have probably got the wrong context. When you put down a boundary (another MN favourite) and the person sends in mutual friends/family to find out why etc... I got a few messages all on the same day from people asking what was happening. I know she already knew that I had blocked her some time before so she had obviously had a FB rant about it. I just played it down, changed the subject.

cranberryhaddock · 20/03/2022 12:21

@Mummyratbag

Anyone vile, abusive, rude etc goes. I don't want that in my life.

Mildly annoying they get unfollowed and I occasionally check I haven't missed any milestones etc.

I have recently blocked someone who I supported for years and years, but I realise doesn't actually want to get to a better place. They are so relentlessly negative I needed to move on for my own mental health. Massive guilt especially when the flying monkeys were dispatched but I could no longer do it. I have no regrets.

Flying monkeys? #curious Smile
OP posts:
Mummyratbag · 20/03/2022 12:00

Anyone vile, abusive, rude etc goes. I don't want that in my life.

Mildly annoying they get unfollowed and I occasionally check I haven't missed any milestones etc.

I have recently blocked someone who I supported for years and years, but I realise doesn't actually want to get to a better place. They are so relentlessly negative I needed to move on for my own mental health. Massive guilt especially when the flying monkeys were dispatched but I could no longer do it. I have no regrets.

Gwenhwyfar · 20/03/2022 11:49

@apple93

I went to browse the girl my BIL is marrying and I couldn't find her profile! (My friend found it) turned out.. she already looked me up and blocked me lol.

I find it quite hurtful as she's got my SIL on social media but I guess I'm used to being left out lol Confused

So she blocked you for no reason?
Gwenhwyfar · 20/03/2022 11:47

@ManateeFair

Did you not read where I said I wouldn't waste my time looking at someone's SM if they had unfriended me?

Well, presumably you must have looked at some point, or you wouldn’t have noticed they’d blocked you. And if you don’t want to look at their social media activity, the fact you are blocked has zero impact on you, so why would it bother you? Clearly the friendship is over, and it’s understandable to feel sad about that, but if you don’t want to look at their social media then I can’t see why being blocked somehow makes the end of the friendship any worse.

You can see that someone has unfriended you just because your number of friends has gone down or a memory with them comes up, but you see there is no link by their name. You don't have to go looking necessarily.
Gwenhwyfar · 20/03/2022 11:45

I agree. In most cases it seems over the top and childish. Unfriend them if you must.

cranberryhaddock · 20/03/2022 11:42

@ManateeFair

Did you not read where I said I wouldn't waste my time looking at someone's SM if they had unfriended me?

Well, presumably you must have looked at some point, or you wouldn’t have noticed they’d blocked you. And if you don’t want to look at their social media activity, the fact you are blocked has zero impact on you, so why would it bother you? Clearly the friendship is over, and it’s understandable to feel sad about that, but if you don’t want to look at their social media then I can’t see why being blocked somehow makes the end of the friendship any worse.

Not sure whether you're speaking hypothetically, or are under the impression I'm in this situation. I already mentioned this has never happened to me, but I can easily see that a person might go to try and mend fences or even apologise for a wrongdoing and find themselves blocked.

Personally that would probably make me think 'sod you, then' and actually feel it was just as well the friendship had ended, if that was their attitude. But I do think it's a potentially hurtful action - and, if I'm completely honest, in some cases I do think it's done intentionally to hurt the 'blockee', as a sort of revenge move for whatever wrong the blocker feels has been done to them.

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman · 20/03/2022 11:30

@DontLookBackInAnger1

If I'm not genuine friends with someone, I don't want them on social media. I don't care what they're up to and I don't want them stalking me. So I delete.

I look at people with hundreds of "friends" and cringe.

Why? I’ve met and liked hundreds of people over the years - of course they’re not all going to be close friends, but that doesn’t mean I would actively avoid seeing what they’re up to now. Not every friendship has to be a close one.

As for the idea that casual friends/acquaintances are ‘stalking’ you, that’s a particularly unattractive combination of pretentiousness and paranoia.

WomanStanleyWoman · 20/03/2022 11:25

I’m torn. On one hand, I agree it can all be a bit dramatic, and that sometimes people rush to hit the delete and block buttons (literally and figuratively) because of something they’ll probably be over in a few weeks anyway. Sometimes I miss the days when, if someone pissed you off, you just stopped phoning them instead of making an event of blocking them or ‘Going NC’.

On the other hand, I’m very glad the technology exists. An ex-friend I blocked over four years ago still keeps trying to get mutual friends to pass on messages, and comments suspiciously quickly on anything I’m tagged in. If it had still been the days of landlines only, the only way I would have been able to block him would be to leave the answering machine on permanently! So while I agree the block button is something of a last resort, I’m glad we have it.

Branleuse · 20/03/2022 09:58

i think that in the age of social media and the internet, then its absolutely fine for people to have their own boundaries about how they use it and the issue of how to avoid people you dont like and dont want anything to do with online.
If I cant stand seeing someone keep popping up in my feed and defriending hasnt stopped this, then I will block. Its noone elses business. Its non confrontational, its just closing the curtains on them in the virtual world.

ManateeFair · 20/03/2022 09:50

Did you not read where I said I wouldn't waste my time looking at someone's SM if they had unfriended me?

Well, presumably you must have looked at some point, or you wouldn’t have noticed they’d blocked you. And if you don’t want to look at their social media activity, the fact you are blocked has zero impact on you, so why would it bother you? Clearly the friendship is over, and it’s understandable to feel sad about that, but if you don’t want to look at their social media then I can’t see why being blocked somehow makes the end of the friendship any worse.