Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU… to set boundaries with my older sister?

87 replies

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 15:41

As the title says - sorry for the second post, it will be my last on this topic!

I am really finding it challenging lately to be amicable with her and am under a big load of pressure from my family to pull out all the stops.

It is her wedding this year, I am bridesmaid and I haven’t had as much involvement in the prep as what she’d like. She was deeply hurt when I couldn’t rearrange work on a weekday for her dress fitting, and accused me of being a distant relative and said that I am responsible for destroying our sister relationship.
She’s older by six years if it makes any difference.

Whilst my mum sees my point in places and describes sister as ‘intense’, she justifies it by saying my sister only cares about me and is desperate for a nice carry-on. My sister will cry to my mum and has apparently said she is worried I hate her. It all seems like really huge scale reactions.

I reassure her often that I do want to spend time with her and care about her but this seems to make her place more demands on me, for instance she has said if I don’t ‘step up’ and be there for her then she will have to consider my place at her wedding.

In recent months I have taken a step back from her for the sake of my own well-being. I keep in touch with the odd message and like her posts, tagging her in things I think she’ll like etc. I would love to get on better, but she pushed me over deliberately on a family holiday - when I calmly called it out she replied that she should have pushed me harder then played it off as a joke. She spent all that week digging at me subtly and being extremely rude to my partner, who treats me wonderfully and doesn’t deserve any of it. Called us both boring for not wanting to drink, and nagged me to have a bottle of wine in each hand. I will drink but not to the amount she does. Majority of it done when my parents were out of earshot. She will try and push me for what my ‘five year plan is’ and mocked me to her other half for taking a long time painting pottery on a family holiday. I only know this because my dad and partner were with her OH at the time and saw the messages and unflattering photos that I didn’t know were being taken. I think my dad might understand at least a little, though he doesn’t say. He will try his best to include us, which is comforting. My sister and her partner love the conversation to be on them at all times and don’t allow room for anyone else’s stories. It’s any which way to put me down, so it seems. I have tried everything: challenging it does not work as she claims it is me looking for trouble, ignoring it seems to feed her idea that I am disinterested in her.

My mum seems to side more with my sister and has asked me to think twice about whether I want to be estranged from my sister. It’s just a lot of pressure and guilt trips.

I hate to imagine a not-so-distant future where we have nothing in common, and our kids don’t get on - but she’s blocked me entirely on social media, from all her accounts, until I ‘step up as her sister and friend’ whatever that is supposed to mean.

I have really done my best to understand where it’s coming from but I’m drawing a blank, I don’t know why she does it, she is pretty, talented, ambitious and career driven. Successful. She doesn’t have anything to be jealous of or insecure about where I’m concerned.

I guess I am just looking for a bit of moral support from others who have experienced similar. Thanks in advance x

OP posts:
slothbyday · 19/03/2022 18:55

Best thing I ever did was putting in boundaries and only allowing contact within my terms and boundaries with my sister who was very similar to yours.
They don't like it, they've turned another sibling against me along with other extended family members. Others though have seen it for what it is and have applauded me for standing my ground and are now doing the same. Can genuinely say there is nothing positive missing from my life with them missing but a lot of negatives no longer there.

billy1966 · 19/03/2022 18:55

OP,

You sound so lovely but terrorised by her.

Her pushing you is not normal.

Do you realise this?

It is not normal.

In my mind she assaulted you.

If a man did that, it absolutely would be called assault.

As others have said and I will repeat, stop trying to understand her.

Stop trying to figure her out.

You can't.

She isn't a nice, decent person.

She is somebody who would lay her hands on another person.

You are saying she wants the best for you and you are sure of it?

Why?

Her behaviour is a complete contradiction of that.

She wants to be close to you, to bully and control you.

Your mother has done a really shit job rearing her, that she has allowed this monster to go unchecked.

Please consider some counselling.
I think it would definitely open your eyes to the unhealthy dynamic in which you were reared and are now stuck in.

If you want your life to be better and more peaceful, continue to step away from this awful woman, who so easily assaulted you.

Flowers
chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 18:53

@2Gen thank you. Really appreciate the insight. I thought as much but it’s hard to understand it as that when it’s passed off as joking, worse when I get. ‘You’re being sensitive’ on the back of it.

I will look into that. What would you advise I do for the wedding, after she’s threatened to demote me? I think that’s designed to make me crawl back. She wants to meet face to face to ‘repair our relationship’ but I feel baffled because I feel like she’s gone about destructing it herself, and is now trying to implicate me. I don’t really want to meet her to talk to her about it because she just puts it all back on me. If that makes sense?

OP posts:
2Gen · 19/03/2022 18:23

[quote chatterbug22]@Cherrysoup yes pushed over. My mum wanted a picture of us together, so my sister grabbed hold of me and squeezed me very tightly for the camera (knows full well I do not like this from anyone, an arm around each other would’ve been nice enough). I winced a bit when she was squeezing me and she took a step back, laughed, and pushed my face to the side quite forcefully as if to say ‘you’re boring’. I just kind of froze and looked to my mum who literally turned around and faced the other way. I said, ‘what was that for?’ and my sister replied ‘should’ve done it harder, and into the ditch’ (there was a hill with some boggy mud behind us as we were in a forest).

I couldn’t quite believe it![/quote]
Now that is full-on bullying OP and you have to make sure she can never, ever do anything like that again, to you but especially to any children you may have! Be sure, any DC you may have will be at risk from her toxicity as well, and far more vulnerable to it than an adult, so you must keep her away from them and best start as you mean to go on! She has so blatantly crossed the line by this, I'm surprised you feel any guilt at all! She is the one who is the problem here, not you! Look into Fear. Obligation. Guilt- F.O.G. and realise that she doesn't really want a happy, loving sisterly relationship with you, she wants to domineer and control you which you must not allow.
Your DM does sound like a flying monkey as well. You need to read about dysfunctional families and toxic people so you can put the responsibility back with your DSIS where it belongs. You can't have a good relationship with these sorts; they destroy people's mental health and suck them dry. You deserve to be well and happy and I'm sorry your in this position; I've had to cut people off too, and trust me, you'll get over any guilt very quick once you read up on all this and breath a sigh of relief. You'll only wish you'd cut her off sooner! All the best OP!

mbosnz · 19/03/2022 18:21

[quote chatterbug22]@mbosnz thank you. It’s always harder to see a situation when you’re in it.[/quote]
It really is! She's your sister - older or younger, that is irrelevant. Being older doesn't make her necessarily smarter, wiser, well disposed to wards you, or kind or compassionate.

Sometimes we get big sisters who are bullies, manipulative, and really enjoy using their perceived power over us as younger sisters.

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 18:19

@mbosnz thank you. It’s always harder to see a situation when you’re in it.

OP posts:
chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 18:18

@Illstartexercisingtomorrow thanks lovely. Must have been tough x

OP posts:
chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 18:17

@Lurking9to5 summer

OP posts:
Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 19/03/2022 18:08

I have lived through this situation with DH and his older sister, with his mum being a massive enabler.

Don’t try to understand it. If you are a normal balanced individual you cannot wrap your head around how someone can Jekyll and Hyde you, but that is the basis of your relationship.

You can’t change it, the change has to come from her. It’s unlikely unfortunately but the best thing you can do is protect your mental health and self esteem.

Lurking9to5 · 19/03/2022 18:07

When is the wedding?

mbosnz · 19/03/2022 18:03

I have three big sisters. What she is doing is using her dominant position with both you and your mother, to bully, intimidate, and manipulate you. You are a grown adult. You get to make your own choices, make your own actions, and wear your own consequences, just as she does. She is not a parent. Don't buy into the narrative of, 'she just wants the best for me'.

Lurking9to5 · 19/03/2022 18:01

Setting boundaries is not a magic solution. The person eroding yr boundaries wont say "well ok then".
I know i tried in my family but there is no facility for feedback in my family. My dad and brother supporr the narc like yr mum supports yr sister. You will be the bad guy for asking for change.

All you can do is fade away with v little explanation.

EvilKinevil · 19/03/2022 17:54

That’s because she’s normalised her behaviour by gaslighting you. You don’t need to feel guilty for watching a ten minute video on YouTube to try to understand your family dynamic. And you’ll be helping your own children too. You don’t want then to witness you getting treated so badly and then blaming yourself for it. That’ll be a confusing role model.

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 17:51

@StormyWindow I’ve tried similar and it goes from 0-100 very quickly. Does not listen. Flies off the handle and accuses me of gaslighting her and says things like ‘I cannot believe you are saying these things’.

It hurts because I do really want to be there for her. I don’t need to reach out to people as much as she does, but I think that’s just a difference in communication style and I wish she could accept that instead of things becoming so inflammatory. We were close growing up, she has always tried to steer me but then big sisters do and it can’t be disputed that she does want the best for me and ask other family members how I’m doing. That does conflict with how she is with me so makes me wonder if she’s aware of what she’s doing or not.

OP posts:
StormyWindow · 19/03/2022 17:47

[quote chatterbug22]@ButtockUp thank you. I feel like taking a step back is right, but that is exactly what I am being accused of doing so it’s really hard to do so comfortably.[/quote]
I wonder what she'd do if, when she accuses you of 'not stepping up' or being distant, you just agreed with her? If you told her calmly that yes, you are stepping back from her because she puts so much guilt and pressure on you that you no longer enjoy being around her? I don't know if I would be brave enough, or sure enough that I wouldn't lose my cool in your shoes but it sounds like it would be the first time anyone had called her out or shone a spotlight on her behaviour so her reaction would be fascinating!

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 17:43

@billy1966 I think I just feel so much pressure to be there. My sister knows I am a worrier and I think probably interacts with me, with that in mind. The problem is I feel I can’t win: if I do step away it feeds into exactly what she tells everyone, that she cares so much about me and I’m disinterested. It really does confuse me and I just want to understand the root cause of why she is that way with me, but I guess acceptance of it comes first - thank you for your balanced reply!!

OP posts:
mbosnz · 19/03/2022 17:42

Upon your update, I have to revise - your sister is a vicious, vindictive brat. Minimise time in her presence.

mbosnz · 19/03/2022 17:41

Your sister is a brat. She is enabled by your mother. Do not negotiate with terrorists, personally I'd be saying, yeah, nah, I think you'd better find a different whipping girl for your wedding.

Then let your sister and her flying monkey, your mother, have their tanties, and do not engage.

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 17:41

@EvilKinevil Thanks. I always feel guilty thinking of it as that, but it has crossed my mind before. I might take a watch. I do get imposter syndrome though and think what if it genuinely is just me being sensitive, like my sister says

OP posts:
chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 17:39

@Cherrysoup yes pushed over. My mum wanted a picture of us together, so my sister grabbed hold of me and squeezed me very tightly for the camera (knows full well I do not like this from anyone, an arm around each other would’ve been nice enough). I winced a bit when she was squeezing me and she took a step back, laughed, and pushed my face to the side quite forcefully as if to say ‘you’re boring’. I just kind of froze and looked to my mum who literally turned around and faced the other way. I said, ‘what was that for?’ and my sister replied ‘should’ve done it harder, and into the ditch’ (there was a hill with some boggy mud behind us as we were in a forest).

I couldn’t quite believe it!

OP posts:
EvilKinevil · 19/03/2022 17:39

Perhaps look up Dr Ramani on YouTube as she talks very well about narcissistic personality disorder. You may have an aha! moment .

billy1966 · 19/03/2022 17:38

She's awful.
She is trying to dominate and bully you.
Your mother is no better, facilitating her.

She's not your friend.

Continue to step back.
You will never win.
You do not want your children around her.

You will NEVER have peace with her in your life.
Accept that.

Stop fighting it.

Accept the person she is and avoid her.

If she continues to fuss about you not doing enough as BM, offer to step down.

Don't pretend to be her friend.
You are not.

Continue to step back and live your life.

She sounds like a very nasty piece of work.

Step away and stop the pretense that you are close.

Don't try and get your mother on side.
There is no point.

Just step away and keep your family safe from her.

Flowers
Cherrysoup · 19/03/2022 17:27

She sounds horrible. I would step down as bridesmaid now and tell her the pressure she puts on you does not in any way watch the shitty behaviour she exhibits towards you. Pushed you over? I’d fucking go ballistic! Is she 10?

Merryoldgoat · 19/03/2022 17:17

I have an aunt like this. I’ve barely spoken to her in 16 years and it’s blissful. I was vilified by wider family at first and no every single one of them has realised what a cunt she is.

She only has people stick around because she’s rich (millionaire rich) and a lot of our family are very poor.

She tries to control everyone with money and cutting her out was the best thing in the world.

PomBearWithoutHerOFRS · 19/03/2022 17:09

But you're not her friend, you're her sister.
Sometimes siblings are also friends, but it doesn't necessarily follow.
There's no obligation, just because you were both born to the same parents.
It sounds like she is presuming, and demanding, more from you than you can (ever) give, in the name of some rose tinted ideal of what she thinks a sister should be and do.
I don't think you could ever be enough, or live up to what she wants, and it will always be your fault in her eyes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread