Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU… to set boundaries with my older sister?

87 replies

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 15:41

As the title says - sorry for the second post, it will be my last on this topic!

I am really finding it challenging lately to be amicable with her and am under a big load of pressure from my family to pull out all the stops.

It is her wedding this year, I am bridesmaid and I haven’t had as much involvement in the prep as what she’d like. She was deeply hurt when I couldn’t rearrange work on a weekday for her dress fitting, and accused me of being a distant relative and said that I am responsible for destroying our sister relationship.
She’s older by six years if it makes any difference.

Whilst my mum sees my point in places and describes sister as ‘intense’, she justifies it by saying my sister only cares about me and is desperate for a nice carry-on. My sister will cry to my mum and has apparently said she is worried I hate her. It all seems like really huge scale reactions.

I reassure her often that I do want to spend time with her and care about her but this seems to make her place more demands on me, for instance she has said if I don’t ‘step up’ and be there for her then she will have to consider my place at her wedding.

In recent months I have taken a step back from her for the sake of my own well-being. I keep in touch with the odd message and like her posts, tagging her in things I think she’ll like etc. I would love to get on better, but she pushed me over deliberately on a family holiday - when I calmly called it out she replied that she should have pushed me harder then played it off as a joke. She spent all that week digging at me subtly and being extremely rude to my partner, who treats me wonderfully and doesn’t deserve any of it. Called us both boring for not wanting to drink, and nagged me to have a bottle of wine in each hand. I will drink but not to the amount she does. Majority of it done when my parents were out of earshot. She will try and push me for what my ‘five year plan is’ and mocked me to her other half for taking a long time painting pottery on a family holiday. I only know this because my dad and partner were with her OH at the time and saw the messages and unflattering photos that I didn’t know were being taken. I think my dad might understand at least a little, though he doesn’t say. He will try his best to include us, which is comforting. My sister and her partner love the conversation to be on them at all times and don’t allow room for anyone else’s stories. It’s any which way to put me down, so it seems. I have tried everything: challenging it does not work as she claims it is me looking for trouble, ignoring it seems to feed her idea that I am disinterested in her.

My mum seems to side more with my sister and has asked me to think twice about whether I want to be estranged from my sister. It’s just a lot of pressure and guilt trips.

I hate to imagine a not-so-distant future where we have nothing in common, and our kids don’t get on - but she’s blocked me entirely on social media, from all her accounts, until I ‘step up as her sister and friend’ whatever that is supposed to mean.

I have really done my best to understand where it’s coming from but I’m drawing a blank, I don’t know why she does it, she is pretty, talented, ambitious and career driven. Successful. She doesn’t have anything to be jealous of or insecure about where I’m concerned.

I guess I am just looking for a bit of moral support from others who have experienced similar. Thanks in advance x

OP posts:
chatterbug22 · 20/03/2022 08:48

@Tiddlesthecat thank you for being balanced in your response. I don’t believe there is 100% bad intention and think what you’re saying has some truth behind it where my sister is concerned, it’s just difficult to deal with it.

OP posts:
chatterbug22 · 20/03/2022 08:48

@JudgeJ thank you

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 19/03/2022 22:39

[quote chatterbug22]@Cherrysoup yes pushed over. My mum wanted a picture of us together, so my sister grabbed hold of me and squeezed me very tightly for the camera (knows full well I do not like this from anyone, an arm around each other would’ve been nice enough). I winced a bit when she was squeezing me and she took a step back, laughed, and pushed my face to the side quite forcefully as if to say ‘you’re boring’. I just kind of froze and looked to my mum who literally turned around and faced the other way. I said, ‘what was that for?’ and my sister replied ‘should’ve done it harder, and into the ditch’ (there was a hill with some boggy mud behind us as we were in a forest).

I couldn’t quite believe it![/quote]
Your mistake is in not pushing a closed fist into her face in your own defence when she assaulted you. I wouldn't even attend her wedding and certainly not dance to her tune by being a bridesmaid.

JudgeJ · 19/03/2022 22:35

I hate to imagine a not-so-distant future where we have nothing in common, and our kids don’t get on - but she’s blocked me entirely on social media, from all her accounts, until I ‘step up as her sister and friend’ whatever that is supposed to mean.

A future with nothing in common with this bully would seem ideal. Just because we share blood doesn't mean we have to like or even tolerate someone.

HeckinMiffed · 19/03/2022 22:24

I;m sorry OP, my twin sister used to treat me like this too, it took me until she started bullying my children and making them feel like they weren’t good enough too before I finally went no contact.
You’re already being accused of not stepping up and I bet it escalates into you ruining her special day. (can you tell I’m speaking from experience?) So you may as well be hung for a sheep as a lamb.
It doesn’t matter if you were the best friend/bridesmaid/sister in the world ever and near destroyed yourself to do what she wants, it will not be good enough. Nothing you ever do will be good enough. I heard ‘you have to stop being like this’ so many times and drove myself to a breakdown trying to stop being me. Still wasn’t good enough.
You can turn yourself inside out and make yourself miserable to be the person she;s trying to bully you into, it won’t be enough. You’re her unch bag, the one who isn’t good enough, the one she mocks and bullies to make her own life seem better.
She’s a controlling bully. You would do well to study the ‘grey rock’ technique and start implementing it. Have a read of the Stately Homes thread too, some great advice on there.
You may not be ready to put up boundaries yet, years of conditioning are so hard to overcome. But for your own sake take a quiet step back and don’t engage. Just smile and nod then go home and cry.
Put minimum effort into wedding, then just drift apart.

Good luck OP, its not easy. your family will guilt trip you but you need to look after yourself.

StEval · 19/03/2022 21:57

This is a toxic and dysfunctional family situation.
Look up Karpmans Triangulation Theory as to why your parents dont challenge her.

Shd is exhibiting narc tendencies in her behaviour of entitlement, bullying and demands- tantrums when she doesnt get her own way.
These people have a very high tolerance for conflict and drama.
They get a kick out of it but most of all they love discrediting you and blaming.
She wont change or see your POV.
The pushing is an escalation, a warning .

The wedding, smile and get through it, then fade away.

Lurking9to5 · 19/03/2022 21:38

[quote chatterbug22]@Lurking9to5 this sounds like a good approach. I do feel a twinge of sad, because I want to genuinely be there and present. She is my sister. She just doesn’t respect me or see me as an equal in any capacity. I think I have been made to feel guilty about a lot though when it comes to her and I have to learn not to, and to have things on my terms.[/quote]
yeh, that's often the core issue. within your family your are who your sister says you are. You are playing the part she wrote for you and if you deviate from that it causes problems in the family, it's unfair to you.

If you push this you will probably end up very let down by your parents... I could be wrong. But from the little bits you've said your mum gives in to your sister and your dad wants peace so if you push back for the first time and push back hard, then you will be perceived to be the problem. You're going off script.

Tiddlesthecat · 19/03/2022 20:39

I could well be wrong but it seems to me as though your sister is attempting to push your buttons in an attempt to get your attention. Clearly she feels hurt that you're not as excited about her wedding as she is. Blocking you on social media is very childish and counterproductive though. I think that the best thing is to try and do something nice together, just the two of you and see how you get on. Keep your parents out of it. You're grown-ups, not children. If, like you say, you don't want to end up estranged, then you have to try and find a way forward. Clearly the situation is making both of you unhappy.

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 20:27

@GetOffTheTableMabel I don’t care what my role is, or what the dress looks like. I care about her having a nice time truthfully. I don’t mind being demoted but if I express that it’ll be pounced on, then I’ll be demonised for it. I will try more of that!

OP posts:
GetOffTheTableMabel · 19/03/2022 20:14

She sounds completely toxic. You need a couple of rehearsed phrases that don’t feed the drama.
Does it matter if she demotes you from being a bridesmaid? It sounds better than being constantly mistreated between now and then. Why not just say “If that’s what you want, I respect your decision”.

She wants to upset you, as all bullies do, so every time you don’t get upset by her you win. There is nothing you could do which would annoy her more, or preserve your mental health more, than just refusing to engage with her spiteful batshittery. Just smile and nod.

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 20:06

Do appreciate everyone’s thoughts here, I know I wrote an essay. I think I have been made to feel guilty for more things than I realise, and it’s only as I wrote it all back out that I realised how it looked. She is very convincing and persuasive though which makes things all the harder. I would hate for anything big to kick off on her special day.

OP posts:
chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 19:39

@Eightiesfan I don’t blame anyone for wanting to keep the peace, but by the same logic I wish it felt easier for me to be allowed to keep my own peace! Thanks lovely x

OP posts:
Eightiesfan · 19/03/2022 19:33

If she was anyone but your sister you would not tolerate this behaviour. She sounds like an entitled jealous harpy. In your place I would be NC, and while I’m at it your mum needs to find her backbone and stop taking your sisters side in all this. I suspect it’s easier to agree with her than to disagree and be on the receiving end of her nastiness, but she is your mother as well.

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 19:29

@Lurking9to5 this sounds like a good approach. I do feel a twinge of sad, because I want to genuinely be there and present. She is my sister. She just doesn’t respect me or see me as an equal in any capacity. I think I have been made to feel guilty about a lot though when it comes to her and I have to learn not to, and to have things on my terms.

OP posts:
Lurking9to5 · 19/03/2022 19:23

It sounds like your dad is fairly passive and will back your mum up siding with your sister, so in your shoes, (and I kind of am, except, I handled everything WRONG) I wouldn't give your sister anything she react to disproportionately. Such a classic manipulative technique, but if you were to challenge her then she would be so hurt, so wounded, she'd martyr up, all of the focus would be how could you hurt her, and before her wedding! You're so callous.

For the time being, I'd grit you teeth and give the minimum so that nobody is asking you ''what's wrong?''.

Then after the wedding, fade away.

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 19:20

@Frigginintheriggin she said it was a joke. I’m aware it’s not acceptable behaviour. She hasn’t done this to anyone else though which is why it’s clear her behaviour only comes out like this in our relationship as sisters. I think my mum did call her out on it and they then argued for the rest of the day, with my sister slamming doors etc in the holiday apartment. We just kept a low profile then went off and had fun and was later told we just ‘took ourselves off’ any wonder!

OP posts:
Lurking9to5 · 19/03/2022 19:15

Can't answer for OP @deliadel but it's really hard to live with your family's unjust demonisation of you. I know this from my own family. I could say ''ok, consider me paranoid then, consider me angry, consider me emotional, blame me for our rift'' but it feels so unfair and so uncomfortable. I feel like I want to avoid this (although that IS what they think). You have to sit wiht the uncomfortable thoughts they say, before they go away. I suppose freedom from the madness lies in there somewhere, sitting so long with the excrutiating discomfort of being blamed and shamed that it no longer has the same impact on you.

Frigginintheriggin · 19/03/2022 19:13

If my sister laid hands on me like that it would be the last time.
Don't allow her to continue this behaviour at your expense.
Personally I wouldn't give a flying fuck what anyone else had to say, I would forget I had a sister.

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 19:11

@C0rBlimey I don’t want to meet her overly, I never feel like I can quite look her in the eye - intimidated, I guess. It throws me off when she projects things back on to me and I’ve tried in so many different ways and it has always been the same result. She does not take accountability and even if I gently point something out she will fly up the wall, no matter how balanced I make it. I do hope things will change one day, she hasn’t yet got kids but plans on it soon and maybe then things will change for the better x

OP posts:
chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 19:09

@Deliadel I think you’ve cracked it to be honest, and credit to you cos it was a long and probably in places boring read - my big essay!

Do need to realise that it’s not my responsibility to worry about what others think. It’s their business not mine! I’m getting there. Spade a spade is possibly what I’ve been missing, it’s a good approach x

OP posts:
Deliadel · 19/03/2022 19:04

Why do you worry about her saying you're disinterested?

So, as an example, say she invited you for a dress fitting and you don't take a day off work. Your sister then cries to your Mum. Then your Mum says to you - your sister is so upset, she thinks you don't care. I'm wondering what stops you from saying, 'I don't care. I can't take a day off work.'

I'm asking genuinely. What stops you from calling a spade a spade and carrying the attitude of 'no shits given' about it?

What if I said, maybe if your attitude was - Mum she's an idiot, I don't actually care - then your sister would have quite a lot less power over you?

If I said- maybe the power she has over you, is down to your worry about your parents perception of you - how would you feel about that? E.g agree/disagree/feel uncomfortable?

You don't have to agree with me! I'm just putting it out there as something to consider.

C0rBlimey · 19/03/2022 19:03

(But to add, I'd probably have blocked her back and not entertain her lunacy)

C0rBlimey · 19/03/2022 19:02

OP, if you really feel you have to meet her then tell her beforehand that "repairing a relationship" requires listening from both sides. Make it clear you're not going to turn up just to take an earbashing from her. She has to acknowledge she's acted badly in this and take accountability. Two voices need to be heard, not just one.

If she doesn't do that, just get up and leave.

chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 19:01

@EvilKinevil thank you! Great point

OP posts:
chatterbug22 · 19/03/2022 18:59

@slothbyday thank you. Appreciated. How did you learn to rise above the people that did judge you for it?

OP posts: