Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children expressing emotions AIBU

140 replies

Idkiibu · 19/03/2022 13:17

Me and my friend have different parenting styles. But reflecting back from our yesterday’s conversation with her, I’m trying to understand AIBU towards my own 2 children?
We are talking about children aged 7-10 years old. My friend’s children are sometimes tired after school etc and it comes out the way that I wouldn’t personally accept from my own children, e.g. shouting at parents, kicking things, saying rude staff like “shut up” and slamming the door. My friend talks to her children in a calm way and is trying to “ride it out”. I respect her patience, I really do.
But I don’t accept this with my own. A few times it happened I said to my children firmly that I’m always there for them, they can embrace me and spend time with me, they can tell me everything and we will find the way out of the situation, etc etc. But I don’t deserve to be shouted at and there will be no door slamming at my house, so they have to approach me in a different way and I’ll help them then. I don’t want my children to bottle things up, but am I wrong that at this age they have to learn not to hurt others emotionally even if they are upset? On the other hand, children are only learning about how to express themselves and can’t always control their emotions.
I feel like our approaches are different and that’s fine but am I too strict to my children? It’s not like they are not allowed to be upset or cry, it’s the aggression and shouting I can’t stomach. One day when my friend’s DS (9) was tired after his own party, he said to his mother “shut up, I hate you”. My heart was broken for her and I don’t know how she managed to stay calm. I said nothing and never mentioned it again after she said “it’s been a long day, he’s so tired”.
Our children don’t have SEN and do well at school, no behaviour concerns etc.

OP posts:
Idkiibu · 19/03/2022 14:21

@Introvertedbuthappy
I find your comment very helpful and please don’t think I don’t try to understand.
Like every other person I can be judgmental but it’s comes from a place of confusion and I reflect a lot along the way about my own parenting, believe me.

OP posts:
Chonfox · 19/03/2022 14:19

I agree with you in theory and I don't accept it from my own DC (who are still quite young), however I'm a hypocrite as I occasionally lose my cool and am very rude towards them. I was brought up with an obnoxious, arsehole father who would shout and swear. This becomes ingrained unfortunately, so I have picked up some of these traits when under stress. I try very, very hard to counter it and do a good job most of the time of being polite and respectful towards my family but I have to actively work at it and the ugly side of my conditioning exposes itself on occasion. So if my DC start giving it back to me as they get older well there's not much I will be able to say/do about that as it will be a case of monkey see monkey do.

My point being your friend's children are getting it from somewhere. Either she's not quite so passive when you're not around (as is almost always the case with parents!) or they're dad is rude?

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 19/03/2022 14:19

But not when they're in the middle of an explosion, is the point. That was my mistake... Coregulate and later reason is the best route. But hey, won't beat myself up. I was a bit out of kilter myself in the moment!!
A good rule of thumb that I have read many times in different child psych books 'A child is not responsible for an adult' s emotions' so even tho what they say might be unreasonable, I'd rather they say it and, as I say, guide them over time.

Idkiibu · 19/03/2022 14:17

@Quartz2208
But it is about me too. Relationships are a two way street? We all have feelings and our own struggles. We are always there for them and I agree maybe I’m too sensitive but “I hate you” would really knock me down.

OP posts:
Introvertedbuthappy · 19/03/2022 14:16

I think your children are different, and I used to think like you until my youngest. On the very rare occasions my oldest gets angry, I just have to use a firm voice, he will almost immediately realise he is in the wrong and will get upset and apologise.

So with my oldest, it would have gone like this in the case of shouting or door slamming (he's a teen but has never really raised his voice at me):
Him: angry shout. Slam
Me: excuse me?! Come back here. I don't know what you are angry about but you absolutely cannot speak to me like that. I need you to come here, apologise and I will help you sort it out, but I can only do that when you speak to me.

With youngest:
Him: angry shout. Slam.
If I tried the above method with him:
Me: Excuse me?! Come back here-
Him: screaming (noooooo). Probably continued screaming at top of his lungs. Significant chance he would turn violent and attempt to shove me. If I tried to de-escalate the violence would increase. He is probably neuro divergent but does very well at school but is massively triggered by being slightly tired or hungry. He's already improved over the last couple of years, but yes - he has issues with managing his big feelings in a way that isn't aggressive. He doesn't watch tv much so it's not that, he has just always been this way.

How I would actually handle it with youngest:
Him: angry shout. Slam.
Me: (probably relieved he isn't taking out his anger on anybody physically) are you okay?
Him: shouts again
Me: let me know when you are calm and I'll come and speak to you
Him: crashes around his room, calming down. After a bit - "I'm ready"
Me: I don't know what you are angry about but you absolutely cannot speak to me like that. I need you to apologise and I will help you sort it out, but I can only do that when you speak to me.
I would never do the above bit until he was calm. Doing that earlier would be the equivalent of pouring petrol and a ton of tinder on a small fire.

Please do not judge your friend (you have used quite a lot of judgemental language in your post). Just because your children react differently does not mean yours are better. We parent for the kids we have, not the kids we want. If I could use your approach (same I use on my eldest) and not have my youngest spiral into a violent meltdown, I would. Please don't think it hasn't occurred to her either.

Idkiibu · 19/03/2022 14:14

@HeyGirlHeyBoy
Thanks for your reply.
Actually “warning” rather than a consequence seems like something very appropriate on this type of situations.

OP posts:
Quartz2208 · 19/03/2022 14:13

The thing is it isnt about YOU. DS has on occasion told me he hates me. He doesnt at all - he is overwhelmed for whatever reason and he cant articulate that in the way he wants to so he says that. Because he loves me and he knows I love him unconditionally.

For my children I and their home is a safe space. A space where they can let go a little bit of the day whilst learning how to regulate them

Theunamedcat · 19/03/2022 14:12

It's a fine line to walk as parents and tbh no-one gets it bang on everytime

Idkiibu · 19/03/2022 14:09

@Theunamedcat
I actually think you’re right here. I need to learn not to take everything personally and she needs to learn that she doesn’t have to accept every negative behaviour thrown at her as it’s normal. But I will never tell her that though.

OP posts:
Idkiibu · 19/03/2022 14:07

@Lolapusht
Thanks for your reply.
I didn’t shout at my child, I used strict voice, it’s different.
I agree, it’s sounds “conditional” and it worries me. At the same time, I need this behaviour to stop before I’m able to help my child. It also hurts me a lot and affects me, and I think even though I’m a grown up, I want my children to care for me as well. I can’t say “it’s ok if you shout and insult me until you’re… 15 and then you have to stop”. I’m struggling with the fear of normalising the behaviour, I don’t want it to become normal. It’s really different to the child being upset or crying or sad, it’s all very very normal. It’s children or people in general dumping bad feelings in you in an aggressive way that bothers me. As if “I’m tired or worried, it’s all your fault”. I had that a bit when my children were in the reception class. That’s a very young age so I knew they are too young to cope. I remember everything was my fault then for a while. But after a while this behaviour stopped. But being 9-10 is different to being 4.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 19/03/2022 14:05

The words your needing here are "middle ground" there is a time and a place and a WAY to express anger and frustration appropriately

Both of you are wrong

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 19/03/2022 14:02

Really well expressed (!) Jacksworld.

A good structure we used successfully here last week was I feel X because Y, I need Z. Really clear and useful communication. My ds can be explosive but while all behaviours are not OK, I am always clear how much he is loved, how anger is OK as I feel inside he actually has quite a bit of shame around it, despite my best efforts.

Idkiibu · 19/03/2022 14:01

Thanks @Ponoka7
I do understand the situations where children are struggling with this kind of a behaviour consistently in more than one setting and “punishment” won’t be effective. Luckily it’s not the case here and sometimes I feel like they want to “try” this behaviour out and see what happens? My DS reads a lot and knows about the “moody teenagers”, this kind of behaviour sometimes is shown on TV like previous poster mentioned etc.

OP posts:
JacksWorld · 19/03/2022 13:59

@Jadecarrot

You seem very smug at how controlled you are. Congratulations.
Not smug, irritated by what OP sees as indulging behaviour. It grates to see how permissive some parents are. They seems to think that they need to tolerate kids' aggressive and rude behaviour to let them grow into rounded individuals. I disagree with this, kids need to learn that it's normal to have these emotions and learn to deal with them in a non destructive way. They need to. learn to identify what is making them feel so mad and frustrated and deal with this in a problem solving way while not judging themselves negatively for having the emotions. Basically we need to teach them self awareness but by bit, that will allow them to be resilient and manage their lives. Of course teens are notorious for lack of self awareness but here I'd say deescalate while always showing that aggressive behaviour is not tolerated but that the emotion behind lashing out will always be respected and supported.
HeyGirlHeyBoy · 19/03/2022 13:58

I voted yanbu but your idea of 'behaviour is a choice' isn't strictly true at this age, the brain isn't fully developed until early 20s! I had to dish out a consequence the other day because of ds angry behaviour, gave a warning first. He was devastated after the fact and when I said I had given a warning, he said I heard it but I was so angry I couldn't stop.. Obviously I held to consequence set but did reflect on middle of the storm not being the ideal time to throw it in. Like most people when children are off balance, reason isn't their strength! Like a pp, I hate you wouldn't really bother me as obviously I know it's not coming from truth but more frustration. Over time we can reflect their feelings and give them better words and ways to express them. They'll get there, but not all at the same time and always better to explode than implode.

Ponoka7 · 19/03/2022 13:57

Good point about television, mine were the playing out generation and what's available now, wasn't then.

Lolapusht · 19/03/2022 13:55

First thing that stood out to me is that you’re making your support for them conditional. They have to behave in a particular way before you’ll entertain a conversation with them. You are presuming they are able to control themselves and are choosing to shout so can therefore chose not to.

Your son was angry so slammed a door and shouted. You lost your temper and shouted at him to tell him that shouting is not acceptable.

You absolutely do not have to put up with unacceptable behaviour, but when children are that upset it’s usually because they’ve lost control/feel scared/threatened etc. Refusing to deal with that doesn’t help them deal with their emotions and learn how to cope when they get upset. They’re still emotionally “young” and many adults can’t regulate their emotions. Shutting down their reaction can also make them feel like they’re not being listened to which can lead to frustration and the easiest release for frustration is an angry outburst, like slamming a door.

The worse time to address behaviour like that is when they’re angry. They won’t learn anything and it’s easy to escalate things until you’re both shouting and slamming doors.

He’s also going to be full of hormones so it’s unlikely that he’s going to get to 18 without ever losing his temper or showing that he’s angry. Teaching him that these feelings are totally normal and not something to be frightened of along with calmly giving him acceptable behaviour parameters and coping techniques will allow him to develop the tools he needs to regulate his emotions. Shutting down his reaction and demanding an apology before you help just makes your support conditional.

Idkiibu · 19/03/2022 13:55

@Jadecarrot
I’m sorry, you got me wrong. I’m a very sensitive person who feels the result of any kind of aggression for a long time. My father was the one who freely “expressed” himself in quite an aggressive way and I’m scared of it until this day and I’m mid 30s. I’m not smug, I feel guilty in case I don’t let my children “be themselves” but at the same time I feel like I will never allow anyone to hurt me unnecessarily, children or not iykwim.

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 19/03/2022 13:54

"How did you react to your DD saying she hates you and what was the age it stopped? Did you apply any consequences afterwards?"

I'd react to what was causing it, so if tired she'd be put to bed, if hungry, fed etc. We'd talk about it when appropriate. She grew out of it around nine. I think a few days of no television is too long a punishment, one night would be enough. The issue is that if a child is honestly struggling with control then punishment isn't appropriate, it would lower self esteem. I think showing understanding, them feeling like they can trust you and kindness are more important than parenting styles.

Idkiibu · 19/03/2022 13:53

@JacksWorld
I actually feel the same way towards some TV programs. I have noticed a noticeable increase in argumentative behaviour between DD and DS after watching some “child friendly” family sitcom where brothers and sisters are always “frenemies” and it’s glorified and “funny”.

OP posts:
Jadecarrot · 19/03/2022 13:50

You seem very smug at how controlled you are. Congratulations.

JacksWorld · 19/03/2022 13:48

YANBU

Child: I hate this/you/all so dumb
Adult : I won't tolerate you taking like that
Child : well I still hate it How does it go on?

"I can see you are angry / mad / frustrated / disappointed and that's ok, we all feel like this some times. I love you very much but you cannot talk to me / you sibling/ dad/ dog / cat in this way, that's unacceptable, we don't do that in our family."

^said in a pretty firm and stern voice to shut the drama down / up.

Once they pause with their drama you go in as good cop:
"I know this has been a challenging day / week/ event / it's really hard, I understand. Remember, I love you very much, tell me more about what is annoying you so much, I promise I will listen and if it's something I can help with or change I promise I will think about it."

Along these lines.

Some kids pick up aggressive, angry behaviour from TV, especially American programmes have a lot of angry characters in it, it's quite toxic and pathetic actually. We don't let them watch that shit until they are a bit older.

Of course children need to and should be able to express emotions but aggressive behaviour is not tolerated in our house. I understand that this wouldn't necessarily work when dealing with ODD, Autism, ADHD and so on. But I refuse to be a punch bag form anyone. I respect my kids but they need boundaries.

bellac11 · 19/03/2022 13:48

Some children wont respond as well if they are left to calm down and you discuss it later as they wont recognise it happened, remember it, feel it the same.

Some wont respond if you deal with it in the heat of the moment, it might inflame the situation more.

But aggressive or selfish or self absorbed behaviour isnt acceptable even if justified by it being the person (adult or child) expressing themselves or 'being them'. Children need help with how to express something without it impacting negatively on others.

Sunnytwobridges · 19/03/2022 13:46

I definitely wouldn’t put up with that behaviour either. I would take your approach every time. Sometimes kids need a firm talking to and boundaries. They have to understand some behavior is not acceptable, and it will be that way all their life so they have to learn early.

Goldbar · 19/03/2022 13:45

I agree with you. We need to guide our children to express their emotions in an acceptable way. The sort of behaviour you describe - shouting, slamming doors, hitting, cruel words - would be abuse if perpetrated by an adult so I don't think it's an acceptable expression of emotion from a child either, even if more excusable.