Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shed dispute

162 replies

runnerblade95 · 19/03/2022 11:55

Sorry if this is a long thread, bear with me! I’m a permanent council tenant who has recently moved into a new flat. Our communal garden is fenced off with 6 sheds facing our block which has 6 flats in it.

A tenant from another block, also fenced in on their side, is using my shed and has been using my shed for months maybe even years before I moved in. I called the council and someone from the neighbourhood team told me that they do not get involved in disputes regarding sheds and that basically it’s nothing to do with them.

They asked me are the sheds visible from where you are. I said yes and that I can see them from my window and that there are 6, presumably, for the 6 tenants that live in my block. The advisor then replied well then to me that sounds like 1 of the 6 is your shed. I advise you to put a note on the shed door stating that you’ve just moved in and that this is your shed and to give enough notice for them to move their items into their own shed. Which should be situated in their fenced off communal premises.

I followed the advisor’s advice and did this with the note on the shed, only to be met with confrontation and aggression. I did exactly what the council told me to do, to no avail.

What the other tenant did let slip is that he used to be very good friends with the previous tenant of my flat and that when they moved out, that they gave him the keys Hmm

Surely, that is not allowed?

So my question is, AIBU to be upset by this and if so, does anyone have any advice as to how I should approach this matter?

OP posts:
tara66 · 19/03/2022 15:55

Can you find out the names of the councillors specifically for your area? There will probably be both Labour and Conservative Councillors - say 3 for each party for your area. Where I am both parties are very keen to help with individual local issues. Both parties send out email news letters every month to tell residents how they have helped residents with matters brought to their attention. This is for all residents not just those in council property.

BeanStew22 · 19/03/2022 15:10

@DDivaStar

Its nice you don't want to remove their stuff but realistically it doesn't sound like they're going to do it willingly.

What do you expect the councillor to do ?

If you want this sorted you are going to have to sort it yourself I am afraid

The person using your shed should have taken it up with his neighbors but has gone sideways to use yours instead. You need to nip it in the bud or live with it

rocksonrocks · 19/03/2022 15:02

Yes, the person who is using the shed does have to enter my communal garden through the gate to access the shed.

How is it a communal garden if it’s “yours”?

whenwilliwillibefamous · 19/03/2022 15:00

OP what happens if you ask the tenancy liaison officer how you can sort yourself a shed, as you would like one?
Then they can either come back with,
"You have one, it's X", and you can get back to them saying someone else has appropriated it, and what should you do to get it back,
Or,
They say, "fill in this form/go on this list", in which case - do that.
I sympathize, it sounds like they are not being professional or helpful. It must be very stressful.

RealBecca · 19/03/2022 14:54

I would remove their lock, take their stuff out and put your own on, and put up a ring camera. Shift the burden on to them to prove they have the right to be there.

Leftbutcameback · 19/03/2022 14:53

If you do have better evidence that it is your shed I would agree about giving notice then changing the padlock and removing items. Very unlikely to keep anything sentimental in a shed as they are so insecure.

Toottooot · 19/03/2022 14:52

‘Log’ it wi 101 min ken.

Leftbutcameback · 19/03/2022 14:39

Lots of assumptions going on on this thread about sheds being rented etc. It's possible they are occupied effectively under licence (ie informally). This would make particular sense of what the council don't get involved in shed disputes.

Leftbutcameback · 19/03/2022 14:37

How do you know the previous tenant owned the shed OP? Did they tell you?

It sounds like the only evidence you have that it is "your shed" is from a neighbour? Unless I've missed something.

RosiePosieDozy · 19/03/2022 14:31

No, that's not right at all. This person should have taken his rightful shed in his communal garden and not started using this one and trespassing in someone else's garden.

Maybe contact the councillor. This man shouldn't bully you into submission.

namejustforthis · 19/03/2022 14:28

@sueelleker

Exactly my point. Yes, the person who is using the shed does have to enter my communal garden through the gate to access the shed. The shed belonged to the previous tenant of my flat with whom he said he was very good friends with and who gave him the shed keys when he moved out hmm like, what the hell? And if he'd given his friend a key to the flat, would that entitle him to come in whenever he wanted too? Previous agreements are nothing to do with you. You could put his stuff in bin bags in the garden when you change the locks, so it doesn't get damaged by the weather.
No it wouldn't as the previous legal agreement giving them rights has ended and OP will have a new agreement saying she now rents the property.

With the shed however the OP doesn't have an agreement that it is now her renting it and the other person presumably so far hasn't been told legally they can't use / access it so it's not the same.

sueelleker · 19/03/2022 14:22

Exactly my point. Yes, the person who is using the shed does have to enter my communal garden through the gate to access the shed. The shed belonged to the previous tenant of my flat with whom he said he was very good friends with and who gave him the shed keys when he moved out hmm like, what the hell?
And if he'd given his friend a key to the flat, would that entitle him to come in whenever he wanted too? Previous agreements are nothing to do with you.
You could put his stuff in bin bags in the garden when you change the locks, so it doesn't get damaged by the weather.

mrsm43s · 19/03/2022 14:22

If your shed isn't included in your tenancy agreement, then you're not renting it. Someone else is presumably renting it. I assume from what you say, that the previous tenant for your property gave up the property, but has continued to rent the shed and is allowing her friend to use it. This is dodgy in terms of the friend jumping the waiting list for the sheds, but I think it's unlikely that it's "your" shed.

Obviously if it is listed on your tenancy agreement, or you are paying for a separate rental agreement for the shed, then that is a different issue.

Bootothegoose · 19/03/2022 14:20

We fitted a lock to our shed (I did, DH passed me tools) after there was a spate of robberies. This was the video we followed, got the locks and padlock from Amazon. It took maybe half an hour, argument included.

namejustforthis · 19/03/2022 14:19

@Bootothegoose

They're throwing their weight around because they want you to back down.

Print off another big sign that says - 'Private Property of Flat 1, not for communal use. Per Council advice please take this as final warning that on 27/03, I will be emptying this shed of any item that is not my own and changing the lock. Anything not removed by that day is assumed to be abandoned and will be binned.' Put it in a plastic wallet and sellotape the top shut so it can't get wet. Fasten it to the opening of the door so you can't get in without seeing it.

Follow through and bin EVERYTHING on that date. The tenant will rant and rave but at the end of the day, there's nothing to be done. They were given warning and the property is now gone. If they turn up to the door, call the police and the council - every time. Do not answer the door without filming. Once they see you won't back down, they'll give up.

The council and the police will not be in support of her if she does this as she is not the legal owner of the shed.

There will be deeds which state the legal owner.

If she does this the person could take legal action against her.

namejustforthis · 19/03/2022 14:17

@SoyaChai

Are you saying she is meant to rent the shed herself if it isn't in her tenancy?

In which case, is the tenant from the other block who is currently using it paying for it? Did she buy it from the previous owner? Sounds like previous tenant just gave her the keys, so she wouldn't have rights to it either surely.

This is for the legal owner of the shed to address.

I would have expected that when the previous resident moved out they would have had to clear the shed and give the keys back to the 'shed's owner / landlord', not pass them into another person as they have no agreement with the shed's owner.

The shed owner can serve notice / remove items via legal route to 'take possession of the shed back' if this is the case.

Then it is for the owner to decide who uses and how next to use the shed.

This could be for the next tenant that moves in. They may allow them to use it for free or they may charge for it.

They may have a waiting list for people in the area wanting a shed although it may not be the closest to where they live and allocate it to them.

It's a bit like council garages. Just because there is a garage block behind your property doesn't mean it comes with your property and there are likely to be separate arrangements on how you rent one of those garages such as waiting lists and separate rental agreements.

You need to think if it like a property in itself if it isn't expressly included in the tenancy agreement as coming with the flat.

Bootothegoose · 19/03/2022 14:17

They're throwing their weight around because they want you to back down.

Print off another big sign that says - 'Private Property of Flat 1, not for communal use. Per Council advice please take this as final warning that on 27/03, I will be emptying this shed of any item that is not my own and changing the lock. Anything not removed by that day is assumed to be abandoned and will be binned.' Put it in a plastic wallet and sellotape the top shut so it can't get wet. Fasten it to the opening of the door so you can't get in without seeing it.

Follow through and bin EVERYTHING on that date. The tenant will rant and rave but at the end of the day, there's nothing to be done. They were given warning and the property is now gone. If they turn up to the door, call the police and the council - every time. Do not answer the door without filming. Once they see you won't back down, they'll give up.

TigerLilyTail · 19/03/2022 14:16

@ChickenStripper

How did you get the key for it?
I think the point is that the OP doesn't have a key for it. The other person has the key.
Prettynails · 19/03/2022 14:15

Forget my last post PLEASE -I didn't realise you didn't have anything in writing etc surely they are on the deeds if they belong or not?

Prettynails · 19/03/2022 14:14

Personally I'd change the locks and leave a note saying 'Unfortunately the previous keys to this shed -were not passed to the new tenant. As pre previous discusssions this shed belong to my flat number x in the block. Please take this matter up with the housing association and speak to x (the one you spoke to who says they don't deal in sheds)

And bin bag everything up and change the locks. Leave it all outside -they will move it quickly -

HappyDays40 · 19/03/2022 14:09

If its not something that the council have jurisdiction over and it is first come first served then I'm not sure there is much you can do.
Check your tenancy agreement.

namejustforthis · 19/03/2022 14:03

Without meaning to sound rude op, it really doesn't matter what any other tenant says.

You need to get clarification from your landlord.

From your post it's likely they own the building (blocks) and the communal garden areas and therefore likely anything in them. If you are talking brick built sheds it's particularly likely. If you are talking wooden sheds like a standard garden shed then possibly they could belong to tenants but as they are on the landlords land those residents would have had to ask permission from housing.

Also the garden can't just be padlocked off etc without establishing who has the rights to them. The same as you can't stop someone from using something which you don't know for sure they don't have the right to use.

Also like another poster added it maybe that sheds are allocated via a waiting list and maybe in the garden of another block. There are too many what ifs.

You really to speak to your landlord again.

ChickenStripper · 19/03/2022 14:02

How did you get the key for it?

BOOTS52 · 19/03/2022 14:02

I would write a letter to the council and keep a copy stating all the facts and how they live in another area yet are accessing your garden and got the shed from their friend who used to live where you are. I would also go to citizens advise and get some support. The council need to take some responsibility and I would find out who is higher up and get the letter recorded delivery to them. I would not put the stuff out and change the locks as they could get aggressive and would cause you endless stress. The sheds are allocated to your properties and that person has a neck on him thinking because his friend gave him the key he has ownership of it. This is your shed but contact the council but get advise from citizens first. I would not deal with the person who took your shed at all. It is normal that the little sheds are allocated to the properties there and not for a person who lives around the corner. Hope you get sorted soon. When you do make sure you have it well secure and good locks on it also.

SoyaChai · 19/03/2022 14:00

Are you saying she is meant to rent the shed herself if it isn't in her tenancy?

In which case, is the tenant from the other block who is currently using it paying for it? Did she buy it from the previous owner? Sounds like previous tenant just gave her the keys, so she wouldn't have rights to it either surely.