Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do murderers rehabilitate in prison?

61 replies

jobhunter7 · 19/03/2022 07:40

I've been reading about the awful Sophie Lancaster story and I was wondering whether people thought people who commit crimes like this do come out of prison rehabilitated by the system at all. As awful as crimes like this are, they were teenage boys. And sometimes people in prison haven't had the best start in life.

OP posts:
jobhunter7 · 20/03/2022 20:26

So should they be jailed for longer?

Also presumably some people decide to have children with people who've committed such crimes... I find that difficult to understand somewhat...

OP posts:
Florenz · 20/03/2022 20:19

I couldn't care less if they do rehabilitate or not. They are murderers and should be treated as such. There is no good reason why they should be allowed to live a "normal" life after they have taken the life of another.

WellNotReally · 20/03/2022 20:17

A DV victims who kills her husband is out for revenge.

This has made me angry. It's such an ill informed, ignorant comment. I slept with a kitchen knife under my pillow on one occasion. Staying alive and protecting the life of my unborn child was the motivation. Not bloody revenge.

If you do work with offenders, you need to do an awful lot more learning around domestic violence victims.

HailAdrian · 20/03/2022 20:11

I think it really depends on the circumstances of the murder. The guys who killed Sophie Lancaster and would have killed her boyfriend, no, I don't believe rehabilitation is possible for them.

Ancientbride · 20/03/2022 20:10

Some can. I knew a man who had been given a life sentence for murder. He got a degree while in prison and then, when out on licence, he trained as a social worker and worked for many years in that field. He never committed another offence but lived in constant fear of being recalled to prison.

tttigress · 20/03/2022 20:08

@bellac11

I thought I remembered reading somewhere that the repeat offence rates for murderers on life licence were lower than for any other crime.
Yeah but murder is kind of a big crime.
tttigress · 20/03/2022 20:07

I think it depends on the person if the rehabilitate.

But it obviously isn't a given, and it would be fairly easy to say what the parole board want to hear.

AllOfUsAreDead · 20/03/2022 20:02

Some can, some can't. One off murderers would be more likely than multiple.

Sex offenders though, nope, they think in a different way. You could 'rehabilitate' them, but the approach is banned.

Ballcactus · 20/03/2022 19:56

@HRTQueen

I work in forensic mh (ex offenders)

Some do some don’t depends on circumstances, back ground, support they get

Sexual offenders no they can’t be rehabilitated

Agree- same field too
bellac11 · 20/03/2022 19:54

I thought I remembered reading somewhere that the repeat offence rates for murderers on life licence were lower than for any other crime.

jobhunter7 · 20/03/2022 19:54

But I'd feel the same about this lady:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne_Perry

OP posts:
jobhunter7 · 20/03/2022 19:50

Knowing somebody that had done what Sophie Lancaster's murderers had done would probably make me not to be friends with them, myself...

Do murderers rehabilitate in prison?
OP posts:
Kanaloa · 20/03/2022 02:32

Absolutely impossible to know. It’s easy to sit and judge from your couch but unless you’re trained and educated and have met the people in question/been very involved in their case you simply can’t if they’ve been rehabilitated or not.

So much depends on circumstances as well - two people convicted of the same crime might have done it for very different reasons/have their own specific issues. One might be rehabilitated and the other might not.

OnlyJoking1 · 20/03/2022 02:29

Having worked with young people in the care system, many have been or still are in prison for murder.
Several of them who had a parent in prison for murder.
A lot of the young people were badly let down by the system.
They didn’t get the input they needed.
These are reasons not excuses.
Rehabilitation hasn’t worked for quite a few of them, because they don’t have positive attachments to their parents, never have had.
Prison offers them things they were unable to get.
A huge amount of prisoners have many unmet needs, lots of prisoners have undiagnosed MH and neuro diversity is very high in prisons.
Some people can’t be rehabilitated.

AlexaShutUp · 20/03/2022 01:28

I certainly believe that people can be rehabilitated, but I also know that not everyone will be. I do believe that it's what we should be aspiring for.

What happened to Sophie Lancaster was just horrific. I have also met her mum and was really moved by the work that she has done since Sophie's death to educate people about hate crime. However, I don't see any benefit in just punishing her killers without at least trying to rehabilitate them. That won't help anyone. Much better if they are truly able to get to a point where they deeply regret what they did, understand the impact that it has had and want to make some kind of contribution to society as a means of at least trying to atone for their crimes - even if we don't actually think that they could ever do enough because they can't undo what they have done. I don't see how leaving them to rot in jail helps anyone.

Dinoteeth · 20/03/2022 01:23

Totally depends on the person, and what drove them to commit murder in the first place.
But I'm surprised 'one punch' types are included, most of them probably get off with manslaughter / culpable homicide, and even at that some of them I have no doubt will come out every bit as nasty as they went in.

The sort to abduct, sexually abuse, then murder should never be released as they will do it again.

ISeeTheLight · 20/03/2022 01:19

According to a friend (social worker in a prison) - some murderers are true sociopaths, they can't be rehabilitated. For others it depends on the person.

Lockheart · 20/03/2022 01:10

I think most people can be rehabilitated. Not all, but most.

It's a convenient and comforting thought, that there must be something innately evil about all these people who have committed awful crimes, something that separates us from them. That they're different from us and that we can never be them. Our children could never turn into them.

But they're just people like you and me. Deeply flawed, unwell, traumatised, stupid, in desparate situations, and yes in some cases just plain nasty. But still people. And people can, in most cases I believe, be rehabilitated.

Finallydoneit20220 · 20/03/2022 00:06

I have some experience on this.
My fil got released from prison two years ago after spending 20 years for a double murder. In a nutshell no i don't think he can ever be fully rehabilitated Mainly because of his awful crimes that tore a family apart not to mention his wife and kids dealing with the fall out. Also after spending so long in prison his mind thinks differently.
Some crimes are unforgivable

MrsKT123 · 19/03/2022 23:39

Speaking specifically of this case, I firmly believe Ryan Herbert cannot be rehabilitated - when you read the details of of what this monster and his friends did, I really don't see how you can think he would ever be fit to be let out.

To look at what her boyfriend said really brings it home for me - “I have never seen it as a hate crime. It was always like, “Sophie Lancaster was killed because she was a goth”. No, she wasn’t. She was killed because some a**eholes killed her. Why can’t we ask what it is about them that made them want to murder someone? Not what it is about someone that made them be murdered.”

He is a murderer. This wasn't 'one punch' this was a horrific and sustained attack.

When the paramedics arrived she and her boyfriend had been beaten so badly they couldn't tell facially who was female. He didn't stand by and watch this happen. He was an active participant.

It's an utter disgrace that he is out to walk free just 15 years later.

He was messaging girls on fbook from prison and laughing at someone getting attacked with a pool cue: www.rossendalefreepress.co.uk/news/local-news/mums-fury-sophie-lancaster-murderers-1705599

It seems all of this 'turn around' only happened in the last 2 years as he's part of a new programme. Obviously people want to see success from this and seemingly he is a benefactor of this.

Read Sophie's Mum's very dignified response... she got a life sentence, he did not.

EmmaH2022 · 19/03/2022 23:09

@lunar1

I don't believe it matters if they can be rehabilitated. It isn't right to ask members of the public to take that risk.

The post is about someone convicted of murder and while I don't think they should be treated inhumanly, I don't think they should ever be in a position to risk the rehabilitation not having worked.

Exactly this

Some might be rehabilitated

Some might not commit crime for different reasons. They may or may not have a hard time restraining themselves.

I don't have data, but was talking to a friend about this today. He said there are many situations where people have been harmed because of early release of prisoners (he used to work in a prison). He was alarmed by this news.

No one should be at risk because a panel thinks a murderer has been rehabilitated. A full Life sentence is appropriate for murder.

Calandor · 19/03/2022 23:00

It depends I think.

If the murderer was: a gang member from youth, mentally ill, an addict, an abuse/SA victim, in a cult.

I think they can be rehabilitated.

If they did it because they enjoy killing I think it's unlikely.

Faevern · 19/03/2022 15:30

@MagicDragonsPuff victims of DV don’t kill for revenge and the anger from one punch is different from revenge anger. Have you worked with offenders for long?

HRTQueen · 19/03/2022 15:18

I work in forensic mh (ex offenders)

Some do some don’t depends on circumstances, back ground, support they get

Sexual offenders no they can’t be rehabilitated

Smidgy · 19/03/2022 15:18

I guess some murderers will be rehabilitated, or didn't really need rehabilitating as such due to the nature of their crime. Others will continue being a danger to society no matter how long they're in prison for or what is done to help them. It's too broad a question to answer because there are so many variables.

However, in this case, I think it is an absolute insult to Sophie Lancaster's memory for either of the people responsible for her death to get early release, or a short sentence. The word "feral" was used in the article and that is exactly what they were. Their crime was inexcusable. It was done for hateful, trivial reasons. It was done for the fun of it. So for one or both to be released whilst they are still so young with their whole lives ahead of them is an utter disgrace.