Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do murderers rehabilitate in prison?

61 replies

jobhunter7 · 19/03/2022 07:40

I've been reading about the awful Sophie Lancaster story and I was wondering whether people thought people who commit crimes like this do come out of prison rehabilitated by the system at all. As awful as crimes like this are, they were teenage boys. And sometimes people in prison haven't had the best start in life.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Namechangeforthis88 · 25/03/2022 07:40

@Whatinthelord and @MagicDragonsPuff there is no UK criminal justice system or prison system. Northern Ireland and Scotland have completely separate prison systems. I'm less knowledgeable about NI criminal justice, but certainly the Scottish legal system is also entirely separate. I have worked in both England Wales prison system and the Scottish prison system. I'll be honest E&W prison system has some advantages over Scottish such as excellent data on likelihood of reconviction for each person in the system, and the opportunity for suitably risk assessed and eligible prisoners to find employment towards the end of sentence. But the wider criminal justice system in Scotland has some advantages (in my opinion) such as a huge and very successful drive to reduce the number of young people in prisons/young offenders institutions. Down from hundreds to a handful.

Ringmaster27 · 24/03/2022 21:19

@Whatinthelord I had to watch a documentary on a women’s prison a while back as part of my study, and honestly some of their stories were heartbreaking. I know they’ve committed crimes and have to face the consequences of that, but some of the circumstances that led them to the offences were just horrendous Sad
One poor lass, in for drug offences, had been a heroin addict for a decade, in a DV relationship. She was getting out, and her abusive partner was supposed to be picking her up, he didn’t show. And she was in tears outside the prison saying she had nowhere to go so would probably end up back in a city centre squat with all her addict friends and the cycle would inevitably start again

Whatinthelord · 24/03/2022 20:47

I find the comments about sexual offenders not being able to rehabilitate interesting. I have always felt this was true and especially with child sex offences. Which is why I am always aghast at the sentences given for these offences being so minimal. Especially in compassion to something like fraud….I just don’t understand the sentencing.

Whatinthelord · 24/03/2022 20:45

@Ringmaster27 oh I agree. I work in a cat C and have seen the same faces come back, sometimes for mere months. It all feels ineffective and pointless. Prison is so expensive, I can’t believe better couldn’t be provided with that same money in the community.

There isn’t the appetite for it though and in general the public seem to want people to be punished above being rehabilitated. I reading about some of the rehabilitative support provided in other countries, but it’s expensive and I don’t see it happening anytime over here.

madelinemouse · 24/03/2022 16:15
  • I work in forensic mh (ex offenders)

Some do some don’t depends on circumstances, back ground, support they get

Sexual offenders no they can’t be rehabilitated*

I've worked with loads of murderers and completely agree with HRTQueen.

The mass murder psychopaths shown on TV dramas are incredibly rare. The reasons for committing murder are varied and likewise the likelihood and success of rehabilitation varies. I know many murderers who I believe do not pose a big risk to the public.

I actually live on the same street as a murderer and it doesn't overly worry me.

Sex offenders though. I do not believe they can ever be rehabilitated and it's just about managing them to ensure public safety. I would not be comfortable living so close to a known sex offender!

DressingPafe · 24/03/2022 15:55

He never committed another offence but lived in constant fear of being recalled to prison

Having worked in this field, this is the biggest motivator. Murderers are released, but on a life licence, and can be recalled at the drop of a hat. So are they rehabilitated or are they just sick of prison and know what they need to do and say to stay on the outside? I never came to a definite conclusion on that one because you can't read people's minds. Spend a bit of time in "the system" and you know all the right things to say. Is that the case here? Time will tell.

Ringmaster27 · 24/03/2022 15:45

@Whatinthelord it’s a vicious circle.
Prisons in this country are so full of people who commit minor offences over and over again, and so many of those people (particularly female prisoners) are the victims of poverty, addiction, domestic violence etc which inevitably leads to them committing crimes.
In a magical fantasy land where appropriate funding was pumped into addiction services, and towards breaking the cycle of poverty, the inmate population would drop drastically. So many offenders reoffend over and over again because life in prison is safer and gives them a bed and 3 meals a day rather than sleeping on the streets, wondering when they’ll next eat. It’s such a deep rooted problem Sad

Whatinthelord · 24/03/2022 15:37

I think some people can and some people can’t be rehabilitated and return safely to the community. I do not, however think that the criminal justice system in the UK is good at rehabilitation.

There are some people who make very bad choices, due to things like mental health needs or addiction, and who are otherwise good people. I think with their underlying issues addressed and support they can be safe in the community.

However there are other people who experience intrinsic desire to harm or abuse others and/or have no ability to empathise or feel emotions towards others. These people are think either cannot or will be very difficult to rehabilitate.

I think saying people who kill should never be released is unrealistic. The reality is that if we kept everyone who committed a sexual or violent crime locked up we’d pretty soon have no space….we already have an increasing and unmanageable prison population.

I personally would like people who can be safely managed in the community to be kept out of prison, but given intensive support to address needs and access housing/jobs etc. Then the minority of dangerous people who will never be rehabilitated can be kept out of society.

Ringmaster27 · 24/03/2022 15:36

I’ve started to look into this a bit with my university study, and there’s not really a definitive answer as there’s so many factors at play.
I’d say that someone like Levi Belfield for example, who has some pretty serious mental illness at play and comes from a violent background etc is not capable of rehabilitation because his brain is just wired that way. He doesn’t feel normal, human emotions like the rest of us, so committing a completely abhorrent crime/s is like water off a ducks back to him.
I’d like to think that offenders who commit crimes at a very young age, have no serious mental illnesses etc can be rehabilitated, but at this point, the system is so broken, I just don’t see it happening.
We hear about the prison environment all the time, and how dog eat dog it is - I think more often than not the “kill or be killed” mentality prevails, dashing any hope of rehabilitation. It’s a vicious circle.

bythebanksof · 24/03/2022 15:34

Working in the legal profession, I know there is a lot of analysis and research on various convicted offender programs and impact on recidivism rates. I'm not familiar with the current data, but when I attend courses presenting findings in the past it was typically smaller scale studies, non-consistent and hard to generalize. However, any potential reduction in future offenses is hugely welcomed.

My own experience is lots of repeat offenders, and poorly resources rehabilitation programs and lack of engagement from offenders. Offences are seldom once off; driving offenses, sex offenses, burglaries, there are whole series of these from individuals.

PeterandSandy · 24/03/2022 15:28

@jobhunter7

Knowing somebody that had done what Sophie Lancaster's murderers had done would probably make me not to be friends with them, myself...
are they out of prison now.

I remember one of their mums just laughed at what they have done.

Says alot, scummy family.

gogohm · 24/03/2022 15:25

Murderers like most groups are not a homogenous group, their crimes vary too. I believe people can change. I'm sure some can and some can't.

ChrissyPlummer · 24/03/2022 15:16

Of course @Namechangeforthis88 but this man murdered a young woman. For someone to point out “well, he hasn’t murdered any MORE young women” is just bloody stupid when the reason for that was him being locked up without access to young women.

PeterandSandy · 24/03/2022 15:07

I think some people are just so horrible that they are incapable. There are families where its normal in the family to be in prison and they grew up with it.

So depressing.

Namechangeforthis88 · 22/03/2022 07:22

You can definitely harm someone in prison!

ChrissyPlummer · 21/03/2022 22:57

Depends on the circumstances that led to the murder I guess. I remember reading about a murderer who was up for parole and his lawyer cited his ‘good progress’ and how he hadn’t harmed anyone else. Yeah….being locked up for the past 20-odd years might have something to do with that 🤔

x2boys · 21/03/2022 22:40

I don't think it raca one size fits all tby
Sophie's murder was particularly brutal and apparently they all tried blaming each other
However there was a stabbing around the corner from me a few months ago a fifteen year old boy was stabbed to death by a fellow fifteen year old as awful as it was ,it appeared it was all down to some stupid argument ,no doubt the perpetrators goaded the victim and they were armed and he wasn't ,but they were also young you would hope the perpetrators would mature .

Kanaloa · 21/03/2022 22:30

But I don’t think anyone really suggested Ian Brady was rehabilitated or even rehabilitatable though? He was never released from prison.

HRTQueen · 21/03/2022 21:35

I don’t believe people are evil I believe people can do the most cruel acts (some would describe what they do as evil)

Some choose to be terribly cruel. But to say they are evil takes away blame from the choices they have made

jobhunter7 · 21/03/2022 21:16

@Namechangeforthis88

I can somewhat understand heat of the moment violent acts... bit more difficult to understand Ian Brady...

OP posts:
Namechangeforthis88 · 20/03/2022 20:54

I worked in prison for many years, with many people serving life for murder. All individuals. Different challenges for every single one. None of them I would describe as evil. Going back a few years it cost roundabout £35,000 to keep someone in prison for a year, I'm sure more now. For the vast majority of people serving life for murder that i have worked with it would have been a total waste of their life and public money for them to spend the rest of their life in prison. It was part of my job to review their files and assess risk.

jobhunter7 · 20/03/2022 20:53

"Locking hundreds away for life is incredibly hard to manage and why wouldn’t you give some a second chance in life."

Well they may do it again for one...

I guess you have to look at the financial cost of prisons versus crime on society...

OP posts:
Iputthetrampintrampoline · 20/03/2022 20:39

My friend killed someone,spent 22 yrs inside released on a life licence. Is he sorry he killed who he killed? No. Has he been rehabilitated? From what to what? Was he ever a danger to anyone else? No he wasn;t. His reasons were personal and carried out for a specific reason aimed at a specific person. He came out very well educated and married and had children over time. I have never known him to be anything other than decent,kind,warm,funny and loving. Did I ever agree with what he did ?well no but I can understand it totally, With him there was nothing to rehabilitate he was the same before the event with us and after the event with us, no one else was ever in any danger from him, He might tell officials he was sorry but he wasn;t and I think any of us in his circumstances would feel the way he felt leading up to the event,the only difference is maybe I would want to do what he did but I don;t think when push came to shove I could do it. He did it,admitted it and accepted his sentance.

HRTQueen · 20/03/2022 20:38

People are difficult to understand

The more complex they are (and what we can’t relate to) the more difficult they are to understand and to manage in society

It’s always a gamble when someone who has a violent past is released. But locking hundreds away for life is incredibly hard to manage and why wouldn’t you give some a second chance in life

Some are truly sorry for what they have done some are truly sorry because of the impact on themselves that won’t shift but their behaviour might of. It’s so complex and there isn’t one rule

There is far more dangerous people in society than what we know of those known to probation and other services at least to some extent can be kept tabs on (but you will always only know a fraction of what they are up to in their lives)

CSIblonde · 20/03/2022 20:29

I feel some people who commit lesser crimes prob are able to rehabilitate . But when it comes to murder.... I'm not sure. You can get an education in UK prisons but there is apallingly little psych help. There was a big deal a few years back in the US re a bespoke prison rehab & psych programme for murderers. They found the reoffending rate actually went up. The offenders had simply learned to parrot what the organisers wanted to hear & go through the motions until they were released. The programne was quietly dropped. Having said that their prison system is far more brutal & normally, little or no effort is put into psych treatment, education or learning a skill/trade. Warders often stay in offices behind toughened glass & only venture into 'pods' or corridors if 24/7 surveillance footage shows its kicking off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread