Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Talking about abortion in a work 'womans day' call

292 replies

RedSquirrel111 · 18/03/2022 21:34

On international woman's day we had a teams call to discuss what it's like being a woman working in our industry. Was mainly women who took part, with a handful of men ready to impart their wisdom....
I mentioned how nearly 20 years ago I had an abortion, how it was viewed and discussed, and how I had to take unpaid leave for it. Its a very uncomfortable thing for me to talk about (due to the way people view abortion, not my experience). But I was determined to do so as think it's quite taboo. Lots of people support the right to chose theoretically, but I don't see many women discussing their experiences. I thought International womans day would be the perfect chance to do that.
I've had a 'kind chat to say it was inappropriate to bring up on the call. Reading between the lines I think it was because I said I never regretted my decision but I regretted the way my (past) employer treated me. I also, and will say I have no evidence for this, but get a feeling from reactions on the call that it was one of my male colleagues that raised it.
I get it's controversial, but it shouldn't be and that was my point in raising it. I also felt that given the context of the teams was 'women in my industry ' it wasn't out of context?
I'm torn between now feeling a bit ashamed and a bit fuck you....

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 19/03/2022 05:55

I think Followthelizards post upthread is testament as to why you were right to do so. Not wanting to be sanctioned, she went to work the day after being raped and again within 12 hours of an abortion as a result of that rape. You otoh did tell work and were sanctioned for it with harsh repercussions.

Women’s lives can only be made better if the stigma of abortion, miscarriage, periods, maternity, menopause, rape etc is addressed. Nothing should be off the cards if it happened at work or if there was a repercussion at work due to a women’s biology. Case in point, being sanctioned for having an abortion.

I would really like to know the aim of this call.

@FollowtheLizards I’m so sorry for your experience. Flowers

Monty27 · 19/03/2022 05:48

You're a brave woman OP. A hell of a lot braver than me.
But do you really think this would have helped the process? Shock tactics don't work in my experience.
Not the way you presented it.
I hope it hasn't caused any negativity on the purposes of the event.

UserError012345 · 19/03/2022 05:47

Oooh yeah that's gonna be a divider.

I understand where you are coming from and what you tried to achieve.

Perhaps of all the things they (whoever complained) thought the session was going to be about, they weren't prepared for this be brought up. Maybe whoever it was has struggled to conceive, miscarried, had their own experience that they didn't want to drag up from memory.

Unfortunately I think that there are things that although legal, we are just not quite there with acceptance.

It's extremely subjective and complicated and each circumstance will be complex. Your words were that you had no regrets but for many I imagine, it was not an easy decision.

I think you were not wrong to discuss but the angle you pitched it at was never going to be well received. It sounds like you were more bothered by having to unpaid time than you were about the procedure.

I don't think it will ever not be taboo. Any maybe that's ok too.

Migrainesbythedozen · 19/03/2022 05:36

@whumpthereitis

A lot of things can be traumatic. It doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be talked about openly.

‘Trauma’ is a very convenient way of shutting people up: ‘don’t talk about this because it will make x feel bad, and if you make x feel bad you’re a terrible person. So just don’t speak’.

No. Trauma is not the alter that all other considerations should be sacrificed upon.

Well said.
Mummyoflittledragon · 19/03/2022 05:29

The man, who was silent and criticised your junior colleague for her comments on a work event massively overstepped. His role was to listen and learn.

The upshot from the call is that two women were admonished for talking about their real issues. Was it a box ticking exercise or were you told there was an aim?

Would talking to HR and asking what is and isn’t appropriate something you would be willing to do?

whumpthereitis · 19/03/2022 05:27

A lot of things can be traumatic. It doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be talked about openly.

‘Trauma’ is a very convenient way of shutting people up: ‘don’t talk about this because it will make x feel bad, and if you make x feel bad you’re a terrible person. So just don’t speak’.

No. Trauma is not the alter that all other considerations should be sacrificed upon.

Migrainesbythedozen · 19/03/2022 05:25

@Aprilx You missed the first sentence of the OP: On international woman's day

It was clearly an IWD workplace event.

loislovesstewie · 19/03/2022 05:22

I think there are some things you don't bring up at work, like religion and having an abortion. It's one of those things where people have very strong feelings either way or the subject could cause distress. I once worked with a person who got religion late in life, it was evangelical, and they decided we had to be converted. Now it's OK to be religious BUT not to bring the evangelizing to work. Eventually he was told to stop. If some have strong feelings about a subject, either way, I think it's best to leave it at home. You don't know if anything traumatic had happened to the others in your group, so best not to.

Aprilx · 19/03/2022 05:15

[quote Migrainesbythedozen]**@BottleBrushTree* @Aprilx It was an International Women's Day* event. And abortion rights will always be centre stage on IWD, especially how abortion affects women in the workplace. It is a vital topic and needs to be spoken about more![/quote]
Per OP, it was a “call to discuss what it is like to be a woman in our industry”.

It was not a call about anything to do with women.

twinsetandpearl · 19/03/2022 05:07

Sorry but I don't agree

I don't think it's appropriate to have raised it at all - sounds like the issue the OP had was not so much the abortion and being a woman in her industry but because she had to take unpaid leave it for it...

Migrainesbythedozen · 19/03/2022 04:59

@BottleBrushTree @Aprilx It was an International Women's Day event. And abortion rights will always be centre stage on IWD, especially how abortion affects women in the workplace. It is a vital topic and needs to be spoken about more!

whumpthereitis · 19/03/2022 04:58

It was a chat in regards to women's issues in the workplace. Subjects such as maternity, pregnancy, and abortion are absolutely relevant. The fact that they are potentially triggering does not mean they shouldn’t be discussed. The triggered should remove themselves, not demand the silence of others.

Abortion is one of the most common medical procedures. Statistically 1 in 3 (or it may be 1 in 4) women will have one. It’s also one of the leading causes of injury and death worldwide for women in countries where it’s illegal. Women die everyday because they can’t access safe abortion. It’s an issue that should be fucking normalized and talked about. It should not be treated as a shameful, dirty secret, or with the attitude of ‘oh, you’re allowed one, but keep it to yourself if you don’t have the decency to feel bad about it!’. Those are the narratives that actively hurt women.

So bravo, OP, and thank you.

Superhanz · 19/03/2022 04:55

You were brave to bring it up but I agree with some other posters that it was possibly triggering. Fertility is a very emotive subject for some women.

Aprilx · 19/03/2022 04:47

@VashtaNerada

Your manager is way out of line. Your comments sound completely appropriate for a discussion about women’s experiences in the workplace. It’s not like you blurted it out in the middle of a budget meeting FFS!
I can’t agree, I think it was not the time. Abortion has nothing to do with experiences in the workplace. I would expect a discussion on women’s’ experiences in the workplace to be about things like; bullying, sexism, promotion, networking, sponsorship, “old boys clubs”, equal pay. I would probably hang up / walk out if the conversation turned to abortion, this would be out of disappointment at the workplace discussion being hijacked for something else entirely.
BottleBrushTree · 19/03/2022 04:46

Sorry OP but I would find it a really odd thing to bring up in a work context. I can’t see how it’s relevant in most workplaces and I don’t actually want to hear about my work colleagues medical histories either. Plus it’s triggering for some people, so inappropriate to have discussed it especially without warning other participants. It’s really not at all the same as clothing options and how parenting impacts on your everyday work life.

VashtaNerada · 19/03/2022 04:34

Your manager is way out of line. Your comments sound completely appropriate for a discussion about women’s experiences in the workplace. It’s not like you blurted it out in the middle of a budget meeting FFS!

MalFunkshun · 19/03/2022 03:39

@whumpthereitis

For all the talk of de-stigmatising abortion, miscarriage etc, it seems as soon as someone tries to talk openly about their experiences, they’re told to shut up.

I do think in such a forum, that surely does encourage discussion about female issues, the hosts should probably anticipate sensitive issues arising, and let people know that if they’re uncomfortable they can step away.

I don’t think it’s reasonable that no one should dare mention something that’s potentially sensitive. Can it be triggering? Yes. Should those at risk of being triggered demand that other people can’t speak on their experiences? Well, no. As harsh as it sounds, no one has the right to not be triggered. You have the right to step away from a conversation, but you don’t have the right to dictate that the conversation shouldn’t be had at all.

Also, for all talk of triggering, what about those that would genuinely benefit from hearing what other women have gone through? That would appreciate hearing someone else speak freely? Are they not to be considered?

I agree with this. FWIW I think you were brave @OP and I am always pro women sharing their experiences, however uncomfortable they may be to hear. It’s precisely by creating that discomfort that change comes about.

The real issue though is that the hosts didn’t properly consider the purpose of this session or how to manage the discussion. If they felt containment was necessary, that was on them to do the proper planning and prep and communicate this clearly. Having a ‘kind chat’ puts the onus back on you to have to do this thinking for them - oh the irony, on IWD, that it’s a woman who has to contain herself…

I would be firmly putting this back on them. You’re sorry it was felt to be uncomfortable - what exactly about this do they feel was inappropriate and what will they do differently next time to ensure participants are aware of the parameters of such a session?

Migrainesbythedozen · 19/03/2022 03:34

@Midlifemusings

I am not interested in hearing about your abortion or your miscarriage or the details of the birth of your child or any medical procedure you had on a work call. Nor do I want to hear about your wedding or your hen party etc. People take unpaid leave for a myriad of reasons and there is no duty to explain why or what procedure you had done that day. You can get documentation without disclosure. I always tell my employees that I don't want to know why they are off, just tell me you are unwell or get documentation that verifies you were unwell (depending on length of time off).
@Midlifemusings This was an International Womens Day event. One would expect abortion rights to be discussed on International Womens Day.
Midlifemusings · 19/03/2022 03:32

I am not interested in hearing about your abortion or your miscarriage or the details of the birth of your child or any medical procedure you had on a work call. Nor do I want to hear about your wedding or your hen party etc. People take unpaid leave for a myriad of reasons and there is no duty to explain why or what procedure you had done that day. You can get documentation without disclosure. I always tell my employees that I don't want to know why they are off, just tell me you are unwell or get documentation that verifies you were unwell (depending on length of time off).

TedMullins · 19/03/2022 02:52

I’m completely with you OP. I’ve also had one and didn’t find it remotely traumatic (being pregnant was more traumatising) I don’t regret it and it was not a big deal to me. it was related to your work due to the way you were treated. I talk freely about my abortion and I’m not going to stop doing that just because some people feel differently. My feelings about it are just as valid as those who did find it traumatic.

timeisnotaline · 19/03/2022 02:28

I don’t know how I feel about the importance of being able to discuss abortions in a workplace when from an employer perspective it should be treated as the same as any other medical procedure, some of which are male specific and I would simply say medical procedure at work for a large range of operations.

But, I would have said to my manager can I check this complaint comes from a woman? Because if men choose to attend women’s events it should be to support and learn, if they attend and then make complaints about the content they should be told that complaining is inappropriate, no one made then go and be exposed to these women talking about women things.

Migrainesbythedozen · 19/03/2022 02:12

@VeganFuture

Migrainesbythedozen

I disagree. This was a call open to lots of people where there may have been many people that didn’t want to hear about abortion for a variety of reasons. And they shouldn’t have to.

There’s is no reason at all that abortion has to be something I listen about if I don’t want to. That’s my choice. HR and managers of people may need to deal with this at times if an employee shares that information, and it should be dealt with professionally regardless of personal experiences or beliefs, but if it’s not part of your job to deal with staff issues, then you shouldn’t have to deal with it if you’re not comfortable for any reason.

I wouldn’t say anything negative to a woman who has an abortion, it’s not my business. I believe in the right to choose. But that’s where it ends for me. I don’t have a job that deals with employment law or rights or managing people do I don’t need to talk about it more. I should be able to go to work and not have to listen to it.

But abortion rights is an integral PART of International Women's Day, and for women in the workforce.

I am trying to understand; why is abortion not ok to discuss but parental leave is? Or any other women's issue? It was IWD. And therefore integral to the entire day.

VeganFuture · 19/03/2022 02:00

Migrainesbythedozen

I disagree. This was a call open to lots of people where there may have been many people that didn’t want to hear about abortion for a variety of reasons. And they shouldn’t have to.

There’s is no reason at all that abortion has to be something I listen about if I don’t want to. That’s my choice. HR and managers of people may need to deal with this at times if an employee shares that information, and it should be dealt with professionally regardless of personal experiences or beliefs, but if it’s not part of your job to deal with staff issues, then you shouldn’t have to deal with it if you’re not comfortable for any reason.

I wouldn’t say anything negative to a woman who has an abortion, it’s not my business. I believe in the right to choose. But that’s where it ends for me. I don’t have a job that deals with employment law or rights or managing people do I don’t need to talk about it more. I should be able to go to work and not have to listen to it.

Migrainesbythedozen · 19/03/2022 01:56

@Justilou1

I think you should ask whether the person who complained about you sharing your experience was male or female…. Also, how is sharing a female-only experience AND having it invalidated TWICE not a WWD topic? Fuuuuck
Exactly!
Justilou1 · 19/03/2022 01:54

I think you should ask whether the person who complained about you sharing your experience was male or female…. Also, how is sharing a female-only experience AND having it invalidated TWICE not a WWD topic? Fuuuuck