Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Talking about abortion in a work 'womans day' call

292 replies

RedSquirrel111 · 18/03/2022 21:34

On international woman's day we had a teams call to discuss what it's like being a woman working in our industry. Was mainly women who took part, with a handful of men ready to impart their wisdom....
I mentioned how nearly 20 years ago I had an abortion, how it was viewed and discussed, and how I had to take unpaid leave for it. Its a very uncomfortable thing for me to talk about (due to the way people view abortion, not my experience). But I was determined to do so as think it's quite taboo. Lots of people support the right to chose theoretically, but I don't see many women discussing their experiences. I thought International womans day would be the perfect chance to do that.
I've had a 'kind chat to say it was inappropriate to bring up on the call. Reading between the lines I think it was because I said I never regretted my decision but I regretted the way my (past) employer treated me. I also, and will say I have no evidence for this, but get a feeling from reactions on the call that it was one of my male colleagues that raised it.
I get it's controversial, but it shouldn't be and that was my point in raising it. I also felt that given the context of the teams was 'women in my industry ' it wasn't out of context?
I'm torn between now feeling a bit ashamed and a bit fuck you....

OP posts:
RoastedFerret · 19/03/2022 10:31

It’s not about ethics. Comparing a termination to the loss of a much wanted child is offensive and frankly if you can’t see that there’s no hope for you.

I really hate this hierarchy of worthiness that people put in place. Not all miscarriages are of much wanted children either. I had a miscarriage when I was 19, I was so bloody relieved. A decade later I had an abortion because my womb was septic and I would have died if I didn't. Nothing is cut and dry, you can't make value judgements and the OP wasn't asking people to, she was simply discussing her experience in the workplace. Her reasons for the abortion are neither here nor there.

eastegg · 19/03/2022 10:31

@lottiegarbanzo

I think we're talking at cross purposes Blossomtoes.

This is a thread about employment issues, including the way that women's reproductive health experiences have impacted upon their employment.

In that context could you tell me, on what grounds OP's employer ought to discriminate between a woman discussing her discriminatory experience when she needed time off for a termination, versus a colleague discussing their discriminatory experience when they needed time off to deal with miscarriage?

As we've heard on the thread, people can be upset by being part of a discussion that touches upon any or all of miscarriage, stillbirth, abortion and pregnancy itself, for those struggling with infertility. So there isn't a distinction to be made in terms of 'topics that might upset people'.

I cannot perceive a distinction, other than something based on a belief that only 'good girl' topics may be discussed - a moral position.

Well said lottie. People are losing sight of the point here.
PegasusReturns · 19/03/2022 10:29

And it’s really not about gaining “sympathy” it’s about ensuring you are not discriminated against.

PegasusReturns · 19/03/2022 10:27

@loislovesstewie if you’d lost opportunities (bonus, promotion, projects) do you think you might feel differently about the importance of discussing reproduction with neodarwinista as it relates specifically to women?

Bizawit · 19/03/2022 10:27

@loislovesstewie

I shall explain my comment: I would not want to listen to others and their experiences as I would feel obliged/forced to comment. I would wish to absent myself. If I was able to do so without having to say why that would be the better option. In other words I would not want to talk about my miscarriages. When I did miscarry I had no need to discuss it, my GP signed me off and there were no discussions. My manager understood. No need for explanations or sympathy from colleagues. It was between me and HR.
Sorry to sound harsh but that is on you. You can’t expect other women to stay silent about issues that affect them because you don’t want to hear about it/ would feel “obliged to comment” and wouldn’t like that. I say this as someone who has ptsd from miscarriage. You are fortunate that you suffered no discrimination as a result of needing time off for your miscarriages, presumably this is because as a society we have been able to have conversations about these things and protect women’s rights on such matters. Unfortunately the same cannot be said for OP’s experience of her abortion. As a result she considered it relevant to share during a discussion about women’s experiences at work.
loislovesstewie · 19/03/2022 10:16

I shall explain my comment: I would not want to listen to others and their experiences as I would feel obliged/forced to comment. I would wish to absent myself. If I was able to do so without having to say why that would be the better option. In other words I would not want to talk about my miscarriages. When I did miscarry I had no need to discuss it, my GP signed me off and there were no discussions. My manager understood. No need for explanations or sympathy from colleagues. It was between me and HR.

dfendyr · 19/03/2022 10:14

@Blossomtoes
It’s not about ethics. Comparing a termination to the loss of a much wanted child is offensive and frankly if you can’t see that there’s no hope for you

Genuinely not being snarky, but what if the termination was due to medical issues and the only option? It feels like the op is being judged for a 'life style' choice, we have no idea why the op terminated her pregnancy, and at what stage.

An abortion can be for a much wanted child and just as heartbreaking.

Bizawit · 19/03/2022 10:13

@Blossomtoes what are you on about? Your comment and taking of offence is ridiculous. Nobody is saying that having an abortion is the same as losing a much wanted child. People are saying that both are relevant in a discussion about women’s experiences in the workplace. Because they are both experiences that uniquely impact on women and can affect what happens to women at work (eg need for time off etc).

Bizawit · 19/03/2022 10:04

@loislovesstewie

BTW I have had 3 miscarriages. I didn't want to talk about them at work either. Neither should I feel that I had to.
What a bizarre comment Confused nobody said you should have to talk your miscarriages at work. But if you had been discriminated against for taking time off for a medical management of miscarriage and you wanted to raise that as an issue of concern during a discussion about discrimination again women in the workplace , then you absolutely should be allowed to do so without being shamed/ silenced.
lottiegarbanzo · 19/03/2022 10:03

I think we're talking at cross purposes Blossomtoes.

This is a thread about employment issues, including the way that women's reproductive health experiences have impacted upon their employment.

In that context could you tell me, on what grounds OP's employer ought to discriminate between a woman discussing her discriminatory experience when she needed time off for a termination, versus a colleague discussing their discriminatory experience when they needed time off to deal with miscarriage?

As we've heard on the thread, people can be upset by being part of a discussion that touches upon any or all of miscarriage, stillbirth, abortion and pregnancy itself, for those struggling with infertility. So there isn't a distinction to be made in terms of 'topics that might upset people'.

I cannot perceive a distinction, other than something based on a belief that only 'good girl' topics may be discussed - a moral position.

Bizawit · 19/03/2022 09:58

@PegasusReturns

Are we supposed yo talk about nice fluffy things on IWD and not the physical realities of being a woman? I’d be pretty dismayed by their reaction here

Quite we should all follow the lead of a company I’ve worked for who gave out pink cupcakes whilst failing to address any of the misogynistic attitudes and sex discrimination Hmm

😂
WeDontShutUpAboutBruno · 19/03/2022 09:48

It’s not about ethics. Comparing a termination to the loss of a much wanted childisoffensive and frankly if you can’t see that there’s no hope for you.

Its not offensive at all.

There are lots of complex feelings surrounding abortion for some women. Look at the many varied reasons why women have them and you may gain some understanding as to why some women do grieve after having an abortion. Quite frankly, if you can't understand that someone who has been raped, or someone who's partner has just died, or someone homeless, or with severe mental health issues, or someone underage or with complicated health problems or a whole mirade of other reasons may make a choice in the best interest of themselves and the potential baby, but still feel upset, then there's no hope for you.

Let's not gatekeep grief and make one 'worthy' while the other has to be kept quiet for fear of offending someone else.

MichelleScarn · 19/03/2022 09:47

@NameGoesHere

These sort of events are tokenistic and employers just want to check a box, not expect anyone to actually delve into the issue. I wouldn’t have shared something like that but good for you in embracing the objective, shame the response wasn’t good.
Apologies for just quoting you here but there's been several posts pointing out how much of a shame it is or disappointing of the lack of a good/positive/well done to you reponse.

Are people saying this in relation to the expectation of a positive good response to the act of having an abortion or wanting to make other people talk about it?

Blossomtoes · 19/03/2022 09:47

Where do you think it's being made?

It’s been made several times on this thread. You might try reading it, it’s not a particularly long one. You, yourself, said it wasn’t offensive.

lottiegarbanzo · 19/03/2022 09:44

That comparison isn't being made though. That's my point. Where do you think it's being made?

Not in OP's workplace discussion about workplaces issues, the subject of this thread. So why try to shoehorn it in? More pertinently, what grounds would her employer have for trying to shoehorn it in?

Blossomtoes · 19/03/2022 09:39

@lottiegarbanzo

Completely inappropriate. And not At all comparable to miscarriage or stillbirth. In fact to suggest that it is is incredibly offensive.

No it's not. Rather, if you choose to be offended that's your choice. This wasn't a discussion about ethics. No-one was seeking sympathy for their reproductive experience per se. This was a discussion about the workplace impacts of women experiencing things that women experience in their working lives.

It’s not about ethics. Comparing a termination to the loss of a much wanted child is offensive and frankly if you can’t see that there’s no hope for you.
loislovesstewie · 19/03/2022 09:31

I agree that this was poor planning. Telling attendees in advance what would be discussed, giving individuals an opt-out would have been fine. What isn't fine is the option to attend and then be told the content and then feel 'do I stay and be upset? Or go and have people wonder why? ' is not acceptable.
Neither would I have wanted to give my reasons for non-attendance as that would be too much in some circumstances.

NameGoesHere · 19/03/2022 09:28

These sort of events are tokenistic and employers just want to check a box, not expect anyone to actually delve into the issue. I wouldn’t have shared something like that but good for you in embracing the objective, shame the response wasn’t good.

catgirl1976 · 19/03/2022 09:20

What did they want you talk about? How much you love kittens and embroidery and how best to fit those in around the working day and your beauty regieme?

You raised an issue that affects women in your industry in terms of work which wa d the point of the discussion

lottiegarbanzo · 19/03/2022 09:13

Completely inappropriate. And not At all comparable to miscarriage or stillbirth. In fact to suggest that it is is incredibly offensive.

No it's not. Rather, if you choose to be offended that's your choice. This wasn't a discussion about ethics. No-one was seeking sympathy for their reproductive experience per se. This was a discussion about the workplace impacts of women experiencing things that women experience in their working lives.

twinsetandpearl · 19/03/2022 09:09

It's not triggering per se it's just largely irrelevant in the context of IWD - the OP could presumably have rung in sick on the day of procedure or taken a days annual leave - what was the employer at the times actual sick leave policy?? If no one got sick leave male or female for anything then how was she disadvantaged?
Instead she made the call with her colleagues about her.

There are many more challenges that women face in the workplace than having a day off for an elective procedure like an abortion - many are made on social grounds (TFMR aside) - clearly not in the same way a cosmetic procedure is - but still - elective. Yes a man doesn't have to go through one physically but nothing we can do about that it's a fact of evolution?

(FWIW I don't believe you should get special leave for an abortion in the same way that someone might if they have a TFMR, miscarriage or stillbirth)

lottiegarbanzo · 19/03/2022 09:06

Incidentally, what are the topics that can safely and happily be discussed in such a session, if all insensitivity is to be avoided?

I'm not sure I can think of any.

Nothing about sexual assault, or aggression, that's for sure. I guess we have to write off the whole #metoo movement as 'triggering'. Given that provoking responses from others who've been similarly affected is its entire point.

NoFriendsNoEnemies · 19/03/2022 09:02

Completely inappropriate. And not At all comparable to miscarriage or stillbirth. In fact to suggest that it is is incredibly offensive.

Abortion is a choice. Miscarriage is not.

The only exception would be tfmr.

lottiegarbanzo · 19/03/2022 08:57

You’ve taken it out of context. What I actually said - or meant to - was that these things shouldn’t be sprung on women in a public forum because you have no idea how the audience will be affected.

This goes straight back to the event's poor planning. This was a discussion on IWD about what it's like to be a woman in this industry. OF COURSE it was going to include mention of unpleasant experiences, including gynaecological ones; how they were responded to and the impact they had at work.

Anyone who felt themselves likely to be upset by such discussions should have been free to opt out of the call. Coerced participation in sensitive discussions is not ok.

Or the discussion could have been structured better, with topics identified beforehand and separate round-tables set up on a few different topics. So a 'pregnancy and reproductive issues' topic could have been avoided in favour of a 'carers' or 'promotion and progression' topic. Though, it's hard to keep pregnancy and childcare out of any topic, as those experiences are so central to so many women's lives.

What did the employer intend to do with the outputs? What's their next step? What is going to change as a result? Asking people to expose their vulnerabilities (whether as speakers or listeners) for a tick-box exercise is not ok at all.

Phineyj · 19/03/2022 08:53

This is on the call host/employer who didn't think carefully enough (at all?) about how to contain and manage any 'difficult' topics that were bound to arise.

I work in a school and we are constantly encouraged to contribute personal experiences...and at least one colleague has been told her personal experience was not the kind required. FFS, don't ask then.

You did nothing wrong.