Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Talking about abortion in a work 'womans day' call

292 replies

RedSquirrel111 · 18/03/2022 21:34

On international woman's day we had a teams call to discuss what it's like being a woman working in our industry. Was mainly women who took part, with a handful of men ready to impart their wisdom....
I mentioned how nearly 20 years ago I had an abortion, how it was viewed and discussed, and how I had to take unpaid leave for it. Its a very uncomfortable thing for me to talk about (due to the way people view abortion, not my experience). But I was determined to do so as think it's quite taboo. Lots of people support the right to chose theoretically, but I don't see many women discussing their experiences. I thought International womans day would be the perfect chance to do that.
I've had a 'kind chat to say it was inappropriate to bring up on the call. Reading between the lines I think it was because I said I never regretted my decision but I regretted the way my (past) employer treated me. I also, and will say I have no evidence for this, but get a feeling from reactions on the call that it was one of my male colleagues that raised it.
I get it's controversial, but it shouldn't be and that was my point in raising it. I also felt that given the context of the teams was 'women in my industry ' it wasn't out of context?
I'm torn between now feeling a bit ashamed and a bit fuck you....

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Justilou1 · 21/03/2022 09:46

Our WWD crap a couple of years ago was entirely owned by one bloke whose feelings were hurt when he kept getting told off for talking over the top of everyone so he could share HIS experiences. He kept telling us he was an empath too. 🤮🤢🤮

HailAdrian · 21/03/2022 09:27

Ooh how naughty of you to bring up something that literally only women can experience and also happens to be a divisive issue. Next time, talk about housework or shopping or something.

ATeddybearshortofaPicnic · 21/03/2022 08:09

I think it would be fair to give feedback to your manager that if they’re going to organize this type of discussion where employees are encouraged to discuss things that are often considered delicate subjects (maternity leave, maternity discrimination, sex based discrimination in the work place, etc) but some subjects are too taboo for the discussion, then that needs to be made crystal clear beforehand. It’s not fair to expect employees to know where the company’s imaginary line is.
Your point about fair leave for a common medical procedure that affects only women is extremely relevant to the topic the meeting was about OP. From an employer’s point of view, an abortion a women chooses because she does not wish to continue a pregnancy is no different to a termination for medical reasons or a miscarriage. All three scenarios require some time off work, with some flexibility in how much time might be needed, some discretion and some compassion.

whumpthereitis · 21/03/2022 03:19

@whumpthereitis

www.repository.law.indiana.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1088&context=ijgls

This is a decent insight as to the mafia state that was Russia in the immediate post Soviet era.

Some more:
www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/inatl/daily/sept99/yeltsin8.htm

demokratizatsiya.pub/archives/02-3_Waller.PDF

“Despite issuing numerous decrees, President Boris Yeltsin has not been part of the solution, but part of the problem. The West's reluctance to criticize his government or to condition assistance and cooperation seem to have encouraged criminal elements in the Russian leader's personal inner circle. Western fears of "undermining Yeltsin" by objecting to the presence of such people in power are having the opposite intended effect by playing into the hands of the extreme ultranationalists and Communists. Though never implicated personally in corrupt activity, the Russian leader appears to have protected criminal elements in the highest echelons of government.”

Sorry, wrong thread!
whumpthereitis · 21/03/2022 03:19

www.repository.law.indiana.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1088&context=ijgls

This is a decent insight as to the mafia state that was Russia in the immediate post Soviet era.

Some more:
www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/inatl/daily/sept99/yeltsin8.htm

demokratizatsiya.pub/archives/02-3_Waller.PDF

“Despite issuing numerous decrees, President Boris Yeltsin has not been part of the solution, but part of the problem. The West's reluctance to criticize his government or to condition assistance and cooperation seem to have encouraged criminal elements in the Russian leader's personal inner circle. Western fears of "undermining Yeltsin" by objecting to the presence of such people in power are having the opposite intended effect by playing into the hands of the extreme ultranationalists and Communists. Though never implicated personally in corrupt activity, the Russian leader appears to have protected criminal elements in the highest echelons of government.”

timeisnotaline · 20/03/2022 19:07

@BobMortimersPetOwl

Pregnancy and miscarriage don't evoke strong emotions?! Are you serious?

Do you think they're on the same level as abortion, something which people hold very strong opinions about, often linked to their faith or moral code?

Don't be so bloody obtuse.

However strongly you feel about abortion, I don’t see how someone else deciding to terminate a child could ever be at the same emotional level as someone’s own experience of late miscarriage and losing their own much wanted child. I guess that’s me being bloody obtuse.
whumpthereitis · 20/03/2022 16:46

But it’s still not something I’m overly comfortable with and not something I should have to talk about with a random person.

No one is saying you should have to. People should be free to opt out if they need to, but what they shouldn’t do is make their comfort someone else’s problem. Your comfort is yours to manage, OP or anyone else shouldn’t be expected to shut up because you may not like what she has to say.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/03/2022 16:37

The discussion was entirely appropriate for a group of women discussing issues which affect them at work. Not every woman will want to discuss miscarriage, loss of a child, caring for elderly or ill dependents, fertility treatment, abortion, caring for disabled child. They are still all issues which disproportionately affect women and their opportunities at work and therefore relevant and worth discussing by those women who want to engage.

Yes, precisely.

C8H10N4O2 · 20/03/2022 16:35

And it needs to be optional with no comeback for those that don’t attend.

It wasn't mandatory, that is pretty clear from the OP's post.

The discussion was entirely appropriate for a group of women discussing issues which affect them at work. Not every woman will want to discuss miscarriage, loss of a child, caring for elderly or ill dependents, fertility treatment, abortion, caring for disabled child. They are still all issues which disproportionately affect women and their opportunities at work and therefore relevant and worth discussing by those women who want to engage.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/03/2022 16:18

Not a fucking chance. I didn’t attend, know that my absence was noted and expect to be spoken about it in my 1:1 with my manager next week. I just want to get on with my job.

I sympathise.

Bizawit · 20/03/2022 16:16

@VeganFuture

I think this phraseology says it all about where you are coming from. Your own personal opinions about “morality” are irrelevant. It’s a legal medical procedure and women are entitled not to have it affect their employment rights. OP experienced discrimination and was very correct in sharing that during a work meeting about women’s equality at work.

I can’t be bothered to go back and check but I’m pretty sure I’ve said I believe in a woman’s right to choose, for me there’s no other option. If a woman does not want to have a baby then it is not in the woman or child’s interest to go ahead with the pregnancy. If my daughter or good friend wanted an abortion I would do whatever I could to help and support. But it’s still not something I’m overly comfortable with and not something I should have to talk about with a random person.

Of course women shouldn’t be discriminated against because of it and if they think that’s an issue at their place of work, they should talk to HR. A chat in a box ticking meeting with people who do not have the power to change anything, is pointless.

In that case I apologise for misunderstanding your meaning and intention x
VeganFuture · 20/03/2022 15:50

No need to bring your transphobia into this thread

Oh dear god. It’s not transphobic to say that women are women and men are men. You can’t change sex and I don’t believe in gender. Precisely why I don’t want to attend these calls, I just want to do my job.

Anyway, I don’t want to derail the thread and I currently feel quite ill as I tested positive for covid yesterday so I won’t be commenting further.

VeganFuture · 20/03/2022 15:46

I think this phraseology says it all about where you are coming from. Your own personal opinions about “morality” are irrelevant. It’s a legal medical procedure and women are entitled not to have it affect their employment rights. OP experienced discrimination and was very correct in sharing that during a work meeting about women’s equality at work.

I can’t be bothered to go back and check but I’m pretty sure I’ve said I believe in a woman’s right to choose, for me there’s no other option. If a woman does not want to have a baby then it is not in the woman or child’s interest to go ahead with the pregnancy. If my daughter or good friend wanted an abortion I would do whatever I could to help and support. But it’s still not something I’m overly comfortable with and not something I should have to talk about with a random person.

Of course women shouldn’t be discriminated against because of it and if they think that’s an issue at their place of work, they should talk to HR. A chat in a box ticking meeting with people who do not have the power to change anything, is pointless.

Bizawit · 20/03/2022 15:32

@VeganFuture

Ereshkigalangcleg

There’s usually an expectation to attend though. We had an LGBT one at work recently. LGB, all good, but I’m not going to sit and listen to why we have to all accept that men can be women or women can be men and we all need to be kind. Not a fucking chance. I didn’t attend, know that my absence was noted and expect to be spoken about it in my 1:1 with my manager next week. I just want to get on with my job.

No need to bring your transphobia into this thread 😂
Bizawit · 20/03/2022 15:30

So sharing her experience of aborting a child
@VeganFuture
I think this phraseology says it all about where you are coming from. Your own personal opinions about “morality” are irrelevant. It’s a legal medical procedure and women are entitled not to have it affect their employment rights. OP experienced discrimination and was very correct in sharing that during a work meeting about women’s equality at work.

VeganFuture · 20/03/2022 15:26

Ereshkigalangcleg

There’s usually an expectation to attend though. We had an LGBT one at work recently. LGB, all good, but I’m not going to sit and listen to why we have to all accept that men can be women or women can be men and we all need to be kind. Not a fucking chance. I didn’t attend, know that my absence was noted and expect to be spoken about it in my 1:1 with my manager next week. I just want to get on with my job.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/03/2022 15:15

And it needs to be optional with no comeback for those that don’t attend.

Absolutely.

VeganFuture · 20/03/2022 15:05

This. The whole thing needed to be framed as "women will be discussing their experiences of being a woman in the workplace and discrimination they have faced. This may include themes that others may find upsetting such as sexual harassment, sexual assault, pregnancy, menstruation, menopause, miscarriage and abortion."

And it needs to be optional with no comeback for those that don’t attend. These are the issues I talk about with my partner, close friends, medical staff and HR if it affected work. Some people may want to talk about this with people they’re not close to, but it’s not for everyone. In the case of abortion, although it’s legal, that doesn’t mean everyone thinks it morally acceptable.

whumpthereitis · 20/03/2022 15:02

So sharing her experience of aborting a child has achieved nothing.

There were a significant amount of women on that call. OP speaking openly about her experience of abortion may very well have helped someone that have been, or are going through the same thing. Statistically, some absolutely have. She’s challenged the common narrative about abortion and demonstrated that it’s not shameful, it’s a common female experience, and it doesn’t have to be taboo. I’d call that an achievement. It’s individuals that change a culture.

You can be as upset as you like, frankly. That doesn’t obligate women to shut up. I say women because I’ve never heard it pressed into men that they need to shut up to spare the feelings of others. No, the emphasis is always on women to be fucking nice.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/03/2022 14:25

So a man tells you that someone else (who you think is male) tells you not to talk about an issue which affects many women on a call meant to centre women's issues and how they impact work?

Ask him back, if he thinks its appropriate for men to define what women are allowed to discuss in a forum set up supposedly to discuss challenges which women face by virtue of their sex.

Men used to say this about menopause discussions - currently they are falling over themselves to "facillitate" it for diversity points.

This. The whole thing needed to be framed as "women will be discussing their experiences of being a woman in the workplace and discrimination they have faced. This may include themes that others may find upsetting such as sexual harassment, sexual assault, pregnancy, menstruation, menopause, miscarriage and abortion."

BobMortimersPetOwl · 20/03/2022 14:05

Pregnancy and miscarriage don't evoke strong emotions?! Are you serious?

Do you think they're on the same level as abortion, something which people hold very strong opinions about, often linked to their faith or moral code?

Don't be so bloody obtuse.

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2022 13:57

why is it different to this newer poster than had a similar experience?

Because @Justilou1 did exactly the right thing and her manager behaved like a cunt.

Throckmorton · 20/03/2022 13:45

So people should talk about important issues just because someone might be upset?!

VeganFuture · 20/03/2022 12:54

@lottiegarbanzo

But how did OP see it helping her, even if no one complained? I was talking about this thread earlier with female friends and only 1 of 4 said that they wouldn’t have minded listening.

OP recognised that this issue, like most important things in life, was not all about her.

The discussion was about women's experiences working in this industry. The subject was this industry and how it is for women to work within. The only meaningful purpose of such a discussion is for the people running it to gather the results, reflect and consider whether useful changes could be made.

As I said here yesterday, the particular issue raised by OP's experience is the wide-ranging individual discretion granted to managers at that time. In this case the use of that discretion to discriminate against a woman. So the pertinent questions arising are:

  1. Do managers still have wide-ranging individual discretion over matters affecting their staff's employment, attainment and progression opportunities?

  2. Do managers have the knowledge and skills necessary to use that discretion appropriately? Is there a training need? Are managers passing things on to HR when they should?

  3. More broadly, Is there a need to review the scope of individual managerial discretion, discover the true current position (on the sorts of decisions managers can take and what their impacts could be, rather than a review of individual cases), which might not match what senior managers imagine it to be, if policies are not watertight or if there's a power imbalance between some managers and HR colleagues. Are some managers still winging it?

These are the sorts of mismatches between policies on paper and in practice that allow institutional discrimination to flourish.

These are the sorts of mismatches between policies on paper and in practice that create invidious individual instances that result in employers being sued and suffering reputational damage.

These are the sorts of reasons that I imagine inspired OP to share her past experience of workplace discrimination; certainly the sorts of reasons why I would feel I was doing my employer a favour by sharing such an example. Especially so if I worked in a male-dominated industry and for a company which I suspected was not completely up to date with best practice in every facet of its operation (and/or one that wanted to be able present itself as a beacon of best practice).

The sort of business that might recognise the need for a discussion of women's experiences in that industry, on international women's day.

I would say that OP recognised very clearly the context of the discussion she was taking part in. Her only mistake might have been to misread the sincerity of her employer's intent.

Were I her, that is what I would be feeding back to her manager. Along with a suggestion that such exercises need to be much better planned and managed next time.

Otherwise they risk becoming part of the sort of leaky and inept structure permitting institutional discrimination, that I described above.

So sharing her experience of aborting a child has achieved nothing. Because we all know these general chats on subjects like this are box ticking exercises. At every place I’ve worked, we are all aware of that. It’s the same everywhere. Unless you are new to the world of work, I don’t know how anyone wouldn’t know that.

The only way to address issues properly, such as the ones you have written, is to contact to HR directly. If OP had done this then she wouldn’t be feeling the way she does and she wouldn’t have upset who knows how many people.

As I said, I don’t go to my place of work to hear about abortion and I shouldn’t have to. I’d have left the call and probably have had a talking to about it at some point by my manager. IN that chat I would have told her my reasons for leaving the call and that if I’m put in that position again, I will give my views at the time to the person being inappropriate. Afterall, if people like OP don’t care who they upset or trigger, why should the rest of us. See

Unsureaboutit9 · 20/03/2022 12:15

@Blossomtoes

That means you had a highly unprofessional shit boss who HR failed to deal with properly *@Justilou1*. It doesn’t make what I said bullshit.
Why can’t you accept that the OPs boss was also unprofessional 20 years ago aswell? Wether you agree with her talking about abortion on that call is one thing, but you say the whole thing 20 years ago was her fault rather than her unprofessional bosses, why is it different to this newer poster than had a similar experience?
Swipe left for the next trending thread