Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My sister doesn’t want my son/her nephew at her wedding..

137 replies

Lj99 · 18/03/2022 21:06

So I’m stuck between an answer on this and looking what other people think..
my son is 16 months old and my sister is getting married in June so he’ll be 19 months by then, he’s a happy little boy & just wants to play all the time. My sister also has two boys who are 9 & 10 who id do absolutely anything for but unfortunately the feelings aren’t the same for her with my son, I know she loves him and doesn’t want anything bad to happen to him but she is and always has been very jealous of mine and my mums relationship and therefore things my son is my mums ‘favourite’ grandchild, which is ridiculous as she loves all her grandchildren equally.

Anyway, she’s asked if my partner can sit out of the wedding ceremony with my son and just join at the party but we’ve spent over £300 on a hotel room, travelling the day before so I can get up early & be at her hotel to help get ready and of course make sure my son and partner are ready also to travel the venue with my mum and step dad, I’ve organised her whole hen do and been to most dress appointments and I’m not maid of honour for those wondering, i am bridesmaids but I do get the feeling it’s purely because we’re sisters and because I refused to be bridesmaid if my son wasn’t allowed to go. The reason I refused was because other children on her partners side of the family are all going and she has paid for, I had to pay for my son but I’d rather. She explained to me how it’s because the registrar said no children which I understand but am I being dramatic for not being happy that she doesn’t want him there or would others feel the same with a young child?

This is a family and friend wedding with other 100 guests including plenty of other children.
She’s also suggested I got him a bow tie to match the colour of my nephews ties but I get the feeling it is only for the pictures to make her look good and so other people don’t wonder why he wasn’t involved as much.. my other family members seem to thing it’s her being unreasonable.

OP posts:
mastertomsmum · 19/03/2022 10:47

Hmm, never heard of a Registrar saying no children. Maybe it’s all different these days. Most churches have a crèche room or some such available. I doubt a Vicar/minister would ban children

LittleBearPad · 19/03/2022 10:42

OP can she trust the parents of the other toddlers to take them out if they are noisy? Have those parents already said they’ll take them out. Can she not trust your DH to do the same if needed.

Everyone’s been to weddings where parents benevolently look at their little darlings causing chaos, it’s unkind and unfair. It’s a good reason why many people say no children.

toomuchlaundry · 19/03/2022 10:05

I wouldn’t go at all if you are being treated differently to everyone else

Lj99 · 19/03/2022 09:57

Those asking what age are other children going, they range from 2 weeks old - about 14 years of age, yes there are other toddlers and to clarify the only reason my son is going to the ‘afters’ is purely because me and my partner refused to go if he wasn’t invited for the whole day. After refusing she then said he can come, until a week ago then changing her mind again to ‘he can sit outside’, my partner is annoyed at this decision purely because it is always my son that gets left out and yes for the person who said there’s more to it, there definitely is but I’m not about to post my entire relationship in a short post of whether my son should be invited to his own aunties wedding or not. In no way would I ever even think about not inviting a family relative whether they were 1 years old or 100 years old. I do fully agree with her wedding her rules BUT those saying that clearly haven’t read that it would only be my son out of family and friends children not invited?

OP posts:
waltzingparrot · 19/03/2022 09:16

Let the bridal couple have the ceremony they want and try not to be offended OP. I was the bride in this position and DN was at the age of squirming/crying, running around. I just wanted to be able to really concentrate on my vows so we asked for DN to not be in the actual ceremony.

There's only so much you can control though ...... MIL coughed her way through the ceremony Grin.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/03/2022 09:05

@BingBangB0ng

I think it’s reasonable for her to ask for him not to be at the ceremony, I guess. I can’t believe she’s said he can only come if you pay for his food etc, while not doing the same for other children. Also that she was going to exclude him completely, while inviting other children, and only relented when you threatened not to go. Why is everyone just ignoring that part?
I missed the bit about the food. That’s really unfair and something to call her out on.
Mummyoflittledragon · 19/03/2022 09:03

I am wondering if your sister has made the registrar excuse up because she thinks you’re the favoured daughter and fears being blackmailed by you and your mum. She obviously very much wants you and your family there otherwise she wouldn’t have asked you to be her bridesmaid or invite your ds to the wedding breakfast and celebration.

@marcopront
The legal comment I made was the reason as to why I hadn’t commented on the registrar. It’s obviously made up. I haven’t rechecked your question. But I think that’s answered it?

BingBangB0ng · 19/03/2022 08:57

I think it’s reasonable for her to ask for him not to be at the ceremony, I guess. I can’t believe she’s said he can only come if you pay for his food etc, while not doing the same for other children. Also that she was going to exclude him completely, while inviting other children, and only relented when you threatened not to go. Why is everyone just ignoring that part?

Avocadobacardi · 19/03/2022 08:50

Having a 19 month old in the ceremony is a total pain in the ass. I’ve done it. By the time you’ve tried to get them to sit but they want to stand on the chair a talk to the people behind, you’ve stuffed them with bread sticks to keep them quiet, you’re whispering the 87th rendition of their favourite peppa pig book and then they’ve had enough and either start shouting or crying it’s not worth it. I think your sister is being reasonable. She wants him to be part of the day just worried about Tje ceremony. You play your part and get your DH to be outside with the toddler. You can’t compare a 19 month old to a 9 & 10 year old at a wedding not to mention the other children are her own!!!

TheWeeDonkey · 19/03/2022 08:45

There's about 3 threads on MN right now with women wringing their hands at how they let their child down by not providing siblings for them. I might point them in this direction to show them how much easier they've made their children's lives.

Mommabear20 · 19/03/2022 08:32

YABVVVVVU! It's her day! She simply doesn't want to possibility of a screaming baby during her ceremony! We requested people didn't bring children under 5 to ours and 3 brought them because they said 'they're well behaved!' And quess what! 2 of them screamed the whole time! Don't be so inconsiderate of her day

MindatWork · 19/03/2022 08:29
  1. It’s one thing to say ‘could your partner sit near an exit so if DS makes a noise he can whip him outside’ but it’s pretty harsh to say ‘I don’t want him in the ceremony at all’.

  2. She’s lying through her teeth about the registrar. I worked in the wedding industry for years and no registrar would EVER say that. As PP said I don’t think they’d be allowed. Only exception I can think of is an independent celebrant who specialises in child free ceremonies, but certainly not a local authority registrant.

sausagesandchamp · 19/03/2022 08:25

Yabu. I think yabu to blackmail her with the bridesmaid thing too. And I'm not against toddlers at weddings. Your sister is and you should respect her choice for her day.

StooOrangeyForCrows · 19/03/2022 08:24

How can you not see you are being unreasonable?

We went to a wedding and the registrar had to stop four times because the congregation had to hear the vows for it to be legal. Four effin times! This was a baby and a toddler that was not benefitting from being there in any way but they ruined the mood, the video and the whole vibe.

Just no.

arethereanyleftatall · 19/03/2022 08:18

Yabu.

Amd so much dramatics in your op for - 'toddler free wedding reception.'

Qwill · 19/03/2022 08:17

She’s your sister, so it means you get to enjoy watching her get married without any distractions. I’m sure your husband won’t mind skipping out on that bit either! Sounds like a win-win!

Qwill · 19/03/2022 08:15

We have taken children around that age to many weddings. Whoever of us knows the couple the least takes looks after the child during the ceremony. The child does not care a bit about the ceremony. Personally I find the ceremony a bit dull so always offer the childcare! It doesn’t sound like she doesn’t want him there as she’s invited him to the wedding, but as just asked that he doesn’t go to an hour of quiet time where he will be bored. I wouldn’t have had to be asked tbh.

Juno22 · 19/03/2022 08:14

I think the clue may be in 'he just wants to play all the time'......

Pick your battles. Even if your little boy went to the ceremony he wouldn't remember it in years to come. He'll be there for the party.

And your comments about the bow tie just being for the photos sound a bit catty.

Chimchimcharoo · 19/03/2022 08:12

My daughter was that age when my brother got married. Although she wasn’t banned my husband had to remove himself and her from the ceremony- she was happy, playing, talking, restless and wanted to explore the room! He had no real place to go trying to entertain in the foyer and walking about outside so everyone could hear the service.

MindfulMarch · 19/03/2022 08:08

@FrecklesMalone

If DH was asked to not attend the ceremony of my sister's wedding to look after our child he would be over the moon!
I really don't think he'd be alone in that!!
MichelleScarn · 19/03/2022 08:05

It’s supposed to be a day of joy, not sitting in silence scared to make a sound.
A day of joy yes, for the happy couple the 'scared to make a sound' is a bit dramatic and probably indicative that you'd be expecting to be noisy.

Happymum12345 · 19/03/2022 07:59

@Migrainesbythedozen

I don’t think you can compare a wedding to seeing a bank manager! Of course if the toddler is crying or upset you would pop outside, but you can keep them happy for a little while when their vows are being exchanged. I’ve been to weddings with babies and toddler and have lovely memories of a happy day. I didn’t let my children distract anyone during the service or speeches and played with them during the rest of the day-danced/went for around the venue etc. It’s supposed to be a day of joy, not sitting in silence scared to make a sound.

hm246 · 19/03/2022 07:53

YABU. I took my 2 year old to a wedding in September, I watched the bride walk down the aisle then I had to take him straight out. A 19month old will not be able to sit through a ceremony.
When you say he can join the party after, can he join the wedding breakfast or just the reception?

Sittinginthesand · 19/03/2022 07:48

Yabvu- weddings are not fun for toddlers. You will enjoy the service more and be able to focus on the service without him. It baffles me why you’d want to take a toddler to a wedding , they are so likely to be disruptive, through no fault of their own. Really selfish, but also self defeating.

Katieandthekids · 19/03/2022 07:45

I'm sorry but I totally understand where she is coming from not wanting toddler squeals all through her wedding ceremony. I have three kids of toddler/ baby age and will be stepping out with them all at my cousins wedding in the summer.

It's rubbish for you but it's her wedding day and she shouldn't have to make any allowances for anyone but her partner.

I didn't have kids at my wedding except my nieces who were 8 and 11 and so knew how to behave in the ceremony.