Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To seek assurances that I’ll be put on a single sex ward?

337 replies

Thoosa · 18/03/2022 19:21

Not single gender. Single sex.

Im due for one, maybe two, surgeries this year. I’m a DV and rape survivor.

I’m nervous.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 18/03/2022 23:52

extract

Ask almost any politician any question about gender identity — even if it’s specifically about women’s bodies or women’s rights — and you will inevitably hear the following sentence with minimal variation.

“What we must remember is that the trans community is one of the most marginalised, abused and vulnerable in society.”

(Continues)

In his much-mocked answer to a question about whether it’s bigoted to say only women have a cervix, Labour leaderSir Keir Starmersaid: “We need to bear in mind that the trans community are amongst the most marginalised and abused communities.”

Asked to give his thoughts on Kemi Badenoch’s reported comments that LGBT activism has gone from wanting freedom to marry who you want, to men wanting to use women’s bathrooms, London MayorSadiq Khanreplied: “The trans community is one of the most vulnerable in our society.”

Liberal Democrat leaderSir Ed Davey, presumably on his own accord, even tweeted that “The trans community is one of the most discriminated against in the UK” in order to condemn a story that the government was unlikely to introduce self ID in order to protect women’s spaces.

It is a shield, provided by their advisors, behind which they cower, and because it rarely receives pushback from informed journalists, it has the magical effect of shutting down the discussion before it even gets started. That’s why politicans love it. It’s the UK equivalent to the“thoughts and prayers”catechism recited by American politicians after every mass shooting.

There’s only one problem with it. It’s not true. It’s not even remotely true.

Let’s begin with the clearest indicator of the extent to which a community is“marginalised and abused”: the murder rate of those within it. Because there is no stable definition of what constitutes a“trans person”, there is no standardised method for recording the deaths of trans people across the UK. However, we know that there have beenjust eight reported murdersof people who defined themselves as transgender, transsexual or cross-dressers in the UK since reporting began in 2008. Even trans organisationTransrespect, which includes people who havecommitted suicideandpeople whose death was originally and erroneously treated as suspiciousin their numbers for“murdered” victims,says the number from 2008 to 2020is eleven.

Note that the UK is not a European anomaly — in Germany there hasn’t been a murder of a trans person since 2008, while 26 countries in Europe have reported no murders of trans people for the entire period.

Even though we’ve seen a sharp rise in the number of people who identify as transgender in the last few years, a trans person hasn’t been murdered in the UK fornearly three yearsand there are, for example, no reportseverof a trans person in Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland being murdered.

Moreover, not one of even the eleven people Transrespect says were murdered, were killed due to“transphobia”. The victim in each case was typically murdered by a male sexual partner due to drugs or money issues. None were killed by a woman — and one was killed by aman who identifies as a woman.

(Continues)

Of the five monitored strands that the police record as hate crimes, the transgender category has, every year, and by some distance, seen theleastnumber of“hate crimes” against it. In fact, religion — the next-lowest — saw nearly three times as many incidents in the last recording year.

Continues: thecritic.co.uk/neither-marginalised-abused-nor-vulnerable/

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/03/2022 23:51

post irrelevant articles

It wasn't irrelevant, a ward isn't single sex with males on it, and you have only made the point of how totally lacking empathy for women and girls so many supporters of the trans identity politics agenda are. Toodles.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 18/03/2022 23:50

@StillWeRise

the teddy bears
Aldi. I don't have the budget to use Lindt teddies as a coping mechanism! Grin
Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/03/2022 23:48

Piper's comments towards thoosa and rise are just plain nasty. And from a health professional??? That beggars belief. And enough of the marginalised stuff too- another hackneyed phrase.
I'm astounded by the lack of empathy towards women- you really do hate us don't you?

So many people are captured by this ideology across all sectors.

Featuredcreature · 18/03/2022 23:48

Tbh when I worked in the NHS it was done by bays not wards.

StillWeRise · 18/03/2022 23:47

the teddy bears

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/03/2022 23:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

StillWeRise · 18/03/2022 23:46

are they Lindt ones?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 18/03/2022 23:45

I'd ask you how you coped with misogyny, but I doubt you have any relevant advice, Piper.

If you think what you are doing is supporting "biological women", I think the best thing you could do is go very far away, and never go anywhere near a woman again. You started off knowingly attacking a rape survivor for feeling scared about going into hospital, and you have only dug deeper since then.

You're using the word marginalised again.

1 in 5 women is subjected to attempted rape or completed rape during her life. I readily believe that transitioned females (as rapists care rather more about the exterior of their victim than whether the victim experiences gender dysphoria) have similar stats, especially as transitioned females (what you might call transmen) seem to be survivors of child sexual abuse at a disproportionately higher rate than the rest of the female population.

Do you have evidence to show that transitioned males are victimised at a "far higher rate" than women? As in, more than 1 in 5?

Do you have evidence to show that the population of transitioned males does not have an offending pattern that reflects the wider pattern of male offending?

You want to single out male transitioners out from other males. I want to treat them like everyone else. Do you hate men, or something? Confused

Eyesofdisarray · 18/03/2022 23:43

@Thoosa and @risefromyourgrave- im sorry for your experiences and so sorry that the misogynists (because they make it very plain) are so denigrating/dismissive of your trauma. Best wishes
I find piper22's comments disgusting; nobody is being transphobic. This same old line is regularly trotted out and is frankly boring.
Piper's comments towards thoosa and rise are just plain nasty. And from a health professional??? That beggars belief. And enough of the marginalised stuff too- another hackneyed phrase.
I'm astounded by the lack of empathy towards women- you really do hate us don't you?

lifeturnsonadime · 18/03/2022 23:39

[quote DdraigGoch]@Piper22 what can be more relevant to a discussion about male sexual violence against women in hospital settings than articles/research about male sexual violence against women in hospital settings?[/quote]
For some reason
@Piper22
thinks that gender identity means that transwomen are not really males.

Which is concerning given that they Piper is apparently a nurse.

DdraigGoch · 18/03/2022 23:36

@Piper22 what can be more relevant to a discussion about male sexual violence against women in hospital settings than articles/research about male sexual violence against women in hospital settings?

Piper22 · 18/03/2022 23:32

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

Fortunately I’m mostly finding him incredibly boring and easy to ignore.

Good! You should not experience a second's self-doubt of yourself or your motivations after those posts. Not a single millisecond.

I do admire your stamina though

Thanks. I bite the heads off chocolate teddy bears in between posts. It seems to help.

@PurgatoryOfPotholes you really shouldn’t sound so smug as all you have demonstrated is your inane ability to post irrelevant articles which have not evidenced any of your points and your hateful vitriol about an already marginalised group of people. Reading many of the comments from posters tonight I’m only ever more relieved that it’s people like me and my similarly non bigoted nursing colleagues who are at the forefront of services in this country. I’ll continue to support both biological and trans women in my professional and in my personal life. Anyway, it’s getting late so I’ll leave you to your chocolate teddies Wink
Thoosa · 18/03/2022 23:23

Thanks. I bite the heads off chocolate teddy bears in between posts. It seems to help.

Grin
OP posts:
HappyDays40 · 18/03/2022 23:23

Mine was mixed, I didn't care but depends on experience.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 18/03/2022 23:20

Fortunately I’m mostly finding him incredibly boring and easy to ignore.

Good! You should not experience a second's self-doubt of yourself or your motivations after those posts. Not a single millisecond.

I do admire your stamina though

Thanks. I bite the heads off chocolate teddy bears in between posts. It seems to help.

Thoosa · 18/03/2022 23:19

Best to you too @risefromyourgrave Flowers

OP posts:
Thoosa · 18/03/2022 23:17

Thanks @Mickarooni I complete agree with every word of that.

OP posts:
risefromyourgrave · 18/03/2022 23:17

And when a Muslim woman goes to hospital, and finds that there is a trans woman on their ward, and instead of complaining discharges herself as she can’t be in the same room as a man. Who wins the oppression olympics then, who gets priority to the women’s bay?
And with that, I need to leave this thread, I’m getting really quite angry and it’s not helping the OP.
I wish you the very best for your procedures OP, I hope they go smoothly and without any unwanted incidents. Flowers

And thank you to all who expressed sympathy to me, it was a long time ago so I cope fairly well, but it does sometimes raise its ugly head.

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/03/2022 23:13

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

Just in case anyone is feeling a bit forgetful.

Piper22, today 20:33

This thread is so transphobic I’m surprised it hasn’t been taken down.

Piper22, also today...

You don’t get to dictate who can post what and to where on a public forum, especially when no guidelines are being broken.

I'd imagine there have been lots of reports of transphobia to try and get the thread taken down too (everything is transphobic as far as I can tell). I don't imagine it'll still be here in the morning. So much for not dictating what and where people can post on a public forum, I suppose it's only allowed for certain opinions.
Mickarooni · 18/03/2022 23:11

@Thoosa

I’m sorry your thread has been derailed by some people with an agenda. I think people need to remember now vulnerable it can feel when you’re in hospital. Even if you’re normally confident and able to advocate for yourself, being unwell and in pain in hospital is a whole different ballgame.
Of course YANBU to not want to share a room with a male bodied stranger. It’s bad enough there are shared rooms at all! It isn’t personal against any subset of male bodied human - you deserve dignity. We don’t accept shared sex bays (except in very specific circumstances such as intensive care and A&E etc) because we recognise dignity is vital, so this isn’t any different. Trans people deserve dignity too. They may very well not want to be in a shared bay. The blanket rule of “if you say you’re female / identify as a female then you’re in a female bay” does a disservice to everyone, including trans people and those with fluctuating gender identity issues.

Thoosa · 18/03/2022 23:09

[quote TigerMTV]@Thoosa - you’re right to be concerned and it’s very understandable that you just want to feel -and be - safe. The recent story is really frightening. It seems that logic has left the building, or the NHS at least.

Completely disagree that you should have to pay private to get dignity, privacy and safety!

I agree it’s galling to have to explain why you would like to ensure a penis-free ward when you’re incapacitated, but until there are men/women/unisex areas I think sadly this will be necessary? It’s shit though I know.

I hope both procedures are successful.[/quote]
Thank you 🙏🏻

It is heartening that most posters - and voters - have been kind and supportive.

OP posts:
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 18/03/2022 23:09

Just in case anyone is feeling a bit forgetful.

Piper22, today 20:33

This thread is so transphobic I’m surprised it hasn’t been taken down.

Piper22, also today...

You don’t get to dictate who can post what and to where on a public forum, especially when no guidelines are being broken.

Mickarooni · 18/03/2022 23:06

” But what has this got to do with trans people? Why are you all not all outraged about contact with any men in any healthcare (or any other) setting that case? The taxi driver that takes you to the hospital, the male porter that wheels you to the operating room, the male radiographer or sonography, the male anaesthetist, the male surgeon, the male nurses and care assistants, the male domestics, the male students, the male maintenance men, the male visitors… Because they’ve got a DBS? Give over.”

@Piper22 - I imagine the OP won’t spend 24 hours a day for several days lying in a bed next to the male taxi driver…..

TigerMTV · 18/03/2022 23:05

@Thoosa - you’re right to be concerned and it’s very understandable that you just want to feel -and be - safe. The recent story is really frightening. It seems that logic has left the building, or the NHS at least.

Completely disagree that you should have to pay private to get dignity, privacy and safety!

I agree it’s galling to have to explain why you would like to ensure a penis-free ward when you’re incapacitated, but until there are men/women/unisex areas I think sadly this will be necessary? It’s shit though I know.

I hope both procedures are successful.