Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To seek assurances that I’ll be put on a single sex ward?

337 replies

Thoosa · 18/03/2022 19:21

Not single gender. Single sex.

Im due for one, maybe two, surgeries this year. I’m a DV and rape survivor.

I’m nervous.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
11
Thoosa · 25/03/2022 13:18

I’m going to try to draft something tonight.

Thanks so much for all the input.

OP posts:
Chasingaftermidnight · 25/03/2022 10:06

I don’t get the ‘tiny percentage’ argument.

Harold Shipman represented a tiny percentage of doctors. But he took many lives and destroyed many more. And despite the overwhelming majority of doctors not being serial killers, his crimes (rightly) precipitated a massive review of safeguarding and major changes in the way GPs operated. The GMC didn’t shrug it off and say ‘oh well, he was a tiny percentage of GPs so let’s not stress about it too much.’

Wayne Couzens represented a tiny proportion of police officers, but I expect that most women would now be hesitant to get into an unmarked police car alone when shown a warrant card.

Yes, the percentage of transwomen is small. The percentage of those who are a danger to women is even smaller. But the tiniest percentage can still do untold damage to women.

megletthesecond · 25/03/2022 09:09

Yanbu.
I flagged this up with the school about an upcoming trip. I am embracing being that parent.

Lovedaffs · 25/03/2022 09:06

I cannot believe this of the LibDems. So disappointing. What has happened! UK political Parties don’t look affer women at all anymore.

FWIW, I agree that trans women shouldn’t be in prisons with men - but they certainly also shouldn’t be in prisons with women either!

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 25/03/2022 08:47

Apparently he isn't, and that was a prison rumour that got out of hand.

But, before anyone breathes too easily, this is what a member of the LibDems had to say at the time.

At the time, Alisdair sat on the LibDem Federal Policy Committee.

To seek assurances that I’ll be put on a single sex ward?
IamtheDevilsAvocado · 25/03/2022 03:49

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

Men are more likely to be sex offenders than women are. I've never once denied that. But if it's sex offenders who are the concern, why is it only trans ones that posters are concerned about?

Because a particular subset of males is being made exempt from basic safeguarding rules.

  1. Previous studies have suggested 10% of males are responsible for most acts of sexual violence. If this is a trend that is typical of various subsets, then 10% of male transitioners will be responsible for most acts of sexual violence committed by transitioners. And this subset is being given free rein to go where they like.

  2. when any subset of males is treated as too pure and kind to commit rape, rapists promptly start on being counted amongst that subset. Because rapists aren't stupid.

This.

Isn't the vile Ian Huntley now identifying as female? Angry

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/03/2022 11:30

It's strange then, how very few of them are in the public eye. And how very many you would absolutely know aren't female.

TheOriginalEmu · 22/03/2022 10:51

[quote HermioneWeasley]@TheOriginalEmu

Confidentiality - do you think we can’t tell what sex people are?

Women are entitled to single sex spaces. That’s it. If it causes problems for trans identified men, that is not our problem to solve. We are not support humans or human shields.[/quote]
I think there are very many trans women who you’d have no idea that they were anything other than a biological female, yes.

HermioneWeasley · 19/03/2022 21:24

@TheOriginalEmu

Confidentiality - do you think we can’t tell what sex people are?

Women are entitled to single sex spaces. That’s it. If it causes problems for trans identified men, that is not our problem to solve. We are not support humans or human shields.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/03/2022 20:55

Your trauma is not secondary to someone else’s identity but it IS secondary to someone else’s confidentiality.

NHS policy does mean that transwomen are put first. The fact that this is rare doesn't mean that it doesn't have a significant impact on vulnerable women who don't want males, however they identify, in safe spaces with them when they are vulnerable.

NHS policy has meant that the confidentiality of the transperson resulted in a rape victim being gaslit.

That's insane. It's not equality. It's not progressive. It puts the feelings of males above the safeguarding of women.

TheOriginalEmu · 19/03/2022 20:43

@Thoosa

There has to be a duty to balance needs and the NHS needs to start working out how.

Now I’ve really let myself dwell on it, I’m getting quite pissed off at the possibility they’d consider my trauma secondary to someone else’s identity.

Your trauma is not secondary to someone else’s identity but it IS secondary to someone else’s confidentiality. The chances of their being a transperson on your ward is already slim, the chances of any transperson on gang wars being there for any reason other than to have medical treatment the same as you is even slimmer.
lifeturnsonadime · 19/03/2022 20:34

I just don’t understand how we’ve got to this, I really don’t

Preferred pronouns and the 'transwomen are women' mantra.

All slowly chipping at women's rights.

Teddybearen · 19/03/2022 19:22

@lifeturnsonadime

That's it in the nutshell.

Women's rights and safety are not en vogue. Women get back in your box.

I just don’t understand how we’ve got to this, I really don’t
lifeturnsonadime · 19/03/2022 19:08

That's it in the nutshell.

Women's rights and safety are not en vogue. Women get back in your box.

TheRealShedSadie · 19/03/2022 19:07

Looking at recent events I think it’s very clear from NHS policy and guidelines, that any male patient can be accommodated on a female only ward on their request. They don’t need to have ‘changed gender’. Simply stating they are a woman will ensure staff will not be able to question or prevent this.

Any female patients who complain or who are upset will be told all patients on the ward are female. Staff risk disciplinary action or their jobs otherwise.

I’m sorry OP but you are right to be wary. Safeguarding is subordinate to self ID in many healthcare settings now.

Wazzzzzuuuuuuup · 19/03/2022 18:57

I find this really concerning that patients are worried about coming into hospital. I am a manager of surgical services. I was recently asked to comment on the policy re single sex accommodation and raised my concerns with the director of nursing and equalities manager. One of my DCs identifies as non binary, so it's not like I am ignorant of the issues at hand. I absolutely agree we need to make spaces where trans folk feel safe but not at the detriment of women's rights and safety.

I was basically told to get back in my box, if you're not wearing a rainbow flag, you're just not en vogue.

If it's in any way reassuring, however, the number of surgical trans folk we have had on my wards I can count on one hand and we always provided a side room for these patients. Surgical wards are usually well managed with side rooms as they are usually trying to manage multiple infection risks to keep all patients safe.

Have you got a choice of provider? Some hospitals have only single rooms on elective surgical wards. For example on our general surgery elective ward we have 2x male bays, 2x female bays and 8 side rooms. The hospital up the road is all single occupancy cubicles. You could look to transfer if this was an option.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 19/03/2022 18:56

@Holly60

I think rather than causing trouble and making the job of overworked NHS staff harder, I’d just pay for a private room. That way you get what you need and NHS staff can get on with what they need to do.
Saying a rape victim is ‘causing trouble’ cos she’d rather not have an unknown man sleep next to her

Lovely…

bigbluebus · 19/03/2022 18:50

My DH once spent the night on an all female bay in an NHS ward. He was caring for our severely disabled adult DD who had been admitted. As she was unable to communicate and had complex health issues, one of us needed to be with her. On this occasion I was not able to be there so he stayed all night. As far as I'm aware no one asked any of the other female patients whether they minded. This is not a Trans issue. I'm sure you wouldn't have felt comfortable with my DH being there - but I guess at least you'd have known he was a man. But if there were no side rooms available then there wouldn't have been a lot you could do (other than discharge yourself).

RegardingMary · 19/03/2022 18:48

@Ionlydomassiveones

It's easier to put 1 patient in a side room than have a bay with upset patients. I've yet to come across a trans patient who actually wanted to be in either bay, out of not wanting people to feel uncomfortable.

It seems a reasonable adjustment to put 1 person into a side room and make everyone happy.

With no TV, no visitors and very little else going on the majority of patients I care for don't want a side room. They're isolating, lonely rooms and certainly nothing to get excited about.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/03/2022 18:47

@Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky

It’s interesting to see how privileging male feelings above females seems to be unquestioningly baked into the nhs
Yes I think this is what gets to me the most, it's just so sexist.

Women are already at a disadvantage, compared to men, in access to health care.

Then even in hospital women's feelings about safeguarding and dignity and privacy come secondary to those of males who identify as trans. And when women suffer a direct harm as a result of these policies NHS staff have been instructed to cover up to protect the identity of the abuser.

It's so fundamentally anti women, I just can't see how it has been allowed to happen.

SevenWaystoLeave · 19/03/2022 18:46

Women actually are entiled to specify female staff only.

Not entirely accurate - women are entitled to ask for female staff only, whether that can actually be accommodated depends on whether all female staff are available. Surgery requires a large team, it's highly unlikely every single member of that team can be guaranteed to be a woman. And if you need a specialist and the only one currently available happens to be male, the hospital can't simply magic up someone female.

Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky · 19/03/2022 18:40

It’s interesting to see how privileging male feelings above females seems to be unquestioningly baked into the nhs

lifeturnsonadime · 19/03/2022 18:34

@Holly60

I think rather than causing trouble and making the job of overworked NHS staff harder, I’d just pay for a private room. That way you get what you need and NHS staff can get on with what they need to do.
I hope you would extend the same to male who want special treatment in the NHS because they identify as trans.
Holly60 · 19/03/2022 18:31

I think rather than causing trouble and making the job of overworked NHS staff harder, I’d just pay for a private room. That way you get what you need and NHS staff can get on with what they need to do.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/03/2022 17:48

My trust policy is that those who identify as female are entitled to be in a female bay as that is how they identify, even if they have a penis, regardless of how the females in the bay feel. Although they would not be told if the patient is trans, the trust is very strict on this.

So the policy of the trust is to put the feelings of males who identify as women above the safeguarding of women.

This is exactly what led to that poor woman being raped and then gaslit by the Trust when she reported it.

This nonsense has to stop because whilst most trans identifying males are not a danger to women (setting aside the issue of dignity and feelings of women concerned) predatory men can, and clearly do, use this to access women.

Swipe left for the next trending thread