Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Harry suing the home office

517 replies

TooEarlyForMe · 18/03/2022 15:11

Does he realise where the money they would have to pay him if he was successful in suing, would come from?

The British public

Thanks Harry.

OP posts:
ajandjjmum · 23/03/2022 19:59

Prince Edward's kids don't get protection, so why should anyone be angry?

pleasehelpwi3 · 23/03/2022 18:22

@Whatafustercluck

I've always been quite sympathetic to H&M. Quite like them actually.

But I work in policing and it makes me angry that if he wins, that's money we won't be able to use for really important work. I understand he wants protection for his children. But it's at the expense of other people's.

Do you feel angry when the Duke of Kent goes on a visit somewhere, and the police have to fund that, just because he's some woman's cousin? Or when Prince Edward's kids want to go somewhere, does that piss you off as well? And the money comes either directly or indirectly from the public purse? Or do you feel angry when your colleagues in the Met steal drugs and cash from the evidence room (or whatever it's called) as the latest report into police corruption published yesterday found? Or do you only get angry when it's Harry and Meghan?
Malibuismysecrethome · 23/03/2022 10:50

Lolling at the thought of the current and future members of the Royal family being victims of modern slavery.
But then I remember real victims and the remark isn’t funny at all. Just deeply offensive to real victims.

CathyorClaire · 22/03/2022 21:05

@Puzzledandpissedoff

It's actually Section b which interests me, Cathy, in that if he'd got the "half in half out" arrangement he wanted then presumably he'd still be an IPP because he'd be representing the RF

However he didn't get it and isn't a working member of the family any more, which I'd expect to change things

Yes, I agree but he's not going to be acting in any official capacity on any visits which is where I think Section C becomes relevant.

I think he misread the terms, threw his toys out of the pram and was then forced to retract the Archewell whinge when it was pointed out to him he'd got it wrong.

Briony123 · 22/03/2022 20:11

@TheHoptimist

He wants protecting- you cant but the protection he needs in the UK.

He was born into a society base don a monarchy where his life was at risk from the moment her was born (relatives of his were killed in IRA bombings)

He is a victim. Just look at the images of the Queen, Charles, William and George. George has been born into a life that in other contexts might be called modern slavery. He has no choice in how he will live his adult life, like his father and grandfather.

Harry opted out of that life but he is still a massive terrorism target, and even more so at the moment. He didn't choose to be born and he didn't choose to be put at constant risk by his parents and grandparents.

So his parents and grandparents should pay. They CHOOSE to be a royal family. They have chosen for centuries. Fought wars to be where they are. They should pay.
Malibuismysecrethome · 22/03/2022 20:06

So the Royal Family and the Queen refused H&M’s half in half out proposal. I wonder if this contributed to the decision.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/03/2022 17:32

It's actually Section b which interests me, Cathy, in that if he'd got the "half in half out" arrangement he wanted then presumably he'd still be an IPP because he'd be representing the RF

However he didn't get it and isn't a working member of the family any more, which I'd expect to change things

CathyorClaire · 22/03/2022 16:28

Been looking into this IPP thing and the definition on the governement website is as follows:

“a protected person” means, in relation to an alleged offence, any of the following, namely—

(a)a person who at the time of the alleged offence is a Head of State, a member of a body which performs the functions of Head of State under the constitution of the State, a Head of Government or a Minister for Foreign Affairs and is outside the territory of the State in which he holds office;

(b)a person who at the time of the alleged offence is a representative or an offical of a State or an offical or agent of an international organisation of an intergovernmental character, is entitled under international law to special protection from attack on his person, freedom or dignity and does not fall within the preceding paragraph;

(c)a person who at the time of the alleged offence is a member of the family of another person mentioned in either of the preceding paragraphs and—

(i)if the other person is mentioned in paragraph (a) above, is accompanying him,

(ii)if the other person is mentioned in paragraph (b) above, is a member of his household;

I think Section C would cover Harry if he was on official duties or on private visits to senior royals classified as IPP's but as far as any further entitlement goes it looks like he's stuffed.

ajandjjmum · 22/03/2022 14:18

Remember when M & H first issued their 'leaving presentation', they said that they were 'internationally protected persons' and would always be given state protection nomatter where they were. This was quickly and quietly removed from the document, after their misunderstanding was corrected.

Must have stung - and obviously still does.

SoItWas · 22/03/2022 11:07

"It really wouid be a bit warped if he were to pour over it all himself."

If I was born famous, I would do this at some point.

Though I'd probably want the ground to swallow me up/to disappear into anonymity forever, until everyone forgot who I was.

You can't go out of your way, to be in the public eye, talk shows, interviews etc, then act astonished when the public form opinions, especially in this age of social media/comments sections. Not like back in the day, when a man could see his King without his crown, and not have a clue who he was, because he'd only ever seen his face etched on a coin before.

NellGwynne · 22/03/2022 08:26

Yes and that’s the thing he appears not to understand or care about.

Whatafustercluck · 22/03/2022 08:23

I've always been quite sympathetic to H&M. Quite like them actually.

But I work in policing and it makes me angry that if he wins, that's money we won't be able to use for really important work. I understand he wants protection for his children. But it's at the expense of other people's.

mpsw · 22/03/2022 08:17

If he was to get reclassified as a person of international importance which is the purpose of the judicial review

The JR can't do that.

What it can do is assess issues such as whether RAVEC is the right body with relevant powers to make decisions on VIP and Royal protection, that it receives the right information so it can do this, membership is appropriate to the tasks required, and decision-making is timely and nor perverse

From The Guardian:

".....Justice Smith, summarised the four grounds forming the basis of the prince’s legal argument.

"He said these included an alleged “over rigid application of the policy” and a “failure” to take into account “relevant considerations”.

"The grounds also claim that conclusions reached were “unreasonable” and that “insufficient information” was provided in relation to the Ravec policy and “those involved in the Ravec decision”, the judge said"

The JR won't remake the decision, but if shortcomings were found, they will have to be corrected, and all RAVEC decisions will need to be looked at again in light of whatever is found in the JR.

That may mean that RAVEC have to reconsider protection for him (which strikes me as a bit pointless, as they've already said that they do this for each planned trip anyhow). It does not mean they will reach a different decision.

Peaseblossum22 · 22/03/2022 07:51

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Well, I doubt he's doing it to fund their lifestyle ... didn't his wife get just £1 compensation for the "breach of privacy" thing?
If he was to get reclassified as a person of international importance which is the purpose of the judicial review as I understand it , then all his international security would be provided, it all comes down to money in the end . Although Ibwould have thought if him visiting your country means the taxpayers of that country having a bill then you might think twice about inviting him.
EdithWeston · 21/03/2022 23:16

@NellGwynne

His full time job now is firing off lawsuits. He must trawl through the DM every day. What a way to spend your life. Why doesn’t he just ignore it and get on with his life?
He'll use what used to be called a cuttings agency, and then there will be staff who present a digest.

It really wouid be a bit warped if he were to pour over it all himself.

NellGwynne · 21/03/2022 20:34

@Chilledchablis1

@ NellGwynne

I agree . I did wonder - and said it on a thread- what would come out of California during W and C’s tour . Oh well they are nothing if not predictable!

Yup. Also straight after it’s made known that H won’t be gracing the RF with his presence at his grandfather’s memorial service. He appears wearing a ridiculous costume to promote his next jaunt.
CathyorClaire · 21/03/2022 20:14

Is this a new one? I can't keep up.

And. Is all this litigation linked to the acres of empty Sussex output Netflix and Spotify must be coming to regret coughing their corporate guts up for?

Chilledchablis1 · 21/03/2022 19:42

@ NellGwynne

I agree . I did wonder - and said it on a thread- what would come out of California during W and C’s tour . Oh well they are nothing if not predictable!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/03/2022 19:40

Well, I doubt he's doing it to fund their lifestyle ... didn't his wife get just £1 compensation for the "breach of privacy" thing?

NellGwynne · 21/03/2022 19:37

His full time job now is firing off lawsuits. He must trawl through the DM every day. What a way to spend your life. Why doesn’t he just ignore it and get on with his life?

Chilledchablis1 · 21/03/2022 19:25

Here we go again - a more suing just reported on Twitter.

“ The Duke of Sussex's lawyers said in a new libel lawsuit that the Mail on Sunday was responsible for "distortion and misrepresentation of the facts".

Xenia · 20/03/2022 16:47

Okay, it looks like I was wrong about the royal baby on the steps of hospital tradition - I just remembered it from the past when I was having my babies but may be it is just a recently thing and only for the heir, not the spare etc. Anyway it does seem they have gone out of their way to annoy the British public and succeeded.

The security detail was interesting as no citizen decides what police protection will be given even if they offer to pay for it. In other words the British police force is not something you pay to hire.

EdithWeston · 20/03/2022 16:45

@Puzzledandpissedoff

I think Princess Anne was actually the first to "appear on the steps with the baby", EdithWeston?

It's never bothered me personally; after all it's their child and surely up to them to decide - and that's without the issue of whether they'd even want to scrub up for a public appearance at such a time

Don't think so.

She was the first Royal that close to the throne to have her babies in hospital, rather than at home. But she didn't do a photocall as such. There were press as she left, but she got straight in to a car and baby Peter was carried out by a nurse. First pix released was when he was about a month old.

custardbear · 20/03/2022 16:28

@Peaseblossum22

Honestly I really think that if they had just said , we feel really uncomfortable with the steps thing so we are going to issue some pictures later most people would have been fine with it . In fact a lot of women would have cheered for all the reasons set out by a previous poster . But they didn’t do that, they created some ridiculous made up smoke and mirrors story that she had gone in to Labour when in fact she had had the baby already . Then instead of just having the christening and not telling anyone they made a huge drama about how they were having a christening but no one could know who was coming and there mustn’t be any photos etc etc . Honestly what a ridiculous drama about nothing .
I agree with this, but will also add that smoke and mirrors thing really pissed people off. No baby on steps - who cares ... but actively lying, misinformation and stirring up a hornets nest about crap like who the godparents are is just childish idiotic games - grow up! But I suspect it's just fodder to keep them in the news
Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/03/2022 14:01

If it's the same one, I also saw the Louis Theroux thong ancientgran - and yes, it was horrible.
But on here it's a bit of a trope that the US is a racist, uncivilised hellhole, so why H&M were so attracted to it is yet another thing left unaddressed

And BTW your mum sounds a very wise lady Wink