Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Harry suing the home office

517 replies

TooEarlyForMe · 18/03/2022 15:11

Does he realise where the money they would have to pay him if he was successful in suing, would come from?

The British public

Thanks Harry.

OP posts:
wordler · 18/03/2022 16:34

Beatrice and Eugenie had their protection taken away in their early 20s when they were 5th and 6th in line to the throne as it was deemed there wasn't sufficient security risk to justify it.

Harry has actually been given a special 'case-by-case' status by the home office which means they will look at each visit on its own merits and the current security risks - if intelligence says the risk is high they will provide the armed protection officers. That's why he got them when he came back for Philip's funeral but not when he came back for the Diana statue unveiling.

So with the case-by-case situation plus the option of hiring excellent private security for the rest of the time he wants to visit the UK, plus the fact that on any royal property he is automatically covered - he does not need to sue the government for the sake of UK trips.

What he wants is his internationally protected person status back - that means that other governments will also provide special armed security wherever he travels as part of the recipricol agreement we have with other countries.

It's why Canada was paying for their security when they were there at the end of 2019. It means they would be able to have free security on any travels rather than having to pay for it themselves as they do now.

DontLookBackInAnger1 · 18/03/2022 16:33

@ForTheLoveOfSleep

* He didn't have a choice about being born into a high-profile family who are undeniable targets for terrorism etc. He has made a choice to reduce his involvement with the "work" of that family, but he doesnt have a choice to take the target off his back (and the same applies to his wife and children).*

Yeah. He could just live quietly and fade into the background like they wanted.... But low and behold the $$$$ Spotify, Oprah, Netflix etc proved too difficult to resist 🙄 So why not hit the Home Office up for some spare change too.

Exactly this.

They don't want a quiet life. A "normal" life.

They still want to be famous, rich and influential.

Having said that, I can see he's now stuck between a rock and a hard place. He's willing to pay for the security but can't. And we won't allow other forms of armed security. So essentially he can't come to the UK anymore.

It's difficult. On the one hand I admire him, on the other I feel he's quite ungrateful for all of the privilege he's had his whole life (and still has).

Peaseblossum22 · 18/03/2022 16:33

Nobody is saying he can’t have any protection just that the police will decide if the threat level and act accordingly , as they do for every high profile individual . After all Salmam Rushdie had police protection for years and I have a friend whose father was the subject of a credible threat and he had protection for several years . Just that he doesn’t get to decide and also the police won’t share ingii or Rangoon with private security and he can’t pay for the police and choose the shots that way.

Of course he would be protected if he came here , can you imagine the outcry if something happened to them .

Alexandria12 · 18/03/2022 16:32

There are numerous women in the UK right now who have left violent partners, have had threats made against then and are in justifiable fear for their lives. Very few of them (with the odd exception like Princess Haya) are in the position of being able to pay for security.

None of them asked to be put in this situation. Where is the 24 hour armed police protection for them?

SickAndTiredAgain · 18/03/2022 16:32

@JudgeJ

Isnt his argument that you cant buy private armed security in the UK?

Do you seriously think that the security companies operating in the UK are unarmed???

You can’t hire bodyguards with guns in the UK.
BringBackCoffeeCreams · 18/03/2022 16:31

Princess Anne doesn't get it and she literally had to fight off a kidnapper.

oldwhyno · 18/03/2022 16:31

I think he should just call their bluff. Get on a plane, and go strolling around Covent Garden sprinkling their charm all over the public. I bet Charles and Her Maj would blink first and send a crew over pretty quickly.

Georgeskitchen · 18/03/2022 16:29

I heard that Andrews protection has ceased since he is no longer officially a member of the RF. Everyone else not in direct line to the throne has security only when they are on official Royal Duty x

cherrycokr · 18/03/2022 16:29

@girlmom21 that & the all round shadiness. But not many seem to mind!

Nightlystroll · 18/03/2022 16:27

Although maybe our courts will say they can. Who knows?

Nightlystroll · 18/03/2022 16:27

@EmpressCixi

If his offer of payment had been accepted it would open the floodgates for all VIPs, foreign and domestic, to have the right to "buy" our police protection squads. Yea, no thank you.

Didn’t we pay for Justin Trudeau’s security recently? And Trump when he visited? In my opinion it would be better to provide the security but for the VIP or their tax payers to fund it instead of us.

We paid for these because they're head of states. We paid for Xi Jinping, who's pretty gross, and we'd pay for Putin if he stays President. And if our Head of States go to their countries, they pay to protect them. But a private individual can't put in an order for 7 Protection Officers for example. Or demand to have all intel relevant to them. Putin can't come to the UK and demand all the Intel we have on him!
girlmom21 · 18/03/2022 16:26

@cherrycokr it's a bit bonkers he still gets the protection of a senior royal without doing any of his royal responsibilities isn't it

JudgeJ · 18/03/2022 16:26

Isnt his argument that you cant buy private armed security in the UK?

Do you seriously think that the security companies operating in the UK are unarmed???

CloudPop · 18/03/2022 16:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

neverthenot · 18/03/2022 16:25

Harry opted out of that life but he is still a massive terrorism target, and even more so at the moment. He didn't choose to be born and he didn't choose to be put at constant risk by his parents and grandparents

I agree with this. We (as in the British) hold onto the hereditary monarchy and I think we have a moral responsibility to protect those made vulnerable by being born into the Monarchy. His Mum died because of the risks being in the monarchy created. You can see his concern, its deeply personal and based in childhood trauma.

If we don't want to pay for those put at risk by being born into the monarchy, we need to get rid of the monarchy so that we don't have to pay for those born into it in future. But whilst we have it we can't moan about the costs it creates by protecting those put at risk.

SickAndTiredAgain · 18/03/2022 16:25

Is Prince Andrew still getting protection?
His daughters don't, do they? Wasn't that part of his argument when Harry wanted it?

I believe only a few royals get full time protection (the queen, Charles + camilla, and the cambridges). However obviously the others get a degree of security due to where they live. I think Beatrice and Eugenie live within royal residences (St James’ palace for one and within the Frogmore cottage for the other). As does Andrew.

And any of the royals carrying out official engagements will have security with them for that.

SandyFog · 18/03/2022 16:24

Isn’t this about him wanting access to intelligence, which his private security guards won’t have, rather than wanting police protection per se?

cherrycokr · 18/03/2022 16:23

I can understand the perspective of someone who is a potential terrorist target, born into the role rather than choosing it, whose mother was killed on a route away from photographers.

Absolutely, of course he has anxiety & paranoia. Who wouldn't!

The answer is to disband the monarchy: then no-one has to endure this nonsense and we don't have to pay for it either.

Absolutely, it's ridiculous

JudgeJ · 18/03/2022 16:23

@TheHoptimist

He wants protecting- you cant but the protection he needs in the UK.

He was born into a society base don a monarchy where his life was at risk from the moment her was born (relatives of his were killed in IRA bombings)

He is a victim. Just look at the images of the Queen, Charles, William and George. George has been born into a life that in other contexts might be called modern slavery. He has no choice in how he will live his adult life, like his father and grandfather.

Harry opted out of that life but he is still a massive terrorism target, and even more so at the moment. He didn't choose to be born and he didn't choose to be put at constant risk by his parents and grandparents.

He has security in the US and I'm sure he could afford to buy similar security in the UK. If he were to attend the functions associated with his Grandmother's Platinum Jubilee he would be receiving the same protection as other members of the Royal Family. Who will be protecting him in the Netherlands a months after his 'dear' Grandfather's memorial service which he ahs decided not to attend. They, Harry and his wife, need to realise that life isn't a pick and mix as it suits the needs of their latest/next 'expose' (can't do acents!).
RoseAndRose · 18/03/2022 16:22

Info on internationallly protected people

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protection_of_Diplomats_Convention

As he no longer represents the Monarch (having quit RF duties) he no longer automatically qualifies

LampLighter414 · 18/03/2022 16:22

Get rid of them all once Queenie dies, they do nothing for us. Before you start talking about Charles charity etc, do you not think others would step in to fill the need?

cherrycokr · 18/03/2022 16:22

@girlmom21

According to the Guardian

"As a senior royal, he has round-the-clock Scotland Yard protection. Security costs are never discussed by Buckingham Palace or the Metropolitan police. But it has been reportedly estimated that the annual cost to the taxpayer of guarding Andrew could be up to £2m."

His daughters don't, do they?

They did have tax paying security at a 500k a yr cost. now it's privately funded...

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 18/03/2022 16:21

@SickAndTiredAgain

What issue is he specifically suing over?

Is it the decision not to give security?
Not allowing him to pay for it?
Not giving his security the intelligence he says they need?

A combination of these?

The decision not to give him security.

He only offered to pay for it after it came out in the press. He tried to have it kept out of the public domain but the court rejected his application for an injunction.

His security wouldn't need the intelligence he says they need. If there was intelligence to say there was a serious / viable threat to him then the MET would step in and protect him.

TatianaBis · 18/03/2022 16:20

I can understand the perspective of someone who is a potential terrorist target, born into the role rather than choosing it, whose mother was killed on a route away from photographers.

The answer is to disband the monarchy: then no-one has to endure this nonsense and we don't have to pay for it either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread