Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Harry suing the home office

517 replies

TooEarlyForMe · 18/03/2022 15:11

Does he realise where the money they would have to pay him if he was successful in suing, would come from?

The British public

Thanks Harry.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Morestrangethings · 21/02/2023 09:14

Billandben444 · 18/03/2022 15:27

George has been born into a life that in other contexts might be called modern slavery
Well, that's worth a belly laugh 😂

I don’t equate it with modern slavery no. There is slavery today, but it’s far from that.

As you said though, ‘other contexts’. I do think he’s been born to a life I wouldn’t want for my children. However, he has free choice and can abdicate. I’m not saying it wouldn’t be a hard thing for him to do but he can if he chooses. Although it would be a hard thing to go against every thing you’ve been taught about duty etc..

At any rate, I hope he is encouraged to have a career of some type. Not one built completely around the anticipation of being king one day. I think those 3 kids all need that. As did Harry and William imo.

mpsw · 03/04/2022 08:00

@longwayoff

Will he be safer in Amsterdam at Invictus than he would be here? I don't follow the reasoning.
The reason which would make sense is that Harry is aware of a specific threat (not just 'feeling unsafe') that is geographically limited to UK, and that he believes that the committee are either unaware of it or have failed to give it proper weight, or that the committee is not competent by means of its composition or procedures. That would account for both the court case and why destinations other than UK are at a different threat level.

Of course in turn that means that thevDuke will need to demonstrate that the threat is continuing, and that his evidence on it is reasonable and well-sourced as well as still timely.

longwayoff · 02/04/2022 21:14

Will he be safer in Amsterdam at Invictus than he would be here? I don't follow the reasoning.

tattychicken · 26/03/2022 08:26

Yes I realise that would be breathtakingly stupid but it did cross my mind...

AnastasiaRomanov · 26/03/2022 06:42

@tattychicken

Was the "someone" the email was sent to Omid Scobie I wonder? 🤔
Wouldn’t be surprised.
Xenia · 25/03/2022 19:13

I think the judge referred to some notice at the top of his draft judgment which I have not seen so I suppose it might be clearer than the rules I quoted. If you can give the draft to the solicitor instructing the barrister and to the client company the issue might be how many employees within that client company can get the draft. It may depend what is written on the draft judgment by the judge I suppose and not just the relevant rules.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/03/2022 14:21

I doubt it, tattychicken ... I can't quite see that even a barrister who "didn't fully think" would be that stupid

tattychicken · 25/03/2022 13:01

Was the "someone" the email was sent to Omid Scobie I wonder? 🤔

StormzyinaTCup · 24/03/2022 23:28

Interesting Xenia
However, I'm still a bit Confused, especially having read her credentials as linked by Puzzled.

Assuming she wasn't sure if it constituted a breach (which I do find hard to believe) surely, and especially in such a high profile case, you err on the side of caution and don't press 'send'.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/03/2022 22:56

To be fair to the lawyers I have also found the rules not 100% clear in the past

That sounds fair enough, Xenia, but with such a high profile client surely anyone with sense would check rather than (reportedly) say they "Didn't fully think"?

Xenia · 24/03/2022 22:50

To be fair to the lawyers I have also found the rules not 100% clear in the past eg the barrister can hand it to the solicitors too to check. and to "the parties" which in my view includes the client. Whenever I have handed it on to the parties (my client) I give them all kinds of instructions as they otherwise want to start telling the world and his wife they won. Instead they must tell no one. If the client is a company the company can distribute it in confidence within the company. Some companies have 10,000 staff. It is not always really simple as to who can see it.

"2.3 The court will provide a copy of the draft judgment to the parties’ legal representatives by 4 p.m. on the second working day before handing down, or at such other time as the court may direct.
2.4 A copy of the draft judgment may be supplied, in confidence, to the parties provided that –

(a) neither the draft judgment nor its substance is disclosed to any other person or used in the public domain; and

(b) no action is taken (other than internally) in response to the draft judgment, before the judgment is handed down.
2.5 Where a copy of the draft judgment is supplied to a party’s legal representatives in electronic form, they may supply a copy to that party in the same form.
2.6 If a party to whom a copy of the draft judgment is supplied under paragraph 2.4 is a partnership, company, government department, local authority or other organisation of a similar nature, additional copies may be distributed in confidence within the organisation, provided that all reasonable steps are taken to preserve its confidential nature and the requirements of paragraph 2.4 are adhered to.
2.7 If the parties or their legal representatives are in any doubt about the persons to whom copies of the draft judgment may be distributed they should enquire of the judge or Presiding Judge.
2.8 Any breach of the obligations or restrictions under paragraph 2.4 or failure to take all reasonable steps under paragraph 2.6 may be treated as contempt of court."

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/03/2022 22:41

I've just seen the chambers website for Harry's barrister, and among other purple prose it says she's "incredibly clever, with a mind like a razor blade" and "already earmarked as Supreme Court judge material"

A little odd, perhaps, for someone quite that clever to claim she "didn't know", but looking on the bright side at least it's not Harry who's getting the flak for speaking out of turn this time

www.blackstonechambers.com/barristers/shaheed-fatima-qc/

Xenia · 24/03/2022 22:37

Before judgments are issued lawyers see a draft to check for typos etc and must never disclose them as they are not yet official/not yet handed down by the judget but Prince Harry's team seem not to have followed that rule.

"After the judgment was made public, Mr Justice Swift criticised Prince Harry's legal team for breaking the embargo on the document.

Mr Justice Swift said a copy of Thursday's ruling had been emailed to someone who was not a lawyer, against court rules, calling this "entirely unacceptable". "

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10647363/Documents-Prince-Harrys-case-against-Home-Office-remain-secret.html

pleasehelpwi3 · 24/03/2022 21:00

[quote maeveiscurious]@pleasehelpwi3 careful, your real unpleasantness is showing [/quote]
You mean you disagree with my opinions?
Doesn't make me unpleasant.....

maeveiscurious · 24/03/2022 20:58

@pleasehelpwi3 careful, your real unpleasantness is showing

pleasehelpwi3 · 24/03/2022 20:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

ajandjjmum · 24/03/2022 19:48

@pleasehelpwi3 A pp had commented that Prince Edward's kids get protection and I said they don't. The Sun link you posted did not relate to that at all - it was commenting on Prince Edward himself using a plane rather than a train. Different thing entirely.

pleasehelpwi3 · 24/03/2022 19:15

@ajandjjmum

Prince Edward's kids don't get protection, so why should anyone be angry?
This took 30 seconds on google to find.

www.thesun.co.uk/news/6514450/prince-edward-blows-5000-of-taxpayers-cash-on-private-jet-for-130-mile-trip-though-train-would-have-cost-just-60/
Of course him and his family are directly funded by the taxes we pay.
In Germany the state funds the church through income taxation (or did when my parents lived there for a while when I was a kid) and you could opt in. A much fairer system- if you want to fund the Windsors' opulent lifestyle, you could tick a box and you'd pay more income tax than those who don't. It worked just fine in Germany- my parents opted out.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/03/2022 19:13

I would expect a QC to be very familiar with court rules and what constituted a breach, especially if they are top end and charging you ££££

You'd think so wouldn't you - or at least that they'd take the trouble to find out?

Then again, if this is the calibre of the people Harry's surrounding himself with, it's perhaps easy to see why his own PPOs are allegedly disallowed access to the Home Office's security information

pleasehelpwi3 · 24/03/2022 19:09

@PierresPotato

To be fair the Duke of Kent, whatever my views on monarchy, seems a dutiful sort of royal cousin. Prince Harry has opted out of the UK / Commonwealth royal family . I understand that tbh. Don't understand the desire to leverage his inherited position in the USA of all places. The least monarchical place I can imagine.
According to a quick google search, so may be out by a million or two:

'He's worth about $10 million according to the blog Royal Splendor, including receiving $400,000 a year from the Queen for fulfilling his royal duties and a stipend from his time in the British Army.'

So that's eight million odd quid that could be funding drugs for cancer on the NHS, like this one:
'The appraisal committee looked at new data showing people taking Kadcyla could live up to 9 months longer than those taking the alternative, lapatinib plus capecitabine' BUT UNFORTUNATELY....the reality is that the price of Kadcyla is currently too high in relation to the benefits it gives for it to be recommended for routine commissioning in the NHS, even taking into account the end‑of‑life criteria and the patient access scheme.”

I'd rather taxes went on funding drugs like this one so that cancer sufferers could live even a little longer as opposed to spending millions so one family has a life of luxury in exchange for turning up some events and cutting a ribbon. I realise that I'm in the minority in that view on this site.

StormzyinaTCup · 24/03/2022 18:42

news.sky.com/story/amp/prince-harrys-lawyer-criticised-as-parts-of-police-protection-claim-against-home-office-to-be-kept-secret-12574161

Prince Harry's legal team slammed

Mr Justice Swift later criticised Prince Harry's legal team for making the ruling public before it was due to be officially published.

Drafts of High Court judgments are typically provided to lawyers before their publication.

Shaheed Fatima QC, who represents Prince Harry, said she and her team had not been sure if emailing the ruling to someone who was not a lawyer last week would break the rules.

She reported it to the judge yesterday - but Mr Justice Swift questioned why she hadn't done so earlier and slammed the "entirely unacceptable" move that was a "clear breach" of court rules.

"It is also unacceptable that you come without an apology to the court," he said.

Ms Fatima said she took full responsibility and then apologised "for the fact that I didn't think fully before the emails were sent".

I would expect a QC to be very familiar with court rules and what constituted a breach, especially if they are top end and charging you ££££ Confused.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/03/2022 18:17

From that BBC article: "After the judgment was made public, Mr Justice Swift criticised Prince Harry's legal team for breaking the embargo on the document"
"Mr Justice Swift said a copy of Thursday's ruling had been emailed to someone who was not a lawyer, against court rules, calling this "entirely unacceptable""

Didn't take long did it?

EdithWeston · 24/03/2022 17:37

BBC account of what happened in court today: it only covered the redaction of documents and did not decide anything about the claim against the Home Office or whether it can go ahead (nothing in the article about possible timelines for that)

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-60860357

Confirmation that parts will not be made public (both sides had requested this, and it's granted on the basis that there are elements of providing VIP and Royal security that have to remain private)

Also The Duke of Sussex's legal team was criticised by the judge for breaking the information embargo by emailing it to someone who was not a lawyer, against court rules - calling this "entirely unacceptable"

PierresPotato · 24/03/2022 12:55

To be fair the Duke of Kent, whatever my views on monarchy, seems a dutiful sort of royal cousin.
Prince Harry has opted out of the UK / Commonwealth royal family . I understand that tbh. Don't understand the desire to leverage his inherited position in the USA of all places. The least monarchical place I can imagine.

Chilledchablis1 · 24/03/2022 07:14

I believe this is today

Harry suing the home office