Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

35 and denied alcohol

258 replies

antisocialsocialclub · 18/03/2022 14:35

Bit of a light hearted one but I am actually annoyed.

Also this isn’t a stealth boast or humble brag at all, because I didn’t come out of this feeling in any way flattered or superior 🤣

I’m 35. I’d like to set the scene by saying I look my age, maybe on a good day I look 30. No way do I look like I’m in my 20s. I definitely look old enough to drink. I have several fine lines and the face a woman of my age has just from existing.

Having a few friends around tonight so just popped out to the shop to get some snacks and a bit of alcohol. I went with DH.

We were at the conveyor belt and the cashier was putting the food through. Then she paused at the alcohol. She looked at DH and then at me and said to me “do you have ID?” I just laughed then realised she was serious. I said I had nothing on me, DH showed his but the cashier said ‘sorry I can’t serve you as I can’t be sure you won’t give the alcohol to points at me’

I laughed and said ‘I’m 35!’ but she wouldn’t budge. I considered asking for the manager but wimped out. Didn’t fancy making a scene for the same outcome.

To cut a long story short, DH had to leave the alcohol because his ‘child bride’ 🤣 left her wallet at home. I actually felt a bit awkward that she thought my 42 year old DH (greying hair and all) was with an under 25 year old. Or did she think I was some street child forcing DH to buy me booze 😊

I know cashiers need to check, I know it’s the law and it’s hard for them etc etc but 1. wow, if she thought I was under 25 I must have had a hard life and 2. I just don’t understand the logic in this situation.

DH was buying the alcohol I was just gormlessly stood with him. What if a parent goes shopping with their underage child and wants to buy a bottle of wine? What they’re saying is you can’t buy alcohol unless everyone accompanying you has ID to confirm legal age?!

I think it’s madness. AIBU?

Also DH has just popped to another shop to get it and I decided I’d stay in the car like a naughty dog 😭 I’m 35!

OP posts:
Momijin · 19/03/2022 02:34

I'd never been ID ever (even when i was underage) but last year during lockdown and wearing face masks, I had to pull my mask down about 4 times to buy alcohol. The bottom half of my face is clearly older than my top half. I'm 51!

Third3NewLife · 19/03/2022 02:26

Don't agree with the look 25 age policy

Don't agree need age verification for energy drinks with zero alcohol

But it's OK to join the armed forces at 18

girlmom21 · 19/03/2022 01:51

@HikingforScenery

Someone close to me had to go back and get a wallet to show ID for ‘challenge 25’ to buy non-alchoholic beer. They’re pretty close to 50.
I got ID'd once for grenadine. It's literally just syrup. The woman in Asda asked me what it was because there was no suggestion on the bottle.

I can only assume it's because it's used in cocktails. Madness.

endofthelinefinally · 18/03/2022 23:45

There is a period during which you can't take any family member between the ages of about 12 and 23 with you to do the shopping if you intend to buy any alcohol. They won't sell it to you because you might be buying it for the young person. It has happened to me and to several of my friends. Really annoying if you just want a bottle of wine for a gift, or a dinner invite.

nokidshere · 18/03/2022 23:32

Smile, take it as a compliment and move on

Which bit of being 60 and being asked for ID is a compliment? I don't expect to have to carry round id at my age, it's ridiculous.

I once got refused strepsils in the local budgens because I turned to my 12yr old and asked him which flavour he wanted. Strepsils are for anyone over the age of 6.

Supermarkets just need to train their staff properly

autienotnaughty · 18/03/2022 23:17

My husband was in his early thirties when he went to the shop with our 13 year old dd in tow (who's quite tall so could pass for 15 at a push) tried to buy some beers but he got id, showed his id then they refused to serve him in case he was buying it for our daughter!! Not sure what self respecting teen is drinking real ales 😂😂

BoredZelda · 18/03/2022 23:09

Are you short?

When I was younger I rarely got ID’d when I was alone, but always did when I was with other people, even when I was pretty obviously (in my eyes) well past 25. I’m 5ft tall and I’m convinced that’s why.

latetothefisting · 18/03/2022 22:24

@melj1213

In your case though it clearly seems a bit overkill in this instance. I probably would have asked for a manager and asked them to explain the rationale.

And if that manager was a decent one then they would have supported their staff and reiterated that it is store policy to apply "Challenge 25" and once a staff member has asked for ID it cannot be sold until the staff have seen your ID and nobody can overrule the staff member as it is the person who sells it who is personally liable for thousands of pounds in fines and potential imprisonment.

It sucks when you're stopped from buying things because they're age restricted but as a checkout operator it sucks for us because we are just doing our jobs by asking and we are the ones personally liable if we fail a test purchase so some people will be overzealous to cover themselves (or may have just failed a test purchase so are being overly cautious). I have been in disciplinary meetings where people have lost their jobs over Challenge 25 failures - a couple of months ago someone in my store failed a test purchase and it was a Trading Standards test purchase so he was given an official caution, a £1k fine (which he had to personally pay, the company can't pay it for you) and he just barely kept his job.

I'm 32 and definitely look it, I was buying a new stiff broom to sweep our outside courtyard and was IDed because it had a blade on the side (which I hadn't even noticed, I just picked up the first outdoor broom I saw) and so had flagged on the till as a "bladed item". I had just come from work so didn't have my ID (I only carry a card wallet with my work access card, discount card and debit card when I go to work). As soon as I said I didn't have my ID I could see the cashier preparing to have to explain and she visibly relaxed as soon as I waved her away with "Don't worry, I work in a supermarket I know the rules. Am I OK to nip back and switch this broom for a different one as I didn't even realise it had a blade and I don't need it?"

But Challenge 25 applies to the person BUYING the alcohol. There is nothing in its guidance that refers to the person/people accompanying them. I'm not aware of any clear guidance stating what shop staff should do if they suspect a person who they don't feel the need to challenge because they are clearly over 25 is buying alcohol for someone else with them who may be under (as is what happened in OPs case). I suspect this is probably because there isn't any, and it's left up to staff's discretion which is why I think it would be appropriate to ask for a manager.

I'm all for managers supporting their staff if they are following guidance/regulation appropriately. But if there is a possibility they have either misinterpreted it or are just being a bit heavy handed/jobsworth then it's worth asking for their decision to be reviewed by someone more senior. Asking for the manager doesn't mean screaming and shouting, I would have done it very politely! If said manager then told me "Yes the cashier is right, although there's no legal restriction or national policy about it our internal store guidance is that we don't sell alcohol to anyone who either looks under 25 or is accompanied by someone under 25" I would think "fair enough, it seems like a ridiculous policy to me but if that's what they are following, that's what they are doing."

However if the manager came and said it was at the cashier's discretion (which I assume will be the case as otherwise nobody shopping with children would ever be able to buy alcohol), then I would ask if they felt the discretion was appropriate in this instance. I'm assuming she doesn't refuse to sell alcohol to every person shopping with a child, so there must have been a reason to say no to OP's DH - which is where the discretion comes in, which can be reviewed.

I've been in the position where I've had to ask for ID for alcohol (cinema I worked in briefly decided we had to ID everyone, no matter their age) and I agree it sucks but I would rather annoy someone than lose my job/be fined. But that's for the person BUYING the alcohol. It would be almost impossible to be successfully prosecuted on the basis that the person you sold it to might then give the age restricted item to someone else, because the prosecutor would somehow have to demonstrate you were aware of the undeclared intent of a 3rd party.

So in cases like OPs I do think the cashier sounds a bit ridiculous/overzealous because the chance that they would have got into trouble for selling alcohol to a man who was clearly (and in her view) OVER 25 just because he happened to be accompanied by someone who might have been younger was close to zero.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/03/2022 22:19

I agree with you OP. I sympathise with the shop staff because I can't imagine there is very clear guidance for them to follow in relation to people being accompanied by possible minors they may possibly be buying for - e.g. if an adult is with a 10 year old presumably it's ok to sell to them but if it's a 13 year old it's not? If they are buying a nice port does that raise fewer alarms than a load of wkds?

I don't see how any kind of consistent policy might be possible with proxy sales. Leaving aside the whole fact that over 5s are allowed to drink alcohol at home anyway, so what could be wrong with an adult parent buying alcohol for their teen to drink later at home; how can you decide whether or not the alcohol is for the child, unless they clearly discuss it or give the game away in the shop?

We've encountered people who gave their 9yo bottles of WKD, because 'it helps to soothe him'; and yet, if he were in a supermarket with a parent buying them for him, I'm guessing most staff would assume he was just there with his mum and not dream the booze was for him.

You could have appallingly irresponsible parents buying alcohol to give to their baby or toddler, and nobody would refuse the sale because they were there with a very young child.

Yet a parent who is in with their 17yo child would likely be prevented from buying - even if it is very much for themselves and the teenager has no interest in the alcohol.

FloBot7 · 18/03/2022 22:18

For those who have no ID because they can't or don't drive, you can buy a PASS card from the post office for £15.

www.postoffice.co.uk/identity/pass-card

Thewindwhispers · 18/03/2022 21:57

Yanbu! I can understand them asking for ID, but don’t see why they couldn’t sell it to DH. That is weird. I never have problem buying alcohol when I’m out with dd. I don’t think the check out person fully understood the rules?

Calandor · 18/03/2022 21:45

And actually I did have someone refuse to sell my mother wine when I was out shopping with her as 'I can't sell it when you're with HER' with a point at me.

I was 21 at the time. I just got my ID and paid for the lot myself.

Calandor · 18/03/2022 21:44

Honestly Check 25 does my head in. I'm used to it at this point as I'm 27 and can never even buy none alcoholic beer without my ID.

The legal age for booze is 18 fgs! And I never had difficulty buying it at under 18 from the dodgy shopkeepers that are everywhere anyway.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 18/03/2022 21:27

@MadameFantabulosa

I really don’t understand this rule, because you can drink alcohol at home if you are over the age of five.
What don't you understand?

There's a big difference between a parent being responsible for giving their child some alcohol at home, and people (friends, strangers etc) buying alcohol specifically for the use of under 18's.

Sleepeatrepeat · 18/03/2022 21:24

Sorry @antisocialsocialclub you are bing unreasonable. The cashier was correct doing her job.

When it was check 18 or 21 it was easier to guess if people were old enough but challenge 25 is so hard.

I am 42. I am fat. I don't look my age (when i have kept up with colouring my grey hair). My friend is 26, she was buying a bottle of wine and was id'd because I was with her and they thought she was OK but I was too young. The bigger irony is I don't drink.

The fine is £10,000 & is personally for the person who made the sale if it goes to court.

Trading standards have and do use underage people as well as people whose age is questionable by a few and a lot of years. They also check for the suspicion of buying for an underage person.

People can and do lose their jobs.

Smile, take it as a compliment and move on

melj1213 · 18/03/2022 21:23

@ihatesoaps

In response to those saying my son can get a provisional licence....he can't as he has epilepsy so will probably never drive.
Then you have to start letting him take his passport out as he is an adult and has to be responsible for his own property. If he loses it then its on him to replace it.
melj1213 · 18/03/2022 21:21

@MadameFantabulosa

I really don’t understand this rule, because you can drink alcohol at home if you are over the age of five.
What you do with the alcohol that I sell you is not my issue as long as I have plausible deniability that allows me to sell the item to you in good faith that it is not being bought for someone underage.

If you buy a bottle of wine and then take it home to share with your 6yo then that's on you and I have done everything legally as I had no way to know you were buying it for your underage child.

However, if you come to my checkout with your wine and say "I'm buying this for my 6 year old" then I no longer have plausible deniability as you have explicitly told me that you are buying an age restricted item for an underage person which then makes the sale illegal as it is a proxy sale.

It's like when people come up to the cigarette and lottery kiosk with their children ... one customer says "Hey Timmy, choose one of these scratchcards for me" and I will happily sell them the scratchcard chosen by the child. The next customer says "Hey Tommy, which scratchcard do you want?" and I can't sell the card chosen by the child as it would be a proxy sale as I have strong reason to belive that the scratchcard is being bought for a child. Two very similar situations but the nuance of the question is what gives me the ability to authorise the sale - the first parent is engaging their child in their decision but the second is asking the child what they want.

TruJay · 18/03/2022 21:18

The stupidest ID incident I had was when me, DH and DS (age 1) were doing a food shop in Morrisons. I needed a new vegetable knife so it was in with the shop. Cashier didn’t even really seem bothered about ages, she said to dh he looked old enough to buy it but said to him “but what is she (pointing at me) going to do with this?” waving the knife. I was taken aback by her tone and all I could think to say was ‘peel potatoes’ Grin as that’s literally what I planned to do with my new veg knife once home, it was very odd!

She gave me a lecture about how dangerous knives can be and are used as weapons etc dh and I were just looking at each other like wtf? It was a bizarre interaction Confused

She sold us the knife though in the end, weird!

MadameFantabulosa · 18/03/2022 21:10

I really don’t understand this rule, because you can drink alcohol at home if you are over the age of five.

HikingforScenery · 18/03/2022 21:10

Someone close to me had to go back and get a wallet to show ID for ‘challenge 25’ to buy non-alchoholic beer. They’re pretty close to 50.

ihatesoaps · 18/03/2022 21:07

It's hard especially as when he was 14/15 he was constantly being charged for adult fares on bus and train...even when he was in school uniform!

WeCouldBeSpearows · 18/03/2022 21:05

@ihatesoaps

In response to those saying my son can get a provisional licence....he can't as he has epilepsy so will probably never drive.
Ah, that is definitely more problematic. Sorry to hear that.
ihatesoaps · 18/03/2022 21:02

In response to those saying my son can get a provisional licence....he can't as he has epilepsy so will probably never drive.

oioimatey · 18/03/2022 20:59

This pisses me off SO MUCH. It's also none of your effing business if I give alcohol to my under 18yo. It's not illegal, it's only illegal to sell it.

I was once in Waitrose buying snails, olives, pâtes, Roquefort and a bottle of pastis. I was ID'd but didn't have my wallet. I was 31. What kind of 17yo buys that stuff? Surely it's proof enough that I'm over 25 Grin

melj1213 · 18/03/2022 20:57

doesn't drive so has no driving licence

I don't drive (no need based on my circumstances) but I still have a driving licence and have done since the day I turned 17 and got my provisional licence, as did most - if not all- of my friends.

Pretty much every 18-25yr old I know has a provisional licence even if they have zero intention of learning to drive because it is the easiest and cheapest way to get valid ID for going out/buying alcohol etc instead of risking losing their passport, which is much more expensive and difficult to replace.

Swipe left for the next trending thread