Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

35 and denied alcohol

258 replies

antisocialsocialclub · 18/03/2022 14:35

Bit of a light hearted one but I am actually annoyed.

Also this isn’t a stealth boast or humble brag at all, because I didn’t come out of this feeling in any way flattered or superior 🤣

I’m 35. I’d like to set the scene by saying I look my age, maybe on a good day I look 30. No way do I look like I’m in my 20s. I definitely look old enough to drink. I have several fine lines and the face a woman of my age has just from existing.

Having a few friends around tonight so just popped out to the shop to get some snacks and a bit of alcohol. I went with DH.

We were at the conveyor belt and the cashier was putting the food through. Then she paused at the alcohol. She looked at DH and then at me and said to me “do you have ID?” I just laughed then realised she was serious. I said I had nothing on me, DH showed his but the cashier said ‘sorry I can’t serve you as I can’t be sure you won’t give the alcohol to points at me’

I laughed and said ‘I’m 35!’ but she wouldn’t budge. I considered asking for the manager but wimped out. Didn’t fancy making a scene for the same outcome.

To cut a long story short, DH had to leave the alcohol because his ‘child bride’ 🤣 left her wallet at home. I actually felt a bit awkward that she thought my 42 year old DH (greying hair and all) was with an under 25 year old. Or did she think I was some street child forcing DH to buy me booze 😊

I know cashiers need to check, I know it’s the law and it’s hard for them etc etc but 1. wow, if she thought I was under 25 I must have had a hard life and 2. I just don’t understand the logic in this situation.

DH was buying the alcohol I was just gormlessly stood with him. What if a parent goes shopping with their underage child and wants to buy a bottle of wine? What they’re saying is you can’t buy alcohol unless everyone accompanying you has ID to confirm legal age?!

I think it’s madness. AIBU?

Also DH has just popped to another shop to get it and I decided I’d stay in the car like a naughty dog 😭 I’m 35!

OP posts:
FloBot7 · 19/03/2022 13:22

Although unlikely to ever be able to prove this is real life, it was the fear of mystery shoppers from the company that we were all afraid of as apparently they would do this to test stores.

My 16 year old cousin took part in a mystery shopping test so your fear is well founded. She could easily pass for over 18. It's so hard with girls these days.

berlinbabylon · 19/03/2022 12:15

Amazon are another who take it too far. The driver if delivering drink, knives, vapes etc have to ask for photo ID regardless

and yet it can't be a requirement for online deliveries because I order wine from other providers and they just leave the boxes at the door if I am not in! I pay by debit, not credit, card, so it's not that I need to be 18 to hold the payment method,, either.

User65412 · 19/03/2022 11:37

I used to work on the checkouts and we were told that if cctv caught a person of age giving alcohol to underage person outside, the store could lose its licence, be fined and we would be dismissed (if we hadn't asked the other person for ID at the checkout). Although unlikely to ever be able to prove this is real life, it was the fear of mystery shoppers from the company that we were all afraid of as apparently they would do this to test stores.
So yes it's OTT but I do understand!

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 19/03/2022 11:29

On the other hand I was once refused an OAP discount on a cinema ticket because the cashier did nt think I looked old enough (I was/am). It was worth agreeing to pay the full price for the lift it gave me all day!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/03/2022 11:28

Except that there are people who have neither a passport nor a driving licence. Forcing anyone clearly over legal age to have one to be able to buy things is ridiculous. When did we start being so afraid of things we stopped using common sense. IDing pensioners for products? What nonsense.

That's a very significant point, actually - a lot of people won't have ID; and of those who do, they may have a driving licence in a purse or wallet close by, but who has their passport to hand at all times when in their own country? If you're clearly over 70, your face is your obvious ID that you carry with you at all times!

I'd be interested to know if it would work the other way as well, if common sense is jettisoned and only ID accepted. If somebody who looked 85 showed you ID that suggested they were 19, would you not think to challenge that? In fact, what would you do if somebody was very clearly about 8 (with voice and mannerisms to match), but had (presumably fake) ID that said they were 19? Are we saying that we don't just accept common sense alone but that, in fact, we deny it completely?

I disagree with a blanket policy of asking everybody, however old, for ID. What would happen if every profession did that and not just shop workers selling booze?

Would you have pensioners out for a walk in the park being stopped to check if their parents know that they're out on their own (which, ironically, they probably wouldn't) and 'just wanting to check that you're safe'?

Bearing in mind that, if an on-duty police officer or other official did see a very young person out alone who later came to harm, whom they hadn't approached or challenged, they could be questioned about their potential dereliction of duty....

As for being asked for proof of age to buy teaspoons and fruit juice, we really must have gone mad. What percentage of teaspoons are used for preparing drugs vs those used for stirring drinks or eating yoghurt? I could probably kill somebody with a big bottle of Coke or a tin of potatoes, should I be so inclined - should we demand proof that the buyer is over 18 to buy these (and also assume, against all proven statistics, that almost all violent acts are perpetrated by children and not adults)?

WeCouldBeSpearows · 19/03/2022 11:08

@BoredZelda

It leaves no room for doubt, no offending people because you did or didn't ID them (I've had both!). Just a straightforward policy of ID is required in order to buy age restricted products.

Except that there are people who have neither a passport nor a driving licence. Forcing anyone clearly over legal age to have one to be able to buy things is ridiculous. When did we start being so afraid of things we stopped using common sense. IDing pensioners for products? What nonsense.

Other ID options are available.

And I have agreed it's a waste of time. But if you risked being disciplined, sacked or fined for not being cautious enough, and risked annoying your customers and getting flack at best and aggression/violence at worst for being too cautious, you might see things differently.

antisocialsocialclub · 19/03/2022 10:57

It leaves no room for doubt, no offending people because you did or didn't ID them (I've had both!). Just a straightforward policy of ID is required in order to buy age restricted products.

That makes sense in my situation if the cashier IDed both my DH and me but she didn’t, she just IDed me.

OP posts:
WeCouldBeSpearows · 19/03/2022 10:55

@BoredZelda

But IDing someone that I know is 22 is also a waste of time and I have to do that too.

That is a misapplication of the policy. The challenge is for anyone you you don’t think is over 25. If you know their age, IDing them is pointless.

I agree it's pointless. But the question was raised and we were advised that we should still ID them as we can't be sure it's not a test purchase by the company.
VampireMoney · 19/03/2022 10:52

@OnaBegonia

Amazon are another who take it too far. The driver if delivering drink, knives, vapes etc have to ask for photo ID regardless, my uncle who is 76(clearly not Benjamin Button) had to dig out his passport to accept some wine. No common sense allowed, they must ID everyone!
I'm clearly over 25 but the Amazon delivery driver refused to give me the bottle of wine I'd bought and paid for. It's all very well saying it covers him, but that item has been paid for by me and him taking it back to his van saying 'no ID no wine' is essentially stealing my goods. I got him back and asked him to call someone in charge, who told him to exercise common sense. It's OBVIOUS when someone is clearly in their forties. If Amazon are going to be pulling stunts like this then they need to ID people BEFORE they allow the purchase to go through not refuse to give them the item at the door! It's just ridiculous. I am blatantly not under 25 and it's not 'flattering' it's bloody annoying.
BoredZelda · 19/03/2022 10:48

But IDing someone that I know is 22 is also a waste of time and I have to do that too.

That is a misapplication of the policy. The challenge is for anyone you you don’t think is over 25. If you know their age, IDing them is pointless.

BoredZelda · 19/03/2022 10:45

It leaves no room for doubt, no offending people because you did or didn't ID them (I've had both!). Just a straightforward policy of ID is required in order to buy age restricted products.

Except that there are people who have neither a passport nor a driving licence. Forcing anyone clearly over legal age to have one to be able to buy things is ridiculous. When did we start being so afraid of things we stopped using common sense. IDing pensioners for products? What nonsense.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 19/03/2022 09:42

The majority of teenagers in Scotland have ID, in the form of a Young Scot card (which is acceptable as proof of age, as well as getting them discounts and free bus travel).

I don't know the situation elsewhere.

IwaswhoIam · 19/03/2022 09:37

When I was 27 I got asked for ID at sainsburys for buying ibuprofen. I had no ID as I was just popping in. The lady serving me told me I need to be 16 to buy it and anyone looking under 18 gets ID’d. I was like wtf? Do 16 year olds even have ID 😂 . I had to walk out empty handed and feeling stupid . That was 10 years ago .

WeCouldBeSpearows · 19/03/2022 09:34

@OnaBegonia

You think asking a clearly over 70 yr old for ID is a good use of someone's time? The person is clearly not under 25 😄 I think it's laughable.
I totally agree that it's a waste of time.

But IDing someone that I know is 22 is also a waste of time and I have to do that too.

Getting rid of the 25 cut off for IDing people means that everyone buying age restricted products are treated exactly the same, and everyone will know that they need to take their ID. Therefore getting rid of any grey areas and making everyone's job easier.

Briony123 · 19/03/2022 09:34

I genuinely think some staff don't understand that the legal age for buying alcohol is 18. They brought in the 25/30 rule because it is difficult for older people to tell the age of younger people. But I've had staff agree that I don't look under 18 but, pointing furiously at their badge, I do look under 30 and so they can't serve me. This has only happened in village shops.

girlmom21 · 19/03/2022 09:32

@OnaBegonia

You think asking a clearly over 70 yr old for ID is a good use of someone's time? The person is clearly not under 25 😄 I think it's laughable.
They take a photo of it though don't they to protect themselves and prove delivery?
CheekySwifter · 19/03/2022 09:28

The fact is that a. The server (likely on minimum wage) is at risk of being fined personally if you are a secret shopper and b. The manager must uphold the cashiers request for ID and therefore that would have been a pointless route to go down anyway.

OnaBegonia · 19/03/2022 09:20

You think asking a clearly over 70 yr old for ID is a good use of someone's time? The person is clearly not under 25 😄 I think it's laughable.

girlmom21 · 19/03/2022 09:12

@OnaBegonia

Amazon are another who take it too far. The driver if delivering drink, knives, vapes etc have to ask for photo ID regardless, my uncle who is 76(clearly not Benjamin Button) had to dig out his passport to accept some wine. No common sense allowed, they must ID everyone!
Most Amazon drivers do completely adhoc, self-employed work. It's the best way to protect everyone.
WeCouldBeSpearows · 19/03/2022 09:08

@OnaBegonia

Amazon are another who take it too far. The driver if delivering drink, knives, vapes etc have to ask for photo ID regardless, my uncle who is 76(clearly not Benjamin Button) had to dig out his passport to accept some wine. No common sense allowed, they must ID everyone!
As a shop worker, I think this is the best approach.

It leaves no room for doubt, no offending people because you did or didn't ID them (I've had both!). Just a straightforward policy of ID is required in order to buy age restricted products.

OnaBegonia · 19/03/2022 09:04

Amazon are another who take it too far. The driver if delivering drink, knives, vapes etc have to ask
for photo ID regardless, my uncle who is 76(clearly not Benjamin Button) had to dig out his passport to accept some wine. No common sense allowed, they must ID everyone!

alexdgr8 · 19/03/2022 05:39

[quote FloBot7]For those who have no ID because they can't or don't drive, you can buy a PASS card from the post office for £15.

www.postoffice.co.uk/identity/pass-card[/quote]
that's v useful to know. thank you.

alexdgr8 · 19/03/2022 05:25

@ihatesoaps

My 18 year old son is always ID'ed. He has no form of ID other than a passport....and I don't like him taking it out with him when he goes out with his mates (who are all 18) When he was at school he had no educational ID/ NUS card, doesn't drive so has no driving licence, and he has a beard.... He looks the oldest of all his mates - in fact he IS the oldest! Pubs locally also won't take a citizen card as too many variants and fakes on the market....

I feel so sorry for him as it's really hard!

why doesn't he apply for a provisional driving licence. would that be acceptable ID ? how does he open a bank account ?
wineosaurus4 · 19/03/2022 02:57

Well a few weeks ago I got ID'd in Morrisons.. for a non alcoholic mocktail can. I am 31 and also 30 weeks pregnant. Give me strength!!

Momijin · 19/03/2022 02:37

@endofthelinefinally

There is a period during which you can't take any family member between the ages of about 12 and 23 with you to do the shopping if you intend to buy any alcohol. They won't sell it to you because you might be buying it for the young person. It has happened to me and to several of my friends. Really annoying if you just want a bottle of wine for a gift, or a dinner invite.
Yes that's ridiculous. My then 19 year old niece unloaded some of my shopping including a bottle of wine. Because she didn't have id, I wasn't allowed to buy it. So now when I go shopping with my kids they know not to touch the wine.
Swipe left for the next trending thread