Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should i consent for my child's images to be used in research?

63 replies

SmallMexicanChihuahua · 18/03/2022 14:11

My 8-week-old son is currently being treated in hospital for an infection. It's apparently very rare and the doctors here have never treated this type of infection in a baby.

Yesterday the consultants were around to discuss treatment and asked if I'd be happy for images of the infected area (his head) to be added to his record and shared with obstetricians to help in future cases like this. I said yes, naively assuming that it would only be at a local level.

They've now brought a consent form for me to sign and they've pre-ticked all 3 areas of consent for using the images:

  • as part of his records;
  • for medical teaching, e.g. lectures, exhibitions, medical videos;
  • for publication in textbooks, journals, medical articles or on the internet.

I looked up the doctor whom I'd be giving this consent, and his name is already on several articles where I can see photos of the children subject of the article: only a small black rectangle is used to cover the eyes but otherwise all features visible.

I'm now not sure if I want to consent to this. Most of the images (they asked for photos from our devices, they haven't actually taken their own as far as I know) include my son's face. I don't know if he'd be ok with this when he grows up, he may feel we've betrayed him by consenting to this. I feel uneasy that this wasn't properly discussed with me and that the form has been pre-ticked so that I consent to all options. Looking back I remember how the (otherwise lovely) doctor urged us to take photos as the events were progressing and now I can't help but think that he was doing this with his research article in mind. I do have an unresolved trauma after being tricked and harmed by a doctor so I might be overreacting. I do want to help people who find themselves in this position in future but it just feels too much right now.
What would you do? AIBU to be concerned about how my son's photos would be used?

OP posts:
NiceTwin · 18/03/2022 17:43

I wouldn't hesitate at all.
I am part of a large research study and have been for 30 years.
If anything they find out from me goes part way to helping somebody else in the future, I will be thrilled.

Soubriquet · 18/03/2022 17:37

I would. Baby photos rarely look like them when they are older

Yogagrandmum · 18/03/2022 17:36

My daughter had loads of pictures taken for research and training. I never gave it a second thought…

EpidermolysisBullosa · 18/03/2022 17:33

I have a rare condition and have allowed photographs of myself to be used by doctors in this way, although in my case it was photos of my feet so being identified was very unlikely.

I wasn't diagnosed until in my 20s, I'd been to the GP about my blistering but EB is so rare they didn't know about it so couldn't consider it as a cause and I was told it must be because of my eczema. It was by seeing pictures of people online with EB years later when I googled chronic blistering that made me realise that is what I had and got me my referral, genetic testing and diagnosis.

So I think images are helpful to share but only if you want to - don't feel you have to unless you're comfortable with it. They can always be shared at a later stage if you or he wants to do so.

Warszawa · 18/03/2022 17:29

If you don't feel ok with it then don't op, if you are thinking it's something you'll regret and bring up past issues then I'd advise you to not.

Sorry to hear about your experience but to be fair this could be something good that comes out of a bad situation for you and your son.

Regardless of what you choose to do I hope your little one gets better soon

MayMorris · 18/03/2022 17:10

I had an enormous lipoma on my lower back/bum. I had photos taken in the hospitals rather swanky photo studio. They needed them for planning the operation but asked to keep for research. My bum and overweight tummy and huge growth now embarrassingly immortalised. I figure if some poor sods lipoma grows in same place and size then their surgeons welcome to compare notes and photos.
They did a fine job removing it by the way!

user1471530109 · 18/03/2022 16:59

I consented to my DD being photographed. They thought she had a rare condition (although clinically diagnosed at the time, they seem less sure now).

They will most likely take their own photos. I had to take her to the teaching side of the hospital which I didn't even know existed. It was like a mini school/uni! She was photographed in a room that was clearly for this purpose. I did it to help future generations of children. She was under 1 at the time.

elliejjtiny · 18/03/2022 16:54

2 of my sons images were used for similar reasons when they were babies (now aged 8 and 14).

Ragwort · 18/03/2022 16:50

Depending on the actual condition you might have no choice but to photograph the whole head and face. Confused

Goldbar · 18/03/2022 15:25

I would provided that it was completely anonymised and the shots were close-ups of the infected area and not the whole face so that my child couldn't be identified from the pictures. I think showing the entire face/head area is wrong.

I would also be uneasy from what you've described.

parietal · 18/03/2022 15:00

I would consent. when the eyes are blanked out and the child has changed a lot it is fine.

Jellycatrabbit · 18/03/2022 14:59

Looking back I remember how the (otherwise lovely) doctor urged us to take photos as the events were progressing and now I can't help but think that he was doing this with his research article in mind

I had to keep a photo diary of my dc in order for the doctor to be able to diagnose a progressive condition. I think this is a more likely reason for the request, to support a diagnosis.

That said, if you aren't comfortable, decline permission. Or select a very few photos that you are comfortable sharing.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 18/03/2022 14:48

Surely raising awareness and allowing medics to increase their knowledge about your son’s condition is beneficial for other sufferers? Medical research is incredibly important, they are helping your son using knowledge they have learned from other children. No one but those with an interest in the field will see the pictures and they will be interested in the condition, not the child per se

Ragwort · 18/03/2022 14:46

I would (& did) my DS was born with a rare medical condition which was corrected by surgery, I am so grateful to previous generations who allowed photographs so that surgeons and medical professionals could learn how to treat the condition. It was 21 years ago .... I doubt anyone would recognise my DS from those photos!

PeterPomegranate · 18/03/2022 14:45

I might consent but YANBU for thinking the possible uses weren’t fully explained to you. You don’t have to consent if you don’t feel comfortable. That’s a good enough reason.

Elsiebear90 · 18/03/2022 14:45

So I had a rare skin disorder as a child, they took pictures of me and my mum agreed for them to be used in medical literature, I’m now 31 and it doesn’t bother me at all. It’s all anonymised anyway, so no one would have a clue it’s your son.

Knittedfairies · 18/03/2022 14:45

I would consent. Your son's treatment may be as a result of other parents consenting to be part of earlier research.

Star81 · 18/03/2022 14:45

Honestly, out of my childrens photos at 8 weeks old I struggle to remember which is which so I don’t think he would be identified from them in the future. If you did tell him about them I’m sure he would be proud to have helped in medical studies that may help others in the future.

betwixtlives · 18/03/2022 14:44

all babies look the same at that age, it’s not like he’ll be recognised in the future and even if he is, why does it matter?

Shiningpath · 18/03/2022 14:43

Who is going to recognise your son, a baby, in twenty years’ time? Instead of feeling betrayed he might feel proud that he helped move medical science forward and helped countless other children.

Sirzy · 18/03/2022 14:42

And most importantly I hope he is on the mend and home soon

Sirzy · 18/03/2022 14:42

Ds was ill At 8 weeks and the photos of him them don’t look like him now at 12 at all so I doubt anyone would link them back to him at all.

If your not happy then don’t consent but things like this can be very useful in influencing future treatments and knowledge

notanothertakeaway · 18/03/2022 14:42

Assuming that the child wouldn't be named, I think this is fine

SevenWaystoLeave · 18/03/2022 14:40

You could explain you're happy for the first two but not the last, and ask for a new form so you can tick what you're happy with yourself.

YANBU whatever your choice, it's entirely up to you what you're comfortable with

Clymene · 18/03/2022 14:39

I would absolutely do it. His name won't be attached to the photos and they will learn so much.

And I can promise you that most people are completely incapable of linking a photo of a baby with its grown up self

Swipe left for the next trending thread