Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to give people free advice?

289 replies

PretZubscription · 18/03/2022 12:44

I work in the legal sector, studied Law at both undergrad and postgrad level and I am hoping to work towards becoming a barrister.

Since starting my undergrad Law degree I have always had people (family & friends) reach out to me to ask for advice. I have always tried to answer their questions based on what I know but warned them I am not a professional. Since gaining my current position I now specialise in a certain area of Law that a lot of people are wanting advice in. I don’t mind people asking me the odd question here and there but I am increasingly getting messages asking for advice and even people asking if I will meet them. I have told these people that I can’t do that and it’s constantly been met with “it’s not really legal advice I just wanted to meet for a coffee and a chat”.

I work very long hours. Sometimes I’m working 14+ hour days going over massive amounts of paperwork and I come home with my brain frazzled. I want to be able to switch off when I finish work and not constantly be asked my professional opinion. I have friends who are hair dressers and I wouldn’t ask them to do my hair for free, so to me this feels like the same thing. However, there is a part of me that’s thinking well it’s not like I’m doing their paperwork and legal advice is more important than that so should I be giving these people some time? A lot of the people who are asking my opinion are not well off and would probably struggle to afford professional advice so I’m not sure what to do. I obviously don’t want their lives to be negatively impacted by not gaining appropriate advice but if I did it for one person, how many would I be meeting? I’m not a charity Sad As I said, I don’t mind answering messages here and there or even pointing people towards a solicitor in that area but suddenly it feels like a lot. I’m on a salary right now so even if I was giving these people advice through work I wouldn’t be paid any extra for it.

So AIBU to not want to give advice to these people? And if I am please can you help me come up with a reply because I just keep being met with “I only wanted a coffee and a chat” when I tell them I can’t meet up with them and give them legal advice.

OP posts:
PretZubscription · 18/03/2022 14:59

Thank you for all of your advice, it has been very helpful and I’m reading all of it. I just wanted to reiterate, I don’t think I’m being a bad friend or unhelpful. I don’t mind messages like “can I take the children away without other parents permission” as the guidance on that is usually straight forward and I am also more than happy to recommend qualified legal professionals who I think would be helpful when people ask. Obviously if I thought a friend/close family member was in trouble I would try my best to help them whilst making sure they had the best qualified professional advising them.

The issue is some people (who admittedly are not very close friends) are messaging me disclosing some very personal stuff and there’s no GDPR in place to cover this. Likewise, the guys who have messaged regarding having contact taken away, there could be a very good reason for this and I would hate to accidentally aide someone who is abusive.

There is always more to the story than a client tells you and until you have all of the paperwork, statements and evidence to read you don’t have a clear picture and to advise friends without this could be very dangerous as I could give some bad advice, not to mention I’m not even fully qualified! I would also hate for something to backfire and sound like my own personal opinion if someone was like well Pret told me to do this if I was advising on options within the law.

I do think telling me to get over myself is a bit harsh when I am trying my best to set up boundaries but constantly being messaged and nervous to attend social events because everyone has a situation they need advising on! It’s not like I’m getting a few comments from people in passing, I am being contacted by multiple acquaintances all of the time who won’t take no for answer. I will be pulling my pants up from now on though and telling people I just can’t do that.

OP posts:
WatermelonRed · 18/03/2022 14:58

Definitely not being unreasonable! My husband has this (different area of work though) and it’s so cheeky the the type of things people ask him for as if it’s no big deal. Always for free as well no matter its advice/help/actual work being done.

Fluxcapacitator · 18/03/2022 14:58

I'm also a 'legal professional ' working in a pretty useful every day area. No one ever asks for my advice. Even my mother who was dealing with a stressful situation involving my exact speciality didn't ask or listen to me. I am worried I give off an air of complete incompetence.

hidethetoaster · 18/03/2022 14:58

Don't even respond to the 2 former male colleagues. They don't sound like they are in your close circle. Just ignore.

You have been kind and helpful until now and set a bit of a precedent. For all the practical reasons you have outlined, this needs to stop now.

You're going to need to develop a polite but firm way to say no. Maybe people you are genuinely close to warrant a bit of your time. But only people in your circle of trust. Ask yourself if each person would willingly sacrifice their evening or weekend to help you with your troubles?

It's hard when you work in an emotive sector but the way you're working isn't sustainable.

Is fine to not respond to people who aren't in your circle. If they ask and you respond to say no, then you've opened a dialogue. You have to ignore.

Daftasabroom · 18/03/2022 14:50

Hi OP, another consulting professional here (engineering) I have no idea how many people have asked me "could you have a look at my ....." Or "do I need a steel joist if I knock a wall down?"

YANBU

imisscashmere · 18/03/2022 14:48

As others have said in one way or another, you need to formulate an effective stock answer and trot it out every time this happens.

You really should not be giving off the record advice.

Flyinggeese1234 · 18/03/2022 14:45

Hi OP my friend has a hair salon and I actively avoid mentioning hair in any context. But one thing I’ve noticed she does is said very lightheartedly something like ‘I love my job but outside of work I can’t even THINK about hair, it’s what I do all day ha ha’.

Maybe something along those lines? Or ‘I’ve promised myself a better work life balance so don’t do anything work related outside of hours anymore. Not even casual. I know you’ll understand, I’m done in after 14 hours and need to keep things separate.’

Anyone who doesn’t immediately back down would be very unreasonable.

BeastOfBODMAS · 18/03/2022 14:44

If you wanted to help people in a compartmentalised way without it taking over your leisure time, perhaps you could volunteer a day a month/quarter with CAB or a relevant charity. Anyone who wants free advice could be invited to come along on that day. If they can’t be bothered (and they mostly won’t) then they don’t need your help that badly!

tkwal · 18/03/2022 14:42

I believe Dr's get this a lot too. And no, you shouldn't be giving your advice to people you have just met for coffee and a chat. You need to be able to leave work behind and enjoy your down time or you will burn yourself out. Friends will understand

FoxInABox · 18/03/2022 14:40

This applies to so many areas of work- we have had a transport company, and would constantly be asked by friends and even friends of friends to borrow vans, including one person who wanted to take the van to Scotland to camp for a week - this is a van used daily for work that they expected us to lose money on whilst we insured it etc- or for us to give up our time & use our vans to move furniture/move whole houses/go the tip etc. We have also had taxis and the same applied then- ‘I’d rather give the money to you’ which quickly turned in to them jumping out saying thanks for the lift and not paying, or in another case which was a long journey which we were doing for 50% of the going rate- so basically just covering petrol as it was a family member- they then with no discussion dropped down to 25% of the going rate, so not only were we doing the job for free but we were paying towards the fuel cost ourselves. That one was tough as I had no choice but to say we couldn’t do it anymore and why, and was then met with ‘we would never take advantage’! We now make up excuses why we can’t help most times, unless it’s very close family/friends. It’s a bit trickier when it’s advice and you’re with them but some of the pp replies sound great.

UniversalAunt · 18/03/2022 14:36

@PretZubscriptionPretZubscription, firstly YANBU.

It is great to read how heartily you are committed to your career & specialism, & you come across a thoroughly decent & helpful person.

However, you are only human with x amount of energy for y number of people & z amount of goodwill, not to mention the everyday matter of hours in the day, your need for R&R & a personal life. You need string boundaries as your knowledge & goodwill means that you are always in demand, same as medical & IT folk.

Were you so inclined, might you pull together a single page crib sheet of the top five FAQs that you are asked & a few useful links or helplines? A small file that you can email or ping over to someone who asks you for a favour. You will know far better than I do about any phrasing & disclaimers that say anything more complex than this requires a consultation with a professional lawyer & here is the link to the CAB/ Law Society search engine (i.e. not me).

As I have said recently on MN, consulting a lawyer for advice might be the best money ever spent & foregoing some discretionary spend for this is well worth it. I think that sometimes people don’t understand that advice does not cost anywhere near as much instructing a solicitor to act on the client’s behalf or representation in court. Advice upfront can save a world of bother & unnecessary legal expenses later on.

milkyaqua · 18/03/2022 14:35

The awful part is, when you do give free advice they usually ignore it, are not particularly grateful for the hour(s) you've spent on them, and then want more! Nip it in the bud; develop a policy and an easy to remember catchphrase.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 18/03/2022 14:34

@BloodyN0rah

Not at all unreasonable, I think I’d have a cut and paste response ready saying that as you work long hours you’ve decided to prioritise your mental health and not offer legal advice in your leisure time but you’re happy to point them in the right direction. There more you do it the more people will expect it, I’ve learnt the hard way that people don’t value stuff that’s free.
Oh, I think that’s a bit wanker-ish. Just say your professional busy doesn’t permit you to give advice outside your chambers / whatever
Teddansononmyown · 18/03/2022 14:32

Sorry but my case load is full at the moment. If you want a consultation I'd be happy to put you on my billable client list.

If you go for coffee and chat and they slip it in...

Afraid I can't give any advice without knowing full facts as its each case on its own merits. I'd hate to give you the wrong advice...if you want to come in for a consultation...as above.

There is always going to be an element of 'can I just ask a quick question?' I'm usually happy to do this for a friend (as in giving steers to good providers, services etc) and will do mate's rates for some, but I'm not working for free!

INeedNewShoes · 18/03/2022 14:32

Not quite the same as I don't risk my career by giving advice free of charge but it's similar as a musician.

'I'm sure you'd love to come and play the piano for the playgroup singsong as it'll be such fun. Oh no, we don't have the funds to pay anyone'

'I've written some songs - I'd love for you to listen to them and advise me on how to get them published. You could even orchestrate them as I know that would be fun for you.'

'Aunty INeedNewShoes would love to do your piano practice with you Pandora'

No I wouldn't and now that DD is school age this shit is happening more and more.

Grumpy, me? Yes I am!

godmum56 · 18/03/2022 14:29

@2bazookas

Get over yourself.

Every professional or expert- trade gets their ear bent while off-duty. It comes with the territory.

As a highly trained expert "whatever", you're expected to be good at PR /customer relations and know how to deflect unwanted trade.

If you don't know how , just ask any prostitute/ washing machine engineer/doctor.

and which one are you?
godmum56 · 18/03/2022 14:27

@DelphiniumBlue

Tell them you are not insured and therefore not able to advice outside your employed work. TBH it is dangerous for you to do so - you will not have all the necessary info in front of you, and may give wrong or negligent advice, for which you will be legally responsible. You can say "it's not my area, and I don't want to give misleading advice", you can refer them to Citizen's Advice or to professional colleagues. But you should not be giving advice in a situation where you are not covered by insurance should things go tits up! Stick to your guns. Just say no.
This. Even "coffee and a chat" stuff can rebound because its like any other regulated profession, you can't take it off like a hat and not "be" a professional when you are giving profession related advice. Its the same as confidentiality, it doesn't end at the office door.
Fluffycloudland77 · 18/03/2022 14:26

There’s no point doing the training to dole out free advice that could land you in trouble if it’s wrong.

Crimeismymiddlename · 18/03/2022 14:24

My legal professional father used to answer all requests for advice with ‘that is not my area of expertise’ worked a treat.

keysonthetable · 18/03/2022 14:24

They can either afford the advice, in which case have a name or two handy to pass to them,
or
they can't afford the advice so directing them to their nearest Citizens Advice Bureau might be a way out.

GnomeDePlume · 18/03/2022 14:23

Someone I knew was constantly claiming he had had legal advice about XYZ topic (relating to property rights). This 'legal advice' was from a solicitor he occasionally met while shooting. I'm sure the solicitor would have been horrified if he realised that his idle conversation with a random was being claimed as actual advice.

Gonnagetgoing · 18/03/2022 14:22

@2bazookas

Get over yourself.

Every professional or expert- trade gets their ear bent while off-duty. It comes with the territory.

As a highly trained expert "whatever", you're expected to be good at PR /customer relations and know how to deflect unwanted trade.

If you don't know how , just ask any prostitute/ washing machine engineer/doctor.

@2bazookas - it's a bit different asking a professional, trade etc for advice.

Most professions e.g. accountants would say to come and see them as a client.

If you ask e.g. a washing machine engineer advice then if they're seeing you they may/will give you advice.

A doctor is different if you're seeing them, but if you ask them about a matter for which you'll need a referral of course they'll say that.

Professional advice which requires proper attention and care - accountancy/tax/legal - should always be handled on a client basis.

OP also I should imagine especially as not qualified yet, doesn't want to scare off potential clients so is trying to find a way to deflect politely but not put potential clients off.

SarahBellam · 18/03/2022 14:22

@2bazookas

Get over yourself.

Every professional or expert- trade gets their ear bent while off-duty. It comes with the territory.

As a highly trained expert "whatever", you're expected to be good at PR /customer relations and know how to deflect unwanted trade.

If you don't know how , just ask any prostitute/ washing machine engineer/doctor.

Are you on glue?
SucculentChalice · 18/03/2022 14:19

I think you have to prepare a stock of excuse sentences and wheel them out so you don't get drawn in. e.g. "Sorry, but I don't anything about that, it isn't my field at all, you need a specialist".

Its awful. Everyone I know hates it but still people ask.

Don't you know that lawyers, even students, are meant to provide a free of charge, available at all hours, legal advice service on every single legal topic under then sun, running the risk of not being covered by insurance and being sued by them if you get it wrong?

Its usually the people who wouldn't dream of giving you their services free of charge either. Case in point are my PIL who changed their mind about letting me stay in their mostly empty holiday home and made me get an Air BnB in the same area, who have had several thousands pounds worth of free advice on complex subject matters over the years. They are a prime example of the type. I am now no contact.

WomanStanleyWoman · 18/03/2022 14:19

In one of the later Adrian Mole books, he asks an accountant friend for advice, but when he tells him to book an appointment, Adrian says ‘Can’t we just have a chat?’

His reply is ‘Accountancy ain’t my hobby, Moley’. I think that sums it up!

Swipe left for the next trending thread