Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to give people free advice?

289 replies

PretZubscription · 18/03/2022 12:44

I work in the legal sector, studied Law at both undergrad and postgrad level and I am hoping to work towards becoming a barrister.

Since starting my undergrad Law degree I have always had people (family & friends) reach out to me to ask for advice. I have always tried to answer their questions based on what I know but warned them I am not a professional. Since gaining my current position I now specialise in a certain area of Law that a lot of people are wanting advice in. I don’t mind people asking me the odd question here and there but I am increasingly getting messages asking for advice and even people asking if I will meet them. I have told these people that I can’t do that and it’s constantly been met with “it’s not really legal advice I just wanted to meet for a coffee and a chat”.

I work very long hours. Sometimes I’m working 14+ hour days going over massive amounts of paperwork and I come home with my brain frazzled. I want to be able to switch off when I finish work and not constantly be asked my professional opinion. I have friends who are hair dressers and I wouldn’t ask them to do my hair for free, so to me this feels like the same thing. However, there is a part of me that’s thinking well it’s not like I’m doing their paperwork and legal advice is more important than that so should I be giving these people some time? A lot of the people who are asking my opinion are not well off and would probably struggle to afford professional advice so I’m not sure what to do. I obviously don’t want their lives to be negatively impacted by not gaining appropriate advice but if I did it for one person, how many would I be meeting? I’m not a charity Sad As I said, I don’t mind answering messages here and there or even pointing people towards a solicitor in that area but suddenly it feels like a lot. I’m on a salary right now so even if I was giving these people advice through work I wouldn’t be paid any extra for it.

So AIBU to not want to give advice to these people? And if I am please can you help me come up with a reply because I just keep being met with “I only wanted a coffee and a chat” when I tell them I can’t meet up with them and give them legal advice.

OP posts:
TheBigDilemma · 18/03/2022 17:11

Yep, everybody gets a bit of it. I get offers to work for free all the time. Apparently, it is for my own benefit, it would help me if I add it to my CV! Grin

RealBecca · 18/03/2022 17:03

I'd just say even things that look simple can be incredibly complex and I cant give you good advice without all the details. I'd hate to charge you but I'm not insured to practice without a paid contract in place/its instant dismissal from my employer/some other excuse.

Dixiechickonhols · 18/03/2022 17:02

Solicitor here. Be less open about what area you specialise in. Be firmer Op. Not my area. Not covered by insurance. You can recommend a colleague or firm to assist.
Remember recent case of architect who gave free garden design advice being sued by her ex neighbours (she was ultimately not liable but massively stressful/exp for her no doubt)
I learnt lesson newly qualified. We were on a high street, local business owners would pop in for a ‘chat’ with my boss (free advice). He spent ages talking to chippy man. Later he went into chippy ordering fish & peas paid (you think man would have said on the house) then boss says oh can you put me a few chips in and he charged boss 20p extra. He’s has a few hundred pounds of free advice! Really hit home to me how people are.

AcrossthePond55 · 18/03/2022 16:58

I'd always say "I will lose my job if I give advice out of working hours. It's one of the conditions of my employment". It usually worked since pretty much no one would want you to lose your job.

In my case, it was true. Civil Service, not allowed to advise or help people I knew in any way with issues involving my agency. But I'd think it'd work for a solicitor/barrister-in-training, too.

Supersimkin2 · 18/03/2022 16:49

Editor here. People think nothing of dumping 600-pp of closely typed memoir that starts ‘Got up. had breakfast’ on you, or worse, on your family who think publishing is ‘nice reading books all day.’

Get skilled at the educated handoff - tell them where to ring and when.

berlinbabylon · 18/03/2022 16:46

That's the point though. These friends put you in touch with someone who could help. They could not help themselves and you had to pay in the end ofr proper advice. I used to say 'I cannot help you because - but here are the details of those who can

that's just good networking - we all (should) do that - point people in the direction of others who may be able to help them (not just law, but anything)

FancyAFlapjack · 18/03/2022 16:45
  1. People are CFs.
  2. People have no clue of the risks they are asking you to take.

I'm a doctor. I've lost count of the number of people who have asked me to "take a quick look at my mole". They get pissed off when I say no, because "It would only take you a second". Sure, but if I say it's OK and it's a melanoma, that mistake could cost you your life, and me my career.

I am always happy to advise friends and family (though not CFs at parties), how to get medical advice for an issue. I will not give medical advice, unless it's a genuine emergency, in which case I will usually be sending them to A&E!

SnowWhiteLobelia · 18/03/2022 16:44

[quote itsabouttimetoo]@SnowWhiteLobelia agreed![/quote]
:)

My former boss (and equity partner of my former firm) tried to do a favour for a friend and bypassed our specialist team to do what appeared to him to be a run of the mill set of documents in a completely different area of law. Ballsed it up and when i quit that job the resulting negligience claim was just getting started.

blanketbag · 18/03/2022 16:43

I have a professional qualification. My local area has a Facebook group and I've lost count of the number of times someone has asked if there is someone of that profession able to answer a 'quick question' or have a chat or similar. Sometimes remuneration isn't mentioned at all, sometimes they'll offer a pint in exchange. One person even offered to cook a meal in exchange. It really annoys me. Why do they think that just because I live by them, they shouldn't have to pay for my knowledge and expertise. I don't think they'd ask for an electrician to come and help them for free but I do wonder whether because for me it would just be time and thought rather than anything tangible, they don't value it as much. Drives me potty!

berlinbabylon · 18/03/2022 16:43

I get this as a lawyer too. And even worse, my mum gets "could your daughter help me" from her friends and my dad was always annoyed I wouldn't do his conveyancing for him.

I do sometimes butt in on social media (including here) when I see people posting rubbish though and will say it's not correct and point people towards reputable websites for accurate guidance.

Rosenspants · 18/03/2022 16:42

Wry smile at this thread. Like pp I am also HPC worker. I make a general comment, like “yes that can be difficult” or “yes it can be complex”. If they persist I say “You can ask for a referral via etc etc” and like pp I say straight out that I don’t do voluntary work. Once a friend asked me to see a member of their family privately. After the consultation, they showed me out hastily. They never spoke to me again after I sent my invoice. There seems to be blurred lines between friends and business. Never mix the two if you can help it. Some people consider it a chat amongst friends. Some don’t want or intend to pay.

Coffeetree · 18/03/2022 16:36

I have very strong boundaries and not giving legal advice. If people seriously want/need advice they'll instruct. It's not about money, it's about doing it properly.

That said, I've fallen out quite serwith someone I considered a good friend. She suddenly sent me some very specific legal questions and made out that they were for a person she was trying to help as a favour. I asked more info and she sort of giggled and confessed it was for her husband's firm! Haven't spoken to her since.

JudgeJ · 18/03/2022 16:33

It’s the same as doctors - a friend of mine is a dermatologist and now lies at parties otherwise people whip off their tops and ask her to look at a dodgy mole.

As an ex teacher I always found that the medical profession were among the quickest to slag teachers off in one breath then seek advice about little Johnny's reading in the other.
I was once berated by a Vicar's wife about school hours and holidays yet she was appalled when I pointed out that her husband did an hour on Sunday morning and the odd hatched, matched and dispatched.

bobthebuilderofstars · 18/03/2022 16:33

I know someone who got a friend's dad to do their conveyancing, even though he didn't usually cover property law.

He didn't notice that the original owner kept the access to the property (or similar). Right royally stuffed them up!

OP find a phrase you like. Then repeat it in from of the mirror 10 times.

"sorry, can't help, as I am not insured yet. Happy to take you on as a client though when I am qualified. I'll give you the first 10 mins free'.

CF them right back.

itsabouttimetoo · 18/03/2022 16:32

@SnowWhiteLobelia agreed!

SnowWhiteLobelia · 18/03/2022 16:27

We are arguing the same point @itsabouttimetoo

itsabouttimetoo · 18/03/2022 16:26

@SnowWhiteLobelia without going into detail, I did get help from the people I was in contact with which led me to the right person - not one of them turned round and said “I can’t help because I’m not on the clock” - the actual full legal support was paid for, hence why I included it, but I wouldn’t have known who to approach and with what had I not been given advice by other friends. All of them have actually followed up to check on me and the case since. My point is that you can set a limit for the advice that you give - but there are plenty of lawyers who do probono work that isn’t full legal advice (and plenty who do too!)

SnowWhiteLobelia · 18/03/2022 16:25

-body

SnowWhiteLobelia · 18/03/2022 16:25

The thing is too, with regulated professions, is that you are seriously screwed if you offer advice that is not backed up by a client - professional relationshoip complete with a contract. It's really not worth some random family member or friend thinking it's really simple and not understanding that you might be in breach of your professional body regulations and vulnerable to all sorts, and losing your job, your livelihood and your repution. Most of our trade boy magazines are filled with disciplinary tribunal reports of people doing just that.

Pluvia · 18/03/2022 16:21

I feel your pain, OP. I work in the construction sector and run my own small company. I get phone calls on Saturday evenings from friends of friends of friends who just want a chat with me about... People have no boundaries.

SnowWhiteLobelia · 18/03/2022 16:21

@itsabouttimetoo

I’m coming from a slightly different approach here but I was recently in a situation where a lawyer was needed urgently. I’m a savvy person, have a professional career and can usually figure out most things but finding someone in the right area of law was incredibly difficult. Had the lawyers I approached turned round and said to me “I’m not on the clock” things would have turned out very differently. Instead each of them generously put me in contact with someone who could help me and eventually an acquaintance agreed to take on the case (at cost of course). There are plenty of people - refugees, vulnerable people who wouldn’t even know where to start, it’s a minefield out there and had I not had those contacts things would have turned out very differently and I am eternally grateful for all of their support.

You are not a qualified lawyer so it’s slightly different, but could you set aside maybe an hour a week to offer probono work when you are - and by probono that could mean putting people in touch with the right people. That way you could factor it into your hours and not end up overwhelmed?

As other people have pointed out, most people in an area of skill (myself included) have given up their free time to help others in their hour of need. It just depends on you how much time you’re willing to give.

Good luck OP !

That's the point though. These friends put you in touch with someone who could help. They could not help themselves and you had to pay in the end ofr proper advice. I used to say 'I cannot help you because - but here are the details of those who can'.

That is what the OP should do. She literally cannot help unless she wants to be disbarred before she is even barred.

gingerhills · 18/03/2022 16:18

I work in a profession where 'friends' are constantly asking me to 'just take a quick look at' something which would entail hours of scrutiny. I once had an extremely close friend who should know better ask me to look at a 100k word document and then got offended when I said I couldn't do so for at least a month. She truly thought i should and could just drop my paid work ad family commitments to give her my unpaid, uninterrupted attention for the next few days with no warning.

Most of the time I just say no.

You can pre-empt it a bit by being very vocal about awful people who ask you for a 'coffee and a chat' assuming your very sparse hours of free time should be taken up giving them free professional advice.

Just learn to say, 'Sorry but I get asked several times a week and if I went for all the 'little chats over coffee' people asked me for, I'd be wired, so I have ot be fair and say no to everyone.'

itsabouttimetoo · 18/03/2022 16:17

I’m coming from a slightly different approach here but I was recently in a situation where a lawyer was needed urgently. I’m a savvy person, have a professional career and can usually figure out most things but finding someone in the right area of law was incredibly difficult. Had the lawyers I approached turned round and said to me “I’m not on the clock” things would have turned out very differently. Instead each of them generously put me in contact with someone who could help me and eventually an acquaintance agreed to take on the case (at cost of course). There are plenty of people - refugees, vulnerable people who wouldn’t even know where to start, it’s a minefield out there and had I not had those contacts things would have turned out very differently and I am eternally grateful for all of their support.

You are not a qualified lawyer so it’s slightly different, but could you set aside maybe an hour a week to offer probono work when you are - and by probono that could mean putting people in touch with the right people. That way you could factor it into your hours and not end up overwhelmed?

As other people have pointed out, most people in an area of skill (myself included) have given up their free time to help others in their hour of need. It just depends on you how much time you’re willing to give.

Good luck OP !

motherofgodhaudyerwheesht · 18/03/2022 16:11

I sympathise. The legal profession (and expense) can be daunting and confusing. If the queries are somewhat related to your field of expertise, perhaps consider having business-type cards in your handbag with the contact details of relevant local help organisations - whether CAB, or support groups, advice lines? "I cant give direct advice but these people may be able to help you' .That way you do give them help and point them in a self-help direction and they feel they have 'got' something from an expert? Sounds it would be worth the effort!

Havanananana · 18/03/2022 16:10

OP - the issue is not whether or not you should be giving advice for free (the answer to which is that you should not, under any circumstances, for all of the legal and liability reasons that people have stated in numerous posts).

The issue is how you set the boundary. Since the boundary is "No advice outside of work" you need to work on saying this. Firmly and politely if possible. Bluntly if not.

Do not engage. Do not give the impression that you will engage. Change the subject. State clearly (and truthfully) that you are not allowed to do work outside of your employment contract. By all means point people in the right direction towards a suitably qualified solicitor etc. but don't offer any opinion and be prepared to walk away, hang up, or reply "sorry, can't help" to emails if necessary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread