Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to give people free advice?

289 replies

PretZubscription · 18/03/2022 12:44

I work in the legal sector, studied Law at both undergrad and postgrad level and I am hoping to work towards becoming a barrister.

Since starting my undergrad Law degree I have always had people (family & friends) reach out to me to ask for advice. I have always tried to answer their questions based on what I know but warned them I am not a professional. Since gaining my current position I now specialise in a certain area of Law that a lot of people are wanting advice in. I don’t mind people asking me the odd question here and there but I am increasingly getting messages asking for advice and even people asking if I will meet them. I have told these people that I can’t do that and it’s constantly been met with “it’s not really legal advice I just wanted to meet for a coffee and a chat”.

I work very long hours. Sometimes I’m working 14+ hour days going over massive amounts of paperwork and I come home with my brain frazzled. I want to be able to switch off when I finish work and not constantly be asked my professional opinion. I have friends who are hair dressers and I wouldn’t ask them to do my hair for free, so to me this feels like the same thing. However, there is a part of me that’s thinking well it’s not like I’m doing their paperwork and legal advice is more important than that so should I be giving these people some time? A lot of the people who are asking my opinion are not well off and would probably struggle to afford professional advice so I’m not sure what to do. I obviously don’t want their lives to be negatively impacted by not gaining appropriate advice but if I did it for one person, how many would I be meeting? I’m not a charity Sad As I said, I don’t mind answering messages here and there or even pointing people towards a solicitor in that area but suddenly it feels like a lot. I’m on a salary right now so even if I was giving these people advice through work I wouldn’t be paid any extra for it.

So AIBU to not want to give advice to these people? And if I am please can you help me come up with a reply because I just keep being met with “I only wanted a coffee and a chat” when I tell them I can’t meet up with them and give them legal advice.

OP posts:
Coffeetree · 19/03/2022 15:24

Anyway the CF was justifying CFery because she thought lawyers are "overpaid".

CityHigh · 19/03/2022 15:06

27k is/was not a bad wage at all! If you think that is a poor wage, that may explain a bit. Work in kitchen. Then you would experience a proper income/hours imbalance. 27k is a fortune. And LOL at 50k for 70 hours being unreasonable! (I agree 70 hours is inhumane - but not uncommon, but the money can't be said to be bad.)

Maybe 27k is a lot of money to you but it is not what the majority of people would class as a ‘good’ wage. You only have to read through previous threads on here to see that. Is it survivable? Yes. Is it more than NMW? Also yes. Being more than NMW does not mean you’re on a good salary. The average full time salary in the UK is 32k. Below average does not = good.

You can spin that all you want but 27k is not a good salary when it is below average. NMW is poor and should be more, but below average wage when you’re putting in unlimited hours is poor. Especially when you have to put in 7+ years of education that you pay for to get qualified.

BTW when I was a waiter on NMW I worked full time hours and I probably averaged about 27k a year when you accounted for cash tips. The tips were much more than the wage. They were split with kitchen staff too.

SnowWhiteLobelia · 19/03/2022 15:02

@Coffeetree

27k is not a bad wage. Neither is it overpaid for someone who studied for 7 years and works 60 hours a week. So am I meant to spend every weekend volunteering? Or do you want to take all this bosom-hoiking over to your MP and ask for Legal Aid cuts to be reversed?
I am not in practice any more but when I was a 4 year qualified solicitor (granted, in a rural area) i was also on circa 27k. It does bite when people talk about greedy lawyers.
Coffeetree · 19/03/2022 14:58

I mean it's a very Maoist approach that I owe something to people who make less than me (I kind of like that), but what's the cut-off. Can I get every other Sunday off?

Coffeetree · 19/03/2022 14:51

27k is not a bad wage. Neither is it overpaid for someone who studied for 7 years and works 60 hours a week. So am I meant to spend every weekend volunteering? Or do you want to take all this bosom-hoiking over to your MP and ask for Legal Aid cuts to be reversed?

Marchingredsoldiers · 19/03/2022 14:44

This is a common attitude leading to the CFery. @marchingredsoldiers, in practice i made 27k for working unlimited hours plus supervising a team.

27k is/was not a bad wage at all! If you think that is a poor wage, that may explain a bit. Work in kitchen. Then you would experience a proper income/hours imbalance. 27k is a fortune. And LOL at 50k for 70 hours being unreasonable! (I agree 70 hours is inhumane - but not uncommon, but the money can't be said to be bad.)

And yes I do read the news and know that legal aid has been slashed. Don't you think that may have contributed to people asking for advice?

My comments seem to have annoyed legal types. But I stand by it. The fees and costs are a lot for many people. I get that not all workers see all the profits.

But my point is that many people earn very small amounts compared with the cost of living. That's why they ask. It doesn't really matter who in the law firm, dentists, builders (it's not all about lawyers!) gets the bulk of the money, it still costs alot. How often are women who want to leave their husbands and are finanically fucked told to "use the free half hour" on MN. Now they are labelled cheeky fuckers.

I also understand that doctors and nurses would get pissed off too. That is another matter. Health is chronically underfunded and people get desperate due to lack of appointments and waiting times.

We can agree though that the government is the root cause for most of this.

(BTW if you work a 70 hour week on "minimum wage" as a lawyer, you will take home nearly twice as much someone working a 35 hour week on minimum wage. Actually more if childcare costs are deduced. Lawyers may not take home the fabled huge sums and/or they are disappointed with their salary, but there are a lot of people earning significantly less.)

By that mindset maybe you should suck it up and get a better paid job? Why? I enjoy my job. This whole is moaning about yours!

89redballoons · 19/03/2022 12:34

I'm a solicitor and when I get this, I always say it's not my specific area of law so I don't really know. 9/10 that's true, my area is quite niche. If they are pushy I say sorry but I'm really not allowed to advise unless engaged through my firm, and I won't be insured if anything goes wrong, which is also true.

Sometimes I can recommend other lawyers to talk to, some of whom offer free consultations etc. That is another good way to deflect.

waitingformytakeaway · 19/03/2022 12:32

@Squeezita from many of the replies on here though it's not just friends and family members it's pretty much anyone a professional meets in a non professional capacity. The desire for free advice is still there. It's not so different actually.

dayswithaY · 19/03/2022 12:21

I feel your pain. I'm not a professional, but I did used to work in a high end store with generous staff discount. You would not believe the number of "friends" who came crawling out of the woodwork hoping to use my discount. Getting me to obtain and pay for the item, they would then "pay me back" for. Some would even return the item to the store for a cash refund!

I had to become quite rude in order to shake them off.

Squeezita · 19/03/2022 12:15

@waitingformytakeaway

You even see it all the time on here -

'Any lawyers about?'

At least on here people can choose whether to respond and its anonymous.

Asking for advice on a forum, where no one is obliged to respond, is very different to guilt tripping a friend/family member.
Winkydink · 19/03/2022 12:04

@waitingformytakeaway and what’s even more alarming on those chats is when I do offer a tentative, caveated, opinion (as a solicitor), the OP will go with the advice based on what someone’s unqualified neighbour’s cousin’s boyfriend said!

waitingformytakeaway · 19/03/2022 10:51

You even see it all the time on here -

'Any lawyers about?'

At least on here people can choose whether to respond and its anonymous.

CityHigh · 19/03/2022 10:29

@sherbertdib

Isnt this just life?

No matter what job, people want your advice and help in your specialist subject

I think there’s a difference between a friend asking a couple of questions about a topic you’re knowledgeable on and receiving messages from people who aren’t in your close circle pressuring you to meet up to give them advice that could end up endangering your whole career.
Wastwater · 19/03/2022 10:29

You are not being U at all. It must be very irritating.
But I can see why people might ask. You are entering a profession that deals with 'the law'. The Law/ justice is inaccessible to so many people, because it is technical, complicated and unaffordable.

HappyDays40 · 19/03/2022 10:26

I'm an OT I get asked to do independent reports for PIP and DLA appeals which I do. I spend about 1.5 hours assessing then about four hour to write up. I have a good success rate ( by being honest as I refuse assessments for people I know don't have a cat on hells chance.)
I get asked by friends to just do a favour for their friends qnd family, I tell them my rates and hey look at me like I've gone mad. You are paying for my assessment skills, years of experience and my write up not just bunging me a tenner or expecting it free.

Fluffycloudland77 · 19/03/2022 10:17

This is true, dh is motor trade and some family members think he can get them a £60k car for 5p a month 🙄 time wasting fuckers.

sherbertdib · 19/03/2022 10:00

Isnt this just life?

No matter what job, people want your advice and help in your specialist subject

TabithaTittlemouse · 19/03/2022 09:11

I tell people that I loose all knowledge when I clock out.
We’ve been in pubs where I’ve had to listen to peoples life stories. At first I was sympathetic but then thought actually fuck it, this is a really rare night out!

SafeMove · 19/03/2022 08:57

@Marchingredsoldiers I have paid a lot of money for my education, spent countless hours of time studying, working and putting my children in childcare so that I can become a specialist in my field and you think I should suck it up and pass that around? Nah. Life doesn't work like that and grifters don't deserve free stuff on the back of others just because they didn't want to do it themselves.

SuziePorterrr · 19/03/2022 08:42

@Marchingredsoldiers

I have sympathy with people asking.

It is bloody expensive to get professional advice. This information asymmtry is why certain professions earn shitloads.

Also every job has its down side. I work bloody hard for little money. No-one asks for my opinion or even gives a shit about my job, which is actually essential for society.

I can understand it being annoying, but really if your profession didn't charge a fortune (resulting in larger than average salaries) you wouldn't have this problem. Suck it up buttercup.

Everything @Coffeetree said in spades.

Do you think this of everyone who charges for a service or is this belief only held for people who you believe to be well paid professionals? What about people who work in IT? Or people such as painters, decorators, plumbers, joiners? Those people are actually mostly in control of how much they charge and it’s usually massive amounts of money, do you think they should come out and offer advice too? Or is that okay because they are seen as blue collar workers?

You clearly have no idea how the legal world works. When I was beginning in Family Law I was earning circa 20k a year and my superiors who had years of experience were probably in 50k on 70 hour weeks. I quickly left. I sympathise with OP if her family and friends have the same mindset as people like you, when you have absolutely no idea what you’re taking about.

This ‘fortune’ that legal firms are charging, particularly in family law, cover the majority of the overheads and after that there’s usually not much left. Of course there are experts in every industry who charge more but overall, the costs are not massively inflated. The secret barrister is a good way to educate yourself on the pittance many, juniors in particular are being paid. When you factor in the hours worked, maybe fall below the legal minimum wage threshold. But as PP said, the government have gotten away with making you think everyone in the legal profession is money greedy and that is why our legal aid system is a massive shit show and many of us end up being hounded by CF who think like yourself.

EveryAvenue · 19/03/2022 08:15

@Marchingredsoldiers

I have sympathy with people asking.

It is bloody expensive to get professional advice. This information asymmtry is why certain professions earn shitloads.

Also every job has its down side. I work bloody hard for little money. No-one asks for my opinion or even gives a shit about my job, which is actually essential for society.

I can understand it being annoying, but really if your profession didn't charge a fortune (resulting in larger than average salaries) you wouldn't have this problem. Suck it up buttercup.

You think someone who does the paperwork (at ops own admittance) makes the prices for whatever legal firm they work at Grin I don’t understand this CF mindset you have.

By that mindset maybe you should suck it up and get a better paid job?

TheChronicalTales · 19/03/2022 08:12

@Marchingredsoldiers

I have sympathy with people asking.

It is bloody expensive to get professional advice. This information asymmtry is why certain professions earn shitloads.

Also every job has its down side. I work bloody hard for little money. No-one asks for my opinion or even gives a shit about my job, which is actually essential for society.

I can understand it being annoying, but really if your profession didn't charge a fortune (resulting in larger than average salaries) you wouldn't have this problem. Suck it up buttercup.

This line of thinking is why we have cheeky fuckers. There is CAB, legal aid and other ways to get free advice. Why would a run to the ground junior who isn’t actually qualified in anything, so I can almost guarantee is not being paid a good wage have to suck it up and help people for free because they can’t be arsed to research how to access free advice?
Coffeetree · 19/03/2022 05:53

@Marchingredsoldiers

I have sympathy with people asking.

It is bloody expensive to get professional advice. This information asymmtry is why certain professions earn shitloads.

Also every job has its down side. I work bloody hard for little money. No-one asks for my opinion or even gives a shit about my job, which is actually essential for society.

I can understand it being annoying, but really if your profession didn't charge a fortune (resulting in larger than average salaries) you wouldn't have this problem. Suck it up buttercup.

This is a common attitude leading to the CFery. @marchingredsoldiers, in practice i made 27k for working unlimited hours plus supervising a team.

Legal advice is expensive because even for the simplest case you have to draft client care letters and sort insurance etc. So if a client pays £50 for an hour's consultation, we just about break even.

That's why we have/had Legal Aid! Do you not read the news? Legal Aid was designed to ensure that everyone could get proper legal help and not have to rely on friends or the odd charity. The government trashed Legal Aid about ten years ago (now it's severely limited and not fit for purpose).

The government got away with trashing Legal Aid because they sold the idea that you're now repeating: that lawyers are greedy and we should work for free all the time.

Next they'll try the same thing with medical care.

Usernameinsponeeded · 19/03/2022 00:49

I’m a solicitor, my friends and family, even complete strangers, always used to ask for advice. I used to hate saying no, but now I enjoy it (saying no).

Just pretend you’re not allowed to help them if you’re not comfortable saying no.

violetbunny · 19/03/2022 00:10

I don't work in a job that's public-facing, but I do work in a niche area. Only large companies tend to have someone like me in-house. I have found that when colleagues leave and move on to other companies it's not unusual for them to keep emailing me for advice! Often because they've moved on to another smaller company where they don't have someone in a role like mine so would have to pay for an external specialist.

I don't mind the odd question here and there, but one person emailed me so much from his new company that I started replying with my email signature as "My Job Title" followed by "Cheeky Fucker's Company Name". He got the hint!