Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to give people free advice?

289 replies

PretZubscription · 18/03/2022 12:44

I work in the legal sector, studied Law at both undergrad and postgrad level and I am hoping to work towards becoming a barrister.

Since starting my undergrad Law degree I have always had people (family & friends) reach out to me to ask for advice. I have always tried to answer their questions based on what I know but warned them I am not a professional. Since gaining my current position I now specialise in a certain area of Law that a lot of people are wanting advice in. I don’t mind people asking me the odd question here and there but I am increasingly getting messages asking for advice and even people asking if I will meet them. I have told these people that I can’t do that and it’s constantly been met with “it’s not really legal advice I just wanted to meet for a coffee and a chat”.

I work very long hours. Sometimes I’m working 14+ hour days going over massive amounts of paperwork and I come home with my brain frazzled. I want to be able to switch off when I finish work and not constantly be asked my professional opinion. I have friends who are hair dressers and I wouldn’t ask them to do my hair for free, so to me this feels like the same thing. However, there is a part of me that’s thinking well it’s not like I’m doing their paperwork and legal advice is more important than that so should I be giving these people some time? A lot of the people who are asking my opinion are not well off and would probably struggle to afford professional advice so I’m not sure what to do. I obviously don’t want their lives to be negatively impacted by not gaining appropriate advice but if I did it for one person, how many would I be meeting? I’m not a charity Sad As I said, I don’t mind answering messages here and there or even pointing people towards a solicitor in that area but suddenly it feels like a lot. I’m on a salary right now so even if I was giving these people advice through work I wouldn’t be paid any extra for it.

So AIBU to not want to give advice to these people? And if I am please can you help me come up with a reply because I just keep being met with “I only wanted a coffee and a chat” when I tell them I can’t meet up with them and give them legal advice.

OP posts:
TooMuchToblerone · 19/03/2022 19:03

YANBU. Also a lawyer here. I went to a friend’s for lunch once only to be ambushed by being told that guy across the road was popping over as he’s getting a divorce and needs advice. Never met him and he was deeply unpleasant and clearly a perpetrator of DV based on what he said. He was downright horrible and argumentative. I gave up and left. Friend was hairdresser and if she did my hair I paid her. My time isn’t less valuable or more free. People don’t see it as the same though.
Have had friends ask if the kids could visit our house to play then been ambushedasked detailed legal lengthy questions on behalf of a family member (only to then discover family member does have a lawyer but doesn’t want to pay to ask the questions). They usually leave with a “oh we must have your DC over soon” but then we never hear again. Pure brass neck. I’m busy, juggling and don’t want to “work” in my free time for people I don’t know. Will have a chat with someone if I do know them but if it gets too detailed I’ll validly say I’m not insured for non-clients.
On the other hand I signed a document once for someone - just witnessed a signature and she produced a bottle of wine. Totally unnecessary but in fact the only person who actually appreciated a small bit of help (that I offered in this case) in 20 years of being ambushed for free legal advice on behalf of people I’ve never met.

JackieWeaver101 · 19/03/2022 18:58

@BananaSplitX

It appears I am a rare one on here, but I do think YABU. You come across rather selfish and self absorbed. I am a professional too. And I also work crazy long hours. But I don’t mind giving friends advice. That’s what friends are for.
Based on your judgement shown on this post, it is likely that your friends are better off without your advice.
SuziePorterrr · 19/03/2022 18:56

@Marchingredsoldiers

This is a common attitude leading to the CFery. @marchingredsoldiers, in practice i made 27k for working unlimited hours plus supervising a team.

27k is/was not a bad wage at all! If you think that is a poor wage, that may explain a bit. Work in kitchen. Then you would experience a proper income/hours imbalance. 27k is a fortune. And LOL at 50k for 70 hours being unreasonable! (I agree 70 hours is inhumane - but not uncommon, but the money can't be said to be bad.)

And yes I do read the news and know that legal aid has been slashed. Don't you think that may have contributed to people asking for advice?

My comments seem to have annoyed legal types. But I stand by it. The fees and costs are a lot for many people. I get that not all workers see all the profits.

But my point is that many people earn very small amounts compared with the cost of living. That's why they ask. It doesn't really matter who in the law firm, dentists, builders (it's not all about lawyers!) gets the bulk of the money, it still costs alot. How often are women who want to leave their husbands and are finanically fucked told to "use the free half hour" on MN. Now they are labelled cheeky fuckers.

I also understand that doctors and nurses would get pissed off too. That is another matter. Health is chronically underfunded and people get desperate due to lack of appointments and waiting times.

We can agree though that the government is the root cause for most of this.

(BTW if you work a 70 hour week on "minimum wage" as a lawyer, you will take home nearly twice as much someone working a 35 hour week on minimum wage. Actually more if childcare costs are deduced. Lawyers may not take home the fabled huge sums and/or they are disappointed with their salary, but there are a lot of people earning significantly less.)

By that mindset maybe you should suck it up and get a better paid job? Why? I enjoy my job. This whole is moaning about yours!

50k is not a bad wage, it is certainly nothing to be sniffed at. However, your original post insinuated that every one who goes into the legal profession are greedy and money grabbing and legal advice is so expensive because they are ripping everyone off. 50k is a very good wage but not one most would categorise as a high earner. As another poster said there are many, many threads on here asking what people class as a good or a high earning salary and the majority of the responses fall at 70-100k.
Dnaltocs · 19/03/2022 18:54

I don’t have a legal background but have a profession. I have this often and like you, with acquaintances asking if I can’t take on the worlds problems. What happens now is I say that I’ll send them a list of appropriate professionals who may be able to help, support or guide them. Included are charity contacts.
Seems to work, so far.

Londoncallingme · 19/03/2022 18:50

@Beancounter1

Reading this thread it seems to me like a real clash of cultures.

In traditional working class cultures (and it still is the case in the minds of some people), that it is not real work if you are not using your hands. It is real work to serve fish and chips. It is real work to cut hair. But it is not real work to just talk.
In these cultures, solidarity and helping people with advice is a strong value, so if you can help out a friend-of-a-friend by 'just talking' then of course you should!

This is why acquaintances from a upper-middle class background wouldn't dream of asking you for legal advice, but most other people will happily do so and expect you to be friendly and help them with advice - they just want a 'chat', its not like they are asking you to do some real work.

I think it helps to understand where people are coming from, so you don't judge them harshly.

Whereas middle class culture it is the norm to befriend a person because they are well connected, might be useful, WC culture doesn’t hVe this, they will befriend the people they actually like. I have a foot in both camps and this is true.
Beancounter1 · 19/03/2022 18:43

Reading this thread it seems to me like a real clash of cultures.

In traditional working class cultures (and it still is the case in the minds of some people), that it is not real work if you are not using your hands. It is real work to serve fish and chips. It is real work to cut hair. But it is not real work to just talk.
In these cultures, solidarity and helping people with advice is a strong value, so if you can help out a friend-of-a-friend by 'just talking' then of course you should!

This is why acquaintances from a upper-middle class background wouldn't dream of asking you for legal advice, but most other people will happily do so and expect you to be friendly and help them with advice - they just want a 'chat', its not like they are asking you to do some real work.

I think it helps to understand where people are coming from, so you don't judge them harshly.

Londoncallingtothefarawaytowns · 19/03/2022 18:34

I think jobs where you'd pay for an opinion are all like this OP
GPs, a plumber , a therapist .. I bet they all get this
I'm not a lawyer ,but I do a job where you'd pay for my opinion. Randoms , neighbours etc all ask for advice.
I don't mind too much , but usually I direct them where to call.

Liverbird77 · 19/03/2022 18:28

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

TheChronicalTales · 19/03/2022 18:27

@Londoncallingme

We all advise friends on what we specialise in - teachers, greengrocers, tech, doctors, hairstylists,surgeons etc etc. no, you wouldn’t ask for hair styling for free but if you developed a bald patch , alopecia you might reach out to hairdressers, doctors, therapists etc to ask an opinion if these people are your friends. What is it that makes you do special that you can’t do that? I shouldn’t worry - I’m sure they’ll soon retreat and the invitations for coffee will stop.
It is really not hard to read all of the OP posts where she states she doesn’t mind giving out general advice and sign posting people correctly.

The difference between messaging your hair dresser friend about alopecia and messaging a semi qualified lawyer friend is that incorrect legal advice could potentially ruin someone’s life and leave OP open to massive legal damages if she advises on only half a story.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 19/03/2022 18:14

I normally just signpost elsewhere with a very general statement like "in certain circumstances you can do that but it is very complex so you need proper advice"

I then either send them off to a colleague/friend (this works both ways, and can result in lucrative work) or in the direction of ACAS, CAB, Union, home insurance or membership bodies.

I am happy to sign the occasional passport photo or certify a copy document free of charge for a friend though providing they do the leg work and are polite and reasonable.

I also try to be really vague about exactly what I do so I can keep using the "not my area", "sorry I haven't seen a conveyance since law school", "you know we only do two lessons on wills and probate" type excuses.

EveryAvenue · 19/03/2022 18:13

@Londoncallingme

We all advise friends on what we specialise in - teachers, greengrocers, tech, doctors, hairstylists,surgeons etc etc. no, you wouldn’t ask for hair styling for free but if you developed a bald patch , alopecia you might reach out to hairdressers, doctors, therapists etc to ask an opinion if these people are your friends. What is it that makes you do special that you can’t do that? I shouldn’t worry - I’m sure they’ll soon retreat and the invitations for coffee will stop.
Family Law is an extremely sensitive area and for all of the reasons stated by everyone on this thread it makes complete sense why OP doesn’t want to nor should she give two men she doesn’t know properly advice regarding access to their kids without being legally covered.
EveryAvenue · 19/03/2022 18:08

FWIW I actually think OP comes across very well in her posts and obviously cares about her profession. Why should she endanger that for people who are just ex colleagues?

EveryAvenue · 19/03/2022 18:07

@BananaSplitX

It appears I am a rare one on here, but I do think YABU. You come across rather selfish and self absorbed. I am a professional too. And I also work crazy long hours. But I don’t mind giving friends advice. That’s what friends are for.
How on earth have you come to that conclusion? Please explain why OP is selfish and self absorbed for not wanting to sit down with Men who aren’t even in her close circle of friends and discuss and advise on them not having access to their children when there’s probably a very good reason for it? Never mind that she’s not even qualified or insured to do so!

What a rude comment.

startingagain13 · 19/03/2022 17:59

I work in mental health, at the moment I'm working with children, however my experience is really in adult mental health. I tend to be unsure of the answer to this but I've been known to sink a good number of glasses of wine to then be hit with some significant problems by friends. Trying to think therapeutically after wine is not a good idea.

berlinbabylon · 19/03/2022 17:58

@BananaSplitX

It appears I am a rare one on here, but I do think YABU. You come across rather selfish and self absorbed. I am a professional too. And I also work crazy long hours. But I don’t mind giving friends advice. That’s what friends are for.
MN took the thread down by the person who was complaining about people being nasty on MN, but this is exactly the sort of thing. Why on earth are you calling the OP selfish and self absorbed. How are you remotely qualified to make that sort of remark about someone you have never met. You owe the OP an apology especially as there are very good reasons not to give free legal advice which have been outlined many times on this discussion.
BananaSplitX · 19/03/2022 17:51

It appears I am a rare one on here, but I do think YABU. You come across rather selfish and self absorbed. I am a professional too. And I also work crazy long hours. But I don’t mind giving friends advice. That’s what friends are for.

Londoncallingme · 19/03/2022 17:50

We all advise friends on what we specialise in - teachers, greengrocers, tech, doctors, hairstylists,surgeons etc etc. no, you wouldn’t ask for hair styling for free but if you developed a bald patch , alopecia you might reach out to hairdressers, doctors, therapists etc to ask an opinion if these people are your friends. What is it that makes you do special that you can’t do that? I shouldn’t worry - I’m sure they’ll soon retreat and the invitations for coffee will stop.

Primrose97 · 19/03/2022 17:49

I so understand how you’re feeling OP - but then I’m a counsellor so maybe I should … I keep very quiet at any party or gathering about what I do as people do expect that on the most casual acquaintance they are entitled to endless amounts of your time for free. Luckily I’ve been trained to hold my boundaries so am able to smile and say No firmly but without having to apologise or justify myself, it’s called being assertive and everyone is entitled to do that.

Xiaoxiong · 19/03/2022 17:47

For me the conversation always goes:
"Aren't you a lawyer, can I pick your brains about..."
"i'm a lawyer, but I'm not YOUR lawyer. You need to talk to someone that you can sue if they get it wrong!"

Refer them to chambers uk or the legal500 if they need a recommendation.

And then change the subject!

Hankunamatata · 19/03/2022 17:43

Just say 'I cant help with this, I recommend you contact x' and if they reply pleading poverty ect just resend the same same message. If they still are demanding a meeting 'I'm working 14 hour days, I do not have the time, contact x if you need help'

angela99999 · 19/03/2022 17:36

If you're still training it's probably not a good thing to give legal advice anyway, I don't imagine you'd be covered by the Law Society if something went wrong because of your advice.

Pinkrose1111 · 19/03/2022 17:29

Just tell them I don't really want to talk about work at all right now. And if they press further just say please contact me during my working hours xyz a consultation fee is X amount. And leave it at that

TheChronicalTales · 19/03/2022 16:55

27k is a fortune

Just because 27k a year is more than you earn, it does not equate to a fortune. That is £1835 a month after tax without pension and student loan deductions. If you have to pay for full time wrap around childcare to fit around a lawyers schedule then you’re looking at at least another £1000. That leaves less than £835 for food, bills and transport. I certainly won’t be encouraging my children to settle for a salary of 27k because in the context of how affordable life is I don’t want them to struggle. I’d also be upset if they were slogging away 70 hours of their lives to earn this. It doesn’t matter that there’s people out there who earn less. It isn’t comparable, it still doesn’t mean that’s a fortune. I want them to be able to afford to do what they want to do. Not be rich, but to be able to live comfortably.

Childcare will be less once the children attend school but you’ll still be looking at breakfast club and a child minder. 27k is certainly more than national minimum wage but NMW is a shambles anyway. As PP said above, this amount after dedicating years of your life to learning a skill is really not a lot. There’s no further training or qualifications you can do to advance yourself. You only have to look at previous threads on here to know that 27k PA is not a lot. Maybe in the context of what you earn, but not in life. Some people are still able to qualify for benefits when they earn this amount, because they struggle to live on it.

Nobody on here was complaining about salary. I haven’t seen OP mention it once. You are the one who brought it up. You said people in ‘high paid’ professions should ‘suck it up’ like they owe those on less money something.

SucculentChalice · 19/03/2022 16:18

@Wastwater

You are not being U at all. It must be very irritating. But I can see why people might ask. You are entering a profession that deals with 'the law'. The Law/ justice is inaccessible to so many people, because it is technical, complicated and unaffordable.
Equally, the internet is full of people who think the law is easy and they know far, far more than any lawyer. Yet another reason its better not to engage because as soon as you identify one, some trolls will do their best to embarrass you professionally.

This unfortunately means that many social media discussions which really could do with more informed input are often woefully lacking in such.

IncompleteSenten · 19/03/2022 16:07

You're not paying for the time taken to give you a piece of advice, you're paying for the years it took the person to become qualified to give the piece of advice.