Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to give people free advice?

289 replies

PretZubscription · 18/03/2022 12:44

I work in the legal sector, studied Law at both undergrad and postgrad level and I am hoping to work towards becoming a barrister.

Since starting my undergrad Law degree I have always had people (family & friends) reach out to me to ask for advice. I have always tried to answer their questions based on what I know but warned them I am not a professional. Since gaining my current position I now specialise in a certain area of Law that a lot of people are wanting advice in. I don’t mind people asking me the odd question here and there but I am increasingly getting messages asking for advice and even people asking if I will meet them. I have told these people that I can’t do that and it’s constantly been met with “it’s not really legal advice I just wanted to meet for a coffee and a chat”.

I work very long hours. Sometimes I’m working 14+ hour days going over massive amounts of paperwork and I come home with my brain frazzled. I want to be able to switch off when I finish work and not constantly be asked my professional opinion. I have friends who are hair dressers and I wouldn’t ask them to do my hair for free, so to me this feels like the same thing. However, there is a part of me that’s thinking well it’s not like I’m doing their paperwork and legal advice is more important than that so should I be giving these people some time? A lot of the people who are asking my opinion are not well off and would probably struggle to afford professional advice so I’m not sure what to do. I obviously don’t want their lives to be negatively impacted by not gaining appropriate advice but if I did it for one person, how many would I be meeting? I’m not a charity Sad As I said, I don’t mind answering messages here and there or even pointing people towards a solicitor in that area but suddenly it feels like a lot. I’m on a salary right now so even if I was giving these people advice through work I wouldn’t be paid any extra for it.

So AIBU to not want to give advice to these people? And if I am please can you help me come up with a reply because I just keep being met with “I only wanted a coffee and a chat” when I tell them I can’t meet up with them and give them legal advice.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Seema1234 · 30/03/2022 23:29

GAH! I have just received a text from a friend of a friend on my personak asking me a long winded question. I've blocked the CF. I can't believe the cheek.

Newestname002 · 24/03/2022 03:07

@SucculentChalice

A few months later, she told me, quite accusingly, that she had had to pay £2000 for someone to do it!

I hope you told her that was money well spent and an investment to ensure she protected HER business? 🌹

SucculentChalice · 23/03/2022 20:11

I once had a "friend" ask me if I could draw her up terms and conditions for her new business. For free. "As a favour". She would send me an email with her instructions. It was quite a complex business involving the hire of vehicles.

She was most put out when I said no, it wasn't my field, I'd never done it before, it was important to get it right and it needed to be done by someone who did it all the time who would be covered by professional indemnity insurance. A few months later, she told me, quite accusingly, that she had had to pay £2000 for someone to do it!

Don't get me started on "mates' rates".

Seema1234 · 23/03/2022 18:45

The term 'Can I ask a quick question?' fills me with dread. There is no such thing as a 'quick question'.

user1497207191 · 22/03/2022 11:08

I'm an accountant too. There are never any quick & easy answers. Everything we did requires research. Starting by fact finding, i.e. for a business, is it a sole trader, p'ship, LLP or limited - there are different rules for each. Likewise different rules between a business and a property let and again different for a furnished holiday let. The "fact finding" alone takes time, and then once you know all that, you then have slightly different rules, gray areas etc to explain for even simple queries.

So, for someone sidling up to me at a party and saying glibly "can I claim for a new kitchen", there are literally dozens of scenarios, and no "yes or no" answer.

Even the simplest of questions from our clients gets a time allocation of an hour to do the fact finding, then the research, then a properly considered response, and most go beyond that initial hour allocation.

ThinWomansBrain · 21/03/2022 23:28

accountant - happens to me too
some people I help if there's a quid pro quo, but otherwise "I work in a charity, don't do tax" is a useful get out.

Just give them your business card, tell them to call and book an appointment.

Thewindwhispers · 21/03/2022 23:14

Tell them that when you give advice to your clients, professional indemnity insurance will cover you if you make a mistake, but if you give informal advice to a friend over a coffee and they rely on it as “legal advice” you would not be covered by insurance should they or someone connected to the situation decide the advice is wrong and sue you…

Total sympathy OP, I used to get this in a different job. People don’t understand that it takes energy and effort to work oht the answer to their question, they think it’s stuff you just know.

HTH1 · 21/03/2022 22:21

@Eileen101

An airy "haha sorry, it's not my area of expertise, I'm in business to business, I know nothing about wills/divorce/employment and I wouldn't want to advise you incorrectly. You could end up suing me Grin" This works for me.
Good plan. I also work in an area which is pretty useless to individuals so maybe just say you changed practice areas (how about something like corporate tax/pension schemes/a niche area of trusts law?)
ForeverSingle881 · 21/03/2022 22:04

A solicitor here as well. You just need to grow a thick skin and say "sorry, can't help, here's the gov website." You're young and polite now, when you're 10 years into your profession it will get easier to tell them all to piss off if they're rude!

surreygirl1987 · 21/03/2022 20:49

Yes - people who have jobs in plumbing / electricals / building etc get massively bombarded with requests for free work!

N1no · 21/03/2022 19:48

The coffee or drink is very common. I do product development for manufacturing fairly niche products. The question is mainly if I can give them a list of suppliers and manufacturer in return for a drink. Most don’t understand that this knowledge is actually a large part of the value of my business.
There is some suppliers I don’t mind sharing but I don’t want to travel across London to meet up somewhere convenient and to spend a couple of hours with them if I could go home and spend time with DH and DD.

It’s not just professionals who get this though. My dad is good at DIY, it’s not his job but he gets often asked if he could come over and help build something. It’s often a large building or renovation project which takes several days. He very often does it without the other person ever helping him in return. His own projects get moved more and more back and I said to him the other day that he needs to stop helping others if he wants to finish the kitchen and dining table before he dies. I think it hit home.

GiftedFish · 20/03/2022 19:54

As someone said, you get this in quite a few different jobs.
Me, I'm a Tradie. I always get "can you just do this, can you just do that" and they never want to pay proper prices for it or expe t it completely free. There are a very select few who I would help out for free as long as materials were paid for by them. It is so annoying. Luckily I can just say I haven't got time to anyone out of the circle which is obviously harder for you to do.
I've had friends in the past really take advantage, because I do like to help others but I defo had to learn to draw the line somewhere.
One friends boyfriend made some ridiculous comment about how I was earning loads of money there - yet in reality I was losing £70 a day every day that I was there. His comment was kind of the straw that broke the camels back and I thought no more!
So no you are not being unreasonable at all. People need to understand this is what you do everyday and you need a switch of point. It's exhausting otherwise.

surreygirl1987 · 20/03/2022 19:19

@eastegg

Chip on your shoulder about lawyers? Yawn.

Well, she is right- although I do feel she is unnecessarily rude about it!

eastegg · 20/03/2022 18:58

@RobotValkyrie

Every single skilled professional gets that. You're not that special, just young and naive, possibly a bit too proud of your oh-so-unique newly acquired qualifications (saviour complex?), and as a result, bad at saying no.

For years (decades), IT professionals have been wearing "no, I won't fix your computer" t-shirts, maybe you should get yourself one of these custom printed for lawyers?

Chip on your shoulder about lawyers? Yawn.
Newestname002 · 20/03/2022 18:42

@Nextlevelnonsense

I hope you had strong words with your friend so she's never tempted to drop you in it in future. 🌹

Nextlevelnonsense · 20/03/2022 16:12

People always find a way to take the piss!
My job is luckily not something that attracts CFs.

However, I have a similar situation.
When my eldest was a tot, she adored having her face painted.
I bought a few bits, and realized I had some talent. I ended up buying a full kit in an online sale. Figured it would be nice to offer to help with school fetes as she got older, and by then I had 2 DC's.
I helped at dance school fetes, school events.
Was lovely that I could give something back. The school made some money, and it was nice.

It was all great, until a close friend offered my services to her local village fayre. She didn't ask first - just told me the date and time.
I wasn't delighted, but I figured it wouldn't hurt to help.

It was a 4 hour slot, and they decided it would be free! This wasn't mentioned until I arrived.
I never personally changed anyone, but this was a whole new level of BS. They had devalued it completely, so it turned into a shambles.
The kids queued, had their faces painted, washed it off (nearby fountain)- then rejoined the queue.
I had children crying, parents complaining! Nobody acknowledged that it was my time/ materials/ efforts.
It was a miserable day, and I never offered, or agreed to do it ever again.

CFs ruin things for everyone.
I now value my time, and make sure others do too.

UnexpectedItemInShaggingArea · 20/03/2022 14:06

YANBU. As others have said, you need a short, stock response. Something like: "I can't give you any legal advice. I can recommend a solicitor who specialises in this area."

House12 · 20/03/2022 13:52

I’d say -without exception - “I’m so sorry you’re having a hard time, unfortunately the demands on my time are just so overwhelming there’s really no way I can help or talk you through it. I really do wish you all the best though.” Literally keep it in your notes app and copy & paste each time! I then just wouldn’t reply if they push beyond that -you don’t owe dialogues to every person that expects one.

JonSnowIsALoser · 20/03/2022 12:58

Of course YANBU. To friends / family asking to meet up, I'd say "Of course we can meet up for coffee and a chat to catch up on the news, but no talking about work please!"

PearlyShamps · 20/03/2022 12:10

This must be so frustrating for you! I think I'd feel the same. YANBU.

I hope you find a way to get a good balance on this, and good luck with the progression of your career Smile

WildfirePonie · 20/03/2022 11:05

It*

WildfirePonie · 20/03/2022 11:05

Tell everyone about your new career change.

Make is something boring and of no use to anyone.

DeccaMitfordsEntryVisa · 20/03/2022 10:38

Not unreasonable at all. My husband is a landscape architect/garden designer. The amount of times he’s asked, ‘you couldn’t just pop over and do a little sketch could you? I’ll ply you with wine …..’ is unbelievable.

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 20/03/2022 09:46

I am a shrink
I get a lot of this
Requests for advice about medication, diagnosis, psychotherapy, legal stuff and also just generic 'you're a Dr stuff' including some randomer rolling up their trousers trying to show me a rash on their leg at a birthday party.

It would in fact be a GMC registration issue if I were to give bad advice based on the kind of partial information they are likely to be offering in a casual setting so I have a blanket response of 'no, I'm sorry I can't advise you please see your own GP and ask for a referral.' The only things I would ever advise on are things that are in the public domain eg crisis line numbers

It is awkward and feels impolite but the thing that motivates me to brave being thought impolite is the prospect of a GMC complaint if I were to get it wrong. That is the real reason not to do it. That and that we need the protection of professional boundaries. It's not good at all to have someone you are professionally advising being able to get hold of you 24-7 or come to your house. One could easily get accused of acting unprofessionally by some disgruntled person. If you never engage on a professional basis with random people then you avoid the risk of a career ending complaint.

I expect the same applies to the SRA

Mosaic123 · 20/03/2022 09:45

My lawyer father used to say "And which address shall I send your bill to". Friends would call at the weekend for advice saying they didn't want to bother him at the office (it was his firm).