Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Live in partner expects assurance of interest in my property

331 replies

joboy2 · 18/03/2022 12:03

My recent female partner would like to move in to my property. I'm 67. She is 69. Until now, I had expected to date a partner with her own property, meaning we would live separately but regularly stay over in each others property. My partner has no property. My main worry is that I have always intended to pass my house on after my death, in its entirety, to my single mother daughter. As I understand it, if my partner moves in and contributes anything in terms of work, money, even decoration, she could, on my demise, declare a financial interest in my house, allowing her to occupy it. I have discussed this matter with her, and been blunt or rather frank and honest as to my intentions. Both she, and her friends seem appalled that I will not consider passing on an interest in my home upon my demise. I have pointed out that if the sexes were reversed, they might take a less charitable position regarding a relatively elderly male expecting an interest in his partners house, indeed they might think he was taking advantage. The upshot is, that I have insisted that some sort of legally binding document be drawn up between us stating my position quite clearly before any move by my partner. The only other options being that we break up over this issue, or we carry on as we are and she continue to live in her own rented accommodation. I wonder what other readers might think, or indeed what advice they might offer. Joboy.

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 20/03/2022 20:30

You know what I personally would do JoBoy— If it’s something you would like to do , but feel uneasy (and I would) , i would stick £10k in a new building society book in her name that you hold - but have it on both signatures. If anything doesn’t work out she then gets this cash to help her find somewhere to rent.

joboy2 · 20/03/2022 19:59

Thank you everyone. Apologies for non replies, but having received 300 odd messages I do think this is far beyond my ability to respond. This is the first time I've checked in since posting. Everyone's contribution has been most helpful. I do believe that I were to predecease my new partner ,which seems likely given relative life expectancy for the two sexes, there may be conflict of interest issues regarding her occupation of the property. Much as I'd like to have a live in companion, I cannot countenance the idea that by giving a life interest to my new partner, my daughter would have to wait for anything up to twenty years to regain her inheritance. My daughter has slight learning difficulties, which mitigate against her and her daughter ever being particularly secure or well off in life. Luckily, she has a delightful big brother, who insists that he will happily forego any inheritance from me if it benefits her. He is hugely supportive of me signing over my property, in its entirety, to his wee sister. So, all in all, I've received sound advice on this forum. Again, many thanks.

OP posts:
Twinkster · 19/03/2022 20:55

@Malibuismysecrethome

saraclara I completely agree with you. It’s a shame more people don’t think as we do.
I agree. Said the same further upthread.
Zilla1 · 19/03/2022 09:54

Indeed. I hope at least some posters will have learned a little about the issues, the rights someone might accrue against an estate, the risks of assigning property to the next generation, the issues of someone giving up the protection of a HA rental and balancing short term and long term. The OP and the intent behind the thread doesn't determine that.

C8H10N4O2 · 19/03/2022 08:53

@Calphurnia88

Anyone, male or female, who gives up the roof over their heads to move in with a partner would be mad not to want some kind of protection in the event of their death. Since the OP thinks this its fine for her to be thrown out in this situation I'd say its just as likely this is a big red flag for the partner and she should be the one looking elsewhere as the OP plainly wants nothing more than FWB.

If sounds like it's the partner that is pushing to move in though, not the OP?

`Assuming the partner exists and if they do, that the OP has been open and honest about what they want from a relationship.

My advice to any man or woman is don't give up your own roof to move in with someone who would be happy to see you rendered homeless on their death. Its common enough in this situation for a couple to set up an agreement which protects both sides whilst still ensuring ultimately that any assets go to their own kin.

I think the OP has exactly what they wanted from this thread.

IncompleteSenten · 19/03/2022 08:53

@JinglingHellsBells

I really don't know why this thread is still going Hmm

The OP has posted once. And disappeared. No other posts on MN.

It's just wasting everyone's time IMO.

Not really. It's an interesting topic for discussion. We don't need the op in order to do that.
C8H10N4O2 · 19/03/2022 08:46

@JinglingHellsBells

I really don't know why this thread is still going Hmm

The OP has posted once. And disappeared. No other posts on MN.

It's just wasting everyone's time IMO.

The OP won't be back. They have a nice long run of posts on a supposedly women centred forum saying that its totally fine for a scenario where and elderly woman is left homeless and with no security in old age, because the only thing which matters is the DD getting an asset free of charge from the moment of death.

Of course neither the hypothetical DD or partner have paid toward the asset at this stage, the hypothetical partner likely would do over time if living there.

JinglingHellsBells · 19/03/2022 08:27

You've bothered to post @Blossomtoes just to pick me up on that? (Rather than engage with the point).

Ah well.

Enjoy the rest of your day .

Blossomtoes · 19/03/2022 08:18

@JinglingHellsBells

I really don't know why this thread is still going Hmm

The OP has posted once. And disappeared. No other posts on MN.

It's just wasting everyone's time IMO.

And yet here you are 🤷‍♀️

Surely it’s up to people posting on the thread how they spend their time?

JinglingHellsBells · 19/03/2022 08:12

I really don't know why this thread is still going Hmm

The OP has posted once. And disappeared. No other posts on MN.

It's just wasting everyone's time IMO.

BlueSummerBaby · 19/03/2022 02:16

[quote JinglingHellsBells]@joboy2 You could give your home/ transfer ownership now to your daughter. As long as you trust her not to sell it and kick you out.

But assuming she is somewhere between 30-45, she may not be single forever.[/quote]
This might not work depending on the daughters circumstances. If she's claiming any welfare benefits as a single mother on a low income for example. A house you live in, however unnecessarily huge or expensive it may be, doesn't disqualify you from claiming. But a house you don't live in is counted the same as if it were savings in the bank and would disqualify you from claiming anything based on low income/little savings.

BlueSummerBaby · 19/03/2022 02:07

I don't understand this at all. You wanted to meet someone who has their own property and for you both to continue to live separately. So why are you moving in with her? She does have her own property, it just happens to be rented not owned. That's not your problem, to put it bluntly. You don't owe her a home with you just because you're dating and she's tired of paying rent! Stay living separately or if that's a deal breaker for her then you're not compatible anyway because living separately is what you want. If you're not compatible breaking up is the right thing to do, as sad as it may be. You could change your mind and live with her, but if she's appalled by the prospect of not inheriting your home, that's not going to be enough for her and there's going to be resentment, then you'll either live miserably together or break up anyway so you can be happy. So if she doesn't want to live separately and also isn't happy to compromise by living together but not inheriting, then you may as well break up now and save yourself some misery!

timeisnotaline · 19/03/2022 01:50

@Londoncallingtothefarawaytowns

DM is in this exact situation. I think everyone is just pretending it'll resolve itself but it won't

DM partner owns a home. He wants DM to move in, but will not marry her or leave the home to her. So if she outlives him, she'll be homeless

Neither DM nor my siblings are interested in " profiting " from the home, but I do expect DM to not be in her 70s or 80s ,having spent the past 15 years making a home and then be turfed out (and this is what will happen to someone you care enough about to be in a relationship with. Sad )

So she has had to kept on her own rental. And spends half her time there.

I have suggested that they have someone is writing which says DM may stay on in the home , until she passes, siblings and I will not pursue and then sale /home left to Partners children.

So I would suggest something similar. You cannot expect your partner to be homeless in her twilight years.

But how is it different to how she is now, without the partner, where she plans to pay rent for the rest of her life? If she saved the rent while living with her partner isn’t she then in the same boat plus more savings when the partner dies to go get a rental again, with the big hurdle being having to move house, but you can pay people to do that? And especially when you know dc would help apply for rentals so it’s not a concern they are a bit frail and tired for the effort or not up to the online processes, this doesn’t seem a big issue to me. What am I missing?
Slowfoxfast · 18/03/2022 21:26

Of course, Merrymouse, but it's all about the negatives of having a partner moving in. What if the partner ends up caring for OP into their old age? Should she have to move out when she is very elderly to find a rented home and perhaps be left destitute? It could happen. The OP doesn't talk about what they are gaining from the relationship. It's presented as all take. We don't know the full story.

Merrymouse · 18/03/2022 20:32

I can't imagine having a relationship with someone that I didn't want to feel secure if they moved in with me. She will be giving up her rented property and will contribute to your household expenses so she should have an interest if you died. Do you really want to have a relationship with someone knowing that you would leave her high and dry in those circumstances? It doesn't say much about you, I'm afraid.

But it takes time to reach that stage, and relationships are more complicated when you already have children, even if they are adults.

BennyTheWonderDog · 18/03/2022 20:25

@Londoncallingtothefarawaytowns That sounds tricky. I think it’s slightly different if the partner actively wants her to move in- in that situation he should of course give some thought to what happens when he dies.

The impression I got from OP is that he doesn’t really want her to move in and that all of this ( moving and inheritance) is coming from her. Hard to know for sure though.

Xenia · 18/03/2022 20:23

There is no right or wrong on this. I would never let a man get my house so will not move one in and that is fine by me. My children's father has remarried and apparently his will leaves all his assets and house to our children (unusual) as his wife has kept her own flat which she lets out and keeps the rent )(which her son will get when she dies or she can move into when her husband dies - her husband has the house my children will inherit from him apparently). She gets his pension.

user3837313202 · 18/03/2022 20:19

@Cookay

If you eventually get married to your new partner the property will automatically go to the living spouse if one dies unless the will specifically leaves it to someone else. This is a common problem where unrelated kids end up getting the property. I've also heard if the property was fully mortgaged the heir will get that debt!
If someone dies intestate with a spouse and kids then the spouse gets the first £270k and half of the remainder. The rest is split between their children (not step children)

The Sideways Disinheritance Trap is a real thing, but can be avoided by using a lifetime interest trust.

You cannot inherit debt. However, the estate of the person who died must pay off any debt before any inheritance can be distributed. In the case of a house with more mortgage than there are savings, this is likely to mean that the house is sold and the equity is distributed according to the terms of the will (or rules of intestacy).

Londoncallingtothefarawaytowns · 18/03/2022 19:20

DM is in this exact situation. I think everyone is just pretending it'll resolve itself but it won't

DM partner owns a home. He wants DM to move in, but will not marry her or leave the home to her. So if she outlives him, she'll be homeless

Neither DM nor my siblings are interested in " profiting " from the home, but I do expect DM to not be in her 70s or 80s ,having spent the past 15 years making a home and then be turfed out (and this is what will happen to someone you care enough about to be in a relationship with. Sad )

So she has had to kept on her own rental. And spends half her time there.

I have suggested that they have someone is writing which says DM may stay on in the home , until she passes, siblings and I will not pursue and then sale /home left to Partners children.

So I would suggest something similar. You cannot expect your partner to be homeless in her twilight years.

GreMay1 · 18/03/2022 19:13

@Xenia

I wouldn't let the partner move in - what's the point at their age. I would never move anyone in and my house goes to my children equally come what may.
Exactly you have made a crucial point. At their age OPS daughter has been around long before this new partner...
JinglingHellsBells · 18/03/2022 19:10

@joboy2 You could give your home/ transfer ownership now to your daughter. As long as you trust her not to sell it and kick you out.

But assuming she is somewhere between 30-45, she may not be single forever.

GreMay1 · 18/03/2022 19:09

RUN for the hills OP. How long have you dated?

The audacity of your partner if it was a man he would be getting called Cocklodger by now.

Let her live in her current house. Do not move in together.

Slowfoxfast · 18/03/2022 19:04

I can't imagine having a relationship with someone that I didn't want to feel secure if they moved in with me. She will be giving up her rented property and will contribute to your household expenses so she should have an interest if you died. Do you really want to have a relationship with someone knowing that you would leave her high and dry in those circumstances? It doesn't say much about you, I'm afraid.

I'm not saying you shouldn't make provision for your daughter but you should also make provision for your partner. Otherwise, what kind of relationship are you having? I do think she has every right to have some expectation or you should let her go her own way now. You can't help who you fall for and thinking you could have a relationship with someone who had their own home is just an ideal. The reality seems to have turned out differently and I think you should adjust to that.

shssandhr · 18/03/2022 19:04

It’s a tricky one. Say you end up being together for the next 20 years, she might end up being your carer at some point. You die, your daughter kicks her out. That does seem a little unfair.

If it ends up being that serious then yes, of course he should consider how to provide for his long-term partner in the event of his death.
But this is a "recent partner" who hasn't even moved in yet and is starting to make noises about wanting an interest in the property. It's too much, too soon and it's a red flag.

JinglingHellsBells · 18/03/2022 18:52

Lots of posts recently commenting how the OP may need his girlfriend to be his carer.

1 we don't know the OP's gender. We assume they are male but could be female. They could be 2 women.

2 The OP is the younger one so they may end up caring for their partner.

It may be that OP you should have never got involved with this woman. You say you expected a woman of her age to own a home.

Maybe you got in too deep too soon without giving thought to how this relationship would develop.

If she is living with you now, you need to make your mind up sharpish over what you want.

I'm assuming your subject line is a typo and you really meant your partner ^wants' to live with you, rather than is now.

Otherwise you will have to 'evict' her.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread