Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pushy friend (possibly narc) - how to deal ?

62 replies

User112 · 18/03/2022 09:05

I met this lady (call her Jane) at a mutual friend’s place a year ago. Realised we grew up in the same neighbourhood (abroad) and went to the same uni. Also, her DS goes to the same school as mine (different year group). Nice. We exchanged numbers and met a few times. Her DH introduced my DH to a local group and they regularly play a sport together.

We have a busy life as DH and I work full time. Jane kept inviting us over to hers and being quite pushy about wanting us to spend hours at her place chatting and playing cards. She doesn’t work and has only one child (secondary school) so had a lot of free time. She is quite active in a local group and likes organising events.
She fell out with a few people in the group - I don’t know the back story. I get along with others and enjoy their company.

Ever since Jane’s fallout with the group, she has been nagging me every single day telling me when she is available to meet etc. she also tells me I need to take a break from work (I wfh 2 days a week) during the day to have tea with her (wtf !?). There is also one other lady who I met at the other friends party. That woman (Lisa) and Jane are meeting a lot these days and other ladies in the group are actively avoiding them.

Last week Lisa invited me over to hers for a coffee and I politely declined. She was super pushy. Jane has been super pushy. I finally gave in and went to see Jane after work yesterday. Guess what Lisa was there! They were bitching about a party I attended (they were not invited) and about other people I socialise with. Lisa says I should meet them more often (coffee with these two and their own group) or how else will I have fun!? Wtf !? And then proceeds to tell me I MUST go shopping with them tomorrow ( wtf NO !!?). I said sorry I can’t as I have to take DH to his tuition. Jane says, oh your DH can take him, you are coming with us !! WTF !?

There are two groups now and they don’t like each other. Jane’s group is very pushy, I don’t like them, I don’t enjoy the company. However, the husbands of this group play tennis with my husband regularly.
The other group, I like the company, they don’t bitch about others, have no problems with me meeting Jane and her group, generally easy going.

Jane gives me major narc vibes. I avoid narcs like plague. The insecurities, casual putting down, wanting to be involved in major decisions of our life, having opinions, making me feel uncomfortable about not telling her stuff, general show off, lacking class in any shape or kind.

I’d have instantly blocked her if our husbands were not friends. Tbh, Jane’s husband is a really nice chap. No probs with him at all.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Casmama · 20/03/2022 14:36

As a previous poster said, your therapy should have provided your with strategies to deal with situations not convinced you that you can diagnose other people.
You can only control your behaviour so take the advice about being more assertive when saying no and don't get drawn into debates.
I also thought it was good advice to call her out when she starts bitching about your other friends otherwise you are being two faced by not doing so and not much better than her.

ManateeFair · 20/03/2022 13:54

I don’t think it actually matters whether Jane is a narcissist or not; what matters here is that she’s clearly a twat.

OP, you really do have to make a choice here. You can stop replying to this nightmare woman’s messages and continue hanging out with the friends you actually do like instead, and accept that this might mean it will slightly awkward if you both happen to attend the same party one day. Or you can carry on letting yourself be bullied into social events with people you hate. Your husbands are unlikely to give a shit either way and will just carry on playing tennis.

PinkSyCo · 20/03/2022 13:49

As hard as it may be you have to be direct with the Janes of this world (even if their husbands are friends with yours) and just tell them ‘No, I don’t want to go shopping’ or ‘I don’t fancy coming round for coffee’. Say no enough and they should eventually get the message. If not tell them to fuck off.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 20/03/2022 13:06

I don’t think people are protective about narcissism. I do think lots of people are really tired of this kind of amateur pop-psychology which means terms like ‘narc’ get thrown around on MN with absolutely no basis in an actual medical diagnosis.

User112 · 20/03/2022 12:58

[quote Burgoo]@User112

I don't think people are defensive of actual narcissists. I do, however, think that many, many people label people w this when actually its more their issue rather than the other person's. It is, after all, a diagnostic label and there could be any number of reasons why a person may act the way they do. My belief has always been to look for the reason for the behaviour as every behaviour has a function.

Narcissism is an odd one because a lot of the time the problem actually comes from a place of terrible sense of self. These people have been conditioned from childhood to respond to supposed threats to their sense of self with aggression.

As I said before, if you have a true narcissist on your hands you are unlikely to notice. They are very smart when it comes to manipulating and controlling the narrative. You will often feel a close bond when you meet, yet walk away feeling like something is amiss but not be able to pin-point what. Why? Because they will often be what you need them to be, in order to get the validation they crave. Its similar with borderline type individuals but without the typical self-loathing.

I still believe that unless you have something extremely important or valuable to her that she will have cut you off months ago. Narcs won't waste their time on "lesser" people, so unless you have a really good reason for her to stick around she won't see you as anything but a hinderance. What do you offer her that others can't? Do you show and interest and validate her? If nobody does then this is a huge reinforcer for her nagging you.

Good luck![/quote]
Thanks for the perspective. It’s exactly been like that for a very long time. That’s how I put up with it, without realising, for this long. Until one day, I thought - hmm wait a minute, I don’t think I want to do that. Then, all the pushiness just 10xd!

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 20/03/2022 12:49

I had a really pushy neighbour who was constantly you HAVE to... You MUST...

I knew I had to stop it so in the end I said to her actually, no, I don't have to. I'm not able to and we'll have to leave it at that.

We simply say hi now.

It wasn't something I did lightly or quickly but there can come a point when you have to call a firm halt and to hell with it.

So I advise that. Say no I don't have to and I'm not going to.

user1498572889 · 20/03/2022 12:45

Just say “no thanks I don’t fancy it. Thanks for asking”. Then don’t answer any more of her texts.

Burgoo · 20/03/2022 12:29

@User112

I don't think people are defensive of actual narcissists. I do, however, think that many, many people label people w this when actually its more their issue rather than the other person's. It is, after all, a diagnostic label and there could be any number of reasons why a person may act the way they do. My belief has always been to look for the reason for the behaviour as every behaviour has a function.

Narcissism is an odd one because a lot of the time the problem actually comes from a place of terrible sense of self. These people have been conditioned from childhood to respond to supposed threats to their sense of self with aggression.

As I said before, if you have a true narcissist on your hands you are unlikely to notice. They are very smart when it comes to manipulating and controlling the narrative. You will often feel a close bond when you meet, yet walk away feeling like something is amiss but not be able to pin-point what. Why? Because they will often be what you need them to be, in order to get the validation they crave. Its similar with borderline type individuals but without the typical self-loathing.

I still believe that unless you have something extremely important or valuable to her that she will have cut you off months ago. Narcs won't waste their time on "lesser" people, so unless you have a really good reason for her to stick around she won't see you as anything but a hinderance. What do you offer her that others can't? Do you show and interest and validate her? If nobody does then this is a huge reinforcer for her nagging you.

Good luck!

bluedodecagon · 19/03/2022 12:21

@User112

You told us what you thought was important and none of it points to narcissism.

I’ve noticed a lot of people who are people pleasers seem to need to demonise someone in order to distance themselves from them. Otherwise maybe you’d feel guilty? Instead of just recognising that you don’t get along, you have to make her a narcissist or a monster. It’s very unhealthy.

If you need permission to end the relationship then consider this permission granted. But you might wanna focus a little bit more on tightening up your own boundaries rather than trying to diagnose complex mental health conditions in other people.

BobHadBitchTits · 19/03/2022 01:11

WTF?!

Whatinthelord · 18/03/2022 23:38

Just stop seeing her altogether. Decline invitation etc until she gets the point.

I’m sure your husband can maintain his own friendships with you needing to sacrifice your time with this woman.

bruce43mydog · 18/03/2022 23:30

i dont want to read and run op but just do what suits you. you cant go against your own boundries where friends are concerned.

User112 · 18/03/2022 20:19

@coffeeisthebest

Having opinions doesn't make someone a narcissist. Not listening to or allowing other people to have opinions is allowing your own inner narcissist to have a voice. We all have one OP. We are all capable of believing we know better than everyone else. If you don't like these women, stop seeing them.
Why are some people here so protective about narcissism as if it’s some queens OBE/MBE!??

I obviously haven’t told you everything about her narcissistic behaviour! Did you really think I labelled her a narcissist based on 2 incidents?
I’ve known her for a year now!

OP posts:
coffeeisthebest · 18/03/2022 15:46

@User112

It’s unbelievable how she offers “solutions” when I say no! Am I being too nice? Some people misunderstand politeness, I never said my NO is up for negotiation. She just negotiates!
Your no isn't clear enough. Please don't confuse wanting to rid your life of people you view as narcissistic with the fact that you need to assert your own voice and will need to have to learn how to disappoint others and handle conflict.
coffeeisthebest · 18/03/2022 15:13

Having opinions doesn't make someone a narcissist. Not listening to or allowing other people to have opinions is allowing your own inner narcissist to have a voice. We all have one OP. We are all capable of believing we know better than everyone else. If you don't like these women, stop seeing them.

billy1966 · 18/03/2022 15:01

OP,
If the husbands enjoy playing together, there will be no blow back.

But you need to stop giving excuses and No, not available, not busy.

I have come across people like this and as @youvegottenminuteslynn has stated, silence is best.

So after saying "No I cant do/make/attend that". I simply didn't engage further.

I would fade them out to only very occasionally seeing them.

You are busy with work and other things...Sorry! and simply don't engage.

Be friendly and polite at social gatherings but avoid if possible.

Life is too short to spend time with tjosecyou don't like.

milkyaqua · 18/03/2022 14:40

Are you posting from the 1970s?

Buttercup54321 · 18/03/2022 14:32

I've had very similar with a pushy friend.She even questions my daughter to see if I actually did what I told her I was doing. Then her husband started texting my partner to check!!!
Now we are always busy and never reply to their questions. Daughter just saysI dont know.
Havent seen them in months. Its bliss

Burgoo · 18/03/2022 14:31

Just one last thing...

If you want to make her stop then you need to make her doing the behaviour aversive. If she is actually narcissistic (which I suspect she isn't, purely because narcs often don't expend this amount of effort on others because they simply don't believe you are worth their time) then you could be a little cool and aloof and not agree or encourage as much. She will likely find this aversive because she will want a degree of deference and warmth from you.

If she isn't narc and just lonely and unhappy then you could say something like "if we are going to continue being friends then I need some space. I want you to see me and have good times and at the same time if I feel suffocated it will make me not want to be around you". This would be EXTREMELY aversive so be gentle with it - you will likely prickle some guilt or shame doing this so just judge it well. If you aren't sure about how much guilt or shame she carries use with caution!

Burgoo · 18/03/2022 14:27

Having met a large number of diagnosed narcissists over the past 20 years I can say that she doesn't sound like a narcissist at all. As someone else said, its a hugely over-used term when we dislike what other people do. It is also actually really rare that people are genuine narcissists. We must remember that narcissists are ALL different. The "best" ones are the ones you wouldn't even suspect are. For example, female narcs are actually somewhat different from male ones. Men are more blatant about it, women often move into a martyr complex - making it sound like they are the centre of the world (e.g. "it must be me who caused this/made them feel bad etc) without actually bragging. But back to the question...

This sounds a little too playground for my liking. What is it with people not being able to just say what they feel and think? If you find her over-powering then tell her! She may simply have no idea. She also may be finding it hard to be alone, especially if she is isolated following these fall outs. If she is stay at home she may find that intolerable - unhappiness or anxiety about being alone isn't narcissistic, its just rather sad.

Be clear what you will and won't accept. Tell her directly. No hints, no undertones of annoyance and no passive aggressiveness. She will likely respect you more for being honest and I for one would appreciate knowing if I am doing something others find upsetting.

In short, grow up and just talk to her about it. If she doesn't like it then just stop talking to her. If you see her in the future let it be awkward. Your husbands relationship has no bearing on whether you opt to be friends with someone. And that's what this is all about. You either:

  1. Opt to be her friend (I use that term purposefully, you are choosing if you pick this option) - suck it up and stay unhappy
  2. Opt to be her friend with conditions and boundaries - this is where you lay down your cards and have a clear convo about what you will and won't accept
  3. Ditch her - and deal with the awkwardness
  4. Accept this is as she is and that you can't change her - maybe she will be easier to tolerate if you accept that she will nag you and you don't have to do as she says all the time

There aren't many other options available really. You could try to shape her behaviour by asking her out at times that suit you so that it becomes more even power wise. You could give her specific times when you ARE free - in advance. You may book her in when you see her - literally say "when shall we next catch up? I am free on X,Y or Z" and arrange it then and there.

Good luck. It sounds a tough situation and at the same time just ignoring it isn't likely to be successful in the longer-term

bluedodecagon · 18/03/2022 14:19

I can’t stand stuff like this because she sounds very annoying and irritating but you don’t need to label her a narcissist.

If you don’t like her, stop hanging out with her.

She’s pushy and you have poor boundaries. If she asks you to something, say no and stop replying. Say you’re busy and that’s it. Turn down all joint events with the husband.

It’s pretty easy.

xsquared · 18/03/2022 14:11

People like Jane are very draining to be around, so just distance yourself from her and decline further invitations for coffee etc.

I'm busy
That doesn't work for me
I'm not available

If she is a narc, they don't usually take no for an answer and can get very nasty. I would just block her from all communication at this point.

crispmidnightpeace · 18/03/2022 13:51

@User112

I met this lady (call her Jane) at a mutual friend’s place a year ago. Realised we grew up in the same neighbourhood (abroad) and went to the same uni. Also, her DS goes to the same school as mine (different year group). Nice. We exchanged numbers and met a few times. Her DH introduced my DH to a local group and they regularly play a sport together.

We have a busy life as DH and I work full time. Jane kept inviting us over to hers and being quite pushy about wanting us to spend hours at her place chatting and playing cards. She doesn’t work and has only one child (secondary school) so had a lot of free time. She is quite active in a local group and likes organising events.
She fell out with a few people in the group - I don’t know the back story. I get along with others and enjoy their company.

Ever since Jane’s fallout with the group, she has been nagging me every single day telling me when she is available to meet etc. she also tells me I need to take a break from work (I wfh 2 days a week) during the day to have tea with her (wtf !?). There is also one other lady who I met at the other friends party. That woman (Lisa) and Jane are meeting a lot these days and other ladies in the group are actively avoiding them.

Last week Lisa invited me over to hers for a coffee and I politely declined. She was super pushy. Jane has been super pushy. I finally gave in and went to see Jane after work yesterday. Guess what Lisa was there! They were bitching about a party I attended (they were not invited) and about other people I socialise with. Lisa says I should meet them more often (coffee with these two and their own group) or how else will I have fun!? Wtf !? And then proceeds to tell me I MUST go shopping with them tomorrow ( wtf NO !!?). I said sorry I can’t as I have to take DH to his tuition. Jane says, oh your DH can take him, you are coming with us !! WTF !?

There are two groups now and they don’t like each other. Jane’s group is very pushy, I don’t like them, I don’t enjoy the company. However, the husbands of this group play tennis with my husband regularly.
The other group, I like the company, they don’t bitch about others, have no problems with me meeting Jane and her group, generally easy going.

Jane gives me major narc vibes. I avoid narcs like plague. The insecurities, casual putting down, wanting to be involved in major decisions of our life, having opinions, making me feel uncomfortable about not telling her stuff, general show off, lacking class in any shape or kind.

I’d have instantly blocked her if our husbands were not friends. Tbh, Jane’s husband is a really nice chap. No probs with him at all.

Jane gives me major narc vibes. I avoid narcs like plague.

No you don't. Would you sit and have coffee with a plague victim?

Keep cancelling and ignoring until they get the message.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 18/03/2022 13:43

No that doesnt work for me.
No I'm not available.
As I said upthread, I'm not available that day.

DONT give a reason as it's opening grounds for negotiation. Dont say sorry.

Chickychickydodah · 18/03/2022 13:37

I’d ghost them .