Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gotten

311 replies

WinniePig · 18/03/2022 07:33

I’ve noticed many Americans using the term “gotten” and assumed it’s American English. Fine. But it’s not a word I would associate with good grammar on this side of the pond. Anyway, I’ve read a number of threads on here recently where the OP has written “gotten” in their original post (and each time I see it I shudder). Even worse…the dodgy verb crops up in this news article on the BBC (third para from end). The BBC (holds head in hands).

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-60789542

AIBU to despair at how this horrible little verb is infecting the English language…

OP posts:
Hospedia · 18/03/2022 09:58

I have some American friends, now located in the UK, and they absolutely love hearing us speak. One of them will think nothing of (politely) asking people where their accent is from if they hear an interesting sounding one while out and about. She will also ask me to repeat certain words that she hasn't heard before and will ask what they mean.

SalsaLove · 18/03/2022 09:56

Can I just add that an American would never dream criticising the way another native speaker uses the language. We find it interesting, but then we tend to love the English while not realising that they dislike and mock us. Shameful behaviour.

Hospedia · 18/03/2022 09:54

Did all the people on here who say “gotten” start saying it after reading Shakespeare, and out of a desire to resurrect old English?

I've said it my entire life because I'm Northumbrian and it's part of our dialect.

PS: if the word "mom" grates on you, you might be shocked to learn that Birmingham exists.

PoxyAndIKnowIt · 18/03/2022 09:52

like the letter “thorn” which obviously my keyboard won’t write but was a single letter for the sound th

It will! (just hold down 't') still used in Icelandic.

þÞ Smile

MonkeyPuddle · 18/03/2022 09:51

There’s so much snobbishness on threads like these. I use ‘gotten’ and ‘off of’ it’s nothing to do with Americanisms sneaking into my language. It’s just how I speak, how I’ve always spoken. I’ve got a broad East Yorkshire (Hull) accent.
Yeah, in some cases it might be Americanisation but in others, like mine, it’s just dialect.

ClinkeyMonkey · 18/03/2022 09:49

@Sarahcoggles

YANBU, I really hate gotten. And people on here will go on about old English, and language evolving etc etc, but actually we all know it’s only become fashionable because of the trend of adopting Americanisms. Kids watch American stuff on YouTube and tiktok, and pick up the words. And then adults adopt it to try and look cool. And sadly, it gradually becomes accepted. But it will make me wince to my dying day!
Maybe you'll get used to it. A few years ago, for example, a kid was a young goat, but here you are happily using it in the plural form to replace the word 'children'.
RashofBees · 18/03/2022 09:47

Even if it was a pure Americanism, what's the problem with that? The hatred of all things American is a very ugly side to MN and must be very unpleasant for American users to read.

I don’t hate all things American. I lived there as a child and it was probably the happiest part of my life. But I find the growing homogeneity of language sad. We’ve largely lost dialect in the UK, and regional accent differences are lessening too. There was a study done recently that showed people around manchester and Leeds have increasingly similar accents, so it’s far from just a US thing. These are natural changes, and inevitable in a world that is getting more connected, but it doesn’t mean I can’t have an emotional response to it. And my response is largely the same as when I read an article about 50% of insect species becoming extinct in the last 20 years (figures made up) or think about how new buildings look similar regardless of where in the world they’re built.

IsFuzzyBeagMise · 18/03/2022 09:47

@Catlover77

It annoys me so much. I would never write it or say it.
Because it's not part of your dialect.
Sarahcoggles · 18/03/2022 09:47

Did all the people on here who say “gotten” start saying it after reading Shakespeare, and out of a desire to resurrect old English?
Or did they watch too much Netflix in lockdown?
If it’s the former, then I’ll accept that.
If it’s the latter then it makes me cringe.
Don’t people want to be British any more? Does everyone want to be American?

I think it’s sad that as a nation we’re choosing to lose our words. I expect that in 50 years it’ll be gotten, mom, kindergarten, sidewalk, diaper and so on. And I think it’s a shame. Why do we need to turn into Americans?

Thewindwhispers · 18/03/2022 09:46

It’s Old English (from Old Norse). It’s used in the King James Bible (1611). It later fell out of use in England except in phrases like “ill-gotten gains” and “Jesus was begotten, not made” but I don’t have a problrm with it being revived here, I think it’s a fun word. I like most Old English words though. I’d love to being back some of the letters that fell out of our alphabet, like the letter “thorn” which obviously my keyboard won’t write but was a single letter for the sound th.

Zilla1 · 18/03/2022 09:45

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER Am unsure but I don't think it ever stopped -

"Baseball, like many popular sports of today, originated in England. The first mention of it was in 1755, when it was called “base ball.” it was a long time after that though before it became a codified sport. The traditional game of British baseball is played to this day in Wales and North-west England, but only on an amateur level and without any significant spectator participation."

Catlover77 · 18/03/2022 09:45

It annoys me so much. I would never write it or say it.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/03/2022 09:37

YABU. I would never write it as it's poor English

Whatever makes you think that it's poor English? If it's described as archaic (British) English, that still doesn't make it 'poor' English - very far from it - but even the designation of 'archaic' is subjective, and descriptive rather than prescriptive: just because a word or phrase falls out of popular usage doesn't mean that it's been banned or cancelled or that bullies will be waiting behind the bike sheds and demanding that you stop saying it.

CounsellorTroi · 18/03/2022 09:37

Don’t mind it at all. We still use this form in forgotten.

TrooBloo · 18/03/2022 09:37

Addicting is the one that has me furious.

‘I find it addicting.’ No you do not. You find it addictive.

Sarahcoggles · 18/03/2022 09:35

YANBU, I really hate gotten.
And people on here will go on about old English, and language evolving etc etc, but actually we all know it’s only become fashionable because of the trend of adopting Americanisms. Kids watch American stuff on YouTube and tiktok, and pick up the words. And then adults adopt it to try and look cool. And sadly, it gradually becomes accepted. But it will make me wince to my dying day!

PAFMO · 18/03/2022 09:33

There's nothing grammatically wrong with "off of". It jars because of the pronunciation more than anything- and the almost (but not quite) redundancy of the "of" particle. If you compare similar concepts like "away from" the almost redundancy of the second particle is still there, but doesn't cause any itching of teeth AFAIK.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/03/2022 09:32

@ThatsNotItAtAll

A lot of American English is actually old English or which didn't evolve but remained in the old form in North America, or regional/ dialect English which became mainstream. Gotten is actually the old form, so going "back" to gotten is de-evolution not evolution of language...
Talking of which, in her novel Northanger Abbey Jane Austen wrote that her main character, Catherine, enjoyed ‘boys’ plays’ such as cricket and ‘base ball’ (two words). Presumably the one that turned into rounders here, and baseball across the pond.
JenniferBarkley · 18/03/2022 09:31

This mystified me when I first joined MN, and now it infuriates me.

Such angst over a perfectly normal, everyday word. If you don't use it that's fine, but your ancestors likely did and as others have said it never fell our of use in the US, Scotland and Ireland. Probably parts of England too.

Even if it was a pure Americanism, what's the problem with that? The hatred of all things American is a very ugly side to MN and must be very unpleasant for American users to read.

Zilla1 · 18/03/2022 09:31

It got James Brown started. Though he was American.

Zilla1 · 18/03/2022 09:30

HNRTT but have you missed your calling to be French and run the Academie?

As PPs have said, you might want to select a pure foreign import or neologism to justify your argument. If not then perhaps understand a little more about English dialects, the evolution of English and the exchange with American where some historical English appears to have been preserved and the range of 'proper' current English usage.

WinniePig · 18/03/2022 09:30

@DampSquid

It's not as bad as "off of" as in "I got off of the bus". You just get off the bus surely Grin
Don’t get me started…
OP posts:
Franca123 · 18/03/2022 09:29

Yep, no issue with off of. Wouldn't write it but would certainly say it.

readsalotgirl63 · 18/03/2022 09:29

Definitely not Scottish as far as I know. My late dad hated it especially when used by siblings who'd emigrated to the US.

I agree - I hate it but think it is here to stay as agree language does evolve and change.

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 18/03/2022 09:29

Has always been in use in Ireland. Warms my Hiberno heart to see it cause such anguish on Mumsnet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread