Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gotten

311 replies

WinniePig · 18/03/2022 07:33

I’ve noticed many Americans using the term “gotten” and assumed it’s American English. Fine. But it’s not a word I would associate with good grammar on this side of the pond. Anyway, I’ve read a number of threads on here recently where the OP has written “gotten” in their original post (and each time I see it I shudder). Even worse…the dodgy verb crops up in this news article on the BBC (third para from end). The BBC (holds head in hands).

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-60789542

AIBU to despair at how this horrible little verb is infecting the English language…

OP posts:
HoldingTheDoor · 18/03/2022 10:23

Also, it’s Santa Claus in Ireland.

Also in Scotland.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 18/03/2022 10:23

Did all the people on here who say “gotten” start saying it after reading Shakespeare, and out of a desire to resurrect old English?
Or did they watch too much Netflix in lockdown?

Grin
Anoisagusaris · 18/03/2022 10:23

@SartresSoul

Hate it but I’m an English teacher so not a fan of Americanism’s in general. They’re creeping into our lingo so much they will eventually take over. See Mother’s Day and Santa Claus as prime examples.
Please tell me you teach your pupils the correct use of apostrophes???

Also, it’s Santa Claus in Ireland.

Gotten is used in Ireland. Perhaps if the English hadn’t forced their language on us, they wouldn’t be complaining about Hiberno-English on Mumsnet hundreds of years later.

SucculentChalice · 18/03/2022 10:22

@Thewindwhispers

It’s Old English (from Old Norse). It’s used in the King James Bible (1611). It later fell out of use in England except in phrases like “ill-gotten gains” and “Jesus was begotten, not made” but I don’t have a problrm with it being revived here, I think it’s a fun word. I like most Old English words though. I’d love to being back some of the letters that fell out of our alphabet, like the letter “thorn” which obviously my keyboard won’t write but was a single letter for the sound th.
It fell out of use because it requires an auxilliary verb as all other Germanic/ON origin languages to to give it the correct tense, OR it requires a prefix or a suffix. Which is why we still have "forgotten", and to a lesser extent "begotten".

And because those languages weren't influenced by Norman French, they still preserve the word order which requires the verb to have a prefix attached put at the end of the sentence.

RashofBees · 18/03/2022 10:21

@SalsaLove - sorry, but you can’t tar everyone with that brush. I was a little sad when I read that the official spelling of many European Portuguese words had been updated, making it more similar to Brazilian. I’m also the kind of person who will sign any petition going to stop old buildings (even quite ugly ones if I’m being honest with myself) from being demolished.

Sad, as one poster has it? Guilty. But I don’t accept the charge of anti-Americanism!

HoldingTheDoor · 18/03/2022 10:20

Then someone else will pop up and say its a Scottish word, which will confuse virtually every Scot, until some northern English people pop up and say they use it in their area.

It isn't confusing me. It's widely used in my part of Scotland. Some other Scottish posters have said the same.

SucculentChalice · 18/03/2022 10:18

I hate everything about the word "gotten", but particularly when the stating-the-obvious types pop up to point out for the trillioneth time that its an American older form of English.

Yes, but Americans use it correctly as the past tense that it always was here before language moved on and used the shortened version "got" which doesn't require the auxilliary verb (usually "have") for it to make sense!

Then someone else will pop up and say its a Scottish word, which will confuse virtually every Scot, until some northern English people pop up and say they use it in their area.

We all know its an attempt to appear trendy by being more American. Modern English stopped using 6 letters plus an auxilliary verb hundreds of years ago. American English has presumably preserved it because what became the US had a variety of languages spoken before English became dominant, including Dutch, French and some indigenous languages, so that is why the more formal past tense was preserved.

What I don't understand in American English is "it fit me". Surely "it fitted me" or "it fits me" is correct. Where did that one come from?

ClinkeyMonkey · 18/03/2022 10:16

[quote Sarahcoggles]@ClinkeyMonkey the word “kid”, meaning children, has a Norse origin, and has been in use in the English language since the 16th century. So it’s not an Americanism, which is what I mainly object to.[/quote]
It seems somewhat hypocritical to me to be happy with the use of 'kid' which, despite its origins, was adopted and popularised by Americans and subsequently imported to the UK and yet be unhappy with, say, 'kindergarten', which is clearly German in origin and adopted by Americans. If, in theory, it starts to replace 'nursery' or 'pre school', we'll all be saying it and only a few sad people longing for the language of yesteryear will complain.

Lurking9to5 · 18/03/2022 10:15

@SartresSoul

Hate it but I’m an English teacher so not a fan of Americanism’s in general. They’re creeping into our lingo so much they will eventually take over. See Mother’s Day and Santa Claus as prime examples.
oh dear.

Oh. Dear.

Oh Dear.

Three things in the post that make me wince.

IsFuzzyBeagMise · 18/03/2022 10:12

@eandz13

I say gotten, I don't actually know where I've picked it up, it just sounds 'proper' in my head! I didn't realise it was an Americanism either, I hate Americanisms Grin Will work on it now I've read this thread!
Keep it. It's grand Grin
SalsaLove · 18/03/2022 10:12

[quote Zilla1]@SalsaLove
they dislike and mock us. Shameful behaviour.

Confusing the part for the whole?

And though I don't agree with the OP, it appears at first glance that it's the importation of the usage rather than criticising that usage in its own setting that many PPs don't like.

Other than that, take the thread to be criticising Americans.[/quote]
No confusion here. I’ve lived here long enough to know.

eandz13 · 18/03/2022 10:11

I say gotten, I don't actually know where I've picked it up, it just sounds 'proper' in my head! I didn't realise it was an Americanism either, I hate Americanisms Grin
Will work on it now I've read this thread!

BobLep0nge · 18/03/2022 10:11

Hate it but I’m an English teacher so not a fan of Americanism’s in general

Some parts of the UK never stopped using gotten. I've used that word all my life, I even remember my great grandmother using it.

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 18/03/2022 10:10

@SartresSoul

Hate it but I’m an English teacher so not a fan of Americanism’s in general. They’re creeping into our lingo so much they will eventually take over. See Mother’s Day and Santa Claus as prime examples.
Americanism's?

You sure about that apostrophe?

SartresSoul · 18/03/2022 10:07

Hate it but I’m an English teacher so not a fan of Americanism’s in general. They’re creeping into our lingo so much they will eventually take over. See Mother’s Day and Santa Claus as prime examples.

Hospedia · 18/03/2022 10:06

sidewalk

We have that too here. A lot of houses locally have their front door down the side as that's how the village was built way back when. You down "down the side walk" to get to the front door (aka, the side path)

InsufficientOven · 18/03/2022 10:04

I agree, grammar has gotten worse
Grin

Hospedia · 18/03/2022 10:03

Well I hope she enjoys it while she can, because in a few years time there won’t be any English words left, it’ll all be American-speak!

How very Little England that attitude is. Of course there'll be English words left.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/03/2022 10:03

@Sarahcoggles

Did all the people on here who say “gotten” start saying it after reading Shakespeare, and out of a desire to resurrect old English? Or did they watch too much Netflix in lockdown? If it’s the former, then I’ll accept that. If it’s the latter then it makes me cringe. Don’t people want to be British any more? Does everyone want to be American? I think it’s sad that as a nation we’re choosing to lose our words. I expect that in 50 years it’ll be gotten, mom, kindergarten, sidewalk, diaper and so on. And I think it’s a shame. Why do we need to turn into Americans?
I attended a U.K. kindergarten in the 1950s. I don’t think of it as an American import, though you don’t often hear the word now. In any case it’s of German origin.

The import I like least is ‘dumb’ meaning stupid, as opposed to ‘unable to speak’. (Also a German import into American - German ‘dumm’ = stupid.)

A novel of mine went into an American edition. At one point (a dog was a major part of the story) I had mentioned ‘dumb animals’. The US copy editor wrote in the margin, ‘Dogs are not stupid!’ 😩

Can’t remember whether I reworded or just deleted that bit.

I dare say plenty of Brits would be unaware of the other meaning now.

JenniferBarkley · 18/03/2022 10:03

I have no problem with people saying whatever they like if it’s part of their local dialect and they’ve used it all their life. The ones that grate on me are the ones who said “got” until the last couple of years, then for some inexplicable reason decided to say “gotten”.

How do you know? I see people criticising its use on here all the time when they've no idea where a poster comes from. Have you really tracked whether all of your friends and family use the word gotten and when the make the change?

And has your language never changed? Surely you notice sometimes you're using a word or phrase all the time when you never used to before. Are your changing habits ok but other people's aren't?

Sarahcoggles · 18/03/2022 10:02

@Hospedia

I have some American friends, now located in the UK, and they absolutely love hearing us speak. One of them will think nothing of (politely) asking people where their accent is from if they hear an interesting sounding one while out and about. She will also ask me to repeat certain words that she hasn't heard before and will ask what they mean.
Well I hope she enjoys it while she can, because in a few years time there won’t be any English words left, it’ll all be American-speak!
MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 18/03/2022 10:02

I'm always a bit baffled at the regular appearance of threads along the lines of 'when did English people start referring to their darling mater by the awful Americanisation of 'mom?

I'm not English, I've never lived in England, and yet I've known for years that Mom is a West Midlands thing. But it's seemingly still to filter through to many of their countrymen and women. Points to insularity and a lack of interest in anything that happens beyond their particular suburb/city/village boundaries.

Zilla1 · 18/03/2022 10:00

@SalsaLove
they dislike and mock us. Shameful behaviour.

Confusing the part for the whole?

And though I don't agree with the OP, it appears at first glance that it's the importation of the usage rather than criticising that usage in its own setting that many PPs don't like.

Other than that, take the thread to be criticising Americans.

Sarahcoggles · 18/03/2022 10:00

@Hospedia

Did all the people on here who say “gotten” start saying it after reading Shakespeare, and out of a desire to resurrect old English?

I've said it my entire life because I'm Northumbrian and it's part of our dialect.

PS: if the word "mom" grates on you, you might be shocked to learn that Birmingham exists.

I have no problem with people saying whatever they like if it’s part of their local dialect and they’ve used it all their life. The ones that grate on me are the ones who said “got” until the last couple of years, then for some inexplicable reason decided to say “gotten”.
Sarahcoggles · 18/03/2022 09:58

@ClinkeyMonkey the word “kid”, meaning children, has a Norse origin, and has been in use in the English language since the 16th century. So it’s not an Americanism, which is what I mainly object to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread