Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gotten

311 replies

WinniePig · 18/03/2022 07:33

I’ve noticed many Americans using the term “gotten” and assumed it’s American English. Fine. But it’s not a word I would associate with good grammar on this side of the pond. Anyway, I’ve read a number of threads on here recently where the OP has written “gotten” in their original post (and each time I see it I shudder). Even worse…the dodgy verb crops up in this news article on the BBC (third para from end). The BBC (holds head in hands).

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-60789542

AIBU to despair at how this horrible little verb is infecting the English language…

OP posts:
OchonAgusOchonOh · 18/03/2022 20:16

@Migrainesbythedozen

Wikipedia requires sources though and Bibliographies so it's not like anyone can edit it and that edit stands. An edit will be reversed if there is no reference to back it up.
Only if someone else re-edits it to correct it. We have the classic example there of LizziAnt's page saying one thing and mine saying another about the same topic.

There are some pages the administrators keep an eye on and don't allow direct editing but most stuff isn't monitored and is a free for all.

Having had a look at LizziAnt's page, it lacks credibility from the first paragraph on. Ireland is referred to as part of the UK - surprised nobody has corrected that. Ulster English is referred to in the text but Hiberno-English is used in the sidebar suggesting these were written by different people. In fact, if you look at the history, you can see Hiberno-English was replaced with Ulster english in the text in 2017. In 2008, someone corrected the statement that british english is spoken in Ireland to say Hiberno English is spoken in Ireland. A correction in 2008 (correcting mistaken interpretation of the OED definition. Ireland follows British spellings etc. but cite does not support odd contention that British English encompasses Hiberno-English) indicates the previous entry is misrepresenting a source document by claiming british english is spoken in Ireland.

So all in all, wikipedia is as reliable as the oul fella in the corner of the pub rambling on about his pet topic.

PAFMO · 18/03/2022 19:54

[quote OchonAgusOchonOh]**@PAFMO* - Scottish English would come under the regional variations (as would Hiberno and Welsh)*

Given that Ireland is an independent country, Hiberno-english is most definitely not a regional variant of British English. Even SIRI knows that. The fact it is spoken by some in a part of the UK does complicate things but that is to do with a history of colonialism that we really shouldn't get in to here. So I guess the question is does British English refer to English spoken in Britain or in the UK? Second question then us does British english include all variants of English spoken in Britain (or the UK)?

I knew you said you're not sure so I'm not targeting the questions at you specifically but rather putting them out there as general questions.[/quote]
True. Though maybe it's considered British as in British Isles (geographical designation as opposed to political) I don't know though.

I can't remember the name of the linguist who devised it, but there's a map of circles and ripples showing the various Englishes and subsets. It starts out as 3 main ones. It will be interesting to see where that puts Hiberno. I'll see if I can find it.

Whywonttheyhelpme · 18/03/2022 19:40

YANBU.

There are so many commonly used words and sayings that make my left eye twitch.

Migrainesbythedozen · 18/03/2022 19:31

Wikipedia requires sources though and Bibliographies so it's not like anyone can edit it and that edit stands. An edit will be reversed if there is no reference to back it up.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 18/03/2022 19:27

@LizzieAnt

I just questioned the use of Hiberno-English as a subset of British English too, Ochon. I looked up British English in Wikipedia* and, lo and behold, Hiberno-English is listed as one of the standard forms, as well as RP and Standard Scottish English. Hmm, a bit like the linguistic version of the British Isles conundrum Grin Whatever its classification, we can agree that Hiberno-English is certainly based on British English, though it's heavily influenced by the Irish language too. Hiberno-English is also spoken in NI, of course.
  • Wikipedia is not the best source, I know. The article seemed to use Great Britain and the UK synonymously too, which didn't help at all.
Whereas this wikipedia page refers to it a separate to british english.

And that is why I tell my students that wikipedia is not a valid source to use as a reference Grin. Problem is any page can be edited by anyone.

LizzieAnt · 18/03/2022 19:03

I just questioned the use of Hiberno-English as a subset of British English too, Ochon. I looked up British English in Wikipedia* and, lo and behold, Hiberno-English is listed as one of the standard forms, as well as RP and Standard Scottish English. Hmm, a bit like the linguistic version of the British Isles conundrum Grin
Whatever its classification, we can agree that Hiberno-English is certainly based on British English, though it's heavily influenced by the Irish language too. Hiberno-English is also spoken in NI, of course.

  • Wikipedia is not the best source, I know. The article seemed to use Great Britain and the UK synonymously too, which didn't help at all.
YingMei · 18/03/2022 18:44

I always fine it bizarre when people are offended by the evolution of language. Language has been evolving since talking began- the English we consider correct now is very different from English a few hundred years ago.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 18/03/2022 18:31

@PAFMO - Scottish English would come under the regional variations (as would Hiberno and Welsh)

Given that Ireland is an independent country, Hiberno-english is most definitely not a regional variant of British English. Even SIRI knows that. The fact it is spoken by some in a part of the UK does complicate things but that is to do with a history of colonialism that we really shouldn't get in to here. So I guess the question is does British English refer to English spoken in Britain or in the UK? Second question then us does British english include all variants of English spoken in Britain (or the UK)?

I knew you said you're not sure so I'm not targeting the questions at you specifically but rather putting them out there as general questions.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 18/03/2022 18:25

@Musmerian

YABU - it’s just an archaic past tense form of the verb that died out in the 19th but stayed in the US and it’s now reappearing again. I would never use it but it’s becoming prevalent again. If language never changed we’d still be using it.
It didn't die out everywhere in the UK.

It's fairly annoying that people insist it did.

I think I'm going to start being completely dismissive of anything that is specifically English, acting like it doesn't exist. I mean, if it's fine to do that for Northern Ireland and Scotland...

Musmerian · 18/03/2022 18:17

YABU - it’s just an archaic past tense form of the verb that died out in the 19th but stayed in the US and it’s now reappearing again. I would never use it but it’s becoming prevalent again. If language never changed we’d still be using it.

PAFMO · 18/03/2022 18:16

[quote OchonAgusOchonOh]@PAFMO - so does Scotland not have their own version of English? I thought they did but being neither Scottish (or British for that matter) nor a linguist, there is a reasonable likelihood of me being wrong Grin

However, posters were referring to UK English rather than British English. If they had said British English I would not have assumed their attitude was so insular as it is a normal term that I'm familiar with. However, I am not clear on how it is defined. It definitely excludes Hiberno-english as that is a recognised variant of English but beyond that I don't know.

Surely if British English is the English used in Britain then any of the regional variants are part of British English? Lots of British posters have stated that gotten is normal in their dialect do surely then it is part of British English?[/quote]
I'm not sure tbh.

British English is the linguistic term, "UK English" may be being used as a synonym for that. Scottish English would come under the regional variations (as would Hiberno and Welsh) which, in turn would ripple outwards to include variations of all of those.

British posters saying "gotten" is part of their regional dialect find no opposition from me. Smile

Migrainesbythedozen · 18/03/2022 18:02

@WinniePig Those that use gotten are using the CORRECT British English.

Migrainesbythedozen · 18/03/2022 18:01

@WinniePig You are ill-informed. Gotten is the original British English. It pre-dates American usage. Americans are, hence, correct to use it, and British/UK people should be using it too. You should have researched before writing your thread.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 18/03/2022 17:56

The “gotten defenders” use the same arguments every time on these threads - it’s regional, it’s old English etc

Do you have any reason to think the 'arguements' have changed since the last time? Fwiw, the people that have an issue with gotten, also use the same single argument against it each time - at least we have more than one 😂

OchonAgusOchonOh · 18/03/2022 17:54

@PAFMO - so does Scotland not have their own version of English? I thought they did but being neither Scottish (or British for that matter) nor a linguist, there is a reasonable likelihood of me being wrong Grin

However, posters were referring to UK English rather than British English. If they had said British English I would not have assumed their attitude was so insular as it is a normal term that I'm familiar with. However, I am not clear on how it is defined. It definitely excludes Hiberno-english as that is a recognised variant of English but beyond that I don't know.

Surely if British English is the English used in Britain then any of the regional variants are part of British English? Lots of British posters have stated that gotten is normal in their dialect do surely then it is part of British English?

elp30 · 18/03/2022 17:49

@JenniferBarkley

This mystified me when I first joined MN, and now it infuriates me.

Such angst over a perfectly normal, everyday word. If you don't use it that's fine, but your ancestors likely did and as others have said it never fell our of use in the US, Scotland and Ireland. Probably parts of England too.

Even if it was a pure Americanism, what's the problem with that? The hatred of all things American is a very ugly side to MN and must be very unpleasant for American users to read.

I'm American and yes, it upsets me that so many on here simply just can't help themselves with finding something, anything to criticize us.

It is not a good look to me.

Trust me, there's plenty of things about British culture and language that I find absolutely silly but I just laugh it off and just accept that it's just the way the culture is and go on with my day.

Perhaps many on here could do the same.
I doubt it though. I'm sure they'll be another thread in a few days...

PAFMO · 18/03/2022 17:38

@OchonAgusOchonOh

I find these references to UK English rather bizarre. I am making the assumption, and do please correct me if I'm wrong, that the term is being used by English posters and that they are actually referring to English English.

Northern Ireland is in the UK. Hiberno-english is spoken by many living there. Scotland also has its own variant of English as does (I assume - I'm not terribly familiar with it) Wales.

It's a very insular attitude really.

No. British English is the correct linguistic term to differentiate it from American English, Australian English, South African English etc. In short- it's one of the many Englishes considered to be perfectly correct when using national and international parameters. Obviously, each one of those then get broken down again into regional Englishes. In this case, British English is being compared to American English so it's the correct term.
OchonAgusOchonOh · 18/03/2022 17:36

@Sarahcoggles

The “gotten defenders” use the same arguments every time on these threads - it’s regional, it’s old English etc. OK that’s fine - regional use is fine, people who’ve said gotten since they started to talk are fine. People who use gotten because they read a lot of Shakespeare and other historical literature - also fine. But anyone else - please tell me this - why did you say “got” for most of your adult life, then start saying “gotten” in the last few years? What was the reason?
Maybe the gotten defenders wouldn't need to use this, or any other, defence if the objectors weren't so strident and objectionable in their attitudes towards dialects other than their own.
MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 18/03/2022 17:35

Demented by 'gotten'

Sarahcoggles · 18/03/2022 17:30

The “gotten defenders” use the same arguments every time on these threads - it’s regional, it’s old English etc. OK that’s fine - regional use is fine, people who’ve said gotten since they started to talk are fine. People who use gotten because they read a lot of Shakespeare and other historical literature - also fine.
But anyone else - please tell me this - why did you say “got” for most of your adult life, then start saying “gotten” in the last few years? What was the reason?

IsFuzzyBeagMise · 18/03/2022 17:26

Absolutely Ochon!

'

OchonAgusOchonOh · 18/03/2022 17:24

@IsFuzzyBeagMise

Like it or not, 'like' is also a feature of my dialect. We tag it onto the end of a sentence.

'Do you know what I mean, like?'

Don't forget "you know, like"
OchonAgusOchonOh · 18/03/2022 17:23

@DontLookBackInAnger1

These types of threads have gotten so old.
Excellent example of the correct use of gotten Grin
IsFuzzyBeagMise · 18/03/2022 17:23

Like it or not, 'like' is also a feature of my dialect. We tag it onto the end of a sentence.

'Do you know what I mean, like?'

DontLookBackInAnger1 · 18/03/2022 17:22

These types of threads have gotten so old.