Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gotten

311 replies

WinniePig · 18/03/2022 07:33

I’ve noticed many Americans using the term “gotten” and assumed it’s American English. Fine. But it’s not a word I would associate with good grammar on this side of the pond. Anyway, I’ve read a number of threads on here recently where the OP has written “gotten” in their original post (and each time I see it I shudder). Even worse…the dodgy verb crops up in this news article on the BBC (third para from end). The BBC (holds head in hands).

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-60789542

AIBU to despair at how this horrible little verb is infecting the English language…

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
knitnerd90 · 20/03/2022 19:25

[quote mathanxiety]@knitnerd90, if I recall correctly, you are in the US too, and I agree with your observation wrt American use of got and gotten.[/quote]
Yep - also in the USA. My English is a complete mess at this point so I use my American-raised-and-schooled children as data points!

interesting one though: In American English, you can say I've got/he's got, etc, to mean "I have": "I've got a sandwich for lunch." My hypothesis is that it's because they perceive "I've" on its own to be inadequate. But you can't use it for get. "I"ve gotten you/I got you a chicken sandwich for lunch." And you can only use it contracted: You can say "I have a sandwich" or "I've got a sandwich" but you cannot say "I have got a sandwich" in AmE.

English, in all its dialects, obeys all sorts of rules we don't think about! (See also: "I'm eating cookies" versus "I eat cookies." We distinguish what's happening now from an habitual action, and this distinction can trip up English language learners. I've been studying Spanish as it would be very useful for work, and it's made me think about these issues in English.)

WalkingOnTheCracks · 20/03/2022 13:45

As many have said, language changes. English is particularly good at it, which is why it has spread so readily.

So, on the one hand, yes, you're being unreasonable to object to that.

But, on the other hand, no, it's perfectly reasonable to have a few personal bugbears about usage, even though you know you're on a loser.

For instance, 'iconic' in its new meaning of 'notable' or 'memorable' pisses me off.

"Ohh, and Bukayo Saka scores an iconic goal there!!!!"

No, he doesn't. No, no - shut up, you tosser.

But to my grandchildren the meaning that I feel has been lost - 'symbolic of an ideal' - will just be an interesting part of the word's etymology.

Maray1967 · 20/03/2022 07:18

As PP have noted, it is a traditional English word. I’m an historian and am very familiar with the word from early modern manuscripts.
Other phrases that we in the UK tend to assume are Americanisms but which are actually traditional English words include diaper instead of nappy.

liveforsummer · 20/03/2022 02:14

Do you really think people start using it after always previously using 'got'? I've never seen that happen tbh.

Tbf I pick up language quite easily and, not with gotten as that's something I used as a child in the 80' s but not so much now, but with many other things. I've lived all over the UK and also abroad so been exposed to different dialects and I've probably picked at least one or 2 sayings up from many of them. Similarly now back home if I was to work closely with someone from elsewhere and they used certain language often I might end up picking that up. The same can't be said for things I see fleetingly on tv. It's doubtful people have been saying it because Americans do but more likely they work beside/ socialise with someone from an area where it's common or have lived somewhere where

Fairislefandango · 19/03/2022 17:16

The “gotten defenders” use the same arguments every time on these threads - it’s regional, it’s old English etc. OK that’s fine - regional use is fine, people who’ve said gotten since they started to talk are fine. People who use gotten because they read a lot of Shakespeare and other historical literature - also fine. But anyone else - please tell me this - why did you say “got” for most of your adult life, then start saying “gotten” in the last few years? What was the reason?

Do you really think people start using it after always previously using 'got'? I've never seen that happen tbh.

Anyway, why does it matter? If the pedants' delicate ears can cope with hearing the word 'gotten' when said by Americans, Shakespeare enthusiasts and users of regional English, why are they suddenly enraged beyond all reason by hearing the exact same word from the lips of someone who happens not to belong to those categories?

If I heard, for example, a 25yo Londoner saying 'gotten', I'd certainly notice (I'm a linguist) and would think 'Oh - gotten - that's mildly unusual for a Londoner', but rather than thinking 'Argh - that's sooo annoying. It's not as if she's American!', I'd probably think she listened to or watched a lot of American content, or was brought up by parents from a part of the UK where 'gotten' is normal. Either way, so what?

Butchyrestingface · 19/03/2022 15:28

@Sarahcoggles

The “gotten defenders” use the same arguments every time on these threads - it’s regional, it’s old English etc. OK that’s fine - regional use is fine, people who’ve said gotten since they started to talk are fine. People who use gotten because they read a lot of Shakespeare and other historical literature - also fine. But anyone else - please tell me this - why did you say “got” for most of your adult life, then start saying “gotten” in the last few years? What was the reason?
I've used 'gotten' my entire life. Originally West of Scotland. Ubiquitous there.

Why would anyone start using it only in the last few years? Confused

On another note, how do peeps feel about the fairly common, informal WoS use of the word 'but'? Grin

StScholastica · 19/03/2022 09:25

Hate it.

liveforsummer · 19/03/2022 09:05

Did all the people on here who say “gotten” start saying it after reading Shakespeare, and out of a desire to resurrect old English?
Or did they watch too much Netflix in lockdown?

No Netflix or lockdowns in the 80's when we were all saying it, and I didn't read Shakespeare til at least the mid 90's so neither is an explanation. It was simply normal language

liveforsummer · 19/03/2022 09:02

@Hospedia

Gotten is part of the pitmatic dialect too, spoken around various parts of Northumberland and Durham. We also use "off of", said to my own DC this morning when I told them "get off of that wall before you fall" - the 'of' is pronounced more like 'uv'.
Yes we'd say off of as kids as well as gotten. I grew up in the Scottish Borders so I guess there would be plenty overlap if language between there and north England. As with gotten I don't here it as much now but I do live further north which could be the reason rather than it actually being over all less used
liveforsummer · 19/03/2022 08:56

OK. I must have not noticed it somehow! Will listen out for it. I just thought it might be a West Coast thing, if I'd not heard it.

I grew up in eastern Scotland and it was very commonly used. Don't hear it quite as much now though

LizzieAnt · 19/03/2022 04:21

This is interesting. The use of got versus gotten as a past participle depends on the meaning of the verb too. Got in the sense of must or have is treated differently to got in the sense of became or received.

getproofed.com/writing-tips/word-choice-got-vs-gotten/

I think these types of distinctions are natural to a native speaker familiar with the word and aren't usually thought about too much. I'd take the examples about the hat upthread to mean something other than when the hat was in your possession, SucculentChalice. It's more about the meaning of the verb - to have versus to receive.

I've gotten a hat = I've received or obtained a hat
I've got a hat = I have a hat

Using the word gotten allows the distinction, actually. It allows clarity regarding the particular meaning of the verb.

Gotten is widely used in Ireland (which isn't mentioned in the article Smile) though probably more in speech than in writing.

mathanxiety · 19/03/2022 02:49

@knitnerd90, if I recall correctly, you are in the US too, and I agree with your observation wrt American use of got and gotten.

mathanxiety · 19/03/2022 02:45

@SucculentChalice, I speak West Brit and Hiberno English, as well as American English, the language of my children and the place where I live. I have learned both Irish and German as second languages. I spent many years studying grammar in both of those languages.

I'm not convinced by the 'hat' examples you are offering.

knitnerd90 · 19/03/2022 01:35

@SucculentChalice

I hate everything about the word "gotten", but particularly when the stating-the-obvious types pop up to point out for the trillioneth time that its an American older form of English.

Yes, but Americans use it correctly as the past tense that it always was here before language moved on and used the shortened version "got" which doesn't require the auxilliary verb (usually "have") for it to make sense!

Then someone else will pop up and say its a Scottish word, which will confuse virtually every Scot, until some northern English people pop up and say they use it in their area.

We all know its an attempt to appear trendy by being more American. Modern English stopped using 6 letters plus an auxilliary verb hundreds of years ago. American English has presumably preserved it because what became the US had a variety of languages spoken before English became dominant, including Dutch, French and some indigenous languages, so that is why the more formal past tense was preserved.

What I don't understand in American English is "it fit me". Surely "it fitted me" or "it fits me" is correct. Where did that one come from?

No. Got is still the simple past tense in AmE. "I got myself a sandwich." Gotten is only the past participle: "I had gotten some sandwiches." Americans use both, as appropriate. They just don't say "had got."

I am sad about the loss of regional dialects and accents, which is an issue in the US too. That's not the same as thinking one is better than the other, though. That's going back to the old days of teaching kids to speak in RP so they'd sound posh.

mathanxiety · 19/03/2022 01:30

YABU and also parochial.

It's an older form of the verb which hasn't completely died out in the UK or Ireland.

solbunny · 19/03/2022 01:29

@ClinkeyMonkey

'I was sat' isn't used here in NI, but I appreciate it's commonly used elsewhere. It does sound 'wrong' to my ears. 'I was sitting' is the phrase I was taught. 'I was sat' used to get on my nerves, especially when someone on a knitting forum (all language experts there of course!) corrected my use of 'I was sitting' (sitting knittingGrinGrin) but I'm used to hearing it now and have decided, in my obviously very very important opinion, that it is acceptable.
Ooo okay this one is fascinating me - I can't imagine saying anything other than "I was sat" Shock never knew this was a thing!
UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 19/03/2022 01:20

I grew up with “gotten” in Canada. It never occurred to me there could be another way, until my British MIL told me how much she hates “gotten”. It now holds a special pleasure and delight for me. 😁

LizzieAnt · 19/03/2022 01:13

Got to me would mean something very recent, ie there and then or that day, whereas gotten to me would mean something that happened in the past.

I don't think this is the way the verb is used in general SucculentChalice.
I'm not an expert in this at all, but afaik gotten can be used in the present perfect (to indicate an action that started in the past and continues to have consequences in the present) as well as in the past perfect (to indicate a time in the past that lasted to another time in the past).

So present perfect = The child has gotten so big, hasn't she?

Past perfect = It had gotten wetter and wetter all through the winter, but thankfully the weather had improved again with the coming of spring.

Got is also the simple past tense of the verb, not the present tense, as I think you said upthread

Got is more widely used in the UK in place of gotten in the examples above - it's not wrong, Migranesbythedozen, but neither is gotten. Their frequency of use varies by dialect, that's all.

solbunny · 19/03/2022 00:40

@SimpleShootingWeekend

YAB Ridiculous. It’s an English word. Even if it was American, that’s no reason to shudder and compare it to a virus. Ditto Mom, another English word that induces sneery posts by untraveled people who imply that others watch far too much low brow television. Only 6 months until the Hallowe’en threads where it will again be pointed out that the whole of the UK does not live in, and draw their language and culture from, the South East of England.
My West Midlands-dwelling friends are always irritated by people ignorantly asserting that only Americans say mom!
solbunny · 19/03/2022 00:30

@Palavah

YABU

Its use in British English predates the colonisation of America, which is why it features in American English, though it subsequently fell out of favour in British English.

This. I also just think "gotten" sounds nice, personally Smile
OchonAgusOchonOh · 19/03/2022 00:28

@SucculentChalice

Ochon If you put some actual words after "I've gotten" I'm sure I'd get what you mean.

Got to me would mean something very recent, ie there and then or that day, whereas gotten to me would mean something that happened in the past.

In other words, I wouldn't be sure whether something that had been gotten was that recent an acquisition or not. I would assume it meant in the past unless the context implied something different to me. It wouldn't add meaning, it would reduce it.

Got to me means something more immediate. I'm British, but not English, from a heavily Scandinavian influenced dialect area. I don't use dialect myself although I understand it perfectly well. To my ear, southern English has lost a lot of distinctions that some other dialects retain.

But got does not necessarily mean recent. E.g. I got a present when I was born.

To me, I got = I received it at a specific time in the past.
I have gotten = I received it at an unspecified time in the past.

I have got = I currently have something at this moment in time.

SucculentChalice · 19/03/2022 00:21

Ochon If you put some actual words after "I've gotten" I'm sure I'd get what you mean.

Got to me would mean something very recent, ie there and then or that day, whereas gotten to me would mean something that happened in the past.

In other words, I wouldn't be sure whether something that had been gotten was that recent an acquisition or not. I would assume it meant in the past unless the context implied something different to me. It wouldn't add meaning, it would reduce it.

Got to me means something more immediate. I'm British, but not English, from a heavily Scandinavian influenced dialect area. I don't use dialect myself although I understand it perfectly well. To my ear, southern English has lost a lot of distinctions that some other dialects retain.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 19/03/2022 00:09

@SucculentChalice

Migrainesbythedozen You cannot use the rules of other languages for British English. It does not work like that. I suggest you speak to a Professor of English Literature at your local university who can explain it to you. You are wrong, it's that simple.

I'm not "using rules of other languages" - please don't make things up to suit your narrative. I'm using standard grammatical rules relating to past and present tenses. Although its not as if they are uniformly taught in Britain, so I'm not sure why asking a professor of English literature would be relevant. Perhaps a professor of English grammar might like to answer questions from non-students a little more, although its equally unlikely. This is school level stuff, not university level. You must be able to distinguish between tenses in your own language in order to do so in other languages.

Ochon If you put some actual words after "I've gotten" I'm sure I'd get what you mean

"I've gotten a new hat" - meaning that I have already acquired a new hat. Its in the past.

"I've got a new hat" - meaning I've literally just acquired a new hat. Or at least its the present imperfect tense. You don't know exactly when the hat was acquired, but you do know from the grammatical tense used that it was fairly recent. With gotten, its less recent and definitely not in the present.

Or to put it another way, "got" is the verb, "ten" is the stem which indicates the tense. If you don't need to indicate that it was in the past then you don't use the "ten" suffix indicating the past tense or past imperfect/imperative.

I'm still confused as your examples really don't use enough words to clearly show what you're trying to say.

What I think you mean is "I've gotten a new hat" is something that happened in the past e.g. I've gotten a new hat every year for my birthday. So are you saying that people are using gotten to mean that they currently have a hat e.g. I've gotten a hat now? I've never heard it used that way.

So am I understanding you correctly?

SucculentChalice · 18/03/2022 23:53

@Migrainesbythedozen

Gotten not only is right, it sounds right.

I have got - sounds very stilted and abrupt, a bit like broken English.

I have gotten - flows well and sounds like proper English.

I did notice many people used "I have got" or "I've got" when I first arrived on this site, and it was very jarring. So very jarring and 'made my teeth itch', to use a Mumsnet term. I continually wanted to grammar correct those and say "it is gotten!". I'm glad others are seeing that 'got' is lazy and incorrect grammar, that gotten is the correct form. I am surprised at how many people on here didn't realise this.

"got" sounds awkward or stilted because its lost its prefix and "gotten" makes it acquire a suffix. So with its prefix in older speech it would have been "I have begot" rather than modern "I got".
SucculentChalice · 18/03/2022 23:49

Migrainesbythedozen You cannot use the rules of other languages for British English. It does not work like that. I suggest you speak to a Professor of English Literature at your local university who can explain it to you. You are wrong, it's that simple.

I'm not "using rules of other languages" - please don't make things up to suit your narrative. I'm using standard grammatical rules relating to past and present tenses. Although its not as if they are uniformly taught in Britain, so I'm not sure why asking a professor of English literature would be relevant. Perhaps a professor of English grammar might like to answer questions from non-students a little more, although its equally unlikely. This is school level stuff, not university level. You must be able to distinguish between tenses in your own language in order to do so in other languages.

Ochon If you put some actual words after "I've gotten" I'm sure I'd get what you mean

"I've gotten a new hat" - meaning that I have already acquired a new hat. Its in the past.

"I've got a new hat" - meaning I've literally just acquired a new hat. Or at least its the present imperfect tense. You don't know exactly when the hat was acquired, but you do know from the grammatical tense used that it was fairly recent. With gotten, its less recent and definitely not in the present.

Or to put it another way, "got" is the verb, "ten" is the stem which indicates the tense. If you don't need to indicate that it was in the past then you don't use the "ten" suffix indicating the past tense or past imperfect/imperative.

Swipe left for the next trending thread