Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think wraparound childcare for year 7 isn’t a thing

132 replies

BananaPie · 17/03/2022 23:07

Help me solve a debate with DH..

I think that when ds goes into year 7 in a couple of years time he will be walking to school and back by himself. He’ll be home by around 4pm and will have homework to complete.

At the moment while he is at primary school he goes to the after school club most afternoons and either me or dh pick him up around 6pm (neither of us work from home).

I think that when he is at secondary school we will need to change our working hours so that one of us can be at home from around the time he gets back from school. That way we will be able to check he isn’t accidentally burning the house down and make sure he settles down to some homework.

Dh’s view is that this will be too tricky to organise with work and we should get a nanny / childminder/ tutor.

Wider context - some special needs issues and we can’t see ds being particularly independent/ sensible by the time he gets to year 7.

What do most people do?

OP posts:
longlines · 18/03/2022 07:03

When I was this age, both my parents worked full time.

We used to have au pairs. When we were younger they looked after us, but as we got older they were just there so there was someone in the house for the 2 hours before my parents got home. As they didn't need to do active childcare they also helped my mum with things like ironing, instead, so a bit like a mother's help.

We'd eat when my parents got home.

It worked well on the whole, and it's an easy set up for an au pair.

HikingforScenery · 18/03/2022 06:59

Can he attend any after school club at all?
Try building up a little bit of independence here and there and gauge. Sometimes, they can surprise you.

I must admit I’m surprised you trust him to walk to and from school by himself but not stay home by himself for an hour or so?

Onetwo34567890 · 18/03/2022 06:58

Make use of the free after school clubs if they are available. At my children’s school they finish between 4-4:30 and there are lots available homework club, languages, gaming, lots of sports etc. My two go to a few a week and then I pick them up after work, or they start making their own way home and I’ll collect them on my way back as we live an hours walk so I can pass the journey they take.

Ineedapuppy · 18/03/2022 06:54

My DS is in Y7 and I have a minder come to the house. They make a snack, chat and sometimes makes dinner.

Changing work hours is a nightmare, leaving DS alone isn’t an option as simply he’s not used to it - for PP that say “I used to do it” etc its worth reflecting that for the past two years kids have been stuck at home with parents, being home schooled, not been to parties - they still need to get independence but it’s not the same as it used to be & we should acknowledge that and put provision in to help kids.

BrieAndChilli · 18/03/2022 06:49

I have to say there is an odd thing that happens about halfway through year 6. Up until that point you can’t imagine them coping with secondary school and walking by themselves etc etc then all of a sudden they get really mature and too ‘old’ for primary school. It’s happened with all 3 of mine even my current year 6 who has always been the baby and a bit of a monkey!

With my eldest who has ASD we just made sure we went over the rules eg no sharp knives/cooking, no trampoline etc etc he is very sensible though and will follow rules even if he could get away with it. I would text/call him to make sure he was ok.
I didn’t worry so much about the rest as they aren’t on thier own as have each other

BarbaraofSeville · 18/03/2022 06:48

@BananaPie

Thanks. Some really helpful ideas here. I guess we’ll work it out nearer the time, but there are a few options I hadn’t thought of.
If he's in Y6 now, it's something you can start easing him into over the next 6 months. Leave him at home while you pop out to the shop or whatever. Or send him to the shop, post box, etc etc.

But I do question your comment 'Dh’s view is that this will be too tricky to organise with work and we should get a nanny / childminder/ tutor'.

Is this a genuine problem, ie he works fixed shifts that cannot be changed, or is it just that he doesn't want to ask his employer for the sort of flexibility that disproportionately falls on mothers?

carefullycourageous · 18/03/2022 06:45

I think you can not judge now what you will need for your child in Yr7 but the following are all common in that year:

  • Go home to parents
  • Go home to an empty house
  • Go home and someone else be there, paid or unpaid
  • Go to someone else's house, paid or unpaid
  • Stay at school (ours has access to the library for an extra hour)
  • Go to activities
  • Combination

It may be that you can send him home alone for a couple of days but not all the days for example. Or you may be able to find a sensible sixth former who would like to earn a bit of cash by popping in and overseeing some homework.

Heatherjayne1972 · 18/03/2022 06:44

My two come home and are here for an hour before I get in
There no breakfast club/afterschool/ holiday care at all here for secondary school kids

School Holidays are the worst. They spend lots of time alone

Mummyoflittledragon · 18/03/2022 06:43

YANBU to think it isn’t a thing for most secondary aged children. However, it sounds as though your ds could do with some support. Dd wouldn’t have been happy to be left until 6 every evening at that age. She told me as much. I know plenty of parents do so it really is dependent on the child. Now she’s year 9 she would cope just fine. In my experience, year 7s aren’t great at assessing risk. I think your dh is correct tbh.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 18/03/2022 06:39

Mindee's I was 15/16 she was 11

Oblomov22 · 18/03/2022 06:39

What SN's does he have? Even with SN, most will be totally ok being at home for an hour till you return.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 18/03/2022 06:32

An hour or so once or twice a week is fine. 3-6 everyday not so much. Bear in mind it gets dark and pretty cold by 4:30 in Nov- Feb. No bad idea to have an adult at home, also IME they need a substantial snack and if not supervised will just eat mountains of junk.

Ideally someone could change their working hours to be home by 4:30 Or yes pay a friendly pensioner/ older teen. Year 10s ( 14-15) are ideal as cannot get other jobs and not in exam year. I did most of my GCSE course work at my minders kitchen table between 4&6 pm.

ChiselandBits · 18/03/2022 06:32

It is difficult. My DS's school finishes v early and only runs clubs a couple of times a week which he isn't interested in. He gets himself home and has at least 90 mins to empty the fridge and watch crap on you tube. It's far from ideal but I'm a ft working sp. It's not that he's in danger but he spends a lot of time in a very unprofitable way. The idea that he would independently study without me standing over him is hilarious. Dd would, but not DS.

BananaPie · 18/03/2022 06:29

Thanks. Some really helpful ideas here. I guess we’ll work it out nearer the time, but there are a few options I hadn’t thought of.

OP posts:
popandchoc · 18/03/2022 06:19

My eldest starts secondary school in sept . They open the grounds from around 7.45 to have breakfast etc if needed. They also do have after school clubs for sports etc . I only go in the office two days a week so they will be the only two days she is alone after school for a couple of hours .

pussycatunpickingcrossesagain · 18/03/2022 06:07

@StScholastica

My DS used to let himself in with a key in a keysafe. It worked well after an initial blip when I got home early and caught him watching the Simpsons whilst drinking a can of Stella. Shock
😹 Oh dear.
Sirzy · 18/03/2022 05:54

Ds secondary school runs a free “homework club” after school each day so it my be worth checking out provision at your school

Rinatinabina · 18/03/2022 05:47

@StScholastica

My DS used to let himself in with a key in a keysafe. It worked well after an initial blip when I got home early and caught him watching the Simpsons whilst drinking a can of Stella. Shock
LOL sorry, thats just hilarious.
autienotnaughty · 18/03/2022 05:45

Every child is different, I wfh until my dd were y9 and y7 then they came home to empty house. But I felt better knowing older dd was looking out for younger dd. My ds has asd I only work part time so I'm there when school finishes. You could use a childminder, relative or rearrange your hours.

milkysmum · 18/03/2022 05:44

From y 6 mine let them selves in and waited till I got back from work.
Sometimes I'd work from home later in the afternoon if I could, other times I get back 5ish.

HerbivorousRex · 18/03/2022 05:32

When I was a student I worked for a family in a similar situation (they also had a primary school aged DC but I think they would probably have used me even if they had only had the older DC).
The DC I looked after had some SEN needs but was able to walk home by himself. I would just make sure that I was there when he got in and then helped with homework/got on with light tidying or cooking jobs whilst he watched TV or played on the computer.
Most of the time he didn’t really need me so I’d do my coursework but it meant I was available for the few occasions where he did need some help or was going to do something unwise/dangerous.
Depending on his needs you might be able to find a college/university student who is willing to keep an eye on him for a few hours in the afternoon until you get back (it’ll probably be cheaper and more flexible than childcare aimed at younger kids).

ThePoint678 · 18/03/2022 03:21

I think you’d have to plan for someone to be at home at least 2-3 afternoons a week to make sure he is safe and getting into homework and if that can’t be either of you then you may have to hire someone to be at home with him.

MangyInseam · 18/03/2022 02:13

[quote nokidshere]@MangyInseam And I don't know where you live but in the uk there are no laws about what age you can leave a child alone or what age a babysitter should be.[/quote]
Yes, I am not in the UK, I am in Canada. Not noted for a lot of terrible babysitting related deaths or anything like that.

But babysitting at 12 used to be very common in many places including the UK. And certainly kids were able to stay alone for a while.

raspberryjamchicken · 18/03/2022 02:07

My eldest is in Year 7 and lets herself in around 3.45. She then is home alone usually for around 45 minutes to an hour before DH or I get home. We have had to start leaving work earlier to facilitate this. It's possible because we're teachers although not ideal as it just means bringing more work home. She doesn't have any additional needs though and I wouldn't feel comfortable leaving her regularly until 6. On occasion she has had to stay alone for a couple of hours but we try not to do this.

I started letting her come home once a week by herself towards the end of Year 6 to get her used to it. I don't think any wraparound care exists for this age. You could maybe find and pay a college student or something?

nokidshere · 18/03/2022 01:56

@MangyInseam And I don't know where you live but in the uk there are no laws about what age you can leave a child alone or what age a babysitter should be.