Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you still celebrate your Irish roots, even if you're not Irish

231 replies

Stressedout65 · 17/03/2022 22:59

One of my paternal great grandfathers was Irish & I had an Irish surname until I got married. I even have a piece of clothing made from the Irish family tartan with the family name coat of arms emblazoned on it. I wanted to wear it to work today as we had the option of dressing for St Patricks Day (in England). I chickened out as it felt false & attention seeking. An Irish colleague said I should have worn it if I wanted to as it's part of my Irish roots & heritage. I feel my Irish roots are now so diluted it didn't feel right. How far back do you celebrate your roots & heritage if they're different to what you actually are now?
I do feel drawn to Ireland, it's culture & music. I don't know if this "connection" I feel is exaggerated because I lost my dad a year ago

OP posts:
MoreCraicPlease · 18/03/2022 07:55

I am Irish and we love anyone with or without links to Ireland celebrating St Patrick’s day. You only have to watch the footage from the White House as proof - we are happy to play along.
There is no such thing as cultural appropriation when it comes to Irish roots!
Enjoy your tartan next year OP.

There is no risk of cultural appr

Gottamakesense · 18/03/2022 07:55

Some weird views on here about cultural appropriation...

I look at it this way. My grandparents say I'm an Irish girl and I must never forget it and that's good enough for me.

My Irish grandfather went back and forth from England to Ireland for work. Met my grandmother, also over here for work. Most of the family stayed in Ireland. Must their descendants lose their identity, community and family connections because circumstances forced some to go to England for work?

Springwreath · 18/03/2022 07:54

Yes! My mother is Irish and my father is English. I sound English and I've never lived in Ireland but we visited twice a year throughout our childhood. However, we lived in a strongly Irish community in England, went to a Catholic school and our lives revolved around our Catholic parish and all the annual Saints days and liturgical events that were celebrated throughout the year. In fact, we probably had a more old fashioned and stricter Catholic upbringing than my cousin's back in Ireland! Grin

ladygindiva · 18/03/2022 07:47

My mother is Irish and my father is Scottish, I was born in Scotland but grew up abroad in various countries until settling in England aged 9. I can't explain why, but I feel Scottish. Not remotely Irish. Maybe because it's my birthplace, more likely because my dad is very vocal in his Scottishness and taught me a lot about the culture and country itself and how in his view its the best place on earth.

MrsGHarrison87 · 18/03/2022 07:46

No, Irish is just a tiny part. I'm more English, Spanish and Danish ( did a DNA kit).

Turningpurple · 18/03/2022 07:41

I find 'feeling X nationality' when its quite distant and you haven't lived there a bit odd. But dont judge people for it.

My mum was Irish. Her mum was, her dad was Greek and met my nana in england. I spent my first years in Ireland as mum moved back.

My dad is another ethnicity all together and i am mixed race. We don't have much to do with dad's side. I don't really feel half South Asian because it hasnt influenced my life so much.

When mum moved back to England most of my time was spent with my Irish family that lived here and definitely has (as I have got older) impacted my view of things and who I am.

I dont consider myself Irish or English. I dont really celebrate either. Though we do have a few Irish traditions. I certainly dont feel greek because my grandad was though, he did influence my life alot as well.

My nationality and heritage is something I really think about only when answering the question on forms.

To be honest, I think alot of people cling on to their long Irish ancestors, because there's a view that being English is a bit shit. Mainly online. Lots of Americans certainly do this.

Yesterday my family exchanged Happy St Patrick day messages. That was about it.

ThatsNotItAtAll · 18/03/2022 07:40

I think claiming to be Irish in particular due to one (of 8) great grandparents being Irish seems "fake" or like cultural appropriation because in certain circumstances it's a "fashionable" identity to claim. Nobody ever claims to be Rumanian or Polish or German or Russian having never lived in the country or spoken the language because of one great grandparent who they never met ...

If you'd honestly say you're Bulgarian under the same circumstances if you swapped out the Irish great grandparent for a Bulgarian one then I guess you aren't being fake.

An American lady told me once that she's Irish because her (several generations of great) grandfather was an Irish stable boy who ran off with the English landowner's daughter. This sounded like a family urban legend or the plot of a soft porn film or mills and boon paperback and unlikely to be true, but what I thought at the time was that that made her English and the descendant of the landowner as much as it made her Irish... funny how she picked the romantic sounding great grandparent to define herself by...

Branleuse · 18/03/2022 07:37

@Sparkl

I’m Irish and I never heard of anyone with ‘family tartan’. I thought that was a Scottish thing. Who knew.
Theyre different to scottish tartan. Its definitely a thing as my ds1 and also my brother have looked a lot into this stuff and ours. I imagine theyre more into it than the ones actually in ireland though
Sparkl · 18/03/2022 07:33

I’m Irish and I never heard of anyone with ‘family tartan’. I thought that was a Scottish thing. Who knew.

girlmom21 · 18/03/2022 07:32

St Patrick's Day is an excuse for a piss up.

Nobody, English, Irish or otherwise celebrates St George's Day in the same way.

JenniferWooley · 18/03/2022 07:31

I suppose it depends on how much of your Irish heritage/culture you were exposed to growing up. Like others on the thread I have an Irish grandparent & it was very much a part of our lives growing up with music, dancing, stories & food and regular visits to & from our Irish relatives still living in Ireland.

I do agree with the PP that it's a shame St Andrews day isn't celebrated in the same way. I don't mean an excuse for a piss up but in the "it's great being Irish" sort of way.

MedusasBadHairDay · 18/03/2022 07:28

I do feel a connection to Ireland, both paternal grandparents were Irish and my father - though born in England - spent half of his childhood in Ireland. So he's always seen himself as part Irish and I've been brought up to be aware of and proud of my heritage.

Saying that, I didn't do anything for St Patrick's as it largely involves going down the pub for my family, and I don't often drink. I did get my usual photo of a pint of Guinness from my dad and uncle though 😂

Schwarz · 18/03/2022 07:25

My dad is Irish so I celebrate as much as I can! I probably wouldn't feel as connected to it if it was more distant than that though.

Doo5 · 18/03/2022 07:23

My parents are Irish and my partners grandparents are all Irish but we live in England. We have both been brought up visiting Ireland, listening to the music, watching GAA, Irish dancing etc so we are very much Irish culturally. Our son will be brought up the same. We have Irish passports too.
You should have worn your item of clothing if you wanted to! I don't see any harm in doing so.

Branleuse · 18/03/2022 07:21

My grandfather was irish and im awaiting my irish nationality/ passport but I dont celebrate st Patricks day

NativityDreaming · 18/03/2022 07:17

I am originally from North America and where I grew up everyone celebrates St Patrick’s Day. We celebrated at school, later at work and in the pubs. We had themed parties and a parade every year. Even my friends who are now living in countries with large expat communities still celebrate.

EdHelpPls · 18/03/2022 07:16

I'm actually Irish. Didn't acknowledge St Patrick's Day at all, which is about how much I celebrate being Irish in general 😁.
It's not that I don't like being Irish, I'm just neutral I suppose!

WlNDMlLL · 18/03/2022 07:16

Just googled and apparently 10% of people in Britain have an Irish grandparent so the number with great grandparents must be loads. According to Wikipedia anyway.

WlNDMlLL · 18/03/2022 07:14

I've got an Irish great grandparent and don't feel any more connection to Ireland than to any other country. Had completely forgotten about the fact til I read your post. I think it's a bit of a tenuous connection to be honest. I'd be interested to know what percentage of people in the UK, particularly in certain parts, have an Irish great grandparent - a lot, if have thought.

Mybestyear · 18/03/2022 07:13

@AffIt

No, it's weird.

I'm from the west of Scotland and have the usual 'mongrel' background of mostly Highland/Lowland Scots, North of England, Northern Ireland etc, but I was born and brought up in Scotland and therefore I am Scottish.

The one rock thrown into my personal genetic pool is that my paternal great grandfather was Romanian: but I never met him, I've never been to Romania, I don't know any Romanian people, and I know fuck all about the place if I'm being honest.

This 'tying your identity to something you're not' is bizarre and smacks of cultural appropriation. Just drink Guinness if you want to, nobody cares.

I’m west of Scotland too and it always annoys me that st Patrick’s day is celebrated more than St. Andrew’s day - just another excuse for a piss up.
HikingforScenery · 18/03/2022 07:10

How do you celebrate roots you don’t have?

MinnieMountain · 18/03/2022 07:08

Odd. I had an Irish great grandmother. It wouldn’t occur to me to have anything to do with St Patrick’s day.

@Aspidistra1 I’d say that’s different if you’re actually in the country (I’m Welsh).

sashh · 18/03/2022 05:52

I'm an English atheist with a tenuous connection to Ireland from great or great great grandparents.

A couple of years ago I spent the evening of the 17th wearing a green top, n a parochial hall singing along with everyone else.

A party is a party.

OutlookStalking · 18/03/2022 05:34

My childrens great grandfather and mother (didnt meet them) were dutch but they wouldn't claim dutch heritage.

It does seem lots in America do claimIrish (or scottish) descent many generations pn though.

whitewashing · 18/03/2022 05:30

No…my great, great grandfather was Irish, he came to Scotland to an industrial area for work, but the link is so tenuous, I never consider myself anything other than Scottish.