Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you still celebrate your Irish roots, even if you're not Irish

231 replies

Stressedout65 · 17/03/2022 22:59

One of my paternal great grandfathers was Irish & I had an Irish surname until I got married. I even have a piece of clothing made from the Irish family tartan with the family name coat of arms emblazoned on it. I wanted to wear it to work today as we had the option of dressing for St Patricks Day (in England). I chickened out as it felt false & attention seeking. An Irish colleague said I should have worn it if I wanted to as it's part of my Irish roots & heritage. I feel my Irish roots are now so diluted it didn't feel right. How far back do you celebrate your roots & heritage if they're different to what you actually are now?
I do feel drawn to Ireland, it's culture & music. I don't know if this "connection" I feel is exaggerated because I lost my dad a year ago

OP posts:
DedalusBloom · 18/03/2022 09:23

My grandfather was Scottish, my dad remarried a Scottish woman and so my step sister is half Scottish whereas I am only a quarter in that respect. That said, we had a lot of Scottish influences/music and holidays there as a family so I do feel quite comfortable celebrating my Scottish heritage, even though it's relatively tenuous. The rest of my family going back to the 1700s is resolutely English but I guess that doesn't feel as interestingly 'other' as it's so pedestrian.

Disclaimer: I absolutely abhor OutlanderGrin

DillDanding · 18/03/2022 09:20

My parents are Irish but I consider myself English. They’ve lived in England since the 60s and me and my siblings were all born here.

They’ve never celebrated St Patrick’s day and nor have we. I notice my grown up nieces and nephews, all of whom have never set foot in Ireland, are more likely to celebrate it and come over all ‘plastic paddy’ Grin

Sailorsusan · 18/03/2022 09:18

I have an Irish great grandmother and my DM was brought up in a Catholic Irish community. I don't celebrate St Patrick's day or claim to be Irish myself, but I would join in if I lived somewhere where it was a big thing (I don't). Why not?!

ancientgran · 18/03/2022 09:17

I was born in England and have dual nationality, both parents born in Ireland. I grew up in the Irish pub my dad owned, went to a Catholic school where the majority of kids had Irish parents but also Polish, Spanish and Italian kids. There was one English family.

I did Irish dancing, my parish priest was Irish, Ireland was always referred to as "home" as in "Are you going home this year?"

I encourage my kids to enjoy their Irish heritage, why not? No one thinks it strange that they identify with their paternal ancestors who were slaves in the Caribbean why should their Irish roots be any different.

ImInStealthMode · 18/03/2022 09:15

And maybe if you wanted St Georges Day and St Andrews Day celebrated in the same way. Do something about it. Start your own parade

If that's aimed at my comment (apologies if it's not) I'm not arsed about any particular national day, I couldn't care less. What I don't understand is English friends with no Irish connections at all going bonkers for St. Patricks Day but not even confidently being even to say when St. George's Day is. I don't get it.

I'd no more celebrate St. Patricks Day than I would Burns Night or American Independence Day or Chinese New Year or Eid. They're not events for me and unless I were invited to join celebrations by people they did matter to then it would feel fake to pretend they were.

axolotlfloof · 18/03/2022 09:14

It's very American to connect to your Great Grandparents.
My Dad is Welsh (but hasn't lived there since he was 6), and I have a Welsh surname. But I am English, because I have never lived in Wales, nor feel particularly connected to it.

Siameasy · 18/03/2022 09:10

It was always an excuse for a piss up. Got Irish heritage on both sides (both surnames very Irish) but so diluted now I’d never consider myself Irish at all

Aprilx · 18/03/2022 09:08

I have an Irish parent, moved to England as an adult after my older sibling was born. So I was born and brought up in England and whilst I recognise that I am half Irish, I feel English because I was raised here. I would feel silly waving my Irish credentials around on St Patrick’s Day, because I don’t feel Irish on any other day.

Piglet89 · 18/03/2022 09:03

@EdHelpPls

It's not that I don't like being Irish, I'm just neutral I suppose.

You’re Swiss!

theworldhas · 18/03/2022 09:02

@sashh
Well surely if he has an Irish passport he must necessarily be an Irish citizen and therefore factually both Irish and British. Of course he can identity with whatever part of his roots he wants, but having a Passport of country X is a bit of a contradiction here.

theworldhas · 18/03/2022 08:59

Saying “I’m Irish” and wearing green or anything else for St Patrick’s Day and feeling affection for Ireland are completely unrelated. St Patrick’s Day is purposefully inclusive and fun, hence all the tourists in Dublin dress up and join in and people and monuments the world over go green.

Rathmobhaile · 18/03/2022 08:46

@BorderlineHappy

Im Irish living in Ireland and it doesnt bother me if anyone says their Irish

And maybe if you wanted St Georges Day and St Andrews Day celebrated in the same way.Do something about it.Start your own parade.

Totally - want to celebrate your national day. Get on and do it.
sashh · 18/03/2022 08:35

@rainyskylight

My MiL is Irish, came over in her twenties. My DH calls people glorifying a tenuous Irish connection “Plastic Paddies”. I think he has a point, albeit put crudely.
That's how Jimmy Carr identifies, he has Irish parents and an Irish passport but is English.
AnIconOfImperfections · 18/03/2022 08:31

My mother is Irish. I’m v proud to be ‘half’ Irish and identify as such. I’m often told, to my delight, that I ‘look’ Irish (dark hair / blue eyes). We visit often and I would love to live there.

I was born in the South of England but when I had my DNA tested, the results were 58% Irish (Galway), 14% Danish, 26% South of England and 2% Scottish. I was very happy about that. I think I would still celebrate my Irish heritage even if it went back a few generations, and was, therefore, a little tenuous 🍀

rainyskylight · 18/03/2022 08:30

My MiL is Irish, came over in her twenties. My DH calls people glorifying a tenuous Irish connection “Plastic Paddies”. I think he has a point, albeit put crudely.

BorderlineHappy · 18/03/2022 08:29

Im Irish living in Ireland and it doesnt bother me if anyone says their Irish

And maybe if you wanted St Georges Day and St Andrews Day celebrated in the same way.Do something about it.Start your own parade.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 18/03/2022 08:27

I'm Irish, and so is my husband. We celebrated when we lived in Ireland as we got the day off! We live in Oz now and didn't celebrate this year, but I think it's on Friday next year so we might take the day off and go on the piss. My local pub did green beer and beef and Guinness pie though, so it is celebrated here, any excuse really!

MoonUnderWater · 18/03/2022 08:25

My parents are Irish and every man jack before them. I have only Irish blood in my veins but I don't celebrate it. It's just a piss up for all nationalities.

Rathmobhaile · 18/03/2022 08:17

I'm Irish, living in Ireland and do celebrate st. Patricks day. I love to see how Irelabds national day is celebrated worldwide.

As for why St. David's day and St. Georges day and celebrated to the same extent - well maybe its to do with your history? Ireland by necessity has a long history of emmigration and those emigrants brought their culture with them. So now we have cities and countries throughout the world celebrating our national day too. Considering my countries size and location off the coast of the rest of Europe I think that says a lot about Ireland. We've never colonised or invaded another country so its easy for us to be generally well regarded by other countries as a result.

I too have never heard of a family tartan. Sounds more Scottish to me.

ImInStealthMode · 18/03/2022 08:16

I took @AffIt 's comment about cultural appropriation to mean people who don't really have any connection to Ireland celebrating St. Patrick's Day.

If you're Irish, of Irish descent by a generation or three, live in Ireland, happen to be in Ireland or have an Irish partner/friends who celebrate then by all means go mad for St. Patrick's Day.

If you're English or Australian or Canadian or any other nationality and have no tangible links to Ireland whatsoever then why on earth are you dressed up in green and downing pints of Guinness like your life depends on it? I've never understood it, despite having friends that do this every March without fail.

We don't all do the same thing for Australia Day, or Canada Day, or St. George's Day. They're generally celebrated only by the nation involved; and not even that for St. George's.

Lastqueenofscotland · 18/03/2022 08:16

I have an Irish born parent and I think it’s odd. There is a weird obsession with Irish heritage

Mamapep · 18/03/2022 08:14

Claiming heritage and a connection to your family history is not cultural appropriation.

My best friend is British Indian, her grandparents were born in India - are you saying her half Indian heritage children shouldn’t identify at all as that ? Shouldn’t wear indian clothes to weddings like their cousins because they’re too far removed from India itself to claim heritage?

In regards to Ireland - so many people moved to UK and the US, so it makes sense there’s a huge amount of descendants in these parts.

RoastedFerret · 18/03/2022 08:10

@Sparkl

I’m Irish and I never heard of anyone with ‘family tartan’. I thought that was a Scottish thing. Who knew.
Snap! I just had to Google it. I'm in Ireland and didn't celebrate St Patrick's day except for having a lie in because we have a 4 day weekend this year. I don't think many Irish people would raise an eyebrows at anyone wanting to celebrate their Irish roots though, go for it if you like.
Mamapep · 18/03/2022 08:00

@AffIt

No, it's weird.

I'm from the west of Scotland and have the usual 'mongrel' background of mostly Highland/Lowland Scots, North of England, Northern Ireland etc, but I was born and brought up in Scotland and therefore I am Scottish.

The one rock thrown into my personal genetic pool is that my paternal great grandfather was Romanian: but I never met him, I've never been to Romania, I don't know any Romanian people, and I know fuck all about the place if I'm being honest.

This 'tying your identity to something you're not' is bizarre and smacks of cultural appropriation. Just drink Guinness if you want to, nobody cares.

It’s not cultural appropriation to celebrate your own roots on an appropriate day that celebrates it.. Hmm
WeCouldBeSpearows · 18/03/2022 07:59

Nope. I'm not American.

Swipe left for the next trending thread