Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you still celebrate your Irish roots, even if you're not Irish

231 replies

Stressedout65 · 17/03/2022 22:59

One of my paternal great grandfathers was Irish & I had an Irish surname until I got married. I even have a piece of clothing made from the Irish family tartan with the family name coat of arms emblazoned on it. I wanted to wear it to work today as we had the option of dressing for St Patricks Day (in England). I chickened out as it felt false & attention seeking. An Irish colleague said I should have worn it if I wanted to as it's part of my Irish roots & heritage. I feel my Irish roots are now so diluted it didn't feel right. How far back do you celebrate your roots & heritage if they're different to what you actually are now?
I do feel drawn to Ireland, it's culture & music. I don't know if this "connection" I feel is exaggerated because I lost my dad a year ago

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Elizabeth7 · 23/06/2022 18:46

Very sorry Stressedout65 that I missed the last line of your original post. So sorry that you have lost your father. I was trying to demonstrate that you have more of an Irish connection than you might realise x

Elizabeth7 · 23/06/2022 18:22

Yes, every nation has much to be proud about.

CulturePigeon · 23/06/2022 18:10

I join in with celebrations for all the British Isles national days...with friends who are Welsh, Irish and Scottish. None of them seems to mind, and actually encourage me! I like the idea of the four nations being 'together but separate' - celebrate your particular identity but include others and don't be nationalistic about it.

I'm English and I definitely celebrate St George's Day (and Shakespeare's birthday). I'm fascinated by all the other cultures, but if I'm honest, I do feel English - it would be pretentious to feel otherwise!

What I don't like is people using these celebrations to be nasty about the other nations. Also, silly celebs who go on Who Do You Think You Are and make a big deal about 'wanting to be Irish etc', then saying how disappointed they are not to be. Being Irish is great - and also Welsh, Scottish etc - but it's not better than any of the others. That's where I roll my eyes.

Elizabeth7 · 23/06/2022 17:23

I think it's great you would like to celebrate your heritage. I realise this is an older post but I have just come across it. I'm not sure if anyone has mentioned that a person can claim Irish citizenship if one of their grandparents was born on the island of Ireland. Therefore one of your parents could choose to be an Irish passport holder if that is the case. So your connection to Ireland is not at all distant. Besides being about your heritage it's very handy to have dual citizenship.

Stressedout65 · 20/03/2022 21:35

@Sparkl glad I didn't imagine it then. It's interesting to me to look at the family tree & history of my name, which is defo Irish (same as Everton/MU & England footballer) . Its a good excuse to party & have a good sing song to the Dubliners etc. Sorry for the stereotyping but they are Irish & I love them! but I couldn't go around claiming to be Irish. Its better than St George's Day, which no one seems to celebrate, & I wouldn't even know when it is 🙂

OP posts:
Sparkl · 20/03/2022 19:53

@Stressedout65 I only got as far as a rudimentary google I’m afraid! Which said something about county tartans being more common with a few family name tartans as well which I think a pp mentioned.
My surname is not at all Irish so I’ll have to go with the county one for me new gúna Wink

TomPinch · 20/03/2022 17:12

Changechangychange,

Ever heard of Wasps?

(and it wasn't England the US won its independence from.)

Stressedout65 · 20/03/2022 07:53

@Sparkl did you find anything about Irish tartan after you secretly judged?

OP posts:
Stressedout65 · 20/03/2022 07:47

@Branleuse & @Sparkl
Thank you for your comment re the tartan, I thought I'd misunderstood what I'd read 🙂

OP posts:
limitedperiodonly · 20/03/2022 01:21

I know some English-Americans. It's not much of a party. One of them is coming back this year.

Changechangychange · 19/03/2022 22:30

@debwong

How come there are no English-Americans or Welsh-Americans?
War of Independence. All the English-Americans quickly invented a dubious Irish or Scottish great great granny and latched onto that instead.
Wilburisagirl · 19/03/2022 21:40

I'm Aussie. My great grandparents were English, Irish & Scottish. I have travelled to and feel an affinity with all those places and keep in touch with relatives in Scotland but think of myself first and foremost as Australian. I have celebrated St Patrick's day in the past, but only really because my local pub at the time was an amazing Irish pub which did fabulous food, so a friend and I went to join the fun.

I actually don't celebrate Australia Day anymore either because of how it impacts Indigenous Australians.

AmyDudley · 19/03/2022 12:39

My heritage is so mixed (including a bit of Irish somewhere way back - as probably many folk have). I don't celebrate any 'days', but if a friend invited me to their nationality's 'day' I'd happily go along and dress up - any excuse for a party. I don't go around declaring myself to be any of the things that I have in my heritage except the one I have most of.
But I'd say if you want to dress up in green and celebrate St Patrick's day go for it, everyone is so drunk and happy, no one cares.

limitedperiodonly · 19/03/2022 12:14

@ancientgran I understand you perfectly.

HoliHormonalTigerlilly · 19/03/2022 10:47

@Ikeptgoing

I think you are over angst-ing this OP

You can celebrate St Patrick's day as as someone who has mixed heritage including Irish if you want to.

The same way I can and do as 1:4 Irish but important in our family. And the same way my mixed race DCs get to celebrate some West African celebrations too and to have support with their hair and culture, don't let anyone tell you different.

I get really annoyed when my "occasionally white passing except in summer months" Afro haired DDs get any "oh but you're white ?... but what's happening with your crazy fuzzy hair?" stupid comments from school or others. You know what? ... MIXED race and bloody proud of it.,

❤️
Sitdownnext · 19/03/2022 05:43

@EdHelpPls

I'm actually Irish. Didn't acknowledge St Patrick's Day at all, which is about how much I celebrate being Irish in general 😁. It's not that I don't like being Irish, I'm just neutral I suppose!
I feel the same way. Live in England, dh is English - kids feel English, I didn’t celebrate Paddy’s Day - not the same thing now. The tremendous excitement about be able to break lent - it was like Christmas - that was back in the day when even the corner shop wouldn’t sell you any sweets without asking about your lentern obligations - all sweetie money was supposed to go in the Charity box! The Hibernians would play Roddy Mc Crory as they marched down past our house to the chapel to attend mass before the celebrations started. It all feels a bit commercialised now. If you feel connected to Ireland op that’s great - enjoy the cultural riches, I feel connected to a few countries I’ve lived in that I have no familial connection with, who cares, just enjoy it!
Ikeptgoing · 19/03/2022 05:15

I think you are over angst-ing this OP

You can celebrate St Patrick's day as as someone who has mixed heritage including Irish if you want to.

The same way I can and do as 1:4 Irish but important in our family. And the same way my mixed race DCs get to celebrate some West African celebrations too and to have support with their hair and culture, don't let anyone tell you different.

I get really annoyed when my "occasionally white passing except in summer months" Afro haired DDs get any "oh but you're white ?... but what's happening with your crazy fuzzy hair?" stupid comments from school or others. You know what? ... MIXED race and bloody proud of it.,

TomPinch · 19/03/2022 01:09

Hah! Well said Evanna13 although celebrating my Irish heritage would require big drums, blue serge suits and a traybake for afters.

SiobhanSharpe · 19/03/2022 00:58

DH's parents migrated from Ireland to England for work, as did many Irish people in the mid 20th century. They met here, married and raised a family in London .
He was brought up in a very Irish community -- neighbours, Catholic schools, pubs, dance halls, friends, the lot. Summers were spent on his mother's family farm in Ireland.
He considers himself as much Irish as English, growing up steeped in Irish culture. They wore shamrock on Paddy's Day (sent to them in damp paper from home) and celebrated it every year. Not over the top, just a very convivial evening in the pub. Church every Sunday.
Naturally he has an Irish passport. DS is getting one too, it's an important part of his heritage and he is proud of it.
DH's Irishness is still integral to him, his parentage and background are Irish even though he was born here. For both DH and DS, St Patrick's Day is a significant cultural marker.

ancientgran · 19/03/2022 00:27

[quote limitedperiodonly]@ancientgran no one is denying you your right to confer Irish citizenship upon your children or grandchildren if they comply to the criteria but why is it so difficult for you to understand that different countries have different rules about citizenship?

Boris Johnson is British and was American for a while.

I am eligible for Irish citizenship because of my grandparents but I took it up 25 years ago because I qualified as an artist which was a tax break open to people who did not necessarily have any Irish links aside from owning property there.

The Irish government were flexible as to who counted as an artist. They wanted the money and I wanted to save it. Win win.

I have never eaten boiled bacon and cabbage in Ireland and it's been a good 40 years since my non-Irish mum dished it up. She did it with barley and I was fascinated by the clear salty gravy with golden fairy rings of dissolved fat on top. Cheap stews aren't exclusive to the Irish as people from many other backgrounds including the English will attest.[/quote]
I don't find it difficult, how rude. My children have triple nationality, I understand the rules for all 3 countries.

My point, which you don't seem to understand, is people are saying how strange to pretend you're Irish when you weren't born there and yet when we look at Johnson he wasn't born in GB but everyone accepts he's British. His parents happened to be living and working in the US when he was born, my parents happened to be living and working in England when I was born. (the same as other people on here) Why is my being Irish brought into question and yet him being British is fine and dandy.

He is British and I am Irish. No plastic involved and it is my birthright.

I never claimed only Irish people eat bacon and cabbage, have a look back and see. I was commenting on the corned beef and cabbage and people thinking it was Irish and I said I'd never heard of that but yes bacon and cabbage was a meal I like. Like your claim about people saying they were proud of bacon and cabbage alot of what you say seems to be made up.

Hope that helps you to understand.

ancientgran · 19/03/2022 00:07

@Uafasach

But why would you crave boiled bacon and cabbage or Guinness just because you were Irish? I am of Irish descent and I don't. I don't expect Irish people to

Who's craving it? The only craving mentioned on the thread was a pregnancy one.

We all like to wander down memory lane but it is weird to assume that people living in Ireland in 2022 want to eat what your Irish mammy cooked you in England in 1952 or live in that world

Some people in Ireland in 2022 do eat cabbage and bacon. I probably eat it twice a month. It is just a normal dinner. I am not doing it under duress, it is not a government sponsored "Oirish" initiative, we are not required to put it on our instagram to attract flocks of American tourists.

I've never known cabbage to be so controversial.

And it was only one craving, I had others and to be fair the curry one was the surprise, I didn't like curry before I was pregnant and couldn't get enough of it when I was pregnant. My Indian doctor found it quite funny.

Pregnancy apart don't lots of us like food we had as children? When my kids come home they often ask me to make a favourite meal from childhood although they all follow their father and don't like bacon and cabbage.

limitedperiodonly · 18/03/2022 23:34

I've never known cabbage to be so controversial

@Uafasach me neither. No need for anyone to get their panties in a bunch

LizzieAnt · 18/03/2022 23:19

Well said, Evanna13.

bruce43mydog · 18/03/2022 22:53

no but my nana followed her irish heritage.

Evanna13 · 18/03/2022 22:50

I am Irish living in Ireland. I have also lived in England. OP, I would have loved to see you in your Irish tartan, had a chat with you about it and about your family history.
I don't drink Guinness, go to parades or usually even wear green for St. Patrick's day. However I have enjoyed the days off this week and have enjoyed some time in the beautiful countryside over the past few days.
My children have enjoyed the last week at school where they have done a lot of Irish dance, music, language etc and it was lovely to see all of the children going to school dressed in green on Wednesday. I think it is an important part of their culture and identity.
I think if people around the world want to celebrate St. Patrick's Day they should go for it. Maybe they have lovely memories of an Irish grandparent or memories of a happy holiday in Ireland. Maybe they remember enjoying Irish dance or music as a child, maybe they still enjoy it today. They should celebrate the happy memories if they want to, life can be hard enough for us all.
I like to see Ireland being celebrated all over the world, its amazing to see all of the famous buildings lit up in green and parades in multiple cities across the globe. Ireland, like anywhere has its good and bad but I am proud of my little country. It was come a long way in the past 100 years.