Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Families in a and e

183 replies

stormynight1 · 17/03/2022 19:24

Currently in a and e waiting to be seen and the rules at the moment are no one with you unless vulnerable etc. I was dropped off and partners now gone home and will come back later to get me. But I’m amazed at how many people are here with Someone there’s a lady in her 30s with both parents i had to stand for 5 minutes in pain until someone left as all sets where taken. Why can’t they read the rules or go wait in the car one couple have just got out a packed lunch type meal.

OP posts:
MostlyOk · 18/03/2022 08:17

As a person who's spent a LOT of time in A&E with family who have chronic illnesses, we actually now pack a small A&E bag which includes 1 day of medication, phone charger, kindle, health bars, a sandwich and a bottle of water. It might look like we've 'brought a picnic' but we know the wait can be in excess of 6 hours (yep, even with chronic conditions).

I think it's best to avoid assuming you know what's going on in the lives of people there.

Sometimes people have 2 carers as if the person has unpredictable/complex mental health issues or brain injuries, it can take 2 people to calm them if there's some kind of meltdown. I find it easier to just read and focus on my family. 😊

Iamkmackered1979 · 18/03/2022 08:12

I was in a&e in the summer. On my own but I was in too much pain to care what anyone else was doing or who they were with. We don’t know peoples circumstances, let alone judge them!! Packed lunch sounds good though I was there from early in morning till tea time without anything at all.

EvenTheReceptionStaffHaveLeft · 18/03/2022 07:51

@Donra

As for not allowing people in with you, well those aren’t the rules any more, there are no longer any Covid restrictions.

Still very much the rule here in SE London. I have an appointment on Monday with a consultant where I am expecting a diagnosis of a life changing condition but I have been told on the phone and in writing that patients cannot be accompanied.

Dinoteeth · 18/03/2022 07:50

@grey12

As someone in their 30s I wouldn't go with my "mummy and daddy".... so I'm sure there is a need for them to be there 🤷🏻‍♀️ also the nurse would have spoken to them and they would have explained the need to be therel
Why on earth not? On both my trips to A&E it was my parents who took me. Mum was the talker but didn't drive and Dad drove but was incredibly quiet. And actually my second trip they'd come to visit me realised how ill I was and called out the GP who in turn said A&E. I lived 30 miles from them at the time so made sense for us all to go together. Both my A&E visits resulted in a week long hospital stay.
drawingpad · 18/03/2022 07:50

You could see me sitting in A&E with DH, or one of my adult DC and wonder why they were with me. On the face of it all would look 'normal' - im autistic though and I often need someone with me. A high stress medical setting is one of the places I am least likely to be able to advocate for myself, I can have non verbal moments in times of high stress and if I vent talk then someone has to do it for me. In the waiting room? You wouldn't have a clue. You would just wonder WTF this adult had someone with her for.

HollowTalk · 18/03/2022 07:38

@Donra

We took our son to A&E last week. My husband drove and I sat in the back of the car in case he was sick. We were there for five hours and I took a blanket, a charger, an iPad, bottled water and snacks. Should I have gone without those comfort items? Or not gone with my child at all?

As for not allowing people in with you, well those aren’t the rules any more, there are no longer any Covid restrictions.

Don't be ridiculous! Nobody is suggesting that a five-year-old goes to A&E on their own. You'd expect their parents to be with them. I've been to A&E when there have been eight people for one patient. That's just ridiculous. Each of those people were sitting down and some patients were standing up.
grey12 · 18/03/2022 07:36

As someone in their 30s I wouldn't go with my "mummy and daddy".... so I'm sure there is a need for them to be there 🤷🏻‍♀️ also the nurse would have spoken to them and they would have explained the need to be therel

Dinoteeth · 18/03/2022 07:33

Whilst that's not great behaviour from that mother and daughter- do you not think that she may still have really felt she needed the support, especially if she was young?

I'm sure everyone going through chemo would cope better with someone there for support though.

It was fairly shitty behaviour from that mother & daughter.
I watched a man forced to leave his elderly mother to go into the waiting area alone.
Yes I was stood in the corridor with various other "next of kin". They've socially distanced the seats out in the waiting room. So patients get a seat and they are as covid safe as they can be.

If every patient brought their NoK into the waiting area they'd be no social distancing.

While I think most of Scotlands covid rules are OTT I do support it for cancer patients who already have enough on their plate without the risk of catching covid.

Philisophigal · 18/03/2022 06:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

Spikeyball · 18/03/2022 06:46

"there’s a lady in her 30s with both parents"

My son will need 2 perhaps even 3 adults with him when he is in his 30s.

We are certainly not bored when taking him to the hospital - too busy trying to prevent all hell breaking loose.

CatsandDogs22 · 18/03/2022 06:19

People judge in the waiting room because they are stressed, bored and in pain.

I have both judged and been judged in the emergency waiting room. I’ve seen the stares from people as we get rushed through ahead of them (because my baby desperately needed oxygen), found myself wondering why they are there when their “so sick it couldn’t wait for the morning” child is bouncing around the waiting room happy as a clam at 2am.

Truth is none of us know what is going on in each other’s lives or how or why we came to be there. And we are all far too bored to mind our own business

Simonjt · 18/03/2022 06:17

@stormynight1

No one’s saying anything to anyone that comes in with someone they just all sit down and the person who’s unwell goes to check in. I have no problem with them eating in a and e packing a packed lunch seems a bit extreme
So people with diabetes shouldn’t be able to safely access A&E?
Simonjt · 18/03/2022 06:15

@stormynight1

Currently in a and e waiting to be seen and the rules at the moment are no one with you unless vulnerable etc. I was dropped off and partners now gone home and will come back later to get me. But I’m amazed at how many people are here with Someone there’s a lady in her 30s with both parents i had to stand for 5 minutes in pain until someone left as all sets where taken. Why can’t they read the rules or go wait in the car one couple have just got out a packed lunch type meal.
I have type 1 diabetes, if I don’t take food to A&E I’ll very quickly become a patient myself.

We had to go in late January, my husband had hit his head, felt sick and was having issues with his vision. Someone with a head injury can’t get themself to hospital without assistance, they also can’t be left alone as they’re liable to fall (even when sat down) and so need someone with them all the time. I’m not sure how you think I could carr for him for 7 hours while sat in my car at home?

RandomBasic · 18/03/2022 06:03

I hope op and the other judgemental ones have read tft. They can make a clipboard now to check a list "Are you epileptic, even though you look 'nornal' and like a strapping young lad? Were you recently the victim of a SA? Are you having a miscarriage? Yes? OK then, you are free of my judgement.

A £3 McDonald's burger chips drink can be cheaper than a meal deal. A broken wrist doesn't mean that you can't eat for 6 hours.

Clipboard out again. 'Why aren't you waiting in the car? Oh, you don't have one. Just go wait in the rain. And you? She can't speak English? Grrr, out, let her manage. I heard her speak English to the receptionist, what do you mean, answering basic questions in English isn't the same as a medical consultation in a language you are not fluent in?

And yes you, how dare you be too poor to afford to heat your house. To the workhouse with you.

AlwaysLatte · 18/03/2022 01:18

Packed lunch is very sensible when you consider the waiting times.

safclass · 18/03/2022 00:52

Even now our trust would not allow a 2nd person, unless the patient needed them ie I have to take my mam due to her conditions. Still very strict. You wouldn't gave gotten through the door!

Wowwwww · 18/03/2022 00:36

I’ve just came back from a&e with my son (he’s a child so allowed one parent). Apart from two others everyone had two parents with them. One family had a little boy who was running around, his dad I thought was picking him up as his brother wasn’t very well but no he joined the family. It was total chaos and full because of all the adults there

Flowersandhearts · 18/03/2022 00:10

@catzrulz

I had my first Chemo treatment today, signs everywhere saying you can be accompanied to Clinic Appointments if the relative/carer waits outside the waiting room until you are called, but cannot be accompanied to chemo due to the size of the ward and social distancing, I'm in Scotland. A young lady arrived with her Mum who was asked to wait in the corridor today until her daughter was called for Chemo. Mum kicked off and refused, said daughter had MH issues, she was totally unreasonable and very rude to staff. When the staff left she was laughing with her daughter and said see it always works if we say MH, they can't prove anything and said it was cheaper than paying for heating at home. So *@stormynight1* you are definitely NBU.
Whilst that's not great behaviour from that mother and daughter- do you not think that she may still have really felt she needed the support, especially if she was young?

I'm sure everyone going through chemo would cope better with someone there for support though.

BoldMove · 18/03/2022 00:07

Maybe the staff don't want the hassle or possible abuse. Last time I was in a n e someone ordered a Mcdonalds delivery! But I suppose if you're in for long wait then why not.

me4real · 18/03/2022 00:05

Unless there were some reason for them to come in, they probably would'tve been allowed in. That 30 year old could have some sort of major issues of some kind and need two people with her. You can't always tell.

TheOriginalEmu · 18/03/2022 00:01

@NinaDefoe

I’m totally out of the loop obviously. I thought that A&E was for absolute emergencies. People in horrendous pain, broken bones, breathing difficulties or generally very very unwell. If you have the time (and inclination) to pack a Tupperware box full of sandwiches, where’s the emergency? I’ve been to A&E once. There was no time to make a packed lunch and I was so ill I couldn’t have eaten a thing.
If you have a chronic condition that requires regular a&e trips then you learn to plan for it. I have a picc line and a feeding tube that if they become dislodged need replacing in hospital, that requires a&e, but I’m not going to drop dead if I stop to make a butty or buy some stuff from a garage on the way. Same goes for issues with my stoma, A child having an asthma attack, a person in mental health crisis, a broken leg.
TheOriginalEmu · 17/03/2022 23:51

I have a medical condition that means I’m often in a&e, every couple of months. I usually pack some food, as I know it’s going to be a wait and I have coeliac disease so eating out of vending machines is limiting.
My mum had cancer and often needed a&e whilst on treatment, she was also my sisters carer. It often meant all three of us being there as my sister would be distraught without her and I needed to be there to talk to the doctors as my mum was deaf. You have no idea of peoples stories.

Flowersandhearts · 17/03/2022 23:42

@stormynight1

Currently in a and e waiting to be seen and the rules at the moment are no one with you unless vulnerable etc. I was dropped off and partners now gone home and will come back later to get me. But I’m amazed at how many people are here with Someone there’s a lady in her 30s with both parents i had to stand for 5 minutes in pain until someone left as all sets where taken. Why can’t they read the rules or go wait in the car one couple have just got out a packed lunch type meal.
YANBU in general however focusing on the woman in her 30s with both parents sort of is- I'm in my 30s, living with family due to illness and would need lots of help to go to A&E due to my condition.
Beansontoastagain · 17/03/2022 23:42

@stormynight1

I’m not biter I told him to go home as he didn’t need to be with me I get people may need another person with them but do 12 out of 15 people need someone with them
Maybe. You don't know and you can't ask because it's really none if your business 🤷
wanttomarryamillionaire · 17/03/2022 23:40

I have worked for the NHS and some people actually treat it like a day out! Trust me op the staff don't like it any more than you do! Also to those saying why shouldn't people eat, it's because there are people who already feel ill enough without having to smell different foods as well! Its a waiting room not a bloody cafe!